Showing posts with label Ontario Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ontario Politics. Show all posts

Friday, January 25, 2019

Podcast Review: Canadaland's Thunder Bay


A few months ago I subscribed and began to listen to the newest podcast created by Canadaland, a Canadian-based media company. The podcast had been in development for at least two years as far as I can tell. The name is simple and instructive. Canadaland's audio documentary seeks to explore the culture, criminality, social tensions, politics, and racism in Thunder Bay.

The show is led by Ryan McMahon, an Anishinaabe comedian, writer, and activist. Given the sensitive material he takes a deft and careful hand at exploring the lives of indigenous Canadians living in Thunder Bay or their experiences with Thunder Bay. He spent months building relationships with the subjects and gaining background information to share the story.

It's possible to summarize Thunder Bay as a true crime podcast, but I think that quite misses the mark. True crime, generally, focuses on a single case or a single criminal. Thunder Bay is about systemic failures and crises. While time is spent to look at the corruption and cronyism that has pervaded local politics it is not simply about that. I feel the time spent looking at a mayor charged with extortion, or a police chief facing obstruction of justice is to demonstrate that radical failure is taking place in the community and it is going largely unchallenged.

The racism faced by indigenous people in Thunder Bay is not hidden or obscured. It is often visible right on the surface for all to see in public postings, statements, public leaders, and widely-held opinions. Many First Nations people have to come to Thunder Bay for schooling. Many of the smaller communities do not have high schools so the children are brought to Thunder Bay for their education. These generally leaves them poorly supervised, lonely, isolated, and in a high-risk area. There is a chilling and recurring fear stated by many that they will be "thrown in the river." Indigenous people in Thunder Bay seem to drown in icy rivers with startling regularity, and some indications exist that there are killers who stalk native people for just this purpose.

The tone of Thunder Bay is not what I would call emotional, but it is definitely sensitive. McMahon in his narration and interviews clearly is speaking in a revelatory manner, and also expresses deep regret and sympathy for victims. Another powerful element is simple disbelief, that there is a city in Canada that can flagrantly flaunt was many assume to be our norms and get away with it.

There is a question that McMahon and Thunder Bay leaves the audience with, one that is deeply chilling - what if Thunder Bay is working exactly as it is intended? Pointing to the litany of stories Canadaland has collected and calling them "isolated incidents" begs incredulity. If you don't believe me, give it a listen for yourself, but be prepared to see a darker side of our country that some are intimately familiar with and others have had the privilege to be shielded from.

To check out Thunder Bay you can use this link, or subscribe using your favourite podcast app.

Tuesday, September 25, 2018

Frustration with the Ebb of Progress

I sit on the left side of the political spectrum, generally speaking. Lately it has hard not to be pessimistic (not that there are many times when I'm optimistic). We'll keep things mostly to narrower topics though the consistent failures of the Trump White House and actions of the Trudeau government are draining.

I should say this isn't exclusively about Doug Ford either. With the unpopularity of the Wynne government this sort of outcome was highly likely. What I find most galling is the simple stupidity of this government. I don't mean that the leadership is stupid, I mean that the policies are. I want to talk more about policies than politics for this piece and how it feels like the left is painted into a corner on so many topics.

This week I was watching a panel discussion on Ontario's climate change 'plan'. Basically the plan of the current provincial government is to scrap the cap-and-trade system and fight the federal government's right to impose a carbon tax. In its place will be nothing. It's a terrible policy, but it's damn popular broadly speaking. Even I, a person who believes we should make interventions to halt climate change had to admit I was pleased when the cost of gasoline went down, to my shame. However, it was a crystalizing moment when I realized it just feels like the collective left is fighting an uphill battle in policy.

Climate change will need policies that will hurt society broadly to prevent worse injury later. Increasing the price of gas discourages excess driving, or at least the development of more fuel efficient, or electric vehicles. But, it's unpopular. The right-wing around the world can even accept that climate change exists and simply refuse to do anything about it and the electorate doesn't care.

Many elements of our system of elections and government is undemocratic. Reforms could be introduced to greatly improve representation at city councils, provincial legislatures, and the House of Commons. These ideas are laughed out of the room when people bother to stop yawning.

Laws that infringe on civil liberties can generally be passed with impunity. Bill C-51 was reviled for the potential it opened for abuse. It was a major election issue in places like Downtown Toronto. The Liberals broke their promise on the main aspects that brought issues, but now that the bad Conservatives are out of office... no fuss.

Our cites, all our cities, need to radically change policy to end sprawl and incrementally improve their density for their fiscal and environmental sustainability. Not to mention, housing affordability. Even modest proposals to densify certain communities is met with tenacious resistance, so much so that most politicians fear to address it.

Transit projects have either been nickle and dimed or become boondoggles to win suburban votes. People are committed to their cars and efforts to improve transportation that isn't more highway lanes and asphalt meet stiff resistance.

The sex education curriculum is rolling back two decades because a vocal minority is afraid of sex and bought lies told about it. I presume a silent majority doesn't care, or finds the birds and the bees "icky".

On any number of criminal justice issues the overwhelming tide of the population wants more cops, harsher sentences, profiling and executions. It hardly matters that experts say this often makes the situation worse, or that resources are better spent elsewhere.

Speaking of spending, good luck on having a conversation about raising taxes of any kind to better serve the public good.

Perhaps to end on a doozy: First Nations and Indigenous issues are consistently dismissed. Their rights, their existence and respect for their communities is routinely overruled for the benefit of the state or the majority. If you talk to Canadians about indigenous issues that answer I've heard far too often is that "they have it too good as it is." 

Conservatism has its roots in preserving the status quo. The left is traditionally a reforming element in society. Pushing change is always difficult. Cobbling together coalitions to push for uncertain change against a known present is never going to be automatic. However over the last week I keep thinking of a line from the HBO series The Newsroom. The character Will McAvoy asks a liberal pundit, "If the left is so smart how come you lose so goddamn always?" The right can become more radical and odious while the left can only seem to cobble together the most minor of victories.

I do not expect to be on the winning side continuously. The pendulum swings, ideas come and go, parties win and lose. Perhaps it's my perspective, but the swing to the right is scary given its radical element at present. We quite literally have white supremacists in the public discourse. Sigh. How is the left not able to win these fights overwhelmingly?


