Showing posts with label Civil Society. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Civil Society. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 1, 2018

The Social Safety Net: Should the Government Step in More?


For many years workers could often, though not always, rely upon an employer to provide some basic benefit package if they worked full-time. It goes without saying that that model is going away. Now, to be fair, there were always a significant portion of the population who never had access to benefits, but my working-class family was among them, so I assume they were widespread.

Aside from my job in the Northwest Territories I have never had benefits in my own name. No dental. No prescription. Nothing. When I left work and was no longer covered by my parents to suddenly dawned on me how expensive maintaining my routine level of care was. Especially when I developed a dental condition that required frequent check-ups. Sigh.

It is hardly surprising that some governments and left-wing parties have suggested that if employers won't provide benefits or pensions that the state is going to have to pick up the slack. Part of me absolutely hates this, and accepts this as a reality. The trend lines all suggest more insecurity not less. I don't love the idea of the state filling in so many more aspects of our life, but seeking an alternative - none leaps to mind.

One issue is how the Ontario government currently intends to go about it. Instead of having a meaningful conversation about costs and benefits of these programs we have created them with the expectation that we will slip deeper into debt. While money is cheap and we can afford to borrow now, that may not always be the case.

If we want the government to be responsible for providing a greater social safety net we should discuss it. I think we also need to examine why employment is failing to meet these former obligations. On so many questions it feels like we're sleepwalking. We just accept high underemployment, unemployment, skills mismatches, contract work, part-time work, etc. Ultimately I think we need to examine work in the twenty-first century, but in the interim collectively supporting one another may be for the best.

Tuesday, August 15, 2017

Charlottesville

On Saturday violence erupted on the streets of Charlottesville, Virginia escalating in vehicular homicide wherein a car was driven through a crowd of people. That's probably the most bloodless, tame way I could describe what occurred a few days ago, but this is an opinion-based blog, so it's probably time to put that aside.

Would highly recommend watching this New York Times video giving a simple breakdown in the events that occurred in Charlottesville. Violence in Charlottesville was likely inevitable on some scale. Neo-Nazis tend to stir up strong feelings, surprisingly. However, there were at least two groups who were anathema to one another. The first was a demonstration and march by White supremacists and neo-Nazis who gathered in park and intended to march through the city to Emancipation Park. A group of counter-protestors gathered at nearby park and intended to countermarch to disrupt their gathering.

While I think that it has been pretty disturbing all on its own, I don't particularly want to discuss the nature of response to these events. Though from what I've seen I am none-too-pleased by some of the media coverage. Some have seemed to find far too much comfort in the "their both to blame" narrative.

I think we have to take a moment now to reflect on how the hell we came to a point in 2017 where people are chanting racist, literal Nazi slogans, waving Nazi, Confederate and other right-wing flags in America. While I cannot substantiate the veracity of the tweets I saw a number of posts apparently from veterans (this is where it gets dubious) about having fought the Nazis and now their flags are waved by Americans claiming to be patriots. Something has gone deeply wrong here.

In a certain sense this is nothing new. In the far-right and white nationalist movements of the United States there has always been a blend of American patriotic and Nazi/German imagery. Right-wing militias, survivalists, Aryan Nation, and certain biker gangs have all formed a cohort of white supremacists. The Nazis are the go-to villains in much of American culture, yet we see with far greater public acknowledgement that there are those who view Hitler as one of the good guys.

It's a baffling about face, especially given the degree to which America's history in World War II made the country what it is today. Still, I don't expect twenty-first century racists and fascists to have a strong grasp of history.

White supremacy has always been tied to terrorism. This is a fact. If you don't believe me do a casual search for the history of the KKK and lynchings. There is a certain dark poetry that the vehicular murder of a protestor and the injury of nineteen others mirrors attacks by Islamic radicals in recent years.

I am going to try to keep my remarks balanced here. I do not believe we're seeing a mass movement of grassroots American Nazis. I do believe that in the last few years that far-right rhetoric has been normalized to a certain extent. A few years ago these people would be far more marginalized and few would be willing to publicly defend them. Parts of the far-right, the racist right, is now part of normal discourse. I don't put this on Donald Trump. This has been an element of American culture for decades, and normalized particularly in the wake of 2007 and during the Obama years and the Tea Party.

