Good stories about politics are disappointingly rare. Good stories about politics set in Canada are even rarer. When I first got wind of Noah Richler's The Candidate: Fear and Loathing on the Campaign Trail I hesitated to pick it up for a variety of reasons, but having finished reading it I am very glad I did.
In 2015 I was a very active member of the New Democratic Party. After four years of a Harper majority I was ready to put my shoulder to the wheel and push to replace the Conservative government with the first New Democratic government in history. It was a heady time, but my closest political friends and I knew that it was going to be a difficult fight and nothing could be taken for granted. However, there was also a whiff of hope and ambition - that we could pull it off and make history. Little did I know Noah Richler and I were on a similar journey.
I bring up my personal narrative here because so much of my experience fed into my enjoyment of the book. I don't believe you have to have been engaged in politics or a New Democrat to enjoy this book, but I think it adds something tremendously to have that little smirk and nod knowing precisely the sort of experience Richler is describing. It is wonderful to have those experiences reflected.
Noah Richler was the NDP candidate for Toronto-St. Paul's in 2015 challenging the incumbent MP Carolyn Bennett. The book follows the journey from his decision to run to working with the party to find a seat to challenge and then the campaign.
Richler describes the bizarre and informal world of politics with great human and a certain wry look. One of the things that I like best is that Richler is motivated by genuine issues of concerns. He has topics that he is opinionated and passionate on and struggles how to square that passion with the realities of running a real campaign. Richler is also flawed, like everyone. He has to find a way to deal with the fact that he expressed his opinions in public and therefore gets in trouble for how his words on social media from the past are interpreted.
There's a bunch of aspects that I appreciate in the story. For example the way the riding executive is described. The unglamorous and unassuming people who dedicate themselves to the political process. The awkwardness of politics, mainly approaching strangers and trying to convince them of a point of view out of nowhere. How the NDP volunteers was described also made me smile because it fit my experience for the most part.
What Noah Richler expresses about the party itself and the frustration about the campaign in 2015 mirrors my own. Four years on that disappointment still clouds some of my political thinking. People made mistakes during that campaign, I have no doubt. One of my favourite scenes is when Richler describes an event in Toronto and the well-heeled audience is full of Liberals and Conservatives back-slapping each other, the true powers behind the country and the NDP feel excluded and unwanted. Perhaps that shapes elections more than we'd like to think.
Overall, I have to very much recommend this book to people curious about how elections work and the more human side of things. It is a great read for people thinking about running, certainly. I'd also add that it would be fun for veterans of the political process.
Showing posts with label Canadian Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canadian Politics. Show all posts
Friday, September 27, 2019
Friday, January 25, 2019
Podcast Review: Canadaland's Thunder Bay
A
few months ago I subscribed and began to listen to the newest podcast created
by Canadaland, a Canadian-based media company. The podcast had been in
development for at least two years as far as I can tell. The name is simple and
instructive. Canadaland's audio documentary seeks to explore the culture,
criminality, social tensions, politics, and racism in Thunder Bay.
The
show is led by Ryan McMahon, an Anishinaabe comedian, writer, and activist. Given
the sensitive material he takes a deft and careful hand at exploring the lives
of indigenous Canadians living in Thunder Bay or their experiences with Thunder
Bay. He spent months building relationships with the subjects and gaining
background information to share the story.
It's
possible to summarize Thunder Bay as a true crime podcast, but I think that
quite misses the mark. True crime, generally, focuses on a single case or a
single criminal. Thunder Bay is about systemic failures and crises. While time
is spent to look at the corruption and cronyism that has pervaded local
politics it is not simply about that. I feel the time spent looking at a mayor
charged with extortion, or a police chief facing obstruction of justice is to
demonstrate that radical failure is taking place in the community and it is
going largely unchallenged.
The
racism faced by indigenous people in Thunder Bay is not hidden or obscured. It
is often visible right on the surface for all to see in public postings,
statements, public leaders, and widely-held opinions. Many First Nations people
have to come to Thunder Bay for schooling. Many of the smaller communities do
not have high schools so the children are brought to Thunder Bay for their
education. These generally leaves them poorly supervised, lonely, isolated, and
in a high-risk area. There is a chilling and recurring fear stated by many that
they will be "thrown in the river." Indigenous people in Thunder Bay
seem to drown in icy rivers with startling regularity, and some indications
exist that there are killers who stalk native people for just this purpose.
The
tone of Thunder Bay is not what I would call emotional, but it is definitely
sensitive. McMahon in his narration and interviews clearly is speaking in a
revelatory manner, and also expresses deep regret and sympathy for victims. Another
powerful element is simple disbelief, that there is a city in Canada that can
flagrantly flaunt was many assume to be our norms and get away with it.
There
is a question that McMahon and Thunder Bay leaves the audience with, one that
is deeply chilling - what if Thunder Bay is working exactly as it is intended?
Pointing to the litany of stories Canadaland has collected and calling them
"isolated incidents" begs incredulity. If you don't believe me, give
it a listen for yourself, but be prepared to see a darker side of our country
that some are intimately familiar with and others have had the privilege to be
shielded from.
To
check out Thunder Bay you can use this link, or subscribe using your favourite
podcast app.
Tuesday, September 25, 2018
Frustration with the Ebb of Progress
I
sit on the left side of the political spectrum, generally speaking. Lately it
has hard not to be pessimistic (not that there are many times when I'm
optimistic). We'll keep things mostly to narrower topics though the consistent
failures of the Trump White House and actions of the Trudeau government are
draining.
I
should say this isn't exclusively about Doug Ford either. With the unpopularity
of the Wynne government this sort of outcome was highly likely. What I find
most galling is the simple stupidity of this government. I don't mean that the
leadership is stupid, I mean that the policies are. I want to talk more about
policies than politics for this piece and how it feels like the left is painted
into a corner on so many topics.
This
week I was watching a panel discussion on Ontario's climate change 'plan'.
Basically the plan of the current provincial government is to scrap the
cap-and-trade system and fight the federal government's right to impose a carbon
tax. In its place will be nothing. It's a terrible policy, but it's damn
popular broadly speaking. Even I, a person who believes we should make
interventions to halt climate change had to admit I was pleased when the cost
of gasoline went down, to my shame. However, it was a crystalizing moment when
I realized it just feels like the collective left is fighting an uphill battle
in policy.
Climate
change will need policies that will hurt society broadly to prevent worse
injury later. Increasing the price of gas discourages excess driving, or at
least the development of more fuel efficient, or electric vehicles. But, it's
unpopular. The right-wing around the world can even accept that climate change
exists and simply refuse to do anything about it and the electorate doesn't
care.
Many
elements of our system of elections and government is undemocratic. Reforms
could be introduced to greatly improve representation at city councils,
provincial legislatures, and the House of Commons. These ideas are laughed out
of the room when people bother to stop yawning.
Laws
that infringe on civil liberties can generally be passed with impunity. Bill
C-51 was reviled for the potential it opened for abuse. It was a major election
issue in places like Downtown Toronto. The Liberals broke their promise on the
main aspects that brought issues, but now that the bad Conservatives are out of
office... no fuss.