Tuesday, August 7, 2018

Buck-a-Beer is Terrible Policy, Great Politics


I'll be honest. It's late on Tuesday and because of the holiday Monday I forgot what day of the week it is, so this has to be written and delivered quickly.

When Doug Ford announced his 'policy' to bring cheaper beer to Ontario I don't know if I could have rolled by eyes harder. It was the exact sort of cheap pandering I had come to expect from the Progressive Conservative leader, but even still, when I first saw the message I thought it was a parody. What could be greater satire than Doug Ford promising cheap beer to win over voters?

To the shame of us all that was an actual commitment and one the government of Ontario has started to move towards making it a reality. The government will lower the minimum cost of a bottle or can of beer from $1.25 to $1. The price was raised ten years ago under Premier Dalton McGuinty. However, anyone capable of basic economics will probably point to the fact that this may not be as simple a fix as that. Prices have only gone up over the last ten years. Inflation and price structuring alone would mean that companies would be hesitant to lower their prices.

The government, ridiculously, is encouraging brewers to lower prices in order to win promotional opportunities at the government-owned LCBO.

Unsurprisingly, there has been significant outcry from brewers about this. Over recent decades small-scale and craft breweries have developed products to cater to a more diverse market. Quality costs money, and some brewers have clearly made the point that in order to meet the prices the Ford government wants, quality or quantity would have to be slashed. 

The truth is that the government of Ontario cannot really control the price of beer. Setting a new minimum will not necessarily encourage anyone to take advantage of it. I remember being a university student and drinking the buck-a-beers. They were awful, almost every one of them. The idea of general affordability is quite popular, no doubt, but whether or not that should be applied to alcohol. I would much prefer people to have cheaper transit or cheaper housing or cheaper food. The public good is much clearer there.

It's ridiculous policy, but it will no doubt be good politics.

Tuesday, July 31, 2018

Protecting Local Democracy


The decision of the Ford government of Ontario to cut the number of city councillors in Toronto is not in and of itself a threat to democracy. The decision to do so in the middle of an election campaign is. As mentioned in previous blog posts the final day to register for local elections in Ontario was July 27th. This means that the democratic players of Ontario made their choices to run based on long-standing decisions about how the election would be structured. Doug Ford's decision throws all of this into chaos.

The 27th should have set the standards for the election for the candidates and the citizens. I do not love how early the registration closed, but the predictability of it is important to the democratic process. The candidates who registered and planned to run in Toronto now have their candidacies thrown into question. This is in addition to the regional chair elections that have also been cancelled. How are candidates supposed to campaign as a result of this fallout?

I do not like the idea of Toronto's City Council being cut down to twenty-five members. That does seem undersized to serve the city. Plenty of people elsewhere have made the argument that it is improper given the representative needs of the people of Toronto. That said, I could far more accept Ford's decision if it would impact the elections held in 2022. Impacting elections to be held in a few months time just seems vindictive to a level of government that left him bruised.

In short, Doug Ford and the new provincial government is acting in bad faith. It would be reasonable, though ill-advised, to make these cuts for a future election. To do so now is unnecessarily disruptive. The public and candidates were not even given the courtesy of having this idea floated during the campaign so they could prepare.

If this is a portent of how Doug Ford intends to govern, I am concerned. While Toronto bears the brunt there is no reason to assume he and his government will not be inclined to meddle in our local democracies in the future. Municipalities are utterly at the mercy of the provincial legislature. As a result, every Ontarian has a reason to be concerned.




Tuesday, May 8, 2018

And We're Off, Ontario


Tomorrow it's official. The writ will be drawn up, the Ontario Legislative Assembly will be dissolved and elections will be held on June 7th to form a new legislature and perhaps choose a new government. Good people who read this blog should brace themselves for awkward and uncomfortable conversations with friends, family members and coworkers. We should also be ready for a deeply ugly and divisive campaign.

As we enter the election I wanted to call out a few things that Ontarians should be mindful of as we prepare to collectively vote.

1. The Basics

Kathleen Wynne is leading a Liberal Party that has been in power since 2003. While she certainly offered some changes from her predecessor, Dalton McGuinty, voters rarely let political parties govern for more than ten years at a time. If Wynne receives a second mandate that will creep close to twenty. The Tories have been dogged by scandal that left them leaderless as Patrick Brown was forced to resign in disgrace. Wisely (sarcasm) the Tories selected Doug Ford to lead them into the election. This leaves a real opportunity for Andrea Horwath. More than a few Ontarians cannot stand Wynne or Ford. With a smooth campaign it could be an opportunity for the NDP to return to power for the first time since 1990. In addition, the chaos may prove valuable in getting Mike Schreiner and the Green Party their first seat.

2. One Hundred and Twenty-Four, Plus One, Elections

There will be one campaign where Wynne, Ford and Horwath battle it out for Ontarians to pick who would be best suited to be the next premier. However, in Ontario we do not vote for the premier, we vote for our Members of Provincial Parliament. One hundred twenty-four election will be fought across the province shaped by local issues and personalities. While the grand narrative will be important and shape the outcome it will all have to be filtered through a local reality.

3. A Province of Regions

Ontario is a big, big province with 13.6 million residents. The interests of the various components of this province are diverse and no every party will speak to them equally. Unless we see a massive blowout for one party distinct regional interests will assert themselves. Do not expect Southwestern Ontario to behave like Toronto, or Northern Ontario to conform to the Western 905. The various sections of the province will respond to the campaign(s) differently.

4. Anything Can Happen

The Progressive Conservatives are presently in the lead, but Ontarians are not paying attention yet. When they engage with the campaign it is possible numbers will shift. If the climate between the parties becomes toxic voters could turn to unexpected alternatives. While the Liberals are in a bad spot not, they have been in the past too. Any three of the major parties could foreseeably form government this summer. Don't count out any possibility until the ballots are cast.

Tuesday, March 13, 2018

Ford Nation Across Ontario


As the initial controversy of the Progressive Conservative leadership race fades, Doug Ford seems to be holding on to his initial win and will continue to be the leader of that party. Barring more chaos he will lead Ontario's right-wing party in the June provincial election.

Each of the potential leaders presented unique strengths and weaknesses. Let's take a moment to examine Doug Ford's potential impact on the June vote.

