Cyberpunk
has long been a genre that has fascinated me but that I don't know a lot about.
I've tried to educate myself on the genre, but with many things there are some
things I love and some things I did not. However, as I reflect on the core
tenets of the cyberpunk genre I more and more believe that it is primed for a
renaissance.
So,
what is cyberpunk? As with many genres nailing it down to a specific definition
is not simple. I would say that cyberpunk is a subgenre of science fiction that
emerged in the 1980s and 1990s with a focus on cybernetic, modifications,
virtual reality, computers/artificial intelligence, and telecommunications
technologies with themes related to the gulf between rich and poor, crime, and oppressive/dystopian
urban environments. It often adapts a cynical or pessimistic tone. A few famous
entries in this genre are Neuromancer by William Gibson, Blade Runner, The
Matrix. On that definition alone I'm
sure it's clear in part why I think we're ready for this genre to dominate
culturally. Aesthetically the genre tends to build a lot from its roots in the
eighties with heavy Asian influences, neon lights and call backs to Noir.
Given
the deep anxieties about the tech sector, the concerns about the concentration
of power and influence in the hands of a few corporations and the political,
economic and social issues rolling through the world cyberpunk feels quite apt
as a tool for critique. Some may argue that this is already happening.
Television programs like Westworld are arguably cyberpunk. The Blade Runner
revival was critically acclaimed, as were films like Ex Machina. As we
routinely have to wrestle with questions of morality and ethics regarding
technology creative people will find utility in this genre. Also, as we
consider the possibility of birthing true artificial intelligence we will have
to deal with that particular fallout.
There
is a slight irony that cyberpunk may simply become life. As more of the
technology of the cyberpunk future enters reality and grows into the mainstream
eventually that aspect may fade in relevance. Still, I think we're sitting at a
critical moment in time when the genre could and should undergo a revival to
help us culturally deal with these tensions.
Some
of my favourite cyberpunk works have been The Wind-Up Girl by Paolo Bacigalupi,
The Diamond Age by Neal Stephenson, Altered Carbon, and Dredd. That's just a
short list. Below is a video game trailer for something that definitely shot my
interest in the genre in the arm. If these themes, concepts and topics intrigue
you I encourage you to explore the genre.
I
had a pair of conversations this week that goes together with some recent news
that I found irritating. The news was that the Disney Corporation may be
seeking to buy out 21st Century Fox. The conversations with my friend involved the artistic hollowness and
shallowness of the film industry and culture more broadly.
I
would like to think I am not a terribly naive person. Popular culture is a
business enterprise. That's fine, since the time of patrons and master
craftsmen artists have needed supporters to financially back them. But for
those who love to the market it might be time to consider the consolidation of
our cultural industries.
An
alarmingly small number of massive corporations produce most of our popular
culture, especially in the areas of film and television. Furthermore, these
companies are often deeply entwined with one another in business deals and
frequently share common interests. If you want to see the twists copyright laws
they are a good case in point. Disney perhaps is the peak of these oligarchs, and
I fear nostalgia and positive associations deflects much of its criticism.
Defenders
of, or those comfortable with, these few titans dominating our cultural life
might point to the "meritocracy" of services like Twitch or YouTube which
allow 'anybody' to find their own audience and create content and share it
widely. Both are platforms owned by massive companies, Amazon and Google
respectively. We have many example of creators running afoul of these company
and losing their businesses, demolishing the illusion of their independence.
Market concentration has made competition incredibly difficult as has the
simple reality of creating such a service in 2017.
While
many enjoy the products of these few dominant media companies the consolidation
and death of meaningful competition is a concern. Disney has being pressuring
distributors for special treatment for the upcoming Star Wars film. Though distribution is also problematic, this can happen as companies become
excessively dominant in the market. The space for small, independent artists is
dictated by large companies over again. A rich culture is a diverse culture
that takes risks. It may be time to shatter the oligarchy that dictates the
terms for the films and television we watch.
Hot
Girls Wanted was a 2015 documentary that Netflix produced into a six episode
documentary series. In advance I will warn the reader that the series deals
with explicit sexual content so those who may be offended should likely avoid
it. The series was the work of Rashida Jones, Jill Bauer and Ronna Gradus.
If
I had to describe the series I could say it displays the gritty intersection
between modern sexuality and technology (especially the internet and smart
phones). From my perspective the documentary is tasteful and explores topics
like pornography and sex without showing excessive nudity.
I
think the way human sexuality has been filtered through technology over the
last 20 years is fascinating. Moreover, I think the reciprocal effects this has
had on our culture is fairly disturbing. The documentarians go out of their way
to highlight relevant statistics that illustrate the content they are sharing.
For example, the prevalence and widespread use of porn, the accessibility to
and interest minors have with pornography, and the cultural implications of pornography.
I
figure at this stage it would probably be best to give you an idea of what each
episode deals with. In the first episode they discuss feminist porn/porn
produced by women and how the changing business model of pornography is making
it more difficult. Episode two looks at casual dating apps like Tindr and its
impact upon relationships. Episode three looks at the world of 'talent'
recruitment in pornography and the way the industry chews up young women. The
fourth takes a look at male talent in the pornography business, but also the
disturbing depictions of race and women within mainstream porn. The fifth looks
at camgirls and the relationships that form between models and their big
donors. It does this by looking at one pair in particular who meet in person.
Finally, the last episode examines the court case of a young woman who recorded
a rape and streamed it on the internet.
I
can easily see how some readers of my blog will be repulsed by these topics.
It's not exactly the regular fare of this blog, certainly. One point that the
documentarians return to again and again is the ubiquity of porn. If it isn't a
part of your life than it is part of most of those close to you and it is
shaping the society you live in. Episode two is probably the most accessible
for those who wish to avoid graphic content.
The show is at times ugly and unpleasant, but also contains within it genuine emotion beyond pity and sadness and shame. Pornography and sex is still deeply rooted in shame. Despite the social acceptance of it, to a certain degree, those who participate in it, profit from it, produce and feature in it will be tarred. Given its widespread appeal I think the documentary challenges our inherent hypocrisy on that.