Our
cites, all our cities, need to radically change policy to end sprawl and incrementally
improve their density for their fiscal and environmental sustainability. Not to
mention, housing affordability. Even modest proposals to densify certain
communities is met with tenacious resistance, so much so that most politicians
fear to address it.
Transit
projects have either been nickle and dimed or become boondoggles to win
suburban votes. People are committed to their cars and efforts to improve
transportation that isn't more highway lanes and asphalt meet stiff resistance.
The
sex education curriculum is rolling back two decades because a vocal minority
is afraid of sex and bought lies told about it. I presume a silent majority
doesn't care, or finds the birds and the bees "icky".
On
any number of criminal justice issues the overwhelming tide of the population
wants more cops, harsher sentences, profiling and executions. It hardly matters
that experts say this often makes the situation worse, or that resources are
better spent elsewhere.
Speaking
of spending, good luck on having a conversation about raising taxes of any kind
to better serve the public good.
Perhaps
to end on a doozy: First Nations and Indigenous issues are consistently
dismissed. Their rights, their existence and respect for their communities is
routinely overruled for the benefit of the state or the majority. If you talk
to Canadians about indigenous issues that answer I've heard far too often is
that "they have it too good as it is."
Conservatism
has its roots in preserving the status quo. The left is traditionally a
reforming element in society. Pushing change is always difficult. Cobbling
together coalitions to push for uncertain change against a known present is
never going to be automatic. However over the last week I keep thinking of a
line from the HBO series The Newsroom.
The character Will McAvoy asks a liberal pundit, "If the left is so smart
how come you lose so goddamn always?" The right can become more radical
and odious while the left can only seem to cobble together the most minor of
victories.
I
do not expect to be on the winning side continuously. The pendulum swings,
ideas come and go, parties win and lose. Perhaps it's my perspective, but the
swing to the right is scary given its radical element at present. We quite
literally have white supremacists in the public discourse. Sigh. How is the
left not able to win these fights overwhelmingly?
Wednesday, August 29, 2018
The Bernier Party
First,
I'd like to apologize for the missing posts over the last couple of weeks.
During August I went on a brief trip to southwestern Ontario and then followed
that up be a few days out of town at a wedding and some social functions at
work. Long story short, it has made it so I've been both busy and disconnected
from current events.
It
was a bit of a shock when I learned the dispute between Maxime Bernier and
Andrew Scheer within the Conservative Party of Canada ended with Bernier
quitting the party and vowing to start his own as an alternative.
From
reports this break-up was brewing for a long time. Bernier and Scheer had been
quietly and not-so-quietly disagreeing in public. Earlier in the year he was
removed from his critic portfolio. When Scheer reorganized the caucus he put
Bernier in charge of developing policy, a bold move that seemed to endorse his
more libertarian ideals. Clearly this was a consistent source of friction
between the two men.
Bernier's
exit from the party is a grave concern. Let it be remembered that Bernier lost
to Scheer for the leadership of the party 49-51%. Bernier built a base of
support within the party and across the country, as well as significant
fundraising capacity. Now, to be fair, that does not necessarily translate into
backing for his own alternative party, but no doubt a few will follow him.
Assuming
Bernier is sincere in his promise to start a party the real question is the
impact that will have on the 2019 federal election. There are already those who
fear (or gleefully hope) that this may fracture the Conservative Party the way
the Reform/Alliance split the right from the Progressive Conservatives from
1993-2003.
I
think there are a few generally safe assumptions to make. First, with a little
more than a year to go until the election it is unlikely that Bernier will get
a full party off the ground to run the 338 candidates across the country. It
seems a tall order. Second, I think it is likely that if Bernier sticks with it
that it will result in him being re-elected in his riding under a new party
banner. The question becomes how much of a tail, or how broad will his support
be. Will the Bernier Party mirror Elizabeth May's Greens and simply elect the
leader and no one else? Or, will it manifest into the seat of a truly national
party and have competitive candidates and multiple MPs from across the country.
Or, will it become a local phenomenon in Quebec?
I
see a real possibility for Bernier's Party to perform better than the Greens,
though I will not guarantee it. Bernier, from the leadership race, gained a lot
of traction in Alberta. It is possible that his more libertarian vision may
catch on in Alberta the same places that the Wildrose Party did.
Overall,
I don't think this will much impact what I think will happen in October 2019. I
tend to believe Canadians are inclined to give governments two terms. Even if
Trudeau is less popular than he was, I think he is on track to win a second term.
Weakness in the NDP's numbers secures the Liberals' left flank with the Tories
united or divided.
Frankly,
I am all for more parties with representation in the House of Commons. It's a
sad truth that our electoral system penalizes that, but I think a greater
diversity of voices should be welcome, even if I strongly disagree with Maxime
Bernier's position. I'm sure it'll be interesting to see what happens next.
Tuesday, June 12, 2018
The Ontario Election: History Repeats Itself
Meet
the new election, same as the old election. As the results of the Ontario have
been decided it is difficult to look over the results and not see a great deal
of similarities between the 2018 provincial election and the 2011 federal one.
In
both cases the Liberals were battered down to third place. The Tories secured
approximately 40% of the vote and in the weakness of the Liberals the NDP
filled the gap to become the Official Opposition after a breakthrough. The
ultimate kicker - the leader of the Green Party managed to win her/his seat.
There
are plenty of parallels to how the Progressive Conservatives won in Ontario to
how their federal cousins did seven years prior. In fact, in 2011 Stephen
Harper's Conservatives won 73 seats to Doug Ford's 76. Similarly, the Liberals
were reduced to 11 seats federally and provincially it was 11.
I
think we see a lot of alignment between these two elections because there
simply is a lot of shared blood between the six parties. I am less clear on the
Green Party, so I don't want to speak out of ignorance. Kathleen Wynne strongly
supported Justin Trudeau in 2015, Jack Layton was a strong ally to Andrea
Horwath and Jagmeet Singh did pitch in for the campaign this time around. An
obvious move given that his brother now represents his old seat. The
connections between the Tories are less obvious, but several Harper era
Conservatives successfully ran for seats this time around.
Aside
from the parallels in the outcomes and votes I think we can likely extrapolate
how some of the politics over the next four years may look. Doug Ford is going
to introduce a conservative agenda to the province for the first time in
fifteen years. There is going to be substantial resistance from the progressive
side and its allies. It will be the ONDP's job primarily to keep the PCs in
check and hold them to public account. Ms. Horwath will be challenged to do it
as well as Tom Mulcair did. For four years he made the case for why the
Conservatives did not deserve re-election.
However,
do not expect the 2022 election to be a mirror of 2015. Doug Ford will have
only completed his first term and the public is more like than not to give him
a second, just out of tradition and habit. More likely it'll be a battle for
the opposition parties to assert themselves and reduce the PC majority, if
possible, and for Mike Schreiner to prove his worth as the sole Green MPP.
On a final note, I predicted 111 of the 124 provincial ridings correctly. In terms of overall numbers I did better, but I figured I'd fess up and say that I was off. I underestimated the NDP breakthrough in Toronto, and which seats the Liberals would manage to hold, and underestimated the PCs in a few spots. Oh well, still not bad for an amateur. I did call all five of my local ridings correctly though, so that's a bonus.
