Showing posts with label Freedom of Speech. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Freedom of Speech. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 26, 2017

Considering Free Speech

There is a subject that has been troubling me. I won't pretend the 21st century is unique in facing illiberal political movements, but I live in this historic moment and feel compelled to note the links between a harder line left and the new right and the difficulty liberal democracies may be facing moving into the future. This post is partially spurred on the German election results, where the AfD gained significantly in the parliament. There have been moments in modern history where polarization in between extremes fractures the polity and wrecks the centre.

In the face of this how do liberal societies defend themselves from those who would use their principles to undermine them?

Today I want to narrow today's topic to the freedom of speech. A liberal, at core, would  not like to limit people's speech. The liberal position says that we need strong justification to curtail anyone's right. Libel laws or harmful speech (fire in the theatre) are obvious restrictions. For classical liberals restrictions are difficult decisions and they prefer to err on the side of speech.

Speech works if we can rely on some basic ground rules. However, the evidence abounds that lies and mischaracterizations spread like wild fire while the truth plods along. Liberal ideals are undone by the most basic human instincts, instincts which are all the easier to embrace in the digital sphere. Enter the era of "fake news." Even beyond the political, lies or misleading headlines stand at equal heights of fact. People are increasingly unable to filter information meaningfully. Look no further than the misinformation on vaccines to see how muddled and mired we are.

As a liberal-minded person I have to concede my discomfort with these sources of "information" or confirmation bias, but I'm not at all comfortable with interfering with these forms of speech.

Then there is hate speech. Here two sides of my thinking war with one another. Speech matters. It shapes thinking and attitudes. Calls for violence are illegal, and I think most can agree are reasonable restrictions for public speech. However, calls for violence are common on the internet and this speech is not curtailed in any substantial way. The debate then goes to what constitutes hate speech. Most people are canny enough to mask their racist rhetoric, or cloak it in policy language. Distrust of Muslims is cloaked in anti-refugee, terrorism, and geopolitics. Anti-black racism is buried in conversations on crime, poverty, and urban culture broadly. the coarse dialog (or rants) of the internet now infect our real world life. Things not uttered in 'polite society' are now bellowed proudly.

Liberalism is a modernist idea and relies on reason, rationalism, and truth. How does it operate in a world where half-truths and lies rule, or at least easily remain on par?

The current debate of free speech is rather odious, in my opinion. Progressive voices seek to silence certain forms of speech deemed inappropriate. It has a streak I find deeply troubling. Protest to disrupt speakers, regulating the use of language, and the bevy of terms to police language seem to belittle real oppression for the sake of bourgeoisie sensitivities of the intelligentsia. To be clear, I am not joining the ranks complaining about all silly university antics.

The right has corrupted free speech as a notion to its own purposes. In reaction to the left they now claim free speech. However, free speech is increasingly used as coded language for expressing racist, bigoted opinions free of consequences.

the last few years has helped to demonstrate to me the power of language. Leaving some to routine abuse by those trying to assert historic dominance makes me uneasy. That said I'm not sure I'd comfortable regulating speech. But speech can be used to undermine a liberal society. Critics may answer the solution is more speech, but I fear there are growing indications that those that seek to distort our polities are fighting with guns while liberals only have knives. This thought is one that worries me.

Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Silencing the Opposition or the Odious

There is a certain tactic in play in the modern protest movement or in contemporary politics that I find troubling, and frustrating. In the lead up to a speech by Donald Trump in Arizona protesters blocked a highway to prevent people from attending the event. I have major problems with this from a philosophical point of view. Anyone who reads my blog or my Twitterfeed no doubt has a good sense of my ideological issues with Trump. I think he is a horrendous candidate, but at the same time I am not going to condone people from preventing people from seeing the man speak.

Far too often it seems to be the objective of groups to silence those they don't agree with. Trump is not the outlier, though he may inspire a level of passion we do not normally see. Last year an infamous men's rights activist (and shameless troll/self-promoter) was scheduled to make speeches in a few Canadian cities. Mayors publicly stated he was not welcome and several people called on the federal government to ban him from entering the country. The mayors' interventions are fine, they are politicians expressing their opinions. However, barring a person from entering the country based on their political views is... troubling.

