Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 24, 2018

Not Running This Time


I have decided not to throw my hat into the local elections this autumn. If you missed my prior post I had serious thoughts about running for a position on the Peel District School Board. There are a number of big issues confronting public education that I know will require thoughtful people to lead discussion on. Especially now with Premier Ford's government in place school boards will have to be passionate advocates for education.

Ultimately though, standing for election is not something you can do lightly. I considered this at points to be an effort to merely get some ideas out there an into the public debate. However, I would remain the avatar of those ideas. I would rightly be held accountable for my ideas and positions, and for various other aspects that I am not entirely comfortable with.

I think a lot of people will talk about why they are running, so I thought it might be worthwhile for someone to share the considerations about why they are not running.

One of the big reasons I am not running this time around is my nervousness about public scrutiny. By scrutiny I don't mean things like criticism of my ideas and platform, I mean personal ones. At thirty years old I've spend about half of my life on the internet. This blog is eight years old and reflects hundreds of thoughts and opinions and I have a Twitter account that had definitely embarrassing things if I was ever confronted with them. I don't mean anything serious, just things that would make me cringe. The idea of people picking through photos or other things that are more private, though still public on the internet, is unsettling.

A big consideration is my employment. I work in the education sector. It could be seen as a conflict, or at least problematic for me to run for school board. My employers have been very kind to me so I do not wish to dismiss their considerations so easily.

Finally, it's all personal. As much as I want to try and put my name forward and fight for ideas I care about I fear I'm not ready yet. My personal and professional situation is not at the place I want it to be. I don't believe I would have the support necessary or desired to make this sort of effort. I sincerely hope that I don't feel this way always and the next time around I feel differently, but at the moment when I look at the prospect of standing for election, it just feels like the wrong time for me.

Dozens of factors weigh in for a person considering this. I have to imagine for every person who runs there are a dozen who seriously considered it but their circumstance or the moment just wasn't right. I hope to personally be in a better one, or if I'm not, I hope to be braver then.

July 27th is the last day to register as a candidate, so get out there!

Tuesday, August 30, 2016

The Strange Debate over Sex Education

I read in the news this week that leader of the Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario, Patrick Brown (PCPO - Simcoe North) was caught in an embarrassing flip-flop on the sex education question. In short, Brown signed a letter in English and Chinese that was distributed to the riding of Scarborough-Rouge River, which is in the midst of a by-election, claiming to oppose the current curriculum. When questioned about this Brown disavowed the letter, saying it was a mistake.

Sigh.

I do not particularly care about Mr. Brown's policy reversal. I think it is rewarding that he intends to, at least for now, leave in the sex education curriculum. I really do not think those that oppose sex education actually care about sex education changes, they seem to oppose sex education in general. I went to dinner with a friend tonight who teaches in public school. She reminded me that the curriculum was last overhauled in the 1990s, and elements of it, including the section on growth and development was the same from the 1980s. Growth and development, you know, the things kids are going through and have the most questions about. It might be nice if teachers had some more up-to-date materials to work with.

I'm going to keep this brief. I do not see what leg opponents of sex education stand on. The program is voluntary. These parents can pull their students from the class with the understanding they will instruct them on these matters. The additions to the curriculum falls in line with how our schools and culture are changing more generally. Schools are attempting, at an institutional level, to be bastions of acceptance, or at least tolerance. It seems odd to endorse things like the Rainbow Coalition but not discuss what gender expression is.


North Americans have quite conservative notions about sex, in general. Sex is viewed in a pretty strange way, though I admit I share some of these more prudish tendencies. That said I hardly think going down the road that ignorance is preferable to knowledge is the right path. I hope governments continue to improve the curriculum rather than bow to the preferences of a vocal, squeamish minority

Tuesday, August 9, 2016

Teaching History in Ontario, Badly

Be forewarned that the following post could be classified as a rant and recommended to be read with a rapid, irate tone of voice.

Why do so many children in Ontario receive a lacklustre history education? I have the grade 10 mandatory Canadian history course in mind. I took that class as a student, I learned about that class as a teacher-candidate, I taught that class as a teacher and now I help students who take it as a tutor. Time and time again I see students have a poor educational experience, completely turned off from the discipline and ignorant to their own country's history.

There is fundamentally little wrong with the CHC2D/P curriculum. The document provides guidelines for a five unit course that focuses on the periods 1914-1929, 1929-1945, 1945-1982, 1982-Present and a unit on historical inquiry. However this document bears almost no resemblance to the education I see students receiving. I assume that the mentalities and approaches to history calcified in the previous curriculum and teachers have not bothered with updating their materials and approach. Which is baffling given that they are expected to address the present which is constantly moving forward.