I
find monitoring and observing our changing attitudes about sex, sexuality,
romance, and love to be perhaps one of the most compelling topics that one
could explore at present. I would love to see Turned On do many more seasons. I
highly recommend it to those interested in these topics and with a constitution
to match the content. Give this provocative series a watch and hope that they
can continue to dig into these ideas.
I'm
definitely late to this party, but it is one of those pieces of fiction that
has stuck with me over the last couple of months. See the trailer here.
Perhaps
the most successful component of The Handmaid's Tale is the introduction to the
world of Gilead. Gilead is the fundamentalist republic which has displaced that
United States government. When we are first introduced to the world of The
Handmaid's Tale is alien and strange. The expressions are meaningless to us,
the clothes are foreign or unfamiliar, and the culture is almost
unrecognizable. Of course, it's not foreign completely, the place is still
recognizable as North America, the language is American English, but there's
something deeply wrong. The best part of the entire series, in my opinion, are
the flashbacks.
Our
main character, June/Offred, played by Elizabeth Moss, often reflects on her
time before she was assigned to be Commander Waterford's handmaid. Handmaids,
for those who haven't watched the show or read the novel, are fertile women
assigned to the elite families in order to produce children. Human fertility
has plummeted and the number of successful live births has decreased
significantly. Therefore controlling fertile women is seen as critical for the
survival of humanity. June's life in the near-future over the course of several
episodes illustrates how everyday life was undermined by the slow crisis and
created the condition for radical social transformation and oppression.
Two
flashbacks in particular stand out. The first I wish to call out is when June
gives birth to her daughter, Hannah. The hospital is surrounded by dozens of
people praying for the mother's going into the maternity ward and for the
newborns within. The maternity ward feels more like an abandoned wing of the
hospital. June goes with a nurse and her child to a vacant nursery. All of the
other children have died or worsened over night. Perhaps more significantly,
the nurse is the first character chronologically, as far as I can remember, to
use the religious extremists expressions "Under His eye," and
"Blessed is the fruit." It seems natural but it disturbing knowing
where such believe inevitably will lead.
The
second flashback takes place at a future date from the one discussed above. The
interim government passes a law that bars women from work and transfers
ownership of their bank accounts to men in their lives (husbands, fathers, what
have you). June and her friend Moira (Samira Wiley) join a group to protest
this radical changes. The protest turns violent in a dramatic scene where the
religious authorities open fire upon them.
Another
call out I will make for the show is the story of Ofglen, played by Alexis
Bledel. Her appearance in the show is comparatively brief, but does a great
deal to show the reach of the world and its darker elements. While I think the
"Canada as utopia" trope is a bit heavy-handed I liked all of the
elements of Americans trying to seek refuge, or figure their lives out in
Toronto is pretty compelling.
The
show is ultimately about women, their bodies, and control. Sex is often used in
the show to demonstrate some point about those three elements. Those scenes can
be long and uncomfortable, but I believe that's the point. The viewer is
suppose to confront the scenes and deal with it.
Though
I should spend more time on it I'll briefly say that the show is stunningly
beautiful. The cinematography is very powerful and captures the colour and mood
of the world perfectly. In many ways the world is desaturated of colour, but
not to the extent that it is rendered lifeless, merely stark. The music and
sound design are appropriately ominous and foreboding at the right moments and
guides you appropriately through the story. The performances are very strong,
particularly from Yvonne Strahovski and Ann Dowd.
I
would recommend The Handmaid's Tale, but I would have the caveat that the show
is quite violent, including sexual violence of many different kinds. This is a
world where women are explicitly objects. That their autonomy, rights and reproduction
are the exclusive domain of powerful men. This review does not encapsulate the
show, but if at all interested I would recommend giving the pilot a watch.
I
am a supporter of a podcast call The Mixed Six.
As a reward for backing the podcast I get the privilege of submitting questions
for the hosts to answer. The two hosts are well-educated and modestly
inebriated men having heady conversations over beers. The conceit is basically
the best conversations I have with my friends after about three or more beers.
I submitted a question on the week of Canada for their perspectives on Canada
and its influence on American debates as Americans, which they answered in episode
19. They are both lefties, it is safe to say, and I found both of their takes
interesting and it inspired some thinking on my part.
It
is no secret that Canada is often used as a prop during American political
debates. Our country plays an important role in the rhetorical exchange of Americans,
but the interesting thing it isn't Canada itself that plays a part in this
debate, it is the conception of America. Both Spencer and Caleb of The Mixed
Six cottoned onto this distinction immediately. Discussions in America about
Canada aren't really about Canada for the most part, they are about America.
The same is true to a lesser extent here, but Canadians have a greater
familiarity with American and vice-versa so it's possible that our
conversations are more grounded in the real experience of American lives.
Depending
on an American's given political perspective Canada can be an illustration to
how thing should/could be or an abject lesson in policy failures. For the
conception of Canada the facts as relates to this is entirely irrelevant. Perhaps
the best case study for this is to look at how Americans discuss our healthcare
system. For many on the American left Canada is a model for what healthcare in
the United States could be. We have universal care that does not exclude any
Canadian on the basis of wealth. Even as a person familiar with these issues in
America I don't understand American
healthcare. How many times have you heard distortions about the nature of our
healthcare? I don't view it as perfect, but it's certainly offers trade-offs
I'm willing to accept. From the conservative point of view we live in a
rationed system of long wait times and privation. Both sides caricature life in
our country as a stick to beat the other, not to say anything about Canada.
This
fetishization of Canada is epitomized during controversial elections and with
coverage of our 'beloved' Prime Minister. It was widely reported that the
Canadian immigration website crashed on the night of the American election and
the days followed it. Liberal/progressive Americans often use the refrain that
if a conservative wins they will flee to Canada. It is a convenient short-hand
to reject the reactionary element of American political life. It's not truly
rooted in a sense of Canada as a real place. Likewise the humiliating fawning
the world does over our Prime Minister really fails to paint an accurate
picture of his government or its policies. Would international press celebrate
his feminist credentials if they saw the arms deal to Saudi Arabia? Or the way
junior female cabinet ministers have been repeatedly thrown to the wolves? Or
what about his broken promises on key electoral issues, or he violation of his
government's commitments to Indigenous Canadians?