America in 2017 is not Weimar Germany. I hate that I have to say that so sincerely. What is socially acceptable, or reasonable within the public discourse though is increasingly embracing these people, and if it doesn't they create their own media to share their own twisted ideology. This problems is only likely to get worse. Racism, fascism and Nazism are inherently violent ideologies and we should sadly be braced for more incidents such as this. There is no part of that that isn't heartbreaking.


Tuesday, September 6, 2016

How We View Ourselves

A couple of weeks ago I was listening to a podcast and the people on the episode discussed a very familiar concept. They were talking about how the fact that our government, politicians and we ourselves see ourselves as consumers and how it has shaped us. I've heard this line of thinking before. Most people who are left-of-centre have heard, and to some degree, agree with the "I'm a citizen, not a consumer" slogan. For a period at least, and seemingly into the present, that is a minority held opinion.

However, this tired cliché transformed as this person unpacked the idea. I wish I could remember where I heard the interview, even money say Strong Towns. Here's the basics. We are all consumers, but we are also all citizens (for the most part), and nearly all of us are workers. We can be easily subdivided into the major categories that make up life, but the priorities of one cohort of society is radically different to another. There are some very easy examples. As a consumer I wanted the lowest cost goods of a reasonable quality. This set of values leads to all sorts of policy and economic decisions. Basically the end logical conclusion are massive box stores or retailers like Amazon. They exchange service for price and expediency. They also trade away reasonable wages, domestic manufacturing and other potential ideals. As a worker first, or primary worker-based mindset I come to different conclusions. I start to see my interests now in the prices of the bulk, poorly-manufactured goods on the shelves, but with my fellow workers. I understand that their plight is inexorably linked to my own. In this equation there is only one Walton family, there are plenty of Wal-Mart greeters, and I know which group I am closer to. There is more to consider than the bottom line... isn't there?

From the consumer mindset I want maximum control over my own resources. Low taxes, low fees, and a small government fit within that rationale. Government can be efficient, but even still it is rarely cheap. A vague sense of collective responsibility falls to the wayside when measured against one's own towering self-interest.

In a world before we were all consumers there was a certain rationality to how we could and did look at society. Look at farmers. This bizarre subset, neither worker nor capitalist, is squeezed out by our collective interests. What do I care about agriculture? I want my share of suburbia and they charge too much for their vegetables anyway. Advocates used to speak on behalf of different factions within society and did not need to be part of a special coalition, task force or interest group.

The examples, I am confident, are endless. Perhaps one to end on is civic identity. Within North America (and I'm sure in some quarters still) one's neighbourhood and town/city was a major source of pride. Boosterism described the unmoored optimism about people's hometown. Perhaps the symptom is more acute in the 'burbs, but I know few who care about their hometowns. They live wherever they could afford it, or happen to work nearby. There is often a vague support, but only if it comes with no sacrifice. They don't know their mayor, or councillor or local issues. 

These identities and which one holds primacy shapes how we perceive the world and what values we manifest. Acting out of our consumer interest certainly is valid, but as it has become predominant and overriding I cannot help but wonder what has been cast aside, and if it will ever be restored.

Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Silencing the Opposition or the Odious

There is a certain tactic in play in the modern protest movement or in contemporary politics that I find troubling, and frustrating. In the lead up to a speech by Donald Trump in Arizona protesters blocked a highway to prevent people from attending the event. I have major problems with this from a philosophical point of view. Anyone who reads my blog or my Twitterfeed no doubt has a good sense of my ideological issues with Trump. I think he is a horrendous candidate, but at the same time I am not going to condone people from preventing people from seeing the man speak.

Far too often it seems to be the objective of groups to silence those they don't agree with. Trump is not the outlier, though he may inspire a level of passion we do not normally see. Last year an infamous men's rights activist (and shameless troll/self-promoter) was scheduled to make speeches in a few Canadian cities. Mayors publicly stated he was not welcome and several people called on the federal government to ban him from entering the country. The mayors' interventions are fine, they are politicians expressing their opinions. However, barring a person from entering the country based on their political views is... troubling.

To be clear, it isn't just people on the right. Leftists also have been targeted. Former British Member of Parliament, George Galloway, for his positions on the Middle East and associations was targeted by critics who claimed a person of his views was not welcome in Canada. Anita Sarkeesian, culture critic who largely focuses on video games, has had to cancel events due to threats of violence.