2018
was a hell of a provincial election and will no doubt make for exciting
politics in Ontario for the years to come. Keep watching, there's plenty more
to come.
Tuesday, February 20, 2018
Millennial Elections
Earlier
this week I was listening to an older episode of CBC's The Pollcast.
In the episode Eric Grenier interviewed
David Coletto of Abacus Research about the impact Millennials had, are having, and will have on elections.
The old wrap that young people don't vote is quickly not being applicable to
Millennials. The oldest of the generation are turning 38 this year, and the
youngest (which is dependent upon how you define Millennials) are either
already or turning the voting age.
My
generation is hardly homogeneous. Different opinions exist within each
generation, but it can be useful to think of broader trends, especially when
contrasting to other cohorts. We have elections that may illustrate real world
examples of Millennial voting behaviour.
In
some elections it is clear that Boomers (born 1946-1964) and Millennials have
diverged sharply on certain questions. It's not unusual for issues to break
down along generational lines, but a number of elections seemed to have hinged
on the gap between Millennials and others. Brexit is a great case in point.
Younger people overwhelmingly voted to remain within the European Union, while
older Brits voted to leave. Coletto suggests in the podcast that Millennials
were key for Barack Obama to winning the primary and the general elections, and
supporting Bernie Sanders and as a result leading to Hillary Clinton's defeat.
As
discussed in The Pollcast Millennials have already important sway in elections
in Canada. The 2011 federal election, the 2014 Alberta provincial election, the
2015 federal election, the 2017 Calgary mayoral election and the 2017 British
Columbia provincial election. In each case Millennials broke for the winning
party and may have made a significant difference. In each case they backed a
centrist or left-wing party and helped them edge out a victory.
Millennials
tend to skew left, but I'm not so sure that is an accurate way to read my generation.
I think certain concepts are accepted as political orthodoxy by Millennials in
general, such as basic legal equality, gay rights, legalization of certain
drugs, etc. However, the embracing of the left we've seen by Millennials I
think more accurately reflects their precarious economic situation. My
generation may support things like pharmacare and free tuition because economic
fortunes seem so grim. I think it may be more accurate to say Millennials are
polarizing and perhaps becoming more extreme, or open to political extremes/radical
ideas. I see this on the right and left. On the right a generation that seems lost
is fertile ground for blaming others for failed promises and drift. This is an
element that will need to be carefully watched going forward.
As
my cohort ages it will have a greater say in the form and shape of our
politics. We are already determining the results of elections, and in the
future political parties will rely on those born after 1980 for victory. We
already may be seeing this happening in Canada in upcoming provincial elections
and the federal election next year. As demographics change so does our
politics, and we are in the midst of it now.
Labels:
Canadian Politics,
Elections,
Millennials,
Ontario Politics
Tuesday, January 23, 2018
Setting the Stage for the Next Debates
In
Ottawa there is some discussion about what should be the terms for the next
federal election debates. Canada has no regulation, as far as I am aware,
regarding our national debates leading into a federal election. A gentleman's
agreement of sorts was what governed how debates operated in this country. A
media consortium worked together with the political parties to set the terms of
the debates.
For
many years this system seemed adequate. I don't think Canadians were
particularly engaged by the debates, but nor were they poorly served by them. In
the 2000s, in the minority years, the public got to see politicians perform on
equal footing and were well moderated by skilled journalists such as Steve
Paikin. However, in the last federal election the Conservatives blew up the
traditional consensus and offered to do debates with any number of media
organization and in different formats.
In
the 2015 federal election the Conservatives threatened to upend this system and
the status quo. Prime Minister Stephen Harper's decision to withdraw from
convention meant that we were poised to confront a reality wherein Canadians
would have no debate as a platform to judge the candidates. Luckily some did
manage to occur, but far fewer Canadians saw them than in previous years.
The
Liberal government is exploring the idea of creating a commission for debates
and enshrining it in law. Very few details are fixed as of yet, but there are
some interesting ideas on the table. Financial penalties could be imposed to
compel/encourage participation. The leader of the Green Party, Elizabeth May
(GPC - Saanich-Gulf Islands, BC), has been leading in suggesting how
parties/leaders should qualify to debate. She has suggested that participating
parties have to have two of the three following criteria: a) received 4% or
more of the national vote in the previous election, b) have an elected member
of the House of Commons under that party's banner, c) be running candidates in
most (or nearly all) of the country's 338 ridings.
All
things considered it is a pretty reasonable benchmark to start with. Such a
standard would allow the Green Part and the Bloc Quebecois to join the NDP,
Liberals and Conservatives in the next federal leaders' debate. Unsurprisingly,
the system isn't perfect. This would have excluded other parties from entering
the debate that have in the past, such as the Reform Party.
With
democracies under strain I think there is a good argument to look at
formalizing institutions like this and strengthening them. The practice of a
leaders' debate is an important part of the Canadian election cycle. We should
never have to worry again if we can see our leaders answer questions and
explain their policies as a group. While hardly perfect on its own I think that
is something work protecting and building upon, if nothing else.
Tuesday, January 2, 2018
Housing First in the Deep Cold
On
December 30th I visited some friends. It was a cold night, a very cold night.
We were in relative comfort and spent an evening playing board games and
enjoying each other's company. I even managed a second place finish in Lords of
Waterdeep, which is a rare feat. I tell this story for what happened at the
conclusion of the evening.
When
we were all done I climbed into my vehicle, started the engine for a moment and
began to drive. My friends live ten minutes away from me, so waiting for the
car to heat up for such a short drive seemed silly on the face of it. So I got
in and drove. I made it a few hundred meters when despite a nice coat, hat and
gloves I started shivering in the car. It was -24 degrees centigrade.
During
the recent cold weather an error was made at a Toronto emergency shelter and
people were turned away while there was still space available. During my brief ride from my friends to my house I was deeply uncomfortable,
though not in any serious danger. I can scarcely imagine sitting out in the
cold all night. The consequences could be, and often are, lethal.
Canadians
rightfully complain about living in one of the coldest countries on the planet.
Our major cities, I'm sure, are some of the coldest in the world for their
size. As a result, our urban leaders have to confront a simple truth: if we do
not provide adequate housing in the winter, people will die.
It's
conversations like this where we need to separate questions about general
housing affordability from the crisis that is homelessness. A person with an
addiction, or mental illness isn't a family making $42000 who can't afford to
rent in Toronto. Increasing supply or rent control will not ultimately get us
to address this particular problem.
Cities
in Canada need to adopt a housing first strategy. It is unconscionable to rely
on temporary and emergency housing and turn these people out into the streets.
Housing first means that people in bad situations are given a stable place to
live. It makes the provision of care and social services much simpler. Experts
argue that it costs less in the long run, but it is by no means cheap. Worst
still any housing first program would disproportionately benefit those that society
currently pushes as far to the margins and away from our mental landscapes as
we can. Moral choices are not always cheap or easy ones, but acting in
immorality for the sake of some savings at the cost of human suffering is
difficult to stomach.