While
familiarity breeds contempt I think is more accurate to say American
familiarity with Canada has created complacency. Canada is as different as a
subset of America, like how California or the South is distinct from the rest
of the country. Canada is America but with French people, it's colder and has
healthcare.
Ultimately
this misrepresentation in foreign media reinforces and lends strength to those
comfortable in the status quo. The privileged can pat themselves on the back
because despite his flaws Justin Trudeau is not Donald Trump, which is hardly
convincing enough on its own. Doubling down on our own (unearned) smug
superiority is hardly helpful for Canadians. It's a curious mix of reactions.
On the one hand we want to be acknowledged for our successes without becoming
complacent by them.
Ultimately
very few of us know another culture, country or society. What we have is our
conception of them. Our broad understanding of these places drives our
reactions to them and perhaps provides tools for our own debates. While it may
be nicer to have the world understand us better I think it is more important to
be more critical of these reflections back on ourselves and not stare too
deeply into blurry that is so appealing.
Political
fiction, for reasons beyond my understanding, are incredibly difficult to do
well. I think it might be because I know just enough to break the suspension of
disbelief. I know enough of the norms of American, Canadians, and (to a lesser
extent) British politics to know what is reasonable and plausible. I suppose I
should say something like "asterisk Trump" but he, tragically, exists
within a certain norms.
Beau
Willimon, showrunner and creator of the American House of Cards, is a passionate critic of American politics so it
is easy to see these influences on the show.
I
consider myself an intelligent fellow and savvy viewer of television, yet after
13 episodes of House of Cards season
5 I feel reasonably confident I couldn't tell you what the hell is going on in
this season.
As
I start parsing the show I come up with easily a dozen plot lines but none hold
primacy, nor stand out. I suppose the primary plot is Frank Underwood's
desperate gamble to stay in power. He faces twin threats: a congressional
committee investigating his potential criminal acts and the election. The
latter is the far more interesting angle. Elections are fantastic sources for
drama and intrigue. Even the savviest politician in a democracy is powerless in
the face of the electorate's will. Willimon takes the audience through an
electoral crisis. Key states are unable to certify (confirm) their election
results due to widespread disruption. This throws the entire election into
question. While some of the wheeling and dealing is interesting the minutiae is
tedious at times, especially because the same characters flip-flop back and
forth.
House of Cards has a real
character problem. It doesn't know how to grow, develop, or introduce new
characters. Three major new characters joined the show, and for the life of me
I cannot tell you their names, nor could I while watching the show. I looked it
up, the characters I have in mind is Campbell Scott as Mark Usher, Patricia
Clarkson as Jane Davis, and James Martinez as Alex Romero. *Shrug*
I
hate to repeat myself, but much of my reservations about seasons three and four are only worse here. We are no longer co-conspirators with Frank. The audience
is left in the dark, or at least I was. The fun of the show is cold and dead.
All that's left are hollow twists purporting to be clever schemes.
It's
a real shame. The show has a some great moments and was truly exciting at
points. Here I'm particularly remembering those great fourth-wall-breaking
quips of Frank's. I hope the early season inspires future TV creators to
produce works that give the audience what season five fails to deliver.
This
post is going to be off from the usual fair on this blog. I hope you'll indulge
me.
Post-apocalyptic
literature is perhaps my favourite subgenre. I like post-apocalyptic video
games, movies, and novels. I even wrote my own novella in this genre. As a
result I think about problems within the genre and its conventions. Post-apocalyptic
fiction can be divided in many ways, but one of the ways is the time scale.
Most fiction is either set in the near-future or the distant-future. In the
first category you have entries like Station
Eleven, Dies the Fires (Emberverse
series), One Second After, The Book of Eli.
Most
post-apocalyptic fiction is written as a social commentary. Stripping away the
trappings of our modern society exposes root the human nature in the authors'
eyes and often the cause of the apocalypse is a comment on the things wrong
with our current world taking to their extreme conclusion. During the Cold War
we saw plenty of examples of post-apocalyptic fiction that examined the
consequences of nuclear war. The Stand and
Station Eleven look at our fear of
plague. Likewise a recent spate of media examines the impact of climate change
and how it may lead to the collapse of modern society.
Post-apocalyptic
literature is often not about the apocalypse itself, but rebuilding society and
what that looks like. The survivors band together for security and get to work
patching the world back together. Normally a handful of highly-skilled
characters lead their groups to some sort of sustainable, or progressive
future. The material written in the 20th century could generally rely upon a
large existing population with resources and skills to rebuild. Farmers, craftsmen,
mechanics and renaissance men and women use their squirreled away knowledge to
put things back in order. However, as we enter the 21st century I am beginning
to have real questions about how likely this sort of scenario is. This flaw has
two sides, the first side is the Into the
Wild problem. In the film Into the
Wild (spoilers) the protagonist goes off on an adventure in the Alaska
wilderness believing he has enough skills and knowledge to survive in the
wilderness. This ultimately results in his death. The vast majority of people
live in cities and possess few of the skills that would be required to pick
through the wilderness. Canned food could last perhaps five years but after
that they have to start preparing their own food. I've had gardens a few times
in my life but I have no idea how to collect seeds from my plants and make sure
they'll germinate next year, or when to plant them, or what conditions they
need. The average level of survival skills without modern conveniences is quite
low, I estimate.
The
second flaw is that our material environment is less well suited to a sudden
collapse in technology/maintenance. A growing number of machines require
functional computers, for example, our cars. We live in a digital and electric
world. These delicate pieces of technology will hardly be useful in their
absence. Even if you accept that there would be simple machines left behind
there is the question of materials. Many of the things our machines are made with
are advanced composites that are not easily replicable in some kitchen
laboratory or work shed. Even our intellectual resources are digital. In
several novels I've read the characters raid libraries for 'how-to' books to
acquire critical skills. The last time I was in the library the book shelves
were given less attention to computer resources. How many times have you talk
yourself something with a YouTube video? What if YouTube is gone/inaccessible?
