Showing posts with label Debate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Debate. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 29, 2018

The Ontario Debate


On Sunday Ontarians had their last chance to see Kathleen Wynne, Andrea Horwath and Doug Ford face off in a debate. I think for those having a tough time deciding it actually might be quite valuable. I think the 90 minutes gives a good portrait of what the three leaders offer our province.





I think it's important for me to put my cards on the table for those who may be reading this without knowing my history. I am a long-time New Democrat, I plan to vote for my local NDP candidate and I hope Andrea Horwath is our next premier.

From my perspective both Kathleen Wynne and Andrea Horwath did well in the debates and Doug Ford struggled. One thing looked pretty clear to me, and I doubt objective observers could disagree - the experience of the leaders really showed. Horwath has a lot of experience in this sort of debate now, she seemed confident and prepared. Wynne has done this all before as well and was generally measured and able to respond. Ford sounded robotic and spouted slogans and rarely seemed coherent.

Wynne was confident talking about every policy area. Our current premier is strong in policy and it shows in a public performance like this. You may dislike her policies, but she has command over them and doesn't get tripped up on details.

Horwath to some would seem aggressive. She needed to defend her momentum and assert herself over her rivals. She seemed assured and spoke clearly about her platform while also pointing out the shortcomings in the PCs'.

Ford. Sigh. Ford appeals to some Ontarians I am sure, but it certainly isn't me. There was no denying that his speaking style mirrors that of Trump's. His declarations that that the 'economy will be great' and 'we'll see prosperity like Ontarians have never seen before' scream the same code. He has a simple message - trust us to cut your taxes and balance the books (somehow) and we won't cut services. A snake oil salesman will find his customers.

There is an intangible quality when watching the debates that you get that is hard to describe. The leaders' personalities come out and you get a sense of the person asking to be entrusted with governance of the province. I can't summarize that for you, but I advise you look into it for yourself.

And for the love of God, someone ban audiences from these things.

It's nine days until the election. Get out there and get informed, Ontarians.



Tuesday, January 23, 2018

Setting the Stage for the Next Debates

In Ottawa there is some discussion about what should be the terms for the next federal election debates. Canada has no regulation, as far as I am aware, regarding our national debates leading into a federal election. A gentleman's agreement of sorts was what governed how debates operated in this country. A media consortium worked together with the political parties to set the terms of the debates. 

For many years this system seemed adequate. I don't think Canadians were particularly engaged by the debates, but nor were they poorly served by them. In the 2000s, in the minority years, the public got to see politicians perform on equal footing and were well moderated by skilled journalists such as Steve Paikin. However, in the last federal election the Conservatives blew up the traditional consensus and offered to do debates with any number of media organization and in different formats.

In the 2015 federal election the Conservatives threatened to upend this system and the status quo. Prime Minister Stephen Harper's decision to withdraw from convention meant that we were poised to confront a reality wherein Canadians would have no debate as a platform to judge the candidates. Luckily some did manage to occur, but far fewer Canadians saw them than in previous years.

The Liberal government is exploring the idea of creating a commission for debates and enshrining it in law. Very few details are fixed as of yet, but there are some interesting ideas on the table. Financial penalties could be imposed to compel/encourage participation. The leader of the Green Party, Elizabeth May (GPC - Saanich-Gulf Islands, BC), has been leading in suggesting how parties/leaders should qualify to debate. She has suggested that participating parties have to have two of the three following criteria: a) received 4% or more of the national vote in the previous election, b) have an elected member of the House of Commons under that party's banner, c) be running candidates in most (or nearly all) of the country's 338 ridings.

All things considered it is a pretty reasonable benchmark to start with. Such a standard would allow the Green Part and the Bloc Quebecois to join the NDP, Liberals and Conservatives in the next federal leaders' debate. Unsurprisingly, the system isn't perfect. This would have excluded other parties from entering the debate that have in the past, such as the Reform Party.

With democracies under strain I think there is a good argument to look at formalizing institutions like this and strengthening them. The practice of a leaders' debate is an important part of the Canadian election cycle. We should never have to worry again if we can see our leaders answer questions and explain their policies as a group. While hardly perfect on its own I think that is something work protecting and building upon, if nothing else.




Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Silencing the Opposition or the Odious

There is a certain tactic in play in the modern protest movement or in contemporary politics that I find troubling, and frustrating. In the lead up to a speech by Donald Trump in Arizona protesters blocked a highway to prevent people from attending the event. I have major problems with this from a philosophical point of view. Anyone who reads my blog or my Twitterfeed no doubt has a good sense of my ideological issues with Trump. I think he is a horrendous candidate, but at the same time I am not going to condone people from preventing people from seeing the man speak.

Far too often it seems to be the objective of groups to silence those they don't agree with. Trump is not the outlier, though he may inspire a level of passion we do not normally see. Last year an infamous men's rights activist (and shameless troll/self-promoter) was scheduled to make speeches in a few Canadian cities. Mayors publicly stated he was not welcome and several people called on the federal government to ban him from entering the country. The mayors' interventions are fine, they are politicians expressing their opinions. However, barring a person from entering the country based on their political views is... troubling.

To be clear, it isn't just people on the right. Leftists also have been targeted. Former British Member of Parliament, George Galloway, for his positions on the Middle East and associations was targeted by critics who claimed a person of his views was not welcome in Canada. Anita Sarkeesian, culture critic who largely focuses on video games, has had to cancel events due to threats of violence.

When speakers do get to hold their events it is not uncommon for protestors to heckle, disrupt and shout down the controversial figure. There is a long list of speakers who have had this fate. On university campuses bioethicists and pro-life speakers are particularly vulnerable, as are controversial political figures or politicians.


My idealistic streak tells me that silencing ideas is not the way to win arguments or make change. Debates are won and minds are changed through the exchange of ideas. The level of comfort people have with silencing people rather than countering them is disturbing. We'd rather live in artificially peaceful consensus than contentious ideological and social strife. Censorship is a troubling thing and while the state has largely removed itself from curtailing our speech and assembly private interests seem very willing to create social censorship and declare persons and topics non grata. Some progressives would say that the messages these speakers share are actively harmful and promote existing power structures and oppression. However, ending debate through disruption does not move the needle on broader society, if anything it creates sympathies for the target. More could be done by counter programming, protest, judicious questioning, letters to the editor, and social media responses. In an era where it is easier than ever to speak out it is odd how much effort is put into shutting people up.