When speakers do get to hold their events it is not uncommon for protestors to heckle, disrupt and shout down the controversial figure. There is a long list of speakers who have had this fate. On university campuses bioethicists and pro-life speakers are particularly vulnerable, as are controversial political figures or politicians.


My idealistic streak tells me that silencing ideas is not the way to win arguments or make change. Debates are won and minds are changed through the exchange of ideas. The level of comfort people have with silencing people rather than countering them is disturbing. We'd rather live in artificially peaceful consensus than contentious ideological and social strife. Censorship is a troubling thing and while the state has largely removed itself from curtailing our speech and assembly private interests seem very willing to create social censorship and declare persons and topics non grata. Some progressives would say that the messages these speakers share are actively harmful and promote existing power structures and oppression. However, ending debate through disruption does not move the needle on broader society, if anything it creates sympathies for the target. More could be done by counter programming, protest, judicious questioning, letters to the editor, and social media responses. In an era where it is easier than ever to speak out it is odd how much effort is put into shutting people up. 

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

Are Millennials Compatible with our Democracy?


Last night I watched The Agenda’s program on youth participation with our democracy. Below I’ll post the videos of the episode.


Millennials Discuss Democracy


Democratic Observers weigh in 

The host, Steve Paikin was trying to get to the core of why only 38.8% of Millennials bothered to vote in the 2011 federal election. Sadly Mr. Paikin did not come up with many (or any) answers. As I watched my peers I could not help but think that perhaps our attention is on the wrong side of the equation. Much attention has been given over to the system failing young people, but could it be that young people are also failing the system?

Anyone who has read this blog for any length of time would know that I’m a democracy nerd and political junkie. It’s something I care about and invest a great deal of time and effort into. This makes me an outlier, which I accept. I don’t expect every citizen to be as engaged as I am as they undoubtedly have passions of their own. I began to wonder whether or not the certain zeitgeist of millennials means that they are inured to politics.

Looking at the twenty-somethings on the panel last night it was clear that they were all articulate, well-educated, and quite savvy. It’s likely that the producers at TVO worked to find an exceptional group, and one that would stand out for the reasons that you’d think they would be leaders in politics today. Beneath their positive qualities ran deep cynicism for politics, politicians and democracy. Even those who espoused concerns and political positions seemed to view participation within our democratic system as a bit of a fool’s errand, or at least as deeply unappealing.

Politics was likened to marketing, yet the objective of being sold to and appealing to constituents to build a mandate should not be interchangeable. Millennials are savvy and understand the tactics of media and marketing firms. When politicians and parties try them they are instantly recognizable and rejected.

I could not help but sense that my peers on the program were fundamentally missing the point. By not participating at all they were dooming themselves to irrelevance. Many in Generation Y prefer to observe the system and critique than get their hands dirty and try to repair it. Jane Hilderman of Samara, in the second clip above, highlighted that man Millennials participated in informal democracy, but ultimately we are governed through the formal process. Petitions and rallies can be easily ignored while candidates, voters and movements cannot.

I’m not sure any of the panel would be satisfied in our system. They seek “authentic” candidates that express their values. I cannot help but wonder if politicians who deviate only slightly from their ideals would be considered a waste of time, or irrelevant. Perfection becomes the enemy of the good and thousands render themselves silent in preference to an alternative that does not exist.

I suppose my question is whether or not Millennials, a generation jaded through media, marketing and entertainment, cannot operate within a system built upon loyalty, trust and imperfect candidates and parties. There may be an economic argument. The delayed adulthood due to debt, poor job market and high housing costs means that Millennials are taking on the responsibilities that drive people to vote later. Still that is no remedy and if Millennials want the system to better reflect their values they will have to start showing up.


Tuesday, January 28, 2014

Rise of the Anti-Hero and Decline of Politics


It should come as very little surprise that shows such as House of Cards (BBC and Netflix) and Game of Thrones, and its antecedent novels are very popular among political junkies. If one looks at the most celebrated television shows in the last few years, especially those that offer interpretations of politics one gets a pretty disturbing trend. A question arises at some point if art is imitating life, or if life is mirroring art.

Frank Underwood (House of Cards), Enoch Thompson (Boardwalk Empire), Tom Kane (Boss), Rick and the Governor (The Walking Dead), Tyrion Lannister (along with most of the other cast) (Game of Thrones) are among some of the few immensely popular anti-heroes who populate popular culture in the realm of politics. The darker, or grayer, media of the present demands flawed protagonists. Some argue that is more realistic, that politicians are people and perhaps their desire for power makes them more flawed than most.