Here
these two flaws marry together to create a real problem. Our highly
specialized, advanced economy means that our existing materials are difficult
to retrofit to primitive purposes and that we lack the skills to resurrect the
old skills. How many traditional carpenters, blacksmiths, masons, hunters, and
farmers do you know? How many horses are out there to move the ploughs when the
gas runs out? How many of those horse-driven ploughs are still out there? If
not, who knows how to actually make them? More and more it looks like a hard
crash at the end of any collapse.
One
of my favourite series, though it's fairer to call it post-collapse rather than
apocalypse, is The World Made by Hand
series. It is set a few years after our normal way of life has come to an end.
A huge number of people have dismally struggled to figure out how to survive in
the new world and barely scratch out a useful existence. Many simply fall in
line with resourceful leaders who need extra hands on their farm/commune.
Lawyers, insurance adjusters and real-estate agents have very little use in a
world where most people have to grow food for their survival.
In
nature when species become too specialized they are in danger of sudden
extinction when things change. Humanity and our economy in that sense is in
danger with a sudden economic/social/environmental/technological change. In
that case it may not be probable that humanity will bounce right back from the
apocalypse but enter a new Dark Age. This brings me to the second form of
post-apocalyptic literature; ones set in the distant-future.
A Canticle for
Leibowitz
is a beautiful set of stories that show humanity's attempt to recover from a
decimating nuclear war over centuries, and perhaps be ultimately trapped in a
cycle of violence. After the war humans revert to savagery and barbarism to
survive. Humanity gradually advances back through centuries of technology as
knowledge is lost and reclaimed. As I think about the trends in our culture and
economy I increasingly wonder if post-apocalypses will have to stick to this
formula to be plausible. Any fracture in our current system would likely result
in serious regression and we do not have easy access to the tools and
techniques to recover. I read an estimate once that it takes about a minimum
population of one billion people to maintain the level of technology and
sophistication we have today. It would have to be the right billion though and
have them connected with transportation and communications.
The
apocalypse is not terribly likely and isn't something one should dedicate much
serious concern on. However, it is a useful mental exercise. For me it forced
me to think about our values in our society and how strong they are in the face
of desperation. How long would democracy, tolerance, or gender equity last in a
world where life was nasty, brutal and short? How resilient are we right now if
everything went wrong?
Images
in the blog come from the following article
Normally
at the end of the year I write a blog post reflecting on the year. For months
now the common consensus among many is that 2016 was a trash fire of a year.
The combination of dismal international news, terrorism and tragedies, a
stagnant economy, the deaths of many prominent and beloved public
figures/entertainers, and the concerning outcome of the American elections is
enough to make it a dark chapter in the twenty-first century for many. With no
disrespect to the recent deaths, including Carrie Fisher today, if you're
measuring this year by that alone, you need to give your head a shake and consider
the recent massacres and tragedies in places like Syria, Istanbul, Orlando,
Berlin, Nice, Nigeria, Iraq and on, and on. But I digress.
And
now for a sharp, and graceless turn. Various media were important for mental
relaxation and de-stressing during 2016. I would like to share these with you and
perhaps it will encourage you to explore them yourself. I hope you can get as
much pleasure from them as I did.
Video
Games
#3
- Cities: Skylines (Plus After Dark and Snowfall DLC)
Cities:
Skylines to many, myself included, is the city-building video game that you've
wanted since you tinkered with SimCity, or sketched maps in the margin or
doodled skylines from your fantasies. Released in 2015 I purchased the game
this year and it was greatly enhanced by the release of two pieces of DLC, one
of which came out in 2016. The game allows an incredible degree of
specialization and detail work. It is incredibly open to mods. Artists (there
is hardly a better word for them) have meticulously reconstructed real cities
or designed environments the feel very real. In some ways it's more of a
sophisticated model-maker for some.
I
play the game as a city manager and simulation game. The sensitivity and
responsiveness of the game is remarkable. There aren't just roads, there are
roads of different widths and intents. You can have roads with bus lanes or
bike lanes, country roads, or arterials. The freeway system is essentially
freeform and allows an incredible degree of individuality. It permits a degree
of experimentation to figure out what configuration of roads and transit work.
Transit options include taxis, buses, trams/streetcars, heavy rail, and
subways. Properties and land grow and develop based on many factors and are
redeveloped to more sophisticated and denser buildings.
Perhaps
on the best additions to the genre is the district system. You can cater laws,
incentives, and regulations to give each neighbourhood a unique feel, just as
in real cities. Unlike SimCity the game feels grounded and far less cartoony.
When one of my cities are successful and well-designed I feel like I've created
a realistic place that could find a home in our world. The progress system and
intrinsic rewards make it a great way to invest leisure time.
#2
- Stellaris
I
am a science fiction nerd. I love the genre. When Paradox Interactive announced
their plan to make their own space strategy game I was incredibly excited.
Crusader Kings II , Europa Universalis IV, and Victoria II are among my
favourite games so I was interested to see how Paradox would tackle this
subgenre in their unique style. They did not disappoint.
Stellaris
breathes in all the major science fiction influences. Events, anomalies and
story elements are torn from Asimov, Heinlein, Dick, Clarke, Star Trek, Star
Wars, and many more. It comes across as loving homage. Players are given a wide
set of tools to create a unique species. As with Cities: Skylines mod support
is broad so already Mass Effect, Star Trek and other mods are in place to
introduce beloved species.
The
randomness in each galaxy I have played on creates exciting new options. The
tech tree means that there is not a "correct" way to play. Like the
Civilization series there are any number of ways to win. However, I would say
that playing a game of geopolitics in space (astropolitics?) there is no clear
end. Victory doesn't seem like owning the galaxy from one end to the other, in
my opinion. The answer this problem the game designers introduced late game
crises. Intergalactic invasion or artificial intelligence uprising can be the
final challenge for your space empire, star republic, or democratic galactic
federation.
If
you love science fiction and strategy I think this game offers a great deal.