First, Doug Ford and the Ford Nation hold real sway in the Greater Toronto Area. As many Ontarians are disgusted by the Ford years another group views them as their advocates and champions. Somehow the sons of a politician and wealthy businessowners defend the little guy. It was enough to win a third of the vote in "liberal" Toronto though. In 2014 when Doug Ford sought to succeed his brother he received 33.73% of the vote.

Second, Doug Ford's name recognition comes at a cost. The rocky tenure and his questionable past are still in the public memory. Ford is a polarizing figure, and some voters are likely just as turned off by him. However, those people are likely to lean Liberal and NDP anyway.

Let's play out some scenarios.

1. ABL (Anyone But Liberal)

Patrick Brown was poised to sweep to the premiership with few Ontarians knowing who he is. Ontario for 23 years has flipped between Liberals and Progressive Conservatives. With the Wynne government unpopular Ford may not matter much, the result is baked in already.

2. Ford Torpedoes the Party

The polarizing spectre of Ford pushes voters toward the Liberals or NDP to stop him from becoming premier. The bullying, blustering, right-wing Ford drives voters to the left-wing parties who dread Ford Nation on a provincial scale. As an unpracticed campaigner he is unable to galvanize the wide electorate into a winning coalition.

3. Ford Helps

Ford's popularity is likely rooted in the GTA. If Liberal fortunes fall his advantage might flip seats in Etobicoke, Scarborough and elsewhere in the city and region. Places like Peel, Durham and York might find his message and persona persuasive. Low taxes and "clean" government are simple messages. Hell, he could steal the line about the gravy train directly from his brother's campaign. This only become more true if the NDP and Liberals fight for the same votes in Toronto and elsewhere.

The PCs might have other issues. Ford seems to be pushing for a new platform despite the significant effort that went into crafting the current one. Candidates were recruited under Patrick Brown and a more moderate platform. He very narrowly won the leadership and knives are out for Ford if he fails or stumbles.

Despite what polls say now the election is too close to call. I assume now it'll be a nasty, dirty election as the two main parties launch desperate attacks at each other. A very real opportunity exists for the NDP to take advantage of its damaged opponents and make gains. All in all, this is set to be one of the most interest provincial elections in many years.


Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Four Candidates Fight for PC Leadership

Believe it or not this Friday Progressive Conservatives begin voting for their next leader. It's hard to imagine. The PC leadership has been marked by chaos and seeming panic from even a casual observer's perspective. Patrick Brown threw his hat into the leadership race, one presumes, in an attempt to reclaim his 'good' name. That lasted eleven days before he withdrew.

Four candidates stand to lead the party likely best poised to form the next government. They will be debating tonight at 6:30 PM, for those interested. 

Tanya Granic Allen is the little known candidate running as a social conservative. Her primary motivating issue is sex education in public schools. She is a staunch social conservative and not easily dismissed. As reported by the CBC she has raised a significant amount of money for her campaign and leads an organization that purports to have 80000 supporters.

Christine Elliott was a former MPP and ran for the leadership against Patrick Brown but fell short. I hesitate to designate her the frontrunner, but she is clearly among the 'sane' choices the PCs have before them. Of those running she has the most experience in the provincial political arena. She has been considered a moderate within the Progressive Conservatives. I think most observers would say that she would be the safe choice for the party in this difficult time.

Doug Ford, yes, that Doug Ford, is running to lead the PCs as well. He is running on a similar brand of populism as his brother Rob. It has always struck me as galling given that his brother was a career politician and his father was a MPP. His main points have been to root out the corruption and waste in Queen's Park and the PC Party. Of all the candidates in the race he likely has the greatest name profile which alone would give him a strong basis to contend the leadership. However, his negative impressions is very high.

Caroline Mulroney is a successful businessperson and daughter of the former Prime Minister of the same name. She was going to run in the 2018 provincial election and when Brown resigned threw her name in to become leader of the party. She is somewhat unknown in provincial politics. Recently the CBC reported that her campaign is struggling. Political experience matters and going for the leadership without holding elected office may be too great of a jump for Mulroney.

A new leader will be selected on March 10 to lead the Progressive Conservatives into the next election. While they continue to poll high it is undoubtedly true that whichever of these four individuals are selected will have to win the trust of Ontarians. If PC members select unwisely they may send their party into the wilderness and deliver Wynne a surprise victory, or create a substantial opportunity for the NDP and Andrea Horwath.

Tuesday, February 20, 2018

Millennial Elections

Earlier this week I was listening to an older episode of CBC's The Pollcast.  In the episode Eric Grenier interviewed David Coletto of Abacus Research about the impact Millennials  had, are having, and will have on elections. The old wrap that young people don't vote is quickly not being applicable to Millennials. The oldest of the generation are turning 38 this year, and the youngest (which is dependent upon how you define Millennials) are either already or turning the voting age.

My generation is hardly homogeneous. Different opinions exist within each generation, but it can be useful to think of broader trends, especially when contrasting to other cohorts. We have elections that may illustrate real world examples of Millennial voting behaviour.

In some elections it is clear that Boomers (born 1946-1964) and Millennials have diverged sharply on certain questions. It's not unusual for issues to break down along generational lines, but a number of elections seemed to have hinged on the gap between Millennials and others. Brexit is a great case in point. Younger people overwhelmingly voted to remain within the European Union, while older Brits voted to leave. Coletto suggests in the podcast that Millennials were key for Barack Obama to winning the primary and the general elections, and supporting Bernie Sanders and as a result leading to Hillary Clinton's defeat.

As discussed in The Pollcast Millennials have already important sway in elections in Canada. The 2011 federal election, the 2014 Alberta provincial election, the 2015 federal election, the 2017 Calgary mayoral election and the 2017 British Columbia provincial election. In each case Millennials broke for the winning party and may have made a significant difference. In each case they backed a centrist or left-wing party and helped them edge out a victory.

Millennials tend to skew left, but I'm not so sure that is an accurate way to read my generation. I think certain concepts are accepted as political orthodoxy by Millennials in general, such as basic legal equality, gay rights, legalization of certain drugs, etc. However, the embracing of the left we've seen by Millennials I think more accurately reflects their precarious economic situation. My generation may support things like pharmacare and free tuition because economic fortunes seem so grim. I think it may be more accurate to say Millennials are polarizing and perhaps becoming more extreme, or open to political extremes/radical ideas. I see this on the right and left. On the right a generation that seems lost is fertile ground for blaming others for failed promises and drift. This is an element that will need to be carefully watched going forward.