To be clear, it isn't just people on the right. Leftists also have been targeted. Former British Member of Parliament, George Galloway, for his positions on the Middle East and associations was targeted by critics who claimed a person of his views was not welcome in Canada. Anita Sarkeesian, culture critic who largely focuses on video games, has had to cancel events due to threats of violence.

When speakers do get to hold their events it is not uncommon for protestors to heckle, disrupt and shout down the controversial figure. There is a long list of speakers who have had this fate. On university campuses bioethicists and pro-life speakers are particularly vulnerable, as are controversial political figures or politicians.


My idealistic streak tells me that silencing ideas is not the way to win arguments or make change. Debates are won and minds are changed through the exchange of ideas. The level of comfort people have with silencing people rather than countering them is disturbing. We'd rather live in artificially peaceful consensus than contentious ideological and social strife. Censorship is a troubling thing and while the state has largely removed itself from curtailing our speech and assembly private interests seem very willing to create social censorship and declare persons and topics non grata. Some progressives would say that the messages these speakers share are actively harmful and promote existing power structures and oppression. However, ending debate through disruption does not move the needle on broader society, if anything it creates sympathies for the target. More could be done by counter programming, protest, judicious questioning, letters to the editor, and social media responses. In an era where it is easier than ever to speak out it is odd how much effort is put into shutting people up. 

Tuesday, June 30, 2015

The Public Sphere and the Confederate Flag

Yesterday while driving through Brampton I stopped at a light and beside me was a man in a pick-up truck with a Confederate battle flag draped over the rear window of his cab. My anger was perhaps only surpassed by my disappointment. Let's leave aside the fact that he clearly obscured his own vision endangering himself and others. It seems unlikely to me that this man, who appeared to be a white man in his late twenties or thirties, was from the American South, but even still it is a remarkably strange symbol to spot in suburban Ontario. I'd like to say it's the first time I've seen such a thing, but Confederate window decals and bumper stickers are oddly common in the province of Ontario.

The Confederate Battle Flag, not the 'official flag' of the Confederacy

Why is there such an attraction to another dead country's flag? It seems highly unlikely to me that these individuals are making common cause with the defence of states' rights. The only association that seems to make any sense to me then is cultural. The Confederate battle flag is, charitably, associated with the American South and white Protestants, but it seems more likely that it is associated with rural values including God and guns. But that's really not the whole story and everyone knows it.

It is difficult to imagine that those who put the Confederate battle flag on their vehicles, or homes or persons are not entirely aware of the racist history behind it and endorse that perspective. Even if they do not they are still culpable. As the expression goes, ignorance is no defence.

Across Canada I've seen people with provincial flags or national flags on their vehicles. It's a clear symbol of pride and identity. If these individuals associate with the American South I have to question why the state flags don't adorn their vehicles. Three answers come to mind: the American state flags are pretty god awful in some circumstances and the battle flag is simple, bold design; the Confederate battle flag is a recognized symbol for that region; they willingly and purposefully take on the meaning.

In society we have a duty to our fellow human beings to smooth out our rough edges, to be polite and thoughtful. Driving around a city with a growing population of black Canadians and non-whites with a Confederate battle flag seems a fairly prominent way to declare your opinion that 'those people' do not belong. That being said, I still believe it is a person's right to purchase and display whatever flag they like. The issue currently in the United States has to do with the display of the Confederate battle flag at state capitals and on the state flag (Mississippi). This seems a simple answer to an outsider like me that for the sake of reconciliation and empathy for the African-American citizens that these flags should be pulled down and replaced.

The freedom of speech and freedom of expression are matched with a duty to be thoughtful, responsible and compassionate. The state should not aim to silence anyone, but I would hope that one day someone would tell that man in the pick-up that his flag might represent the values of the American South, but also its heritage, which includes slavery, wanton abuse and murder, lynchings, marginalization, oppression and a kind of human suffering and indignity that one can scarcely imagine.