In my experience CHC2D/P, also known as Canadian History since World War I, is taught as 3.5 units. The first unit is an exhaustive study of World War I, this is followed by a combined 1920s/30s unit, which is of course followed by World War II. If there is time a fourth unit is dedicated to "the rest". The entire second half of the 20th century and the 21st century is boiled down to whatever can be crammed in before the final exam. I recall when I was a high school student our class got past the mid-1960s while our peers across the hall ended WWII in June. I suppose it is a great irony that history teachers are unable to manage time, but for me, talking to students, it is immensely frustrating.

What I once assumed to be a laughable fluke seems actually to be the norm. If classes manage to get to the fourth unit, 1945-Present, it is so watered down and broad little meaningful information can be extracted by the students.

Most teachers (I hope) are not wasting time with their pupils, but they have poorly allocated the time they do have. From looking at countless worksheets and unit tests teachers become far too obsessed with the World Wars. Students are forced to study minute details about those conflicts. More time is dedicated to those 10 combined years than to the rest of the century. World War I was likely the most consequential war in the modern era. It fundamentally shaped the world into what we know it as today, but if you think a grade 10 student needs to understand the Schlieffen Plan as a term, but not be able to identify who Tommy Douglas was then you and I have very different understandings of Canadian history. The Schlieffen Plan is only relevant if you know about the Franco-Prussian War in 1870. Otherwise, "The Germans invaded Belgium to surprise France in their offensive" is all that needs to be said on the topic.

Instead weeks of school time are dedicated to battles that Canada did not participate in and scrutinizing every piece of military technology. I am not arguing that World War I is not important, what I am asking is that if you wanted to teach someone what was relevant about Canada's history would you spend a quarter of the time on 1914-1918?

I believe the focus on the World Wars reveals a strong Eurocentric bias in the Ontario curriculum. Hitler's rise to power is not terribly relevant for a Canadian history class. It would be exceptionally relevant in a world history course though, or government. The focus on the World Wars sucks the oxygen away from other pressing issues. Labour unrest and political radicalism was at its peak in that period and arguably has far more to do with the country we live in today as the Battle of Ypres and the Liberation of the Scheldt. The Winnipeg General Strike and general unrest from 1910-1940 deserves just as much say.

Perhaps my perspective on this next part is heavily influenced by where I grew up. The Canada we know and love today was born in the Post-War period. The wartime, and hard times of the early 20th century are crucial, but many of the institutions we associate with our country comes from the post-war period. The welfare state, socialized medicine, our flag, multiculturalism, open immigration, technology, Canada's status as a middle/minor power all stems from mid-20th century. I teach mostly non-white students. When I ask them about their family history and they say their grandparents or parents came in the 1970s I can tell them that that was because of the point system and previous to that they likely could not. It shocks them, literally, that there was a time when people like those in their families were not welcome here. A great deal of time is spent on events (many of which are only tangentially related to Canada) rather than the spirit of Canada in different time periods. From proudly white and British and a reticent French contingent to what we are now was a hell of a journey, one this course isn't communicating.

History has certain fracture points that tend to echo decades or centuries down strongly. Martin Luther's theses is one example that pops to mind. But aside from these moments the most recent past has a greater impact on our day-to-day life. The last couple decades are critical for understanding the world we currently live in. In particular the events of September 11th, 2001 would fit well in a history course today. It profoundly impacted our lives today in Canada and elsewhere and the ripple effects are still out there. Students in this course, 15-16 years old, have no memory of 9/11. They don't understand that North America has transformed since then. That the post-Cold War euphoria transformed into the paranoia security state etc. we know today. Right now a graduate from CHC2D/P has very little information that helps them understand how Canada came to be the country it is today. Canadians know shockingly little about their history and politics. Is it any wonder if they are left with 40-50 year gap in their knowledge to how we got from World War II to the present?

Finally, Canadian history is not and should not be a film studies course. The number of students I have spoken to that have described multiple classes being dedicated to multiple films for little tangible educational benefit is staggering. I showed clips in my class. The most I showed, I believe, was the episode of Band of Brothers on a long-weekend Friday where they liberate the concentration camp, as I thought the visuals would be more effective for them. The D-Day landing in Saving Private Ryan is incredible, but the whole film doesn't belong. Hollywood is not renowned for its tact and thorough depictions of historic periods, events or figures. Offering them as a solid resource gives a plastic, flimsy understanding of history to students.