As my cohort ages it will have a greater say in the form and shape of our politics. We are already determining the results of elections, and in the future political parties will rely on those born after 1980 for victory. We already may be seeing this happening in Canada in upcoming provincial elections and the federal election next year. As demographics change so does our politics, and we are in the midst of it now. 

Tuesday, February 6, 2018

The Progressive Conservatives' Second Chance

This was the topic I hoped to write about a week ago, but it remains relevant today as well.

Over the last few months there has been space created for men and women to speak out about sexual abuse, assault and misconduct in public forums in an effort to seek justice and redress. For some I think it was about simply standing up and being heard. This wave has crashed upon Canadian politics and the aftermath is still reverberating. Tonight I'd like to focus on Ontario.

We are delusional if we believe that the allegations against Patrick Brown and Rick Dykstra are unique to the Progressive Conservative Party and Conservative Party. Men, powerful men in politics and elsewhere, have used their position and authority to try to leverage it to their personal advantage. This should be accepted as fact. What's concerning is that there have been numerous personal rumours swirling about Brown for years that have not come to the surface, until possibly now.

It's possible that the court of public opinion will eventually pull back their scrutiny of Brown and Dykstra and they'll be permitted back into public life. At the moment, in the current climate, they are verging on persona non grata.

Oddly, in the end, this may come to benefit the Progressive Conservatives. Polling seems to indicate that people view this issue as falling on individuals rather than institutions. The PCs are still Ontarians' first choice to form the next government in the wake of Brown's crash. The MPPs and party moved so quickly to push Brown out that little could be argued that they tried to defend him or cover anything up, at least to the public's eye.

Brown had managed to do a few successful things. He raised a great deal of money, expanded the party membership (though by how much is now in great question), and recruited a number of star candidates for the upcoming election. However, he remained wooden and cool on the campaign trail and during speeches. Ontarians didn't know him and didn't much care for him. He was simply an empty blue suit to replace Wynne. My sincere opinion was that when Ontarians learned of him the PCs fortunes would sag.

The Ontario Progressive Conservatives have a unique opportunity, but also a severe risk. Choosing a new leader may give them a chance to find someone with greater charisma and talents to lead a party and a government. Or, at least find one that will sit better with the public than Brown did. It should be remembered that this is all hypothetical. They may find their perfect John/Jane Doe to lead the party, but it may leave voters unsatisfied in a surprising way.

The same type of candidate who could win over the Progressive Conservative Party membership is not necessarily the same to win over the voting public. The PCs therefore hare gambling on being able to find the right person in a few short weeks to lead their party, and perhaps our next government. Of course, this ignores the fractures and in-fighting that inevitably follows, even if things go relatively smoothly. Bitter partisans will only hurt local campaigns if feelings are hurt before election day. Ontarians have yet to pay attention to the upcoming provincial election, but this news bomb was woken them up. The public is willing to give the PCs a second chance, so they best not waste it.



Tuesday, January 16, 2018

The Loathing of Kathleen Wynne

Recently the Toronto Star published a piece questioning whether or not critics were motivated by Kathleen Wynne's gender, or that it was tied to her unpopularity. The initial premise is, of course, ridiculous to my mind. Ontarians have plenty of reasons to oppose, or not support the Ontario Liberals and Premier Kathleen Wynne (OLP - Don Valley West).

The primary cause, from my perspective, is time. In democracies parties in power tend to only last eight to twelve years in office. Ontario's Liberals have been elected since 2003. They were nearly removed from office in 2011, but the execution was staid when Wynne gave a fresh face for a tired party.

All these years have allowed bad policies, scandals and entitlement to pile on to the government. With over fourteen years in office no one's hands are clean anymore. Long memories for tax increases, a lukewarm economy, and wasted money have eroded support. Anxieties about the high provincial debt and deficit are justified.

I have lived in Ontario for nearly all of my life, and came to political awareness mostly during the Dalton McGuinty years, Premier Wynne's predecessor. McGuinty was never truly popular from my recollections, but no alternative enticed Ontarians enough to make a change. McGuinty was premier when social media was present, and while he had critiques it hardly felt as toxic as the conversation around Wynne. Memes and images take aim at the Premier herself. My barbershop, as an example, posted pictures comparing her to Orville Redenbacher to explain why prices were going up. Critics seem to revel in mocking the Premier's appearance on top of her policies.

I have never voted for the Ontario Liberal Party. I am not a supporter, even if I agree with some of their policies. That said, Premier Wynne seems subject to a particularly harsh brand of criticism. This may simply be a product of politics of the 2010s. Things tend to have a more jagged, raw edge. Politics can be personal and mean. Like the case with Rachel Notley in Alberta, I cannot help but think the tenor of their detractors is nor partially drive by their gender.


Our first female, gay premier is positively hated by some in this province. That's not unusual, especially given the age of her government and the popularity of some of its policies. As we draw closer to the election this is only likely to intensify. I would hope that critics of the Wynne Liberals will stick to the substance and that the appearance, gender and sexuality of the Premier is not a factor in the debate and coming vote. 

Tuesday, November 28, 2017

Democracy Dies in Darkness


Nothing has worried me more about the future of Ontario democracy lately than the news that dozens of papers in the province will be shuttered. A deal between Postmedia and Torstar will result in the closing of 38 community newspapers in Ontario. News media has been in crisis over the last couple of decades. Newsrooms and coverage has been contracting, investigations and critical reporting shrinking. Newspapers are hollow shells of what they once were.

The journalism in most smaller and medium-sized cities and towns has been severely lacking in the twenty-first century. The fourth estate is fighting a rearguard action against irrelevancy and insolvency.

The simple truth is that journalism, especially mass reporting, has been critical to the healthy function of our democracy. We are less than a year away from municipal elections, and only a few months from a provincial election. The next elections will be much the poorer without their commentary and coverage.

As I write this I can hear the criticism clear as day. The newspapers had a narrow viewpoint, a small ownership base, they were/are a dying medium that failed financially and failed to adapt to new circumstances and alternatives exist to take their place. These, for the most part, are valid critiques. However, we have not seen a website, Twitter account, etc. replace a newspaper and truly fill its function. The journalism could be relied upon to be factual, even with editorial bias.