Earlier this week I was playing my space empire of retile-like imperialists. I
encountered a signal from a gas giant. A group of non-corporeal beings begged
for help to migrate to a new home. I transported them to a new gas giant... but
then later they asked to move into a gas giant in my territory. I do not know
if this will go anywhere, but I love playing it out. First contact, space
battles, xenophobia, uplifting, it has it all.
#1
- The Witness
Released
early in the year I may have dedicated the most mental processing power to this
game during 2016. On the surface The Witness is a simple puzzle game but as you
play you uncover more and more meaning. There are multiple layers of puzzles in
the game and meaning. The game contains thoughts on truth and reality.
According to the designer Jonathan Blow The Witness is about truth. The world
is built to be consistent and coherent. An underlying logic holds the game
together.
Puzzles
and mysteries are at the core. Unraveling the game became somewhat an obsession
for me. At times I have considered meticulously documenting the entire game,
including things like the statues to see if there is any meaning I could
extract. Bringing up the statues I should take a moment to talk about the art.
I love the visual aesthetic of the game. I love the bright colours, the diverse
environments and the... magic for lack of a better word. There is a serenity in
The Witness.
There
is an immense sense of satisfaction in peeling back the layers of the island
and in solving individual puzzles. Portal 2 is perhaps my favourite game of all
time and The Witness is the first time I felt the same way in a long time. I
have a feeling it will stick with me for a long time.
Books
Non-Fiction
Paris
1919, reviewed on this blog, offers incredible insight in how World War I
shaped the world we live in today. For all the attention given to World War II,
the First World War has done a great deal to determine the world we live in
today. Diplomatic history is fascinating in how the petty relationships of a
handful of men determine the fate of states and nations. There is a great value
in better understanding this period.
The
Wind-Up Girl by Paolo Bacigalupi was a unique take on the future. In a world
decimated by climate change and resources are scarce the human and political
drama in Thailand is enthralling. The world is alive and horrifying, yet it
feels like a possible glimpse into our dark future. The story follows a western
business man trying to operate a factory in the corrupt Kingdom of Thailand but
through his actions, the actions of others, and random circumstances gets
caught in web of rivalries, treachery and violence.
Artificial
intelligence is a topic that captures my imagination. A series that is built
upon mystery, AI, incredible visual and social commentary is going to appeal a
great deal to me. I was not into LOST at the time, but I imagine the excitement
I felt discussing the show and theories with friends was what drove the
popularity and affection for that series. The incredible performances of actors
like Jeffrey Wright, Ed Harris, Anthony Hopkins and Sidse Babett Knudson made
sometimes flat writing gripping. Westworld raises questions that demand
reflection in regards to AI. The season was by no means perfect but it was
perhaps the most enthralling television I watched in 2016.
Honourable
Mentions: Black Mirror, Stranger Things, Pitch, The Circus.
A
few years ago Andrew Coyne gave a speech and he talked about why he thought
Parliament would be increasingly important and why our consensus on certain
issues meant that politics would transform. He argued that the neo-liberal
consensus would lead to new debates, debates about the nature of humanity and
address the questions that new technology has and will raised. Mr. Coyne seems
to have been disproved, at least for now, and my own theory is that the global
consensus on neo-liberalism is fracturing. Still, there are a number of issues
that the Canadian Parliament should start weighing before we are overwhelmed.
Artificial
intelligence is one of my favourite themes in science fiction. Over the last
couple of years popular culture has latched onto this concept and a number of
films and television series have come out exploring humanity's relationship
with artificial intelligence/sentience. The majority of these depictions are
negative, or threatening. The public clearly has some anxiety over the creation
of artificial intelligence. Writers like Nick Bostrom seem to be suggesting
that there are tangible dangers to AI and that precautions are required to
protect us.
As
far as I am aware there are no laws governing/regulating the development of artificial
intelligence. It would not be unreasonable, for example, to insist that
artificial intelligence be developed on air-gapped computers, or that all
programs or automatons have a built-in kill switch. The dangers of rogue AI are
so extreme that even modest precautions should be accepted at face value.
Beyond
paranoia (healthy as it may be) about the development of artificial
intelligence there are inevitable questions that will arise if we successfully
develop artificial life. If we create independent, autonomous beings as
represented in fiction like Westworld,
Ex Machina, Her, etc. what rights will be extended to them? Should any? Should
artificial beings be treated like biological citizens, or should they be
treated like, say, corporations? Corporations are legal persons but they are
not allowed to vote and do not exert other rights as living beings. If you
kill/disable an AI is that murder, property destruction? Will androids/AI be
owned? Is that slavery?
One
of the big questions about artificial intelligence is how will we tell if it is
real. Artificial intelligence designers may merely create things that are very
capable at imitating people, rather than genuine sentience. Then you get into
debates about sentience and the nature of humanity's consciousness.
One
of my concerns for years is that the creation of androids will exacerbate
issues of sexism and inhumanity. When you have the ability to exploit and abuse
things that are indistinguishable from humans the threat to broader society
seems fairly obvious. Creating intelligent, responsive beings for the sole
purpose of our pleasure and violent impulses is unsettling.
Obviously
the Canadian Parliament does not need to pass laws on these matters
immediately, but it would be wise to start raising these questions and laying
some basic regulations to protect ourselves from the worst case scenario. This
might be the perfect work for the Senate to take up. As much as this may sound
like science fiction, I think the trend lines are fairly clear we're heading in
that direction, so why not prepare for it?
There is a certain tactic
in play in the modern protest movement or in contemporary politics that I find
troubling, and frustrating. In the lead up to a speech by Donald Trump in
Arizona protesters blocked a highway to prevent people from attending the
event. I have major problems with this from a philosophical point of view.
Anyone who reads my blog or my Twitterfeed no doubt has a good sense of my
ideological issues with Trump. I think he is a horrendous candidate, but at the
same time I am not going to condone people from preventing people from seeing
the man speak.
Far too often it seems to
be the objective of groups to silence those they don't agree with. Trump is not
the outlier, though he may inspire a level of passion we do not normally see.
Last year an infamous men's rights activist (and shameless troll/self-promoter)
was scheduled to make speeches in a few Canadian cities. Mayors publicly stated
he was not welcome and several people called on the federal government to ban
him from entering the country. The mayors' interventions are fine, they are
politicians expressing their opinions. However, barring a person from entering
the country based on their political views is... troubling.