History, by its nature, is a narrative discipline. We're trying to tell stories, present arguments and offer up perspectives. A dull recitation of facts and dates with more relationship to world or European history with scant context and the enticement of frequent films is hardly serving our students to become informed, knowledgeable citizens. Not all history teachers are bad at what they do; though a shocking number who teach though are not trained in history. We are lucky to have a mandatory history course, but who is it currently serving? It's time for Canadian history to better reflect the entire 20th century and for what's happening in classrooms to better match what the curriculum intends.

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

Northern Update and How We Vote

Today was an unusual day. The South Slave Divisional Education Council, in essence a school board and my employer, holds meetings once every two months in one of its five communities. The last community is normally Lutsel K’e, a fly-in community on the Great Slave Lake. After getting up at 4:30 and getting ready I boarded a DHC Otter and flew from Fort Smith to Hay River, to Fort Resolution to Lutsel K’e. Once our meeting was complete we returned the way we came depositing staff and our elected representatives as we went.

At one point during the trip I could not help but think, “I imagined I might get a job that required travel, but this is not what I suspected.” There is a certain surreal quality that creeps into my life. I live in a place where small aircraft is often the most effective means of transportation and at the moment the sun is having trouble setting. When I woke up at 4:30 it was bright and sunny, and it never truly becomes night anymore.

The week before I was asked to share my thoughts after three days of meetings between principals, administration staff, literacy coaches and program support teachers (special education). As I often say, I have very little to do with the business of the SSDEC, educating children, but as a somewhat outside observer I find it deeply impressive the dedication and results the educators here achieve despite all of the hardships and challenges. It’s humbling, inspiring and deeply impressive.

Changing gears, as the Ontario election date approaches I increasingly think about how I would vote. This is compounded by the fact that my family often asks me for insight on elections. Not instructions, more like preliminary research and help cut through the noise.

Not being on the ground and dealing with the question concretely I am given the freedom to consider how we pick who we vote for. There are innumerable options which range in the validity. Party, local candidate, ideology, leader, or various ephemeral or superficial considerations all weigh in on the choice. But what if you like the party but don’t like who they are running locally? What if you like your local candidate, but hate the leader/party? What if you like the party, but dislike the current leader?


We only get one vote, yet we are forced to make it do many things. I am a strong opponent to people using phrases like “voters clearly...” or “the people want...”. When asked to boil down all the things you are and believe into a single vote there can be no perfect distillation, even if you were voting for yourself! It’s an interesting challenge, and I am curious to know what qualities voters in Ontario will be considering when they head to the polls in coming weeks. 

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Racist No More


My piece from last week on the Idle No More movement garnered significant attention over the last seven days. It is in not terribly surprising given the moment we are living in. In my discussion I touched on a lot of different aspects of the movement and response. However, over the past week there was something I want to revisit – racism.

Racism, obviously, is a highly loaded word. In contemporary society there may be no more serious allegation than that of “racist”, but I am beginning to doubt that. Clear displays of racism are essentially intolerable in Canadian society. Overt symbols such as the swastika, the Ku Klux Klan and certain words (which I chose not to write) are simply not permitted and solicit strong public outcry.

While modern Canada has worked hard to eliminate overt racism the systematic and institutional racism that existed within previous systems of power continue to linger. Coming out of an Education background I became very familiar with the institutional biases that are stacked against non-majority students. Studies show again and again that non-white students underperform. Theories exist to explain it; my favourite one was essentially coined by George W. Bush as the “soft bigotry of low expectations.”

So while you would be hard pressed to find a white American who would use the “n-word” in polite conversation, you probably would struggle to find a Canadian to call First Nations, Métis, and Inuit “savages”. That being said, many of the institutional problems that confront these marginalized minorities persist, and worse still, they persist within the minds of their fellow citizens.

Comment sections on news articles have now been long-known to be hotbed of the most virulent and abusive of remarks. Mallick from the Toronto Star wrote an article this week about the degrading tone and what it might suggest about the Canadian public in general. I know I have my own biases, I made that clear enough I believe last week, and in general in this blog. It is my opinion that there are commonly held opinions that if applied to other groups would clearly be construed as racist remarks, but given our own cultural context appear normal.