Let's consider some of what we have lost in these communities and others. Newspapers during an election can be counted upon to at least profile all the candidates for office for their audience. Newspapers often organize debates and moderate them. Perhaps most importantly they provide a platform for candidates to communicate to the public en masse without expending great amounts of money. I've worked on campaigns and the hardest thing is getting the public's attention. Newspapers and local media catch a distinct audience in a geographic audience and can serve them meaningfully and deeply.

Then there is the usual coverage of day-to-day politics and government. How are public institutions faring? What issues confront the community? How do changes in laws and policies or events impact local people and organizations? Newspapers have been failing in some of these respects, but nothing has offered their reach, capability, or public service.

As we move forward we risk depriving the public of objective sources of local information. Our civic life will only be poorer in their absence until alternative models can be arrived at.



Tuesday, April 25, 2017

Is it Time for Phamacare?

I was surprised when the Ontario New Democratic Party's leader, Andrea Horwath, announced a policy for pharmacare. It's the single boldest policy position the Ontario NDP has taken in decades. 

The reasoning is simple: one in four people in Ontario aren't taking the medication they need because they cannot afford it. The province will begin by covering the most commonly prescribed essential medications. The estimated cost of the plan would be $475 million per year. That number sounds onerous, but in a provincial budget of $133 billion it will make a small impact. Horwath, during the announcement, suggested that this could find savings for the overall budget as patients who can better manage their care are less likely to end up in hospital or with worse chronic conditions.

I was at first concerned about this policy. It seemed like a bloated social program that would doom the NDP from winning any support from centrist Ontarians. The initial price tag gave me some comfort, to be sure. I'm sure the price of a universal system would be staggering, but the ONDP isn't talking about that at this stage.

The policy started to make a great deal of sense to me when I framed it within my family. My father retired a few weeks ago and medical expenses are something he's thinking about. My grandmother and uncles are on limited income and have significant health complications. If the burden of some of their life-saving medicines was removed it would surely improve their situation.


As our economy undergoes a transformation to a less stable, less predictable, and less secure I think that the state is going to have to provide the supports to keep our society functioning and skim from the productivity of the low-labour economy. I look forward to seeing what this program's details, but I think it might be the next logical step as we face an aging population and a precarious economy. 

Tuesday, September 13, 2016

The Ontario Liberals Could Hold on in 2018

In Ontario, it seems to me the Liberals are set to keep winning until their opposition offers a credible alternative to the Kathleen Wynne (OLP - Don Valley West) government. That statement, I believe, sums up the current state of Ontario provincial politics.

Why is this the case? Steve Paikin recently wrote an article asking the question 'why aren't the Liberals more popular?' I think it was an accidentally provocative question. Many who follow Ontario politics closely have little love for the Ontario Liberals. As Paikin points out, even the areas where the government is getting things right are overshadowed by larger controversies, or issues of mismanagement.

What about the polls? They would suggest that I am out of touch entirely with my assertion. Here is Eric Grenier's breakdown for Ontario. As you can see the Progressive Conservatives are in the lead in the ~40% range, the Liberals are around the 30% range and the New Democrats are sitting in the low-to-mid 20% range. When there is no decision on the line it has been easy for Ontario voters to express their displeasure by drifting towards the opposition parties. This was the case in the lead up to the 2011 and 2014 provincial elections. Both of which, I will note, resulted in Liberal victories.

I think these numbers are very soft. When asked to pick a party the entire dynamic could shift. I asked Eric Grenier if there was any information about how well Ontarians know their provincial leaders. He responded that looking at those who were undecided on their performance was a hint. Patrick Brown (PCPO - Simcoe North) was at 49.3% and Andrea Horwath (ONDP - Hamilton Centre) was at 38%. The real issue, as near as I can tell is that neither opposition party is offering a real alternative to the Liberals. If Mr. Grenier's guess is correct fully half of Ontarians do not know the Leader of the Opposition, or the head of the third party who has been in place since 2009. The governing party remains in place partly by casting the alternatives as radical, ill-prepared, untested, or all three.

I have many issues with the Liberal Party of Ontario. I grew up in part in Dalton McGuinty's Ontario which is what led me become a New Democrat. But, the Liberals are a centrist, pragmatic party that plays politics for its votes in a way that appears crass, but ultimately works (see the Scarborough Subway or Mississauga Gas Plants). I don't think there is a hunger to go back to the Mike Harris days of cuts and discord in the public service and Bob Rae's tenure may have poisoned the well for New Democrats far longer than feared. Likewise the Liberals are buoyed by a popular federal leader who was recently swept to power in part due to a strong showing in Ontario. A strong organization remains on the ground with a network of activists and donors. The base is strongly motivated by fears of the right and fears of the left.


As far as I can tell, a plurality, perhaps a majority, of Ontarians badly want to end the Liberal government for their mismanagement, corruption and long term in office but basically maintain the majority of their policy platform. However, offering Liberal-Light is unlikely to inspire any opposition's base or draw voters substantially away from Wynne. If a leader could inspire confidence among voters the Liberal ship could sink. Nothing is certain in politics, but in my estimation, despite what polls say or recent by-election results, I wouldn't bet against Kathleen Wynne and the Liberals in 2018 yet. 

Tuesday, August 30, 2016

The Strange Debate over Sex Education

I read in the news this week that leader of the Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario, Patrick Brown (PCPO - Simcoe North) was caught in an embarrassing flip-flop on the sex education question. In short, Brown signed a letter in English and Chinese that was distributed to the riding of Scarborough-Rouge River, which is in the midst of a by-election, claiming to oppose the current curriculum. When questioned about this Brown disavowed the letter, saying it was a mistake.

Sigh.

I do not particularly care about Mr. Brown's policy reversal. I think it is rewarding that he intends to, at least for now, leave in the sex education curriculum. I really do not think those that oppose sex education actually care about sex education changes, they seem to oppose sex education in general. I went to dinner with a friend tonight who teaches in public school. She reminded me that the curriculum was last overhauled in the 1990s, and elements of it, including the section on growth and development was the same from the 1980s. Growth and development, you know, the things kids are going through and have the most questions about. It might be nice if teachers had some more up-to-date materials to work with.

I'm going to keep this brief. I do not see what leg opponents of sex education stand on. The program is voluntary. These parents can pull their students from the class with the understanding they will instruct them on these matters. The additions to the curriculum falls in line with how our schools and culture are changing more generally. Schools are attempting, at an institutional level, to be bastions of acceptance, or at least tolerance. It seems odd to endorse things like the Rainbow Coalition but not discuss what gender expression is.