Labels:
Affordable Housing,
Canadian Politics,
Cities,
Homelessness,
Poverty
Tuesday, December 5, 2017
Liberal Tax Reform Mire
The Liberal tax reform introduced months ago has been a communications disaster for the government. Closing certain tax provisions will increase the amount paid by high income Canadians. The Trudeau Liberals seem to have stumbled blindly into this issue. They seemed entirely unprepared for the resistance to these changes.
The Prime Minister and his team seemed to believe that relying on their tired rhetoric of "strengthening the middle class and those working to join them" would be enough. When you repeat the same thing over and over again to justify everything from tax cuts to road construction to opening a hockey arena don't be surprised if its effectiveness dulls.
There are strong, well-financed forces to push to keep the status quo. Doctors and small business owners will be limited in their tools to save on taxes. A number of wealthy individuals use the existing law to avoid taxes. While perfectly legal there are questions whether it was the intent of the government, or ethical for some parties to pay less in a progressive tax system.
While progressives are generally in favour of changing the tax code the failure of the Liberals to articulate these reforms successfully is putting them at risk. Opponents in advocacy groups and the Conservative Party have painted this as a massive tax increase on small business and an attack on doctor. The attacks have been, to this point, successful on raising doubts about the wisdom of the changes. In reality, it seems offering some sort of transition period would have done a great deal to dissuade modest critics, but the Liberals did not see reason to see that far ahead.
In politics communications often matters more than the policy itself, to my eternal grief. In some parallel universe the Liberals sold these policies to enough Canadians to ensure their passage, now it will cost Trudeau significant political capital. Part of the explanation is who the messengers are.
Justin Trudeau was born with a silver spoon in his mouth and his finance minister, Bill Morneau is a very wealthy man. Men who have taken advantage of the same system the seek to right. Morneau has been dogged by questions about his finances and personal business dealings and whether or not the meet the rigour of disclosure and freedom of conflict of interest. Chantal Hebert warns that the Conservatives, by pursuing Morneau will lose sight on the defeating these reforms.
It would be fitting for the Liberals to stumble forward into success. It would join a questionable list of policy accomplishments for the Trudeau government. It leads me to wonder how many more lucky breaks they may have in them.
The Prime Minister and his team seemed to believe that relying on their tired rhetoric of "strengthening the middle class and those working to join them" would be enough. When you repeat the same thing over and over again to justify everything from tax cuts to road construction to opening a hockey arena don't be surprised if its effectiveness dulls.
There are strong, well-financed forces to push to keep the status quo. Doctors and small business owners will be limited in their tools to save on taxes. A number of wealthy individuals use the existing law to avoid taxes. While perfectly legal there are questions whether it was the intent of the government, or ethical for some parties to pay less in a progressive tax system.
While progressives are generally in favour of changing the tax code the failure of the Liberals to articulate these reforms successfully is putting them at risk. Opponents in advocacy groups and the Conservative Party have painted this as a massive tax increase on small business and an attack on doctor. The attacks have been, to this point, successful on raising doubts about the wisdom of the changes. In reality, it seems offering some sort of transition period would have done a great deal to dissuade modest critics, but the Liberals did not see reason to see that far ahead.
In politics communications often matters more than the policy itself, to my eternal grief. In some parallel universe the Liberals sold these policies to enough Canadians to ensure their passage, now it will cost Trudeau significant political capital. Part of the explanation is who the messengers are.
Justin Trudeau was born with a silver spoon in his mouth and his finance minister, Bill Morneau is a very wealthy man. Men who have taken advantage of the same system the seek to right. Morneau has been dogged by questions about his finances and personal business dealings and whether or not the meet the rigour of disclosure and freedom of conflict of interest. Chantal Hebert warns that the Conservatives, by pursuing Morneau will lose sight on the defeating these reforms.
It would be fitting for the Liberals to stumble forward into success. It would join a questionable list of policy accomplishments for the Trudeau government. It leads me to wonder how many more lucky breaks they may have in them.
Tuesday, November 28, 2017
Democracy Dies in Darkness
Nothing
has worried me more about the future of Ontario democracy lately than the news
that dozens of papers in the province will be shuttered. A deal between
Postmedia and Torstar will result in the closing of 38 community newspapers in Ontario. News media has been in crisis over the last couple of decades. Newsrooms and
coverage has been contracting, investigations and critical reporting shrinking.
Newspapers are hollow shells of what they once were.
The
journalism in most smaller and medium-sized cities and towns has been severely
lacking in the twenty-first century. The fourth estate is fighting a rearguard
action against irrelevancy and insolvency.
The
simple truth is that journalism, especially mass reporting, has been critical
to the healthy function of our democracy. We are less than a year away from
municipal elections, and only a few months from a provincial election. The next
elections will be much the poorer without their commentary and coverage.
As
I write this I can hear the criticism clear as day. The newspapers had a narrow
viewpoint, a small ownership base, they were/are a dying medium that failed
financially and failed to adapt to new circumstances and alternatives exist to
take their place. These, for the most part, are valid critiques. However, we
have not seen a website, Twitter account, etc. replace a newspaper and truly
fill its function. The journalism could be relied upon to be factual, even with
editorial bias.
Let's
consider some of what we have lost in these communities and others. Newspapers
during an election can be counted upon to at
least profile
all the candidates for office for their audience. Newspapers often organize
debates and moderate them. Perhaps most importantly they provide a platform for
candidates to communicate to the public en masse without expending great
amounts of money. I've worked on campaigns and the hardest thing is getting the
public's attention. Newspapers and local media catch a distinct audience in a
geographic audience and can serve them meaningfully and deeply.
Then
there is the usual coverage of day-to-day politics and government. How are
public institutions faring? What issues confront the community? How do changes
in laws and policies or events impact local people and organizations?
Newspapers have been failing in some of these respects, but nothing has offered
their reach, capability, or public service.
As
we move forward we risk depriving the public of objective sources of local
information. Our civic life will only be poorer in their absence until
alternative models can be arrived at.
Labels:
Canadian Media,
Canadian Politics,
Ontario,
Ontario Politics
Tuesday, November 14, 2017
Morality and Foreign Policy
Before
I write this all out I should say that I am undecided on this topic. It began
as reflecting on a series of news items over the last couple of weeks. In the
end this may end up as more of a Devil's advocate piece, or just reflect some
evolution in my thinking.
In
Western democracies we often use sanctions, political or economic, to penalize
governments who violate human rights or operate outside of the geopolitical
concert. It's a tricky balance riddled with hypocrisy. There are glaring
examples of these contradictions, such as Chinese and Cuban relations with the
United States.
Countries
exist within a spectrum of human rights. The willingness of us to tolerate a
government's human rights abuses seems inversely proportional to its economic
importance. We make arms deals with Saudi Arabia and trade with increasingly
autocratic Turkey, while we help overthrow the government of Libya and sanction
Iran.
However
our policies can be slow to respond or adapt, especially when European states
are involved, or a big economic relationship is in play. Hungary has been going
down a troubling path for years now but there is no calls to discipline them.