There are many more examples which demonstrate the sort of insidious nature of politics. The Wire, also a HBO program, revels in the deeply corrupt world of Baltimore politics, and the extent to which politics is broken and is unfixable. Borgen a Danish property creates a vipers’ nest out of their politics. Best Laid Plans, an adaptation of the novel of the same name, satires Canadian politics as an unprincipled farce unworthy of decent people. In fact, the premise of the story is that a decent person can only win accidentally.

The modern culture seems enamoured with the anti-hero: Don Draper, Tywin Lannister, Tony Soprano, Walter White, among others, are our cultural icons. All of these horrendous figures, in their own way, illustrate a key message about power and politics. The implicit message of many of these shows is that honest, moral people are weak and ultimately fail, those who will lie, cheat and steal will ultimately win over the honourable. To a certain extent I believe we have internalized this belief. Any politician is immediately suspect and assumed to be corrupt, which is validated in virtually all media.

Television programs, such as The West Wing, whose antagonists let alone protagonists were rarely immoral would probably be laughed at as ridiculously optimistic portrayals, or perhaps more scathingly, unrealistic today. That being the case there are very few “good” figures in contemporary fiction that can be lauded. Parks and Recreation and its main character Leslie Knope are clear idealists, but the show is based around the ineffectiveness, petty corruption, and farce of local politics. As much as Parks and Rec may inspire, it equally damns.

If as a culture we romanticize our anti-heroes, accept and love their flaws and presume that is the normal order of things it should come as no surprise when allegations of corruption or personal weakness come to the surface and that these revelations would have little tangible impact on his/her support. It is commonly said that politicians are held to a higher standard, but I am not certain that is true anymore. If the most prominent figures in popular culture are adulterers, drug dealers, and criminals is it surprising that people are willing to overlook the trespasses of their real-life leaders?

Politicians should not be viewed as perfect, but there is something worrying if the standard slips so low that we are merely choosing between various corrupt snake-oil salesmen. More worrying is the relationship this creates between the public and those who aspire to politics. Anyone who declared an interest to their family and friends to run would be met with concern. What if your values align itself with a party in disgrace, like the federal Conservatives, or Ontario’s Liberals, or any party in Quebec, really? When I have expressed an interest in running one day my mother has said she will support me but, “please don’t become corrupt. Try to do some good.”

Politics has never been less corrupt than the present. The level of financial disclosure, reporting, and regulation has never been higher yet we are more convinced than ever that every politician is out to line his/her own pockets. We possess a remarkably cynical view of politics today and it should be no wonder that few people want to volunteer their time or stand for election in the formal political arena.

As good as our anti-heroes are, maybe they are bad for us overall.



Tuesday, December 17, 2013

The Threat of Illiberal Democracy


Apologies for not posting a Worth Reading last week. I was on the road for work and my hotel’s internet was less than optimal. My personal laptop was not exactly eager to cooperate with their wireless system. By the time I got home Friday evening I did not feel the motivation to write, and so here we are.

Back in university I wrote a paper about the August Putsch in 1991 in the Soviet Union. I argued that the traditional interpretation of Boris Yeltsin as a democratic champion was terribly flawed, and that the years immediately following his rule did not reflect what we would typify as a liberal democracy.

In the spectrum between liberal democracy and totalitarian dictatorship there is a great deal of variation. Much of that middle spectrum can be called illiberal democracy. In the initial definitions this was seemingly democratic states who restricted the freedoms of their citizens. Russia is a good example of this, and Singapore is sometimes held up as part of this phenomenon. Basically the government intrudes into the lives and freedoms of the citizenry. However, is it possible that illiberal democracy could form from citizens’ disinterest in the state?

I think the threats to modern liberal democracy are manifold and as opposed to the state encroaching in our freedoms we have a disengaged populace who is allowing institutions to decay and fail on their own. The government is the easiest one to begin with. Decreasing voter turnout, declining participation in formal politics, increased ignorance and apathy towards our politics means that political leaders are given a freer hand in abusing our system.

Prorogation is an obvious example here. Putting aside Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s (CPC – Calgary Southwest, AB) tenure in office, there is evidence elsewhere that the conventions that used to govern our system are in absolute freefall. British Columbia’s Legislative Assembly sat 36 of 576 days, is this really evidence of a healthy, vibrant democracy? If you heard that about somewhere else, what would you think? If that comment was about Zimbabwe you would dismiss as an obvious truism of an undemocratic society.