North Americans have quite conservative notions about sex, in general. Sex is viewed in a pretty strange way, though I admit I share some of these more prudish tendencies. That said I hardly think going down the road that ignorance is preferable to knowledge is the right path. I hope governments continue to improve the curriculum rather than bow to the preferences of a vocal, squeamish minority

Tuesday, June 21, 2016

Sixth Anniversary of the Orange Tory

Tomorrow marks the sixth anniversary of this blog. It has been a long, fun and at times difficult project. I cannot count the number of times I have stared a the screen and the blinking cursor and have no idea what I'm going to write about. Before I go forward I want to thank my regular readers for continuing to visit this blog. Over the last year I've heard more from your than previously. Thoughtful comments are always a tremendous boost. Sometimes blogging can feel like yelling into the void and its nice to know someone is listening, even if they disagree.

Readership of the blog peaked in July 2015. For reasons beyond my understanding readership suddenly surged that summer and then immediately declined. It has been climbing again since January but I have long learned that building a readership is not a linear process. My recent post, Small Business and the Suburbs, is now my fifth most read post, so who knows? I obviously do not write to get a bigger and bigger audience, I write about the things that interest me and hope others enjoy it as well.

I thought the book reviews were a good addition to the blog. Sadly as I look at my reading list there is not a lot that will go on to the blog with one exception. I am nearly done The Big Shift by John Ibbitson and Darrel Bricker and a review should appear later this month. If you are interested in non-political book reviews I am posting my books on Goodreads. I am trying to read 50 books in 2016. I am watching some political fiction and think a review for some of that will be forthcoming as well.

Over the next year there are a couple of stories I assume I will be writing about more often than not. First is the NDP and Conservative leadership races. The outcome of these contests will shape our national politics for at least the next three years and easily longer. As I have written both are off to slow starts but they are long affairs. I hope to do more writing about urban issues perhaps using Brampton as a case study since that is my current home and hometown. To the process and outcome of the electoral reform committee is close to my heart and I have been following closely (with much trepidation). Over the next five months the American people will be holding their elections. I don't pay as much attention to the United States as I once did but this will be an important campaign to watch for sure. Especially given all the immigration applications we might soon be receiving.

Ultimately this blog is about ideas. It's about expressing opinions and collecting thoughts in one place. When I started writing I thought of it almost as a way of getting my personal philosophy down on paper (so to speak). It has helped refine my ideas and try to stake out my own bizarre place on the political spectrum. It may have also permanently doomed any dream I might have for public office (or general employment). From feedback I have received I know people appreciate the "Orange Tory" approach on issues, progressive/liberal/socialist on some issues and libertarian/conservative on others and just as often simply moderate. Thanks again to readers, new and old. Please continue to comment or reach out on social media, I'm @SLee_OT on Twitter, and I hope this blog continues to be a project worth sharing in its sixth year.

Tuesday, March 29, 2016

Failures of Leadership and Stagnation in Ontario

This afternoon I was reading on the Toronto Star website trying to get ideas on what I might want to write about for today. I think it is fair to say that I have been feeling disappointed in politics over the last few months. Since the federal election there has been little to be too excited about from my point of view. While I lean more towards the policy and ideas side of politics I still want to be inspired and like my political leaders, and I feel a distinct absence of that.

I've spent nearly all of my life in the province of Ontario. It is my home, it a place I love, but at the same time if feels more and more like a place that is failing. I think it is more than fair to say that the provincial political system is broken. The Toronto Star recently reported on what can only be seen as corruption, or dangerous blurring between politicians and big donors. Cabinet ministers in Ontario's government have been given fundraising targets and must appeal to big corporate donors in areas they are responsible for to achieve their goals. This stinks. The Liberals held a fundraiser and raised $3 million in one night. I am naturally very suspicious of money in politics, I think it has a corrupting influence and distorts the principles of our system.

Premier Kathleen Wynne (OLP - Don Valley West) had promise in my eyes when she was elected. A left-of-centre Liberal, I thought she had the approach to clean up the McGuinty years and change Queen's Park for the better. The longer her term in office goes it seems like the rot may be going even deeper. Billions of dollars are added to the deficit and Ontarians have little to show for it. Indeed, our public services remain strong, but infrastructure investment continues to lack behind.

The alternatives offer little hope in my eyes. Patrick Brown, the new Progressive Conservative leader comes from a more right-wing section of the Conservative Party. He speaks like a moderate and has made gestures towards the middle, but I have to wonder if the young leader promises anything else other than budget cuts, fee increases and public strife were he elected. Does he offer any meaningful change to reform the problems in Queen's Park? I have my doubts.

I am a New Democrat, with the membership card and everything, yet I have been left very cold by Andrea Horwath's (ONDP - Hamilton Centre) leadership. The zag to the populist right in the 2014 election campaign and the NDP strategy during the minority years did not greatly inspire me. Nor for a bunch of internal party reasons am I particularly enamoured with the central leadership at this time. Nor do I  see the NDP making clear policy choices to fix the problems in this province.

I'm sure this is clearer to Ontarians elsewhere, but it feels more and more that this province is stuck in the muck. The old industrial economy has essentially vanished and nothing has really filled its place. If it wasn't for the public sector and the Toronto economic engine I wonder if the place wouldn't have already fallen off the proverbial cliff. How much of our economy is being driven by a housing bubble, which while creating jobs gobbles up farm land and puts housing out of reach of the poor and the young?

Sometimes this is when looking to mayors would offer more hope. I didn't vote for my current mayor and I was unsure of her. I remain mixed on Brampton mayor Linda Jeffrey, I have real questions about her policy directions, but mostly it is the rest of council's positions on transparency, city management, development and transit that has me grinding my teeth. In an odd way John Tory might be the Ontario politician I have the most faith in, but it isn't motivated by any excitement, more of a basic competence. Even that opinion is given pause when I consider issues like Smart Track and the Scarborough Subway.

In a recent conversation with a friend I launched into a tirade about the status quo. There are so many things wrong in Canada, Ontario, and the GTA that are perpetuated mostly by a fear of change and acceptance of the status quo. Things could be so much better. The lack of inspiration I feel about our current political class may reflect more of my own cynicism than their actual capabilities. Given the sea change on the federal scene perhaps there are some MPs out there who could make a difference. I'd like to be proven wrong. Who is out there to believe in?