For
decades there have been questions about the effectiveness of these policies. South
Korea and China have improved in their human rights and grown their economies
as the world has entered and trade increased. Cuba, Iran, and North Korea seem
to have become more and more entrenched as the sanctions dragged on. Sanctions
hurt the wrong people and enrich the elite.
I'm
not suggesting we sell nuclear technology to North Korea or weapons systems to
Iran. What I am doing is questioning the utility of broad sanctions. Sanctions
and penalties may make sense for regimes that employ slave labour or terribly
exploitative worker practices because giving access to our market only
encourages these abuses.
The
logic of sanctions also raises questions. Cuba and North Korea, as examples,
have been under broad sanctions for decades. They have failed to bring down
their regimes. Will four more decades improve the situation or condemn
generations to poverty and backwardness? Eventually under this logic doesn't
regime change become imperative? If forty years of economic hardship is
justified isn't the use of force to compel regime change? Iraq and Afghanistan
illustrate the folly of such interventions, but laying endless economic siege
hardly seems worthwhile either. In the case of some countries the sanctions are
so strict all that is left is military force for negotiation.
Part
of my writing on this was inspired by some of the coverage of President Duterte of the Philippines. The man seems a brutal, awful man, but should we let that
define our relationship with the 103 million Filipinos?
To
a certain extent, especially in semi-democratic/democratic countries it feels
like punishment for their choices. It is a grand scale of election meddling. Say
Canada put something in place to sanction Duterte, does the government remove
them if a challenger beats him in the next election?
As
cold as the calculus is it might be worthwhile to consider the opportunity
costs for Canada in these sanctions. What options are being abandoned for a
system that has not truly proven to be effective? I know in recent years
sanctions have targeted leaders rather than countries. In that instance at
least I can see a correlation. However, with over one hundred and ninety
countries no blockade is tight, so I think it would be worthwhile to consider
our effectiveness and intentions when we call for bans, boycotts, sanctions and
penalties on those regimes we find odious.
Tuesday, October 24, 2017
Bill 62 is a Disgrace
Bill
62 is a disgrace. In the fullness of time it will be seen in the same light as
separate drinking fountains for different races. It is a clear, cowardly attack
on a cultural practice that applies only to a tiny minority.
In
case you are unaware Bill 62 is a Quebec piece of legislation that will
prohibit those covering their faces from receiving or providing public services
on behalf of the government. While I appreciate Quebec has a different tradition of secularism than
English Canada it is hard not to see this as a targeted hit against Muslims. I sincerely doubt the framers of the law had
any concerns about excessively observant Catholic nuns in mind. The law is
clearly intended to penalize Muslim women.
My
values tell me that the state shouldn't be in the business of dictating our
clothes (aside from basic decency). The hue and cry that these sorts of laws
are intended to protect and liberate women seem, at best, paternalistic. In
modern Canada we all access government services constantly. From buses to
police officers, from driver's licenses to permit clerks, we frequently have to
interact with public servants and depend upon their work.
In
a secular society it is not required for the people not to profess their values
or hide their religion, rather, it is the government that should be neutral and
fair. This law hardly perpetuates the idea that Quebec government is an
unbiased party. Instead it seeks to punish those who do not conform to its
preferred group.
As
a feminist raised in the West I do not like the niqab or the burka. At first blush
they seems to be in the long tradition of controlling women's bodies and
sexuality. That being said, I have no intent or desire to ban them or badger
women who wear them. Nor would I prohibit mini-skirts for the opposite reasons.
It's not my place. I've spoken with women who wear head coverings. They have
been consistent that it is a choice they have made, and that they like it.
Quebec
could do much for the Muslim women in its society. This act seems a declaration
that a small subset and the broader community do not belong. While the law is
likely to be struck down by the courts it would send a more powerful message
for elected leaders to repeal it. I doubt that will happen. However, sometimes
moral courage appears at surprising times.
Tuesday, September 26, 2017
Considering Free Speech
There
is a subject that has been troubling me. I won't pretend the 21st century is
unique in facing illiberal political movements, but I live in this historic
moment and feel compelled to note the links between a harder line left and the
new right and the difficulty liberal democracies may be facing moving into the
future. This post is partially spurred on the German election results, where
the AfD gained significantly in the parliament. There have been moments in
modern history where polarization in between extremes fractures the polity and
wrecks the centre.
In
the face of this how do liberal societies defend themselves from those who
would use their principles to undermine them?
Today
I want to narrow today's topic to the freedom of speech. A liberal, at core,
would not like to limit people's speech.
The liberal position says that we need strong justification to curtail anyone's
right. Libel laws or harmful speech (fire in the theatre) are obvious
restrictions. For classical liberals restrictions are difficult decisions and
they prefer to err on the side of speech.
Speech
works if we can rely on some basic ground rules. However, the evidence abounds
that lies and mischaracterizations spread like wild fire while the truth plods
along. Liberal ideals are undone by the most basic human instincts, instincts
which are all the easier to embrace in the digital sphere. Enter the era of
"fake news." Even beyond the political, lies or misleading headlines
stand at equal heights of fact. People are increasingly unable to filter
information meaningfully. Look no further than the misinformation on vaccines
to see how muddled and mired we are.
As
a liberal-minded person I have to concede my discomfort with these sources of "information"
or confirmation bias, but I'm not at all comfortable with interfering with
these forms of speech.
Then
there is hate speech. Here two sides of my thinking war with one another.
Speech matters. It shapes thinking and attitudes. Calls for violence are
illegal, and I think most can agree are reasonable restrictions for public
speech. However, calls for violence are common on the internet and this speech
is not curtailed in any substantial way. The debate then goes to what
constitutes hate speech. Most people are canny enough to mask their racist
rhetoric, or cloak it in policy language. Distrust of Muslims is cloaked in
anti-refugee, terrorism, and geopolitics. Anti-black racism is buried in
conversations on crime, poverty, and urban culture broadly. the coarse dialog
(or rants) of the internet now infect our real world life. Things not uttered
in 'polite society' are now bellowed proudly.
Liberalism
is a modernist idea and relies on reason, rationalism, and truth. How does it
operate in a world where half-truths and lies rule, or at least easily remain
on par?
The
current debate of free speech is rather odious, in my opinion. Progressive
voices seek to silence certain forms of speech deemed inappropriate. It has a
streak I find deeply troubling. Protest to disrupt speakers, regulating the use
of language, and the bevy of terms to police language seem to belittle real
oppression for the sake of bourgeoisie sensitivities of the intelligentsia. To
be clear, I am not joining the ranks complaining about all silly university
antics.
The
right has corrupted free speech as a notion to its own purposes. In reaction to
the left they now claim free speech. However, free speech is increasingly used
as coded language for expressing racist, bigoted opinions free of consequences.
the
last few years has helped to demonstrate to me the power of language. Leaving
some to routine abuse by those trying to assert historic dominance makes me
uneasy. That said I'm not sure I'd comfortable regulating speech. But speech
can be used to undermine a liberal society. Critics may answer the solution is
more speech, but I fear there are growing indications that those that seek to
distort our polities are fighting with guns while liberals only have knives.
This thought is one that worries me.
Tuesday, August 1, 2017
Canada as a Concept for Others
I
am a supporter of a podcast call The Mixed Six.