A free press is also a critical component of a liberal democracy. Even if you accept the presence of strong redoubts of meaningfully critical, thoughtful media, it is safe to say that the lowest brow, least critical, least relevant media is gaining traction over anything thoughtful. More people probably get their news from Buzzfeed than the Globe and Mail, or their local paper. Institutional, thoughtful reporting is in a real crisis. The consolidation of papers by large companies, and the diminishing market share, along with sad appeals to market increasingly disinterested in news has hurt our free press.

The state is not particularly interested in silencing the freedom of speech, but very few citizens care to listen (or speak) anymore. Most of my participation in political events consists of myself and the usual suspects. Freedom of assembly is only somewhat battered, but no one cares to participate. While you may reject my premise that Canada, and other countries, are progressively sliding towards illiberal democracy, I don’t think it is possible deny that the vibrancy of our democracy is fading.

Accountability at the federal level now seems to be defined by whether or not criminal charges have been laid. This type of arrogance is only possible because so few people care. The Mayoralty of Rob Ford can continue blithely because he can be rest assured that the huge number of Torontonians will not vote and he can still carry the day despite his abysmal behaviour because people have such a low opinion for our system already.

The passivity of citizens must have some sort of long-term impact. I do not blame the government, or some other boogie man. Some sort of socio-economic/technological change is dramatically reshaping the culture and leading to the shocking erosion of traditional institutions. This loss of faith and acceptance is having a tangible impact on how we are governed and the lives we lead. Sadly, I see no averting these changes, and those who are expressing concern may be crying into deaf ears of a public who prefers to not listen. 

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Shallow Politics: Canadian Politics and Media


In the back of my mind on Tuesdays I am always thinking about what I am going to write. Sometimes the news of the day just doesn’t provide me with the materials I want to work with. Today I saw these tweets on Twitter from a Toronto-based journalist:



You can follow Ms. Csandy at @AshleyCsanady. I highly recommend it.

Over the last couple of weeks I have been pleased with our media, on balance. They have done a good job at holding our dysfunctional politics to some form of account. At least the grubs under the rock are being exposed and we have to deal with it.

However, our media and politics, one must admit, are burdened with an incredible shallowness. Before I take both out behind the metaphorical woodshed, I should add that the public may be largely to blame in this. Politicians and media are serving us, they do not perform this twisted theatre for their own amusement.

Media outlets are hungry for eyeballs, and politicians live and die on their ability to draw attention. These (should be) self-evident truths, but both groups have learned an important lesson in the modern era: emotion is more valuable than reason. I should probably couch that claim in that it is as old as the Age of Reason itself. Ironically we are re-learning it with disastrous consequences for public life.

I recently finished reading Sasha Issenberg’s book The Victory Lab. One of the key discoveries is that people seem to be rarely swayed from their political positions. Political campaigners used to believe that with the correct policies voters could be won over. From my understanding this was particularly prominent problem among the Democrats. However, people are not interested in marginal tax rates and infrastructure programs, they are interested in values. It is a more complicated concept than I explain in a paragraph, but basically emotional factors and whether or not a voter feels connected to a candidate has far more to do with a candidate’s likelihood of success than policy. Policy can reflect this values, but it seems the latter informs the former, rather than vice versa. This was famously captured in the “who would you rather have a beer with?” question. With fundamentally different approaches to foreign policy and the world voters were often more split on a question of personal comfort.

Combine this with realities of new (and old) media and you start to get a rather unsettling picture of what our public discourse may one day become. Consider Ms. Csanady’s tweets. If evening news programs decided to lead with the recently introduced Conservative crime omnibus bill and framed it as a dispassionate discussion of the impact of criminal charges to cable thieves (or another nail in our parliament’s coffin) I sincerely doubt many outside the hardest of political junkies would have stayed tuned in.

Justin Trudeau (LPC – Papineau, QC) is a strong embodiment of this problem to my opinion. His strong name recognition and (inexplicable to me) public appeal means that any story that features him would attract disproportionate part of the political-news audience. By invoking the name Jack Layton, a politician that many Canadians have at least a passing affection for, and setting Trudeau loyalists against New Democrats you have set the stage for meaningless conflict that has great appeal.