Imagine if this comment, “The majority of them could not seem to harness the positive energy to do something constructive,” was said not about Aboriginals on reserves, but about African-Americans. If a Congressman or woman said those comments he/she would be rightfully targeted by the media and tried in the court of public opinion – harshly. Sadly, I think far too many Canadians read comments like that and say, “Yes, that’s the truth.” It’s that soft bigotry; we expect nothing from indigenous people and assume they are capable of nothing.

As a counterpoint activists on social media began to use the hashtag #Ottawapiskat to point out hypocrisy in the treatment of reserves versus every other aspect of the federal government. Given my political persuasion it is particularly galling to hear over and over how reserves need transparency as our government has rammed in massive omnibus budgets with unforeseen consequences.

The treatment of Aboriginal people and our colonial history is Canada’s national shame. Like many we want to avoid our shame and blame others instead of taking responsibility for it. We misdirect criticism, minimize abuses and misconstrue attempts at reconciliation as attacks. Perhaps the biggest problem is that for many Canadians is that the issues confronting Native peoples are Native peoples’ problems. They don’t see them, they do not feel responsible and blame those facing this issues rather than the issues themselves. When protesters and leaders try to get Canadians’ attention one can almost hear the audible sigh, “What do they want now?”

I sincerely hope we do not get to a crisis point in this country, but as I said last week it feels like the two major sides in this debate cannot even agree on terms, or the parameters of the discussion. Therefore we have these current “discussions” where at least one side, and sometimes both, chooses not to listen.

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Reflections on Newtown


I avoided it at first. The news came to me while I was driving home from some Christmas shopping. It was an early report and not entirely clear so I was afforded the luxury to ignore it for the moment. A few hours later I turned on the TV and saw President Obama’s remarks following the tragedy.

Over the weekend I was busy and preoccupied so I did not give the massacre in Newtown, Connecticut much thought at all. Then on Monday afternoon I decided to watch the morning broadcast of MSNBC’s Morning Joe. I spent a great deal of the time with a clenched throat and misty eyes. I’d like to first of all commend the Morning Joe team for focussing on the victims, the community and possible solutions – and not the perpetrator of this unimaginable crime.

My previous experience with the shooting had been largely through radio, or President Obama’s remarks, but I am a more visual person and so I do not think that reached into me as much as seeing the photos of agonized parents, shaken first responders, or, most painful, the faces of the lost children. Photos of the victims are available here, at the Hartford Courant website. The Courant has excellent, and heartbreaking coverage of the shooting.

Looking at their little faces, and bright smiles it becomes immediately obvious how young these children were, and how innocent and how monstrous an act this was. For a few weeks now I have been working as a teacher at a private tutoring company. I teach students in middle school, or high school, but the facility has plenty of pre-schoolers and young elementary students around. When I watched the news coverage of the incident at Sandy Hook I saw their little faces, and their bright eyes, and their awkward, frantic movements.

Returning to the Morning Joe broadcast, the first thing I saw was a statement given by Joe Scarborough, video clip below.

Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Scarborough, a four-term congressman, was endorsed by the National Rifle Association each time, and had an A-rating from that organization. His position has changed. He says that Sandy Hook changed everything and reasonable restrictions on military-style weapons are needed. The discussion from the rest of Monday’s broadcast made clear that there appears to be a lot of agreement that some restrictions on weapons available in the United States must be implemented. Many of the Morning Joe hosts have visited to Newtown, or know Connecticut which added an effective weight to their comments.

I hope the panels on Morning Joe on Monday are right and that change will come, but we’ve seen this before. The horror is different, and more painful, but there have been 31 school shootings since Columbine in the United States and laws have become more relaxed for guns, not tighter. Restricting guns is only one part, the types available are one aspect, but who can purchase them is another. Better identification and treatment of mental health problems is a component, as is addressing cultures of violence and indifference to human life.

I hope the families and people of Newtown can find peace one day, and that the survivors can live lives unmarred by this trauma and continue their blissful innocence. I hope their deaths are not meaningless, and that because of this horror things change in America so that a crime of this magnitude cannot happen again.



Tuesday, November 15, 2011

The Value of a Good Education


 Last week in my post about why Canadian history is great I mentioned I am a graduate student in history. This week I would like to turn my focus to post-secondary education. During the provincial election I wrote on Liberal education policy, with a focus on K-12, you can read my thoughts there.

During the election Dalton McGuinty and his party promised to create thousands of new positions in universities, not to mention three brand new universities. Every year thousands of students enter the post-secondary system in Ontario. An increasing focus on college education is beneficial, but when people think post-secondary, they are usually thinking about university. Premier McGuinty and the government of Ontario are aiming to make Ontario the most educated workforce in North America, and the world, to attract employers. But are we doing that correctly?