As a reward for backing the podcast I get the privilege of submitting questions
for the hosts to answer. The two hosts are well-educated and modestly
inebriated men having heady conversations over beers. The conceit is basically
the best conversations I have with my friends after about three or more beers.
I submitted a question on the week of Canada for their perspectives on Canada
and its influence on American debates as Americans, which they answered in episode
19. They are both lefties, it is safe to say, and I found both of their takes
interesting and it inspired some thinking on my part.
It
is no secret that Canada is often used as a prop during American political
debates. Our country plays an important role in the rhetorical exchange of Americans,
but the interesting thing it isn't Canada itself that plays a part in this
debate, it is the conception of America. Both Spencer and Caleb of The Mixed
Six cottoned onto this distinction immediately. Discussions in America about
Canada aren't really about Canada for the most part, they are about America.
The same is true to a lesser extent here, but Canadians have a greater
familiarity with American and vice-versa so it's possible that our
conversations are more grounded in the real experience of American lives.
Depending
on an American's given political perspective Canada can be an illustration to
how thing should/could be or an abject lesson in policy failures. For the
conception of Canada the facts as relates to this is entirely irrelevant. Perhaps
the best case study for this is to look at how Americans discuss our healthcare
system. For many on the American left Canada is a model for what healthcare in
the United States could be. We have universal care that does not exclude any
Canadian on the basis of wealth. Even as a person familiar with these issues in
America I don't understand American
healthcare. How many times have you heard distortions about the nature of our
healthcare? I don't view it as perfect, but it's certainly offers trade-offs
I'm willing to accept. From the conservative point of view we live in a
rationed system of long wait times and privation. Both sides caricature life in
our country as a stick to beat the other, not to say anything about Canada.
This
fetishization of Canada is epitomized during controversial elections and with
coverage of our 'beloved' Prime Minister. It was widely reported that the
Canadian immigration website crashed on the night of the American election and
the days followed it. Liberal/progressive Americans often use the refrain that
if a conservative wins they will flee to Canada. It is a convenient short-hand
to reject the reactionary element of American political life. It's not truly
rooted in a sense of Canada as a real place. Likewise the humiliating fawning
the world does over our Prime Minister really fails to paint an accurate
picture of his government or its policies. Would international press celebrate
his feminist credentials if they saw the arms deal to Saudi Arabia? Or the way
junior female cabinet ministers have been repeatedly thrown to the wolves? Or
what about his broken promises on key electoral issues, or he violation of his
government's commitments to Indigenous Canadians?
While
familiarity breeds contempt I think is more accurate to say American
familiarity with Canada has created complacency. Canada is as different as a
subset of America, like how California or the South is distinct from the rest
of the country. Canada is America but with French people, it's colder and has
healthcare.
Ultimately
this misrepresentation in foreign media reinforces and lends strength to those
comfortable in the status quo. The privileged can pat themselves on the back
because despite his flaws Justin Trudeau is not Donald Trump, which is hardly
convincing enough on its own. Doubling down on our own (unearned) smug
superiority is hardly helpful for Canadians. It's a curious mix of reactions.
On the one hand we want to be acknowledged for our successes without becoming
complacent by them.
Ultimately
very few of us know another culture, country or society. What we have is our
conception of them. Our broad understanding of these places drives our
reactions to them and perhaps provides tools for our own debates. While it may
be nicer to have the world understand us better I think it is more important to
be more critical of these reflections back on ourselves and not stare too
deeply into blurry that is so appealing.
Wednesday, July 5, 2017
Canada 150: Tomorrow
In
the final entry in this three-part series I would like to discuss Canada moving
into the future. Four days ago Canadians from coast to coast to coast
celebrated the formation of the country. I think many of us reflected on our
present position. We rejoiced in the many riches this country has offered us
and our families and simply enjoyed ourselves. I am sure that some among us took
a moment to reflect on our history, with pride and with criticism. I wonder how
many of us took some time to think about the future of this country and its
people.
Now
that the big party is over I think it would be wise for us to start to think
about where we want our country to go and what we want it to be in the future.
For me the question comes down to this, 'What do we want Canada to look like
when we celebrate its 200th birthday?" 2067 is approaching sooner than we
may think. More importantly the decisions we make today in our communities, cities,
provinces, and country will shape our/their future.
Perhaps
it is out of character for me, but I am quite optimistic about the future of
this country. Unfortunately I do not think our leaders or we as citizens give
much attention to long-term thinking so here are some questions we should start
thinking about today.
On
Canada Day there were approximately 36.5 million Canadians. We are one of the
smaller wealthy, Western countries of the world. That does not seem likely to
remain the case. By 2067 Canada will have nearly doubled its population (based
on estimates) to over 60 million. That would make us roughly the same size as
Italy, the UK, and France. I think Canadians are comfortable thinking of
themselves as a small country, but this is going to change in the space of a
couple of generations.
Canada
today is about the size of Poland, and despite our greater wealth, we are only
expected to contribute so much to international military operations, foreign
aid, and leadership. This will change in the coming decades. Barring unforeseen
consequences or disasters this is the path we are on. As we grow we must also
mature into a country more willing to exert its influence on the world. All
signs point to less stability in the near future, so a more robust Canadian
military and foreign policy will likely be needed.
Nearly
doubling our population alone will have a tremendous impact on our communities.
What will be the next great cities in Canada and how will we prepare for that?
How do we spread growth around so that our largest cities don't crack under the
strain? How do we prevent the loss of valuable green space and farm land in
sprawling cities? How do we adapt/expand our infrastructure to meet these new
demands? Some provinces and cities have plans on the books to try to address
the medium term change, but many are failing to comply. It is reckless to just
stumble blindly into the future given the costs that will be involved.
One
thing that will probably be a big question for Canada is how we adapt to and
deal with the impacts of climate change. I have my doubts that humanity will be
able to bend the curve on CO2 emissions in a meaningful way in time.
What is our policy about the Arctic? How will we enforce our sovereignty? Will
this expand our agricultural potential in the 'near North'? Will we have to
move people as sea levels rise and storms become more powerful? How will we
deal with inconsistent precipitation leading to drought and flood years? These
are things we need to start thinking about and will shape 2067 Canada.
There
are many things we cannot predict, nor do anything about. We are entering a
period of intense automation, which may make work as we know it obsolete. Perhaps
we are on the verge of the Star Trek utopia, or, a dismal society where there is
a large underclass of unemployed/unemployable people. New industries will rise
and fall. New technologies may change our lives, communities, and society as we
know it. Politics domestically and internationally are unpredictable to say the
least. However, as we walk into the 21st century I feel there is every indication
that for next fifty years Canada is set to continue on a path of becoming an
even greater country, if we have the wisdom and foresight to make it so.
Tuesday, June 27, 2017
Canada 150: Today
This
Saturday marks Canada's 150th birthday. It's a fascinating milestone in some
ways. Compared to some countries were are young and immature. Compared to our
North American peers, the United States (1789) and Mexico (1810), we are the
junior member. There are a number of countries that make us seem like children.