To be clear, it isn't just
people on the right. Leftists also have been targeted. Former British Member of
Parliament, George Galloway, for his positions on the Middle East and
associations was targeted by critics who claimed a person of his views was not
welcome in Canada. Anita Sarkeesian, culture critic who largely focuses on video
games, has had to cancel events due to threats of violence.
When speakers do get to
hold their events it is not uncommon for protestors to heckle, disrupt and
shout down the controversial figure. There is a long list of speakers who have
had this fate. On university campuses bioethicists and pro-life speakers are
particularly vulnerable, as are controversial political figures or politicians.
My idealistic streak tells
me that silencing ideas is not the way to win arguments or make change. Debates
are won and minds are changed through the exchange of ideas. The level of
comfort people have with silencing people rather than countering them is
disturbing. We'd rather live in artificially peaceful consensus than
contentious ideological and social strife. Censorship is a troubling thing and
while the state has largely removed itself from curtailing our speech and
assembly private interests seem very willing to create social censorship and
declare persons and topics non grata. Some progressives would say that the
messages these speakers share are actively harmful and promote existing power
structures and oppression. However, ending debate through disruption does not
move the needle on broader society, if anything it creates sympathies for the
target. More could be done by counter programming, protest, judicious
questioning, letters to the editor, and social media responses. In an era where
it is easier than ever to speak out it is odd how much effort is put into
shutting people up.
Warning:
The following contains light spoilers for The Walking Dead.
This
past Sunday was the fifth season finale of the immensely popular The Walking Dead. Because I am a big
political nerd I cannot help but notice that many of the seasons following
season one are wrestling with questions of governance. It should be noted that The Walking Dead is no way unique in
this. Post-apocalyptic literature, film, and television have often tried to
deal with the questions of rebuilding order when everything falls to hell. Part
of the explanation for this is the close relationship between the
post-apocalyptic and dystopian genres. Very few stories simply deal with the
aftermath of the collapse of the 'old world', but instead include the tendencies of our fellow man in dark and
twisted new societies.
If there's people, someone must be in charge.
Most
of the time in post-apocalyptic fiction the narrative focuses on a small group
of survivors, usually fewer than twenty. Is that really government? Government
is a complicated word and imbued with a lot of what we think of as the state.
Governing per se is nothing more than providing management and direction. The
lesson of most fiction indicates that lone wolves who exist outside of a
community or group are usually not long for this world. Any time two people
interact there are structures and patterns in place to 'govern' behaviour, but
as a group grows in size these patterns must be strictly outlined and made
formal. So, while a group of survivalists picking through the ruins of our
civilization may not seem the same as what happens in the House of Commons (or maybe
too similar...) there is a common thread there.
First
let's take a look at the arc of The
Walking Dead. Season one of the series was much more focused on the
question of what has happened and how to survive. Rick Grimes, a former sheriff,
and close associate of several among a group of survivors instantly becomes the
de facto leader. However tensions exist within the group, particularly with his
best friend and former colleague Shane. Season two and onwards much more
tackles the question of governance. In many ways the failures of the group can
be tied to factionalism and rival leadership camps. Famously at the close of the
second season Grimes says after challenging the group about his decisions,
"If you're staying, this isn't a democracy anymore." How to govern the group is often at the heart of conflict in the series.
Since
that point, despite the fact that Rick's power in the group has waxed and waned
and waxed again the fundamental element has remained in place that once Rick
has made a decision the group keeps to it. Instead of infighting the group has
produced a number of trusted advisors who counsel Rick (Herschel, Glenn,
Michione, Carol, to name a few), but ultimately stick with his policies, even
when they disagree. In brief, season three saw the consequences of Rick's
unchecked powers and approach. When the group was established inside the prison
in season four we see Rick relieved of leadership and a "Council"
take charge of running day-to-day affairs until things reach a crisis point.
Season five saw the return of Rick's advisor-assisted leadership. The central
conflict in the most recent season was the tension between two different
governing structures: Rick's group with a centralized, pragmatic and harsh
leadership style versus the more traditional, theoretically democratic and
lenient style of the Alexandrians. Remember, governing is not just about making
decisions and giving orders; how to carry out justice and relationships with
outsiders is also part and parcel of the responsibilities of leadership.
The Walking Dead is hardly
unique in this depiction. Within the zombie genre Max Brooks' World War Zrarely shows a vibrant democracy, but a much harsher, more centralized,
more militant, less democratic governance all around the world. The 28 Days Later/28 Weeks Later films depict military-based
governance, as does the video game TheLast of Us and TV series Falling Skies.
In all three cases the military is depicted as a means of providing security
(the most precious commodity in instability) but also oppression or containment
of the people they are protecting.
Communities tend to find creative places to call home after the end.
Interesting
enough is that even democratic governments that survive in many pieces of
fiction immediately take on extra-legal powers to control the chaos. In the
novel One Second After or the TV series Jericho)
the elected municipal governments begin acting like city-states to try to
survive in the absence of the state and national governments.
Another
common trope in the post-apocalyptic genre is the theocracy. In times of crisis
people often turn to religion as it is a powerful unifier that provides social
cohesion in a way a single leader often cannot. Margaret Atwood's A Handmaiden's Tale blends the military rule and religion quite nicely, but the results are the
same. James Kuntsler's series of post-collapse novels prominently features a strange religious group with a
prophet-like figurehead and a charismatic leader in the ruins of Upstate New
York.
The
theme repeated over, and over again in hundreds of books is remarkably similar.
The new leadership class tends to come from ex-military (Mike Havel in Dies the Fire),
police (Rick Grimes in The Walking Dead),
former/current politicians (Johnston Green or Senator Tomarchio in Jericho or the Warden in Children of Men)
or a charismatic, capable person (Carnegie in The Book of Eli or
Caesar in Fallout: New Vegas).