Tuesday, November 10, 2015

Book Review: Paikin and the Premier by Steve Paikin

Since Confederation there have only been twenty-five individuals who have served as the Premier of Ontario. It is a small and exclusive club. Steve Paikin has been a reporter at Queen's Park for decades now and has a rare perspective. As Paikin writes, the books origins were in an observation that he was the only journalist to interview every Premier since 1971.



Paikin and the Premiers: Personal Reflections on a Half Century of Ontario Leaders is a collection of interviews and connecting biographies and histories. The interviews mostly consist transcriptions of interviews conducted at TVO. I found this perhaps the most disappointing part of the book. Paikin might be the best poised journalist in Ontario (or Canada) to land high-profile, challenging interviews. Former-Premiers Bill Davis and Mike Harris will not sit down for anyone, nor will current Premier Kathleen Wynne. When I began this book I assumed these would be new dedicated interviews with the Premiers on topics related to being a leader, governing Ontario, etc. The transcripts are fine and offer insight into the men and woman who have led the province, but at times it feels a bit like a square peg in a round hole. I cannot help but think this book would be substantially better with fresh interviews. I will concede this format did not work as well with me as I watched many of these interviews originally on TVO.

While most of the text is the transcripts of interviews I think the best parts might be Paikin's interstitial writing. The setup and context for each interview and the brief windows into Ontario's political history might be the most interesting aspects. Some of this is predictable given the subjects of the interview. Most of the interviewees were sitting Premiers. Their honesty and forthrightness could be, let's say, limited. Going into an election that one seemed doomed to lose (Eves, Rae) they were talking like victory was around the corner. It would be more valuable to interview them today and reflect back on that time.

The interviews with the men I was least familiar with were the most interesting. In particular, John Robarts, Premier from 1961-1971, had a fascinating and difficult life and remarkable premiership. The personal histories might be the real strength here. Paikin has a well-known sympathy and interest in politicians.

This book has a niche appeal. If you're interested in Ontario politics and snapshots of the past it may be of interest to you. I know it did not meet what I was hoping to find, but that's not to say it isn't interesting or compelling at points. Paikin's earlier books The Life: The Seductive Call of Politics and The Dark Side: The Personal Price of a Political Life are far stronger case studies of political life. Sadly, these interview may best be explored through TVO's archive of interviews rather than in written form.




Tuesday, June 16, 2015

A New Flag for Ontario?


This year two of Canada's flags mark their fiftieth birthdays. The most prominent is, of course, the national flag, the red maple leaf. However, as the Red Ensign was lowered in Ottawa and across the country and replaced with the red maple leaf it rose somewhere else. Until 1960s Ontario did not have an official flag. There was significant resistance to replacing the Red Ensign so Premier Robarts of Ontario decided to adopt it as Ontario's flag and replaced the Canadian coat of arms with the Ontario one. Thus the flag of Ontario was born. Steve Paikin outlined the history of Ontario's flag here. 

Ontario's Red Ensign


Last week in the Worth Reading I included an article by Martin Regg Cohn suggesting the merits of replacing Ontario's flag. As Cohn put it, "Today, that flag flies in the face of our diversity - its design unheralded, its anniversary unmarked, its inspiration utterly unoriginal. Like our flagging monarchy and segregated schools for Catholics, it is an anachronism that defines Ontario's political culture of inertia." I am not so hard on Ontario's Red Ensign, but the knowledge that its origins comes something more out of reactionary spite than proud tradition certainly dampens what few warm sentiments I may have had towards it at one time.

I assume that the main objection that Mr. Cohn has about the Ontario Red Ensign is that it is overtly British. Let's leave aside the question of whether or not the Union Jack should be on our provincial flag, is the Ontario flag a good flag? The North American Vexillological Association has five simple principles of flag design.

1. Keep it Simple - The flag should be so simple that a child can draw it from memory.

2. Use Meaningful Symbolism - The flag's images, colours, or patterns should relate to what it symbolizes.

3. Use 2 or 3 Basic Colours - Limit the number of colours on the flag to three which contrast well and come from the standard colour set.

4. No Lettering or Seals - Never use writing or any kind or an organization's seal.

5. Be Distinctive or Be Related - Avoid duplicating other flags, but use similarities to show connections.

Canada's National and Provincial Flags, note Ontario and Manitoba's Red Ensigns

Ontario's Red Ensign fails four of these five criteria. No child could draw it from memory, it contains several colours, and its sole distinguishing feature is the inclusion of the seal of Ontario. The worst though, in my opinion is that it is not distinctive. Looking at a picture of all of Canada's flags it takes a careful eye to not mix up Manitoba and Ontario. Canada is fortunate in that many of our provincial flags are quite beautiful and distinctive. Newfoundland and Labrador (and the separate Labrador flag), Saskatchewan and Nunavut's flags are all very appealing, in my opinion, and even New Brunswick, the Northwest Territories and British Columbia, despite being overly complex, are unique and unlikely to be confused for something else.

A more serious flag debate is taking place in NewZealand. New Zealand's flag is not too different from Ontario's in conception, but worse still, it is very similar to Australia's. For decades there has been pressure to swap the Kiwi flag for something more appropriate. A binding referendum is planned for 2015 and 2016. New Zealand's process may provide a handy guide if Ontario chooses to replace its own flag. A panel of New Zealanders were assembled to select four of the best candidates for flag replacements, submitted by anyone. The public will vote this winter on which of the four they prefer and in April the question will be asked which flag should be the national flag going forward.


When I first considered writing about this I thought the idea of replacing Ontario's flag was silly, but the more I think about it the more it makes sense. I was once asked by a friend from Alberta if there was such a thing as an Ontarian identity. I'm sure the lack of easy symbols doesn't help. Perhaps a new flag more representative and pleasing could forge a more cohesive identity. Looking online people already have some ideas, usually incorporating the provincial flower, the trillium. Obviously there are bigger problems facing the province, but there always will be, just like Canada in 1965, but I doubt few today would object to the change once made.