Though we can honestly put that aside. France may have existed in some form
since the fifth century, but the modern France we understand today dates from
either 1945 or 1871, however you examine it. This leads me to the first thing I
want to talk about.
When
I was growing up it seemed to me that Canadians could not rest easy with Canada
as itself. We were constantly comparing ourselves to other countries and
usually the comparison was not favourable. At best we would exaggerate small
achievements beyond their reasonable scope, or award ourselves participation
ribbons for some historical event or piece of trivia. I think, thankfully, we
are moving past that as a collective culture.
From
my childhood in the 1990s and early 2000s to the present I get the distinct
impression that Canadians are unapologetically proud of their country. They do
not feel the need to pull out the international measuring stick and feel
inferior or superior to other countries. The blanket anti-Americanism I recall
from my youth has ebbed away. Our emotional/cultural relationship with the
United States will always be complicated I imagine, just like say Denmark and
Germany, or the UK and France, or Turkey and Greece, except our historical
links are far closer and our differences smaller. This maturity has the
tremendous benefit, I believe, of allowing Canadians to look inward and ask
themselves how to make this country better without looking wistfully through
the glass at others.
I
consider myself a patriot. There are as many reasons to love our country as
people who live within it. I'd like to take a minute to celebrate what I find
so special about it, if you'll indulge me.
I
think the moments when I feel most connected to Canada is when I'm travelling.
It doesn't have to be elaborate. I feel it when I bike down the bike path in
Brampton. I've felt it driving down rural highways across Ontario, and crossing
the Northwest Territories, or flying over the Rocky Mountains, or zooming along
in a GO bus towards the CN Tower, passing through Ontario on the train to
Ottawa, or zipping through Toronto on the subway. I guess it has to do with
something about taking in our country. It's breaking a routine and seeing other
Canadians going about their lives in all its mosaic beauty.
The
place I have felt most in touch with this feeling is in Ottawa. There is a
magic, for lack of a better word, at looking up at the Peace Tower on
Parliament Hill. Looking at the statues, the Ottawa River, the Rideau Canal,
the sculptures, the monuments and buildings fills me with awe. I am a big
politics and history nerd so I am sure that plays no small part, but Ottawa
embodies our collective spirit. The natural beauty of this country from icebergs, to wildlife, to incredible vistas inspire wonder for a country of such
wealth.
While
it has become clichéd there has to be something said about our openness as a
country. We are not perfect, certainly, and I think we ignore those who are
upset with growing diversity and how our transforming society is living some
behind, as in Europe, as in America. Still, Western countries around the globe
struggle to do what we are accomplishing in this country. There is much work to
be done, but men, women and children of different ethnicities, faiths, and
beliefs live side by side, work together, go to school together, and build
relationships with one another in peace. Is that idealistic? Yes, but I think
it is rooted in fundamental truths about our country. It is something to
cherish.
Our
country has radically transformed over the last 150 years. The process has been
painful and at times very difficult but it has brought us to the present
moment. Canada on its sesquicentennial has much to celebrate. So, on July 1st
take a moment to enjoy our shared country and the people who make it what it is
today.
Tuesday, June 6, 2017
Choosing Party Leaders
In
the wake of the 2015 both of the two opposition parties were forced to find new
leaders. Stephen Harper stepped down as long-time leader of the Conservatives
and shortly after the election the Edmonton convention forced Tom Mulcair out
as leader of the NDP. In May the Conservatives gathered together to announce
the selection of their leader, Andrew Scheer. Some controversy surrounds the
selection of Mr. Scheer, especially given the incredibly narrow victory he had
over Maxine Bernier.
My
party, the NDP, is also in the process of selecting a new leader. Last week I
had the pleasure of meeting Peter Julian (NDP - New Westminster-Burnaby, BC)
who is vying for the leadership race, and soon Guy Caron (NDP -
Rimouski-Neigette-Temiscourata-Les Basques, QC) will visit Brampton as well. As
I compared the leadership contest I could not help but wonder if the
Conservatives used a superior system to the one the NDP intends to use. Allow
me to explain.
The
Conservatives used a somewhat convoluted system, but the rationale was actually
very sound. There are 338 federal ridings. Each riding was allocated 100 points
as long as they had over 100 members. The points would be divided by the
proportion of support each candidate received. So if candidate A gets 30% of
the vote in Brampton South she got 30 points, candidate B for 25% of the vote
he got 25 points. The winner was the first candidate to get over half of the
points. Then preferential ballots were used to bump off the candidate with the
lowest vote total and was eliminated or redistributed.
In
contrast the NDP is using a one-member-one-vote system with preferential ballot
spaced over a couple of weeks. This will give members time to respond to thecandidates left in the race, as I understand it. The NDP system encourages a mass membership to help select the party leader. I
think there is benefit in spreading the vote out and allowing voters to respond
as it goes. I'm curious as to how that will impact media coverage.
However,
comparing the two systems I think the Conservative method has distinct
advantages over the one the NDP has used. The Conservative leadership selection
has two main advantages. First, it reflects how we elect governments. Until
Canada switches to another electoral system it makes sense for the selection of
a leader to match the first-past-the-post system in part. Before the 2011
election the NDP had a big problem: expanding beyond our traditional
strongholds. There were maybe 50 or 60 ridings that the NDP competed in at all,
but the party was nowhere in places across the 905 in Ontario, the vast
majority of Quebec, rural Ontario, Alberta, New Brunswick, etc. The party won
in traditional areas of the West, urban centres, and areas of the near north. A
one-member-one-vote system just reinforces our strengths were we are already
strong. If we want the die-hard membership in a handful of areas to pick the
next leader we are on that path.
The
benefits of the riding-centred approach to selecting a leader is that it
empowers local electoral district associations. When the Peter Julian visited
Brampton we had New Democrats come in from Scarborough, Dufferin-Caledon,
Mississauga, Hamilton and across Brampton come by. These scattered New
Democrats were eager to meet one of the candidates, but the way our leadership
system works the candidates have a great incentive only to visit strongholds
and big cities.
The
NDP needs to rebuild and grow its grassroots. I'm sure the leadership campaigns
will help do that, but I think the other method would produce a more robust
party at the end. I've spoken about this with long-time New Democrats and
received substantial pushback. The Conservative system is inherently unfair.
The 100 New Dems who might vote in Brampton South would be equal to the 1000 in
Parkdale-High Park. That's unfair, but it reflects our democracy as it is
currently constituted and winning Brampton South is theoretically as important
for the NDP as Parkdale. In a riding system the candidates are encouraged to
build the party where it is weakest and visit all communities in the country.
There
is no perfect way to pick a party leader, but I think there are clear
advantages and disadvantages to different systems. I think perhaps we should
put some thought into what we want our leadership contests to reflect and what
we want to get out of it for the parties we belong to.
Tuesday, March 28, 2017
Political Parties Shifting Gears: Opposition and Government
A
strange phenomenon occurs in our system of government after elections. If an
opposition party manages to unseat the government they have to switch sides.
Our parliamentary tradition is purposefully antagonistic. Opposition parties
are expected to criticize the government and challenge its policies. This
structure results in some very unusual moments when the newly displaced
governing party can begin to criticize policies they only weeks/months before
they were responsible for.