Ultimately the "Strong Man" governance all likely stems from the
inverse sentiment of the Benjamin Franklin statement, "Those who would
sacrifice liberty in the name of security deserves neither." As wise as Benjamin
Franklin was there exists many instances when centralized control is badly
needed in emergencies. Post-apocalyptic fiction trades on the fact that scared
people will surrender a great deal of authority to those who can protect them,
provide for them and keep them safe. To be sure this is not a new phenomena.
Think back to the Republic of Rome who would surrender its semi-democracy to a dictator
in times of profound crisis. In the modern United States there are any number
of provisions to institute martial law to keep order.
In my
opinion writers in this medium and consumers of it are attracted to
authoritative or authoritarian for some very simple reasons. While the
leadership model provides a structure for traditional hero narratives it also
harkens to our own thinking of how to deal with issues. In addition we admire,
just as the other characters within the narrative, competent and capable
leaders. It also helps from the perspective of elevating characters and
creating drama. Believe it or not, but The
Walking Dead and other post-apocalyptic fiction are deeply political. They
are not only critiquing social issues but providing a framework to work out
fundamental philosophical questions at the heart of governance and ethics that
have been debated since before Ancient Greece. I know a lot of people have had
the conversation/debate over what their "Zombie Survival Plan" is,
but have you ever thought what your plan to rebuild and get along with your
fellow survivors might be? Ultimately that's what might keep you alive longer
than any machete or canned food.
The
politicization over what women should or should not, or can or cannot wear is
nothing new in this or many other countries. In recent weeks the issue has
swirled stemming from a Muslim woman who wants to take the oath of citizenship
wearing a niqab. In case you are unaware the niqab is a head scarf that women
wear that also covers the face, excluding the eyes.
Hijab on the left, niqab on the right.
Our
Prime Minister says that covering one's face while taking the oath of
citizenship is contrary to 'normal' Canadian values. It's a pretty galling statement
given the huge number of Muslim immigrants and citizens in this country who
would theoretically share in defining those values. The hijab and the niqab in
particular agitate Western liberal sensibilities. While Western countries often
trumpet their support of freedom equally important are concepts like general
legal equality and secularism. These traditional garments challenge all three
principles in the eyes of some: Freedom - it is forced upon people, equality -
it is imposed only on women to enforce modesty, secularism - it is a blatant
and conservative expression of religiosity. In some places, Quebec and France
for example, the liberal feminist element views it as an oppressive tool and
therefore seek to ban them.
The
rhetoric on how women dress is as tiresome as it is rote. Aside from basic
standards of decency, the state should not be involved in dictating how women
(or anyone) should be dressing, nor should individuals be compelled through
intimidation or threats by their family members to dress a certain way. A
liberal society is about freedom of action and freedom of choice, or have we
forgotten that? It manifests in all cultures, but in North America is usually
consists of insisting women where longer skirts, higher collars and less
form-fitting items.
Having
grown up in Brampton I recall the conversation more than a few times. I went to
schools with a few girls who wore hijabs. Every once in a while someone would
ask why they wore it and if they were forced to. While strictly anecdotal each
of them always replied that it was a choice that they had made and that they
liked it. These were young Canadian women making decisions for themselves.
Obviously they came from a cultural context where that was suggested or
encouraged but they made the choice for themselves, and ultimately have the
freedom to change their mind if they decide it no longer suits them.
If
the issue about the citizenship oath is that people cannot see the woman's lips
move and prove she is giving the oath then we better prepare to make people
give the oath one-by-one. Or have people who cover their faces give the oath in
private so that they can clearly be heard saying the words.
I'd
hope that the Prime Minister's comments are not solely motivated by politics.
Canadians are feeling insecure and suspicious of Islamic extremism, perhaps the
most since the years immediately following 9/11. There is little to fear,
especially on the question of what people wear or don't wear. That is not where
the country breaks.
People's
personal fashion should not be a matter of public opinion. It should not matter
what the broad public thinks on an issue of personal choice. That's what
freedom is in a country such as ours.
I try to think of myself as a progressive man, but I fall
within many categories that place me in a privileged position in society. I am perceived
as white (despite not having a purely European background). I originate from a
middle-class family and currently earn a comfortable living. I am heterosexual
and cisgendered, and, most importantly to my comments that follow, I am male. I
offer this as a prelude because on this topic I feel disclosing how a person
self-identifies is a valuable piece of information for understanding their
comments and perspective.
I am not sure if it is because of the growth of critical
analysis of more topics in popular culture, or the fact that I am more
interested and so follow up on articles that discuss these topics, but regardless
I have read many more feminist or gender-issue articles over the last year on
popular culture. Popular feminist figures in new media such as Laci Green and Anita Sarkeesian have helped to broaden my perspective, along with the formal education I
received at university.
As far as I understand it the basic premise of feminism
is that all people are equal and that historic prejudices and power structures
exist within our society and institutions that disadvantage certain groups. As
a historian this is a very difficult premise to disagree with. I do not have
the space here or the knowledge to outline the historic development of this
important movement, but it is fair to say that how this end is accomplished has
been hotly contested.
I’ve wanted to write on this topic for a while. My
interest in writing about this topic has been spurred on by three issues that
pointed out that social problems are more imbedded than most of us are
comfortable admitting.
GamerGate. Sigh. GamerGate is the catchall term to describe the vociferous
attacks, online and real-life, directed towards women in the video game
industry and the media outlets that cover them. These attacks are perpetrated
under the banner of “ethical journalism” that doesn’t even provide a fig leaf’s
worth of decency for the most horrendous misogyny the internet can offer up. For
example, Ms. Sarkeesian has been targeted with threats to her life and public
talks where she is critical of tropes of video games damaging depiction of
women.. Several women have been harassed and had their private residences
shared on the internet forcing them to leave their homes.
GamerGate is particularly disturbing because video games
have done a lot in the last few years to shed the “boy’s club” and overtly
sexist appearance. A growing cast of interesting video games, designers and
studios are creating experiences and characters much more relatable as human beings
and not just digital eye-candy. Still, the medium has a lot more work to do.
There are real questions of ethics in the video game industry, but this has
been made irrelevant in the witch hunt. Sex sells and there are more than
enough depictions of elf-maidens in bikini-armour out there to depress anyone
hopeful for the future of video games.
