Showing posts with label Andrea Horwath. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Andrea Horwath. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 25, 2017

Is it Time for Phamacare?

I was surprised when the Ontario New Democratic Party's leader, Andrea Horwath, announced a policy for pharmacare. It's the single boldest policy position the Ontario NDP has taken in decades. 

The reasoning is simple: one in four people in Ontario aren't taking the medication they need because they cannot afford it. The province will begin by covering the most commonly prescribed essential medications. The estimated cost of the plan would be $475 million per year. That number sounds onerous, but in a provincial budget of $133 billion it will make a small impact. Horwath, during the announcement, suggested that this could find savings for the overall budget as patients who can better manage their care are less likely to end up in hospital or with worse chronic conditions.

I was at first concerned about this policy. It seemed like a bloated social program that would doom the NDP from winning any support from centrist Ontarians. The initial price tag gave me some comfort, to be sure. I'm sure the price of a universal system would be staggering, but the ONDP isn't talking about that at this stage.

The policy started to make a great deal of sense to me when I framed it within my family. My father retired a few weeks ago and medical expenses are something he's thinking about. My grandmother and uncles are on limited income and have significant health complications. If the burden of some of their life-saving medicines was removed it would surely improve their situation.


As our economy undergoes a transformation to a less stable, less predictable, and less secure I think that the state is going to have to provide the supports to keep our society functioning and skim from the productivity of the low-labour economy. I look forward to seeing what this program's details, but I think it might be the next logical step as we face an aging population and a precarious economy. 

Tuesday, October 23, 2012

Canada: A Strictly Ceremonial Democracy


It has only been a few weeks since I started posting twice a week. With the prorogation and Liberal leadership race in Ontario, the second omnibus budget bill in Ottawa, and some other minor issues that have popped up in recent weeks it feels like I don’t have enough time. I determined what I would write about a long while ago today before McGuinty resigned or the economic was introduced. Suddenly posting three times a week seems like a good idea. Luckily for me this is just a temporary problem and I am sure a slower news cycle will take hold soon enough.

The common thread of the two stories of the moment is the health of democracy in Canada. Watching The National’s At Issue panel on Thursday I was stunned by the force of the language used and unanimity of their condemnation of the federal government’s use of a second omnibus budget. To paraphrase Andrew Coyne, many international news items reporting from the developing world will refer to the ‘largely ceremonial’ legislature. Canada now has a largely ceremonial legislature.

In essence, in Canada, our House of Commons and provincial legislatures are more similar to the American Electoral College than the parliamentary democracies of our past. The leader of the party that receives the most seats gets to rule with limited checks or balances on his or her power. The only group that can threaten his/her control is the caucus of the governing party in a majority situation. But MPs in that caucus, so fearful of retribution from the leadership and the desire to climb the party ranks and perhaps secure (a now neutered) cabinet post, will not stand up to their leaders.

Bill C-45, the formal name of the second omnibus budget bill, is, as the Toronto Star calls it, an affront to our democracy. These omnibus bills fundamentally undermine the purpose of our representative parliamentary democracy. The job of a Member of Parliament is pretty straightforward. They must represent their constituents, hold the government to account and scrutinize laws. When a piece of legislation is over 400 pages, affecting dozens of pieces of legislation and the implications of the changes are not clear, how is a MP to do his/her job? In the space of a few short weeks, with limited debate, Bill C-45 will become law and our environmental laws and who knows what else.

Drip by drip the fundamental institution of democracy fades ever so slightly into something less than a democracy. No, I don’t suspect that one day jackbooted men will walk in our streets and cameras will carefully watch our every move and dissenters will be banished to camps in Kenora, but our democracy will start to feel a lot less real, and much less responsive until it resembles the ones found in countries like Singapore, or worse, Russia.

The recent prorogation in Ontario is a symptom of the same terrible disease. The province will be governed by the cabinet without public input until at least January 25th. At that time a new Liberal leader will be selected and Dalton McGuinty will resign. Still, the legislature will not be sitting. Ending the parliamentary session to undergo a leadership race is inexcusable. Constitutional expert Peter Russell slammed the McGuinty government for abusing its powers and shutting down the legislature http://ontarionewswatch.com/onw-news.html?id=410.

As ONDP leader Andrea Horwath (ONDP - Hamilton Centre) pointed out on The Agenda last week, governments have gone through leadership races without ending a legislative session. The government’s explanation is weak and as Martin Regg Cohn argued, it is a mismanaged retreat.

I fear our democracy is in decline. It has been in decline for decades but there has been a brief and rapid acceleration. Our constitution is dependent upon the respect of tradition as much as written rules. Governments increasingly abuse these unwritten rules. Even if voters punish the Ontario Liberals and the Conservatives it may not (and probably will not) reverse this trend. Governments do not abandon the power and concentration of authority, even if the parties switch.










Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Hot Tempers and a Summer Election



As the debate over the federal budget comes to a close the rhetoric over Ontario’s budget is heating up. Steve Paikin of TVO did a far better job than I could at summarizing the controversy, but I will do my best. A few weeks ago Andrea Horwath (ONDP - Hamilton Centre), leader of the NDP, managed to extract some concessions from Dalton McGuinty’s (OLP – Ottawa South) Liberal government’s budget. It was a tense negotiation and the ONDP were able to extract a few concession, including a significant new tax to offset spending cuts.

When it came time to support the bill in the Legislative Assembly the ONDP abstained from voting, allowing for the superior numbers of Liberals to outnumbered the Progressive Conservatives and pass the budget. This tactic also gave the ONDP deniability to the budget, as it did not pass with their support.

The budget then moved to the finance committee where Ontario New Democrats made several amendments to the budget with the support of the Progressive Conservatives. The Liberals claimed that this was a breach of Andrea Horwath’s promise to pass the budget. On Monday Premier McGuinty threatened to call an election if amendments were made. The Opposition called his bluff and eliminated five sections of the budget.

That being said, it appears the budget will pass tomorrow and Ontarians will be spared an election. Watching this debate unfold in social media was interesting. Those allied in common cause to fight the federal Conservative budget quickly turned on each other and sniped at one another over this Ontario dust-up. The differences between Liberals and New Democrats once again became quite clear, and on some level that made me sad.

The discussion around the Ontario budget, in my opinion, has been flawed. Criticism has been harsh against the Ontario New Democrats, and relatively silent about the Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario. If the PCs did not side with New Democrats on the amendments they would not have passed. One might have thought this was a carefully constructed plan. Especially given how many of the amendments went against Tory policy. From very early on Tim Hudak (PCPO – Niagara West-Glanbrook) has refused to participate in the process.

Recent polling has the three parties in Ontario virtually tied. The PCs lead in the mid-30s, the NDP around 30% and the Liberals in thehigh-20s. All parties risk a great deal with this budget brinkmanship. The fortieth Legislative Assembly of Ontario may not be long for this world, while it may survive the dog days of summer, the fall may see us going back to the polls.