The Rob Ford saga presents a similar problem. Often elements of the story that were more salacious made headlines and grabbed attention. The lewd comment Ford made regarding an alleged incident of sexual harassment is a perfect example. In the very same interview Ford confessed to drinking and driving. A crime that most Canadians take very seriously, but because sex and the embarrassment of his wife was involved that was buried. It returned in the later coverage, but it is still an important symbol of what is valued in the current culture.

I sincerely doubt that the politicians from years gone by who we praise could survive in such an environment. The inability for only the most cursory of labels of issues to permeate and the inability for sustained discourse on issues of importance means that our public life is facing a breakdown. Democracy is dependent upon an informed electorate, yet our electorate cannot (or will not) make decisions based upon information. Post-modernists would point out that this fantasy of the rational citizen never really existed. Everyone is burdened with their own peculiar set of bias and dispositions; there is no dispassionate evaluation of policy choices.

Debates and elections are no longer battles of ideas, but battles of personality. In such a shallow measure it should not be surprising that those with more persona than sense rise to the top and those bookish politicians who prefer to concentrate languish in obscurity. As a trend it is hard to imagine it changing any time soon, if at all. There is rarely great thoughtfulness or eloquence in 140 characters or a 10 second sound-bite. In a system where power is often bestowed to he/she who can hold the spotlight longest is it any surprise things begin to look more and more like a circus? 

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Centralization versus Democracy


This week I have done a lot of thinking about the competing forces of democracy and centralization. These are not often forces that are considered in opposition to one another, but I think this is increasingly something worth examination.

Before I continue I think that there is a big hole in my analysis, and I should be upfront about that right now. That is that I was not alive during other political eras and therefore cannot say from personal experience what it was like to try to participate in our democratic system in 1978, and I can only really speak from experiences following the year 2005. My conclusions are based on (what are from my point of view) logical deductions.

As Samara Canada’s “The Real Outsiders” states, “Not only is voter turnout decreasing, but every year fewer Canadians are getting involved in other kinds of political activities, like joining or donating to political parties, signing petitions or attending protests.” The study goes on to discuss this group as the disengaged, and given their status political parties routinely ignore these voters.

But why did so many people disengage over the last few decades? What has changed? Democratic reformers, such as myself, point to our political institutions and the false majorities, but the system never stopped 70%, or nearly 80% of voters in the 1960s, from voting. Instead we must look to our politics and see what has changed in the intervening decades and how it may have altered the political landscape at the local level.

Beginning in the Trudeau era power moved away from the Members of Parliament to the Cabinet, and the Prime Minister’s Office. No party has reversed this trend, and if anything it has dramatically escalated under Prime Minister Stephen Harper. Worse still, the practice of centralized power was copied within the opposition parties and in the provincial spheres. In short order the leader of a given political party controlled the apparatus of his or her party. Members of Parliament, of MPPs, or MLAs, or MNAs, etc. who spoke out against the leadership were muzzled and the result was a sufficiently cowed caucus.

What does this have to do with democratic participation? While it would be nice to think that people participate in political parties because of altruistic civic instincts, I am not sure that it applies to the majority. Most people involved in politics wants to A) feel their voices are being heard, and B) shape the decisions taking place. This means helping to elect preferred candidates (both in the general election and nomination) and helping to push the overall leadership to your point of view. Before this gross centralization legislators more than likely had the interest of their constituents, and therefore their re-election, at heart. Their ultimate loyalty was to the constituents whom they served, not their masters in the leader’s office.

The effect of all of this is that even if citizens join a party, or volunteer and elect a new legislator they are more likely to eventually turn against them or betray their trust. This still happens from time to time, a backbencher or someone in cabinet (of upper echelons of a party in opposition) speaks out against the leadership’s decisions. Minister James Moore (CPC – Port Moody-Westwood-Port Coquitlam, BC), for example, spoke out against the Northern Gateway pipeline, which is incredibly unpopular within British Columbia. Sadly, Minister Moore retreated from his outspoken position when party discipline was reaffirmed.

Citizens get involved in politics because they want to influence the outcome. Increasingly it seems that parties are moved by polls and focus groups and not by activists and loyalists. As a result it can hardly be surprising that membership wanes. People have no interest in participating in toothless organizations that act as rubberstamps for those placed above them. Think of the American presidential primaries for Obama in 2012. They were a formality, and turnout, as a result suffered. When parties can appoint candidates, or transform legislators into convenient mouthpieces and puppets, citizens see little value in participating.