Tuesday, April 21, 2015

Power, Profits and the Public Good

I can understand the urge for many people to privatize government agencies, assets and services. The government can be inefficient and clumsy. Some services are better provided by the private sector. However, there appears to be a category of services that seem roughly to be a draw between public and private provision. The Northwest Territories has dealt with substantial problems regarding power generation and distribution. There are various systematic problems dogging the system. In public meetings on the topic it is not unusual for people to say "We should privatize the power corp," or "It's the government's fault, they need to get out of it." This suggestion, often rooted in frustration, is understandable but entirely inappropriate.

In the particular case of the Northwest Territories the problem is multifaceted. The territory's power grid is complicated. Most of the communities are isolated from one another and must have its own independent power generation, especially in the smaller and more northern areas. That means diesel generators burning expensive fuel in the scattered communities. The problem became more severe in Yellowknife this year when low water levels meant that the hydro system was rendered ineffective and had to switch to its diesel generators at enormous cost. The cost to extend power to Yellowknife from the South Slave or connect the South Slave to the national grid stands in the billions and therefore out of the government's reach.

Privatizing the Northwest Territories Power Corporation would do nothing to address this problems. If anything the additional costs to anticipate this risk would simply be put on the consumer pushing the prices ever higher.

In the province of Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne (OLP - Don Valley West) has announced her government's intention to sell 60% of Hydro One. Martin Regg Cohn laid out the government's case in his most recent piece. Basically there is no better time to borrow money. The continuing sluggishness of the world economy has resulted in very low interest rates. Capital markets are seeking somewhere to invest their money to make it work and therefore the cost of borrowing money is much lower than usual. This is why you are hearing people suggest that this is a good time to use deficit spending to improve the economy. The plan is to use the capital from the sale of existing power transmission lines to construct new transmission lines and, from what I read elsewhere, pay for other infrastructure.

The government of Ontario has convinced several key people that the sale is for the better. The simple fact is that the provision of power is not a service like retail, it is a utility and unlike other utilities (internet and cable) it is fundamental to the health and well-being of citizens. Virtually every home is connected to the grid. Aside from remote homes/cabins pretty much everyone has access and I do not think anyone in good conscience would deprive people of electricity. That being the case it is not a market good that can conform to the flexibility of prices. It would be better then to treat power utilities like they are - a public good. Complete ownership by the state allows for greater control and management and no waste or poor maintenance for the sake of profit.

While Ontario might be in a favourable position to sell hydro assets today the market will inevitably change. What happens when the province wants to buy back these assets? How inflated will the costs be then? How will this impact changes needed to the dismal electricity situation in Ontario? For the betterment of society as a whole I think we would be better off understanding that electricity is expensive, complicated and infrastructure heavy while also being essential to deliver. This makes it a perfect candidate for public ownership and any tinkering with that may only result in more difficult challenges in the future. 

Tuesday, February 3, 2015

A Parliamentary Democracy, If You Can Keep It

In a Globe and Mail piece I shared out in a recent Worth Reading that shared disturbing poll results. According to the poll 17% of Canadians believe that in "difficult times" the Prime Minister can dissolve the Supreme Court and 23% say he/she could dismiss Parliament and rule alone. Not even 'in a time of crisis', just difficult times. Now could be defined as difficult, any time could if a government wanted it to be. If you are anything like me and care about the things I care about those numbers cause a chill to go down your spine.

I heard a history professor remark once that one of our great delusions is that democracy is permanent. That it is a natural outgrowth of progress and that one day, inevitably, all societies will embrace this perfect form of being. But the truth is that democracy is incredibly fragile and we've seen liberal democracies crumble and fall more often than we care to remember. In fact many of the dictatorships of the twentieth century emerged from democracies, not some other form of government. I think this permanence has deluded us. The notion is that somehow the current situation will perpetuate itself in some sort of natural order.

As a hand-wringing democrat I have spent a great deal of time worrying over the state of affairs in this country: the abuses of Parliament by Prime Minister Stephen Harper; the increasing absenteeism of the provincial legislatures; the flagrant corruption (moral, ethical and fiscal) that has polluted municipal politics. Canadians may be perfectly justified in their growing cynicism and disengagement.

The changing demographics of who votes nowadays is an ironic return to the former status quo. Wealthier, older, whiter people, disproportionately rural, fill voting booths and make important political decisions. It is not difficult to see how these changes are and will affect political discourse and policy in this country. If politicians can afford to ignore a group of voters, they will.

It would be easy to read something like this and presume that I fear that one day jackbooted thugs will patrol the streets of Canada and silence opposition. I do not believe that to be the case. What I envision is that one day it will be harder and harder to look at our country and say that we have a robust democracy. Presently roughly 20% of our voting age population supported the party of the current Prime Minister in the 2011 federal election. As has been documented innumerable times in the media, academia and this blog our Prime Minister exerts incredible amounts of power. Party discipline is spectacularly high. Even whispers of dissent are eliminated immediately. A bloated appointment system for the Senate, public service, judiciary and Cabinet keep eager and ambitious politicians in line far more effectively than oppression. This is to say nothing of the growing issue of domestic spying or other increased police powers. 

More and more I fear that the evidence that is most damning is that political parties are breaking the law and seemingly paying not legal or political consequence for it. The federal Conservatives broke their fixed-date election and election spending law, the collapse of opposition in Alberta, and more recently are the debacles in Ontario. The provincial Liberals are accused of breaching election law by offering a position to a former candidate, Andrew Olivier, so he would not run again. The Liberals have argued that no concrete offer was made and therefore the law wasn't broken. This sort of fragrant disregard, and it is hardly unique, definitely undermines the notion that the rule of law governs those in power.

More and more our parliaments do not resemble centres of democratic action but stage managed public relations events. Debates are staged and meaningless, votes are predetermined, opposition is marginalized, time for debate is curtailed, omnibus legislation limits scrutiny, election laws increasingly exclude citizens, our appointed senate continues to exercise legal authority, and the government increasingly uses public funds to run partisan ads which sometimes do not align with actual programs.

If I were to describe what Canada's institutions of government are rather than what they are supposed to be you would think I was talking about a country in the former Soviet Union or developing world that can only tangentially be called a democracy. There are no simple fixes; rules for parliaments must be made explicit and enshrined, laws must be changed, electoral systems reformed, political parties and political culture must change and that would just be a start.  As we glide towards an illiberal democracy and politics becomes a hobby for elites and partisans will Canadians notice? Will they care?