In Canada media the firestorm swirling around Jian
Ghomeshi once again highlights how we deal with prominent, powerful men accused
of sexual assault or violence against women. For various other crimes large
segments of the public would unquestionably consider the allegations against
Mr. Ghomeshi, but as is tragically typical of rape/assault cases the character and
credibility of the victim is the first questioned. I am embarrassed to admit
that my mind first went there. While I am not a fan of Mr. Ghomeshi I have
listened to and enjoyed his interviews and thought he was a valuable contributor
to Canadian media. The only protection his accusers seem to have is that they
are not alone and that Mr. Ghomeshi has left a trail of women behind in his
life who are now ready to stand together.
When a similar story happens to, for example, a college
football player I can easily and comfortably dismiss the defenders because that
person is not part of my cultural tribe. As a Toronto-based media icon and
progressive the willingness to accept Ghomeshi and openly reject his victims at
face-value proves that elements of rape culture and misogyny are not too
difficult to find when the perpetrators of these crimes are people we ourselves
are fond of. The treatment of these victims and how these crimes are handled
makes it no surprise that they go underreported.
The third piece of media I wanted to share was the video
recorded of a woman walking down New York City’s streets and the endless parade
of catcalls made after her. See the two-minute video below.
In my heart of hearts I hoped that brash New Yorkers were
more inclined to this behaviour. However my opinion was heartily rebuffed when
I was told by a journalist that his female friends often experienced harassment
and a former co-worker of mine reported serious, and threatening street
harassment twice in the space of a week. And upon reflection I can remember how
my friends were sometimes treated as we walked down the street and suddenly
this video did not feel so alien.
It should not matter what any of these women were
wearing. No one deserves to be harassed. No one deserves to be assaulted. No
one deserves to be attacked. In the cool, dispassionate mind many would accept
this. Except we don’t. Many of us still cannot help but blame the victim
because we are socialized to believe that women are not in control of their own
bodies.
One of the reasons I am writing this piece is that I deal
with these contradictions. Do I respect women more or less because of their
appearance? Do I judge a woman on how she’s dressed rather than who she is?
While I think a woman should dress as she pleases do I still quietly slut-shame her? It’s the contradictions in our culture that further confuse and
problematize these issues. A popstar dancing in limited clothing in front of a
giant lit sign reading “FEMINIST” seems to drip with hypocrisy to me, but conflict among the intelligentsia
can’t seem to determine whether or not this is a betrayal of feminism or
celebration. At least it’s not as dumb as a young actress declaring that she’s
not a feminist because she “loves men.”
Some of the most ardent misogynists are those who say
this is a settled issue. That sexism is “fixed” and that only those ardent
man-haters are the ones that want to talk about it. This is not a settled
issue. Across our culture and entrenched in our media are symbols and exploitation
defined by gender. More and more men are openly the victims of sexism as well
are their depiction in media becomes more masculinized and dissociated from
reality. Perhaps the great curse is that progress means both genders are
blatantly objectified now.
This is by no means a “correct” opinion. Given the
diversity of opinions and approaches I am confident that I have failed to
properly articulate these various perspectives in some way. Try as I might to
be a proper 21st century feminist man I am burdened and conflicted by a
socialization and culture and reinforces misogynistic values towards many
different groups. So far the only solution I have found is to actively
challenge the status quo both external to the world around me and, perhaps more
importantly, the world inside my head.
Last night I watched The
Agenda’s program on youth participation with our democracy. Below I’ll post
the videos of the episode.
Millennials Discuss Democracy
Democratic Observers weigh in
The host, Steve Paikin was trying to get to the core of
why only 38.8% of Millennials bothered to vote in the 2011 federal election. Sadly
Mr. Paikin did not come up with many (or any) answers. As I watched my peers I
could not help but think that perhaps our attention is on the wrong side of the
equation. Much attention has been given over to the system failing young
people, but could it be that young people are also failing the system?
Anyone who has read this blog for any length of time
would know that I’m a democracy nerd and political junkie. It’s something I
care about and invest a great deal of time and effort into. This makes me an
outlier, which I accept. I don’t expect every citizen to be as engaged as I am
as they undoubtedly have passions of their own. I began to wonder whether or not the
certain zeitgeist of millennials means that they are inured to politics.
Looking at the twenty-somethings on the panel last night
it was clear that they were all articulate, well-educated, and quite savvy. It’s
likely that the producers at TVO worked to find an exceptional group, and one
that would stand out for the reasons that you’d think they would be leaders in
politics today. Beneath their positive qualities ran deep cynicism for
politics, politicians and democracy. Even those who espoused concerns and
political positions seemed to view participation within our democratic system
as a bit of a fool’s errand, or at least as deeply unappealing.
Politics was likened to marketing, yet the objective of
being sold to and appealing to constituents to build a mandate should not be
interchangeable. Millennials are savvy and understand the tactics of media and
marketing firms. When politicians and parties try them they are instantly
recognizable and rejected.
I could not help but sense that my peers on the program
were fundamentally missing the point. By not participating at all they were
dooming themselves to irrelevance. Many in Generation Y prefer to observe the
system and critique than get their hands dirty and try to repair it. Jane
Hilderman of Samara, in the second clip above, highlighted that man Millennials
participated in informal democracy, but ultimately we are governed through the
formal process. Petitions and rallies can be easily ignored while candidates, voters
and movements cannot.
I’m not sure any of the panel would be satisfied in our
system. They seek “authentic” candidates that express their values. I cannot
help but wonder if politicians who deviate only slightly from their ideals
would be considered a waste of time, or irrelevant. Perfection becomes the
enemy of the good and thousands render themselves silent in preference to an
alternative that does not exist.
I suppose my question is whether or not Millennials, a
generation jaded through media, marketing and entertainment, cannot operate
within a system built upon loyalty, trust and imperfect candidates and parties.
There may be an economic argument. The delayed adulthood due to debt, poor job
market and high housing costs means that Millennials are taking on the
responsibilities that drive people to vote later. Still that is no remedy and
if Millennials want the system to better reflect their values they will have to
start showing up.