Despite all the complaints about the cost of tuition a very large proportion of the cost of education is subsidized by the provincial government. If memory serves undergrad students only pay 30% of the cost, and the province picks up 70%. The rate for graduate students is even higher. Are we spending our money properly?

The government is making an economic argument for why we should educate ourselves. The subsidies students receive are across the board, we do not target fields we need growth in. All students are treated equally regardless of whether their program is sports and recreation or physics. From my own experience, teachers’ colleges are by far and away producing more teachers than the province can hire. I heard in teachers’ college that Ontario graduated 7,000 teacher-candidates that did not find positions. That ignores the students at American universities or out-of-province. How many tens of thousands, or hundreds of thousands of dollars went into teacher education that resulted in careers other than what was intended? Why are we overinvesting in these programs?

Master’s or graduate programs are equally questionable. If I recall correctly the province subsidizes Master’s education to the tune of over 80%, and the tuition is higher, so it is a greater cost to the public. Universities are expanding their graduate and research components to compensate for budget shortfalls. A handful of new grad school positions can provide the same income as a class of undergrads.

Higher education used to be the preserve of an elite, for better and worse. The only people who got an MA or MSc intended to be an academic. Master’s degrees are now an effort to distinguish themselves from the sea of BAs and BScs. Government policy now openly favours academic inflation and the erosion of the value of each degree. I am not a fortune teller, but the economic productivity that is thrown off by my area of education is tenuous at best. Those getting an MA in English, or philosophy, or popular culture may not be the best investment for the province. Colleges are becoming finishing schools for university graduates who need real skills to enter their desired fields. Clearly, the economic end-goals of the province and students are not being met.

But is education about economic ends? I feel confident that if I asked why my peers in the MA History program were in the program, they would say they were drawn to it because of a love of history and a love of learning, likewise with my friends in other MA programs. I do not mean to be an idealist, but universities should be centres of advanced learning and knowledge, not just career-prep centres.

If the province is truly interested in using post-secondary education to crank the economy then shouldn’t it target its funding? Grants should be given to the skilled trades, or perhaps they should get 100% free tuition. Degrees in engineering, technology, advanced sciences, business and accounting should be highly subsidized, perhaps on the backs of students who want a classic liberal education in the arts and humanities. The goal of a post-secondary education is to get a career with a high income and good benefits.

That’s what a post-secondary education is for, right?

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Our Education Premier


Dalton McGuinty likes to style himself the education premier. His success on that file may be his proudest accomplishment since being elected. In this he combines his policies for public education (K-12) and post-secondary, which I think is an error.

I do not believe the direction of public education under the Liberal government has taken is much to celebrate over the last eight years. Not everything was incorrect, obviously. Smaller class sizes and peace with the unions is positive. Other frequently trumpeted benefits, such as increased graduation rates might be cause more for alarm than celebration. I addressed my concerns about the Ontario education policy of increased graduation rates here.

Education has increasingly turned to statistical measures to determine success – How many kids are graduating? What are the scores on the standardized tests? How many kids passed the literacy test? These questions don’t actually address issues like – Are our standards of education slipping? Are our children learning successfully? Are our students literate?

I have worked in education on several different levels – volunteer, teacher, and now as a teaching-assistant at a university. Professors much deride the declining quality of the students emerging from our public education system. Anecdotal evidence suggests that even though many thousands of students are entering Ontario universities, first year programs are increasingly becoming high school completion classes because students lack basic skills.

More students graduate every year as a percentage, but every year the value of an Ontario Secondary School Diploma drops further. It no longer signifies a particular level of skill and knowledge.

I should point out that many of my objections are likely products of our times. These patterns are unfolding across North America in many different jurisdictions with very different governments. I’m convinced for the most part that neither Tim Hudak nor Andrea Horwath would fundamentally alter this educational reality. Education is often more a product of society and economy than public policy.

On post-secondary, there are also major issues. Despite the promises of both the Progressive Conservatives and Liberals to add tens of thousands of new spaces in post-secondary institutions our schools are not adequately providing the resources to staff them. During a panel discussion I attended at Brock University the panellists were in total agreement that universities are cutting back on tenured staff in favour of part-time staff and larger class sizes. What does this do to post-secondary education in Ontario?

At Brock University our infrastructure is doing well to keep pace with our growing student body. However the departments are not. All faculties are facing budget cuts annually. Growing classes are increasingly taught by instructors and space for researchers is shrinking.