Disengagement can only be reversed through empowerment, but, tragically, it is not in the interest for those in power to democratize their political parties. Democracy offers uncertainty when rigid authoritarianism provides much greater comfort to those already ensconced in power. However, the methods to fix this problem are in the hands of the citizenry. If hundreds, or thousands of people join a riding association or political party with a common set of goals then they can affect real change. Political parties are ultimately democratic institutions, leadership can be kicked out and replaced with more democratic or grassroots-friendly candidates.

My experience within the Ontario New Democratic Party has given me hope so far. I believe I have already had a small impact. The Executive of my local riding association has been very supportive and eager to encourage new members. I helped to establish a social media presence by launching a Brampton West NDP Facebook page.

Speaking of which, I have a guest post on Samara Canada’s blog today, which discusses social media and its importance in engaging millennials and reinvorating our politics. Check it out here, Opacity and Unresponsiveness Alienates Canadians.

Tuesday, December 20, 2011

Erosion of Civil Societies and its Effect on Democracy


This week I am taking a slightly different tact from my regular post. I guess you could call this almost an essay.

For a paper I recently completed for one of my courses I had to read an American political scientist named James C. Scott. Dr. Scott teaches at Yale University and is an expert in peasant politics, and the power of the state in relation to the voiceless elements of a given society. In his 1985 book, The Moral Economy of the Peasant: Rebellion and Subsistence in Southeast Asia, Scott argues that the cultural element is a key consideration to revolt and protest. Complicated networks of dependency and interrelationship in a peasant society led to informal organization and effective resistance to oppression.

This dovetailed strangely with some of the materials my students have been using on their final papers. One of the chapters in the text they have been using discusses the importance of civil societies in Victorian Canada. The Coles’ Notes are that civil societies in early nineteenth century Canada helped those with limited political voice, and who were marginalized overall, be heard and contribute to the democratic process.

The final element that has been rattling around in my head of late is the report released by Samara Canada called The Real Outsiders. The study focuses on Canadians who are somewhat disengaged from traditional democracy in Canada. Samara’s report received quite a bit of media attention and editorials in response to its overall assessments.

One of the contributors to this discourse mentioned the importance in the decline of civil societies to the decline in democratic participation. Having all of these different notions banging around inside my head led me to draw some conclusions to the changing patterns in Canadian society and democracy overall.

Someone commenting on the report from Samara pointed out that the decline of civil societies has made the entry point in democratic involvement quite high. Fifty years ago most members of a community were members of a number of local organizations. Religious organizations, charitable groups, local governance groups, school councils, unions and volunteer associations allowed people to serve their communities and organize without entering formal democratic politics. In addition these organizations allowed individuals to lobby for policy choices and gain experience leading organizations, paving the way for more involvement in public life.

Today, civil society seems remarkably weak to me, at least based upon my own anecdotal observations and experiences. The decline of church attendance, and other traditional non-state institutions could be a serious impediment to democratic participation. Democratic governance can be extremely esoteric to new initiates. The role the federal or provincial governments play in our daily lives may not be immediately apparent, much of what is apparent is normally annoying – poor infrastructure, ineffective bureaucracy, parking tickets, etc. Motivating people to plunge into the complicated system can be daunting. On the other hand the mission and purpose of community groups and their effectiveness is quite obvious. Experience on a smaller local level can be leveraged to greater political participation. I particularly wonder about the impact on young people. These community organizations, traditionally, would be the gateway to greater participation.

Since the 1980s with the rapid growth of globalization the traditional groups within society have seen real erosion. Members of our society are mostly concerned with their own affairs, and have limited connections to their communities. Scott spoke of the importance of local culture, but local traditions have broken down dramatically overtime. New subcultures and digital societies have sprung up now that people have the freedom to organize themselves based on their interests instead of their geography, or culture.

We participate in groups of like-minded people, with like-minded interests, but we no longer know our neighbours or local needs. The erosion of civil society likely means that we are less committed to our communities. Sometimes it can feel like we are a nation of 34 million individuals, with only the vaguest of common interest and connection, the province even more so, 12 million strangers that happen to have the same geography. Our technological isolation from each other may be the root of this disconnect, given how local society is so key to political organization.

Perhaps now it is time for us to less enamoured with the idea that we can talk to anyone on the other side of the world, but that we should reach out to people just outside our doors.