Showing posts with label Multiculturalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Multiculturalism. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 24, 2017

Bill 62 is a Disgrace

Bill 62 is a disgrace. In the fullness of time it will be seen in the same light as separate drinking fountains for different races. It is a clear, cowardly attack on a cultural practice that applies only to a tiny minority.

In case you are unaware Bill 62 is a Quebec piece of legislation that will prohibit those covering their faces from receiving or providing public services on behalf of the government. While I appreciate Quebec has  a different tradition of secularism than English Canada it is hard not to see this as a targeted hit against Muslims.  I sincerely doubt the framers of the law had any concerns about excessively observant Catholic nuns in mind. The law is clearly intended to penalize Muslim women.

My values tell me that the state shouldn't be in the business of dictating our clothes (aside from basic decency). The hue and cry that these sorts of laws are intended to protect and liberate women seem, at best, paternalistic. In modern Canada we all access government services constantly. From buses to police officers, from driver's licenses to permit clerks, we frequently have to interact with public servants and depend upon their work.

In a secular society it is not required for the people not to profess their values or hide their religion, rather, it is the government that should be neutral and fair. This law hardly perpetuates the idea that Quebec government is an unbiased party. Instead it seeks to punish those who do not conform to its preferred group.

As a feminist raised in the West I do not like the niqab or the burka. At first blush they seems to be in the long tradition of controlling women's bodies and sexuality. That being said, I have no intent or desire to ban them or badger women who wear them. Nor would I prohibit mini-skirts for the opposite reasons. It's not my place. I've spoken with women who wear head coverings. They have been consistent that it is a choice they have made, and that they like it.

Quebec could do much for the Muslim women in its society. This act seems a declaration that a small subset and the broader community do not belong. While the law is likely to be struck down by the courts it would send a more powerful message for elected leaders to repeal it. I doubt that will happen. However, sometimes moral courage appears at surprising times.


Tuesday, March 17, 2015

The National Dress Code

The politicization over what women should or should not, or can or cannot wear is nothing new in this or many other countries. In recent weeks the issue has swirled stemming from a Muslim woman who wants to take the oath of citizenship wearing a niqab. In case you are unaware the niqab is a head scarf that women wear that also covers the face, excluding the eyes.

Hijab on the left, niqab on the right. 


Our Prime Minister says that covering one's face while taking the oath of citizenship is contrary to 'normal' Canadian values. It's a pretty galling statement given the huge number of Muslim immigrants and citizens in this country who would theoretically share in defining those values. The hijab and the niqab in particular agitate Western liberal sensibilities. While Western countries often trumpet their support of freedom equally important are concepts like general legal equality and secularism. These traditional garments challenge all three principles in the eyes of some: Freedom - it is forced upon people, equality - it is imposed only on women to enforce modesty, secularism - it is a blatant and conservative expression of religiosity. In some places, Quebec and France for example, the liberal feminist element views it as an oppressive tool and therefore seek to ban them.

The rhetoric on how women dress is as tiresome as it is rote. Aside from basic standards of decency, the state should not be involved in dictating how women (or anyone) should be dressing, nor should individuals be compelled through intimidation or threats by their family members to dress a certain way. A liberal society is about freedom of action and freedom of choice, or have we forgotten that? It manifests in all cultures, but in North America is usually consists of insisting women where longer skirts, higher collars and less form-fitting items.

Having grown up in Brampton I recall the conversation more than a few times. I went to schools with a few girls who wore hijabs. Every once in a while someone would ask why they wore it and if they were forced to. While strictly anecdotal each of them always replied that it was a choice that they had made and that they liked it. These were young Canadian women making decisions for themselves. Obviously they came from a cultural context where that was suggested or encouraged but they made the choice for themselves, and ultimately have the freedom to change their mind if they decide it no longer suits them.

If the issue about the citizenship oath is that people cannot see the woman's lips move and prove she is giving the oath then we better prepare to make people give the oath one-by-one. Or have people who cover their faces give the oath in private so that they can clearly be heard saying the words.

I'd hope that the Prime Minister's comments are not solely motivated by politics. Canadians are feeling insecure and suspicious of Islamic extremism, perhaps the most since the years immediately following 9/11. There is little to fear, especially on the question of what people wear or don't wear. That is not where the country breaks.

People's personal fashion should not be a matter of public opinion. It should not matter what the broad public thinks on an issue of personal choice. That's what freedom is in a country such as ours.

For more on this topic I recommend Aaron Wherry's piece in Maclean's.