There
were some bizarre moments in the wake of the 2015 federal election where sharp
critiques came from the Conservative opposition. The Conservative Party were a
dangerous opponent to the inexperienced Liberal government because in many
cases the critic knew more about the ministry than the minister answering.
Parties
have to undergo significant transformations to make the transition successful.
The internal culture, language and structures of a party are quite different
between government and opposition. Oftentimes what makes a party succeed at one
would cripple it in the other. The Conservatives have succeeded in their
criticism in part because they have managed to hold on to the discipline the
maintained in government. Outside of the House the party shreds itself over the
leadership race, but interim leader Rona Ambrose seems to be doing a good job
holding feet to the fire.
I
think politicians and partisans must do a certain amount of double-think to
pull this off. Somehow the issue they didn't voice any concern over years in
power are a scandal on the opposition side. The move from government to
opposition can reveal factions within the party that had been muzzled for the
sake of party unity. Stephen Harper ran massive budget deficits during his
tenure, but budget hawks kept quiet. Now they can release their bile on the
Trudeau deficits. Unmanaged these factions can tear a party apart. However, the
leadership race that accompanies this sort of switch is often a battle of the
soul and who is best posed to challenge the new government.
As
a New Democrat I am used to my party being on the opposition benches. There is
a strange thing that happens with that party as well. As the target changes so
does the rhetoric. The NDP can have a more difficult time finding a way to
criticize centrist Liberals than right-wing Conservatives. The Harper
government could be a crisis of democracy but Trudeau, well... This issue is
particularly noticeable for Liberals if they have to switch from criticize the
NDP to the Conservatives, or vice versa, as has happened in the provinces.
Much
has been made of how the Trudeau Liberals and Harper Conservatives are
increasingly resembling each other, especially as the Liberals move to curtail
debate. Ultimately there seems to be patterns in our politics that often
transcends party. These changes in position force a rethink of party positions
and posturing. For the NDP, does the party make another bid for government? Do
they aim to recapture Official Opposition status first? Or, does it return to
being the permanent third (fourth/fifth) party? How they choose to challenge
the Liberals and select as a leader will determine that result to a great
extent.
Tuesday, February 21, 2017
Draft Nathan Cullen?
After
the Edmonton Convention and Tom Mulcair was pushed out by delegates the
lethargic NDP leadership race got underway. A number of the prominent
candidates from 2012 begged off competing. For many of them it made a lot of
sense. Several of them had lost their seats in the Liberal victory in 2015, not
to mention they are five years older now.
Several
promising candidates said that they were not inclined to run. Brian Topp is
working with Rachel Notley's NDP government, now the only NDP government left
in the country. Megan Leslie, the young, popular former MP from Halifax, said
that she was not ready to re-enter the political arena. Conversations with the
media indicated that she was emotionally exhausted after the difficult
campaign. She now works at WWF Canada.
One
leadership candidate offered a more nuanced explanation for why he wasn't
running for leader in 2017. Nathan Cullen finished third place with 24% of the
vote in 2012. When asked if he would run again he cited three reasons why he doesn't wish to run. First, he didn't think it was best for his family.
Leadership and Ottawa are distant from his wife and family. A valid
consideration and one I do not begrudge the British Columbia MP. Second, his
riding is Skeena-Bulkley Valley, one of the remotest ridings from the capital.
He stated that for the sake of the constituents he served them better as MP. The third reason he cited is that he wanted to focus on the upcoming Special Parliamentary
Committee on Electoral Reform.
While
I will not presume to speak for the personal considerations one of these
factors has changed immensely. After Justin Trudeau broke his promise to
implement electoral reform Nathan Cullen was furious. He has aggressively
criticized the government and been effective both in committee, during Question
Period, and in the media.
The
NDP has faded into the background since the election, and especially since Tom
Mulcair was given the boot. Nathan Cullen is one of the few members of the
party who have kept the party at the centre. He managed to apply pressure
smartly and use the media to force the government to not hold a Liberal
majority on the Electoral Reform Committee, and formed a consensus with
opposition members to produce a consensus report.
New
Democrats, I believe, want a leader who is passionate and can take the fight to
this government. They want a full-throated criticism of the Trudeau Liberals.
All of these broken promises almost always go against the progressive promises
Liberals made. A savvy NDP leader could take great advantage of these Liberal
failures and begin making the case for why progressives should not and cannot
trust Trudeau and his government.
I
supported Nathan Cullen in 2012 and think he has something to offer. He could
build a platform around being the true progressive voice in Canada and
guaranteeing electoral reform. Cullen offers a charisma and humour that would
be welcome at the head of the NDP.
While
draft has an unwanted connotation of force. If Mr. Cullen and his family's
consideration hasn't changed, then I accept that. However, as I look at the
current and assumed line up of candidates I know I am still looking for
something different. I hope Mr. Cullen changes his mind and reconsiders
leadership of the New Democratic Party.
Tuesday, February 7, 2017
Sigh... Electoral Reform
If
you have electoral reform advocates in your life or on your social media
accounts you have no doubt received an earful in the last few days. Prime
Minister Justin Trudeau and his new Democratic Institutions Minister Karina Gould
(LPC - Burlington, ON) announced their intent to abandon electoral reform. Like
those I mentioned I was furious. As far as I am aware this is the closest
electoral reform has gotten to being achieved at the federal level. That is
also pretty pathetic.
I
think it is fair to say that electoral reform is probably on life support
federally for at least ten years and probably longer. The Liberals blatant
mismanagement and betrayal of their commitment likely means that the Liberal
Party will not be trusted on this file for a long time by advocates. Instead of
wallowing in anger and misery I'd like to take a little bit of time to see what
we can do differently in the future.
Too
often in Canada the governments leading the charge for electoral reform have
been half-hearted at best. They seem to stumble into the issue and blindly move
forward until it is ultimately defeated. The next parliament/legislature that
begins to move forward on electoral reform needs to actually fight for it. I
think if the Liberals were open about having skin in the game and preferences
it would have been better. Let them advocate for preferential ballots
forcefully. It's not the type of reform I want but at least it would be a
position to debate rather than the shell game. The Canadian public is never
going to come to a 'consensus' on this issue without leadership. I think a
Prime Minister/Premier who proposed proportional representation and tried to
make the case for it may very well succeed.
The
other side of the equation is the public. Public engagement on this issue will
never be very high, but their comfort and familiarity with the topic needs to
be such that they don't immediately reject the questions. Some of the Electoral
Reform Committees work on sussing out values rather than positions was
valuable. The next time this issue comes up a citizens assembly can be guided
by that information and then the proposal can be clearly communicated to the
public. Any system can be explained in a five minute video more or less. CGP
Grey proved that long ago.
Finally,
advocates need to communicate so that they seem less like superior zealots. A
lot of thought leaders in media and academia found the rhetoric from leading
advocates to be distasteful. I think they let their passion blind them to the
reality. Reformers will need allies in the media, political parties and
academia to lend credence to their push.
Right
now reformers are probably best off letting the federal issue go. Introducing
alternative forms to the municipal and provincial levels of government seems a
wiser effort at this time.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