Public education in Niagara is also in trouble. Every year in Niagara there are rumours of schools closing. Many are well founded because of diminishing enrolment. Niagara will likely lose more than one high school in the coming years. What does that do for our quality of education? I agree in efficiencies and making the system effective, but schools used to be the heart of communities – these are not consequence free decisions.

Education has not received substantial attention in this election, frankly, few issues have. Perhaps when this election is over and the results have poured in I’ll look back and write what I would have liked to have heard.

Remember, Election Day is this Thursday October 6. Get out and vote!

Remember to follow me on Speak Your Mind. My latest post about a Welland Riding debate in Thorold can be found there. 

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

DSBN Academy: Road of Good Intentions

In January the District School Board of Niagara announced plans that they would introduce a new school called DSBN Academy. The new school is not to deal with overwhelming student enrolment, in fact Niagara suffers from quite the opposite. No, the purpose of the DSBN Academy is one of social promotion.

The school, when it opens, will provide a program for students grades six to eight, and will gradually expand to a full six to twelve school. While only serving seventy-five students upon opening the school will be incredibly costly, and here’s why.

DSBN Academy’s mission is provide a stepping stone for low-income children whose parents do not have a post-secondary education a path into a post-secondary career. Students will be required to submit their parents’ tax returns to ensure that they meet the low-income qualification. In addition, these students are not to be behavioural students, or those with learning disabilities. Niagara is a vast school board. It stretches from Hamilton to the American border, the width from Lake Ontario to Lake Erie. The DSBN Academy is intended to be situated in Welland, a central location in the region. A summary of what the DSBN Academy is can be found here.

Its centrality is key because all of the students will be provided free transportation to the school with bussing. This is where part of the problems begin. The cost to bus students to the Academy is estimated to be about $500,000 per year. The program in general is going to be quite expensive, and the cost per pupil is considerably greater than that of regular schools.

After the Board of Trustees approved the plan it was met immediately with strong and vocal opposition. I attended the Board meeting in which it was approved. Many of the trustees earnestly expressed a desire to help poor students succeed and break the cycle of poverty. This is a truly laudable goal, but whether or not DSBN Academy addresses that is a different story altogether. Various figures have come out to oppose it ranging from Tim Hudak, leader of the Progressive Conservative Party of Ontario to Peter Kormos, NDP MPP for the riding the school would sit in. The Left hates the idea of class-based segregation, and find the entire program slightly offensive. It also strikes at the core of public education, that a single school cannot serve an entire community. The Right sees the program as folly. This is a financial sinkhole and very impractical. In addition, a charter school and educational reform would be far more worthwhile.

My first impression is that if DSBN Academy gets off the ground it will be highly successful. Why? Well, if you remove the economic barriers to success, and only take those students who are motivated and willing to work hard are going to do quite well. Especially if you surround them with peers who want the same things, and are similarly motivated. Parents who send their children to this school will already be involved in their education, which is a huge factor in success.

When I first heard about DSBN Academy I thought it sounded like a Charter School within the public system, like Geoffrey Canada’s charter school in Harlem. Charter schools are becoming increasingly popular and successful south of the border, but they have not made a major appearance in Canada. Low-income families have to enter lotteries to win scholarships to enter these schools as they flee the public system.

I worry that the turn to a school like this is a sign that the Board has given up on the existing schools to provide meaningful service to the low-income students. Why can’t a regular high school in Fort Erie, Welland or Lincoln provide the same path to a post-secondary future? The concept behind the DSBN Academy is a good one – providing low-income students a path to university or college – but that should be the mission of every school. I applaud the initiative of the Board of Trustees, but I find this path to be misguided. The millions that will be spent on this Academy could be far better invested in programs, such as breakfast programs, and investment in school resources. Let’s make the schools we have work instead of opening new ones.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Is When that Important?

In my recent blog post titled, “Student Success, Provincial Failure” I described that I would like to add some prescriptions to what I view as the problems with the Ontario public education system. First, before I go on I want to point out that not all aspects of Student Success are objectionable, in my view. Aspects do have merit.

The mission of the Ontario government at present is to increase the number of graduates, as part of this strategy the government made it very difficult for students to leave high school. Previously students could drop out at age 16, and it has since been upped to 18. This was years ago, but the point is the same. Some students are not ready for a high school education in their adolescents. A combination of life circumstances, maturity and intellectual ability seems to hamper some students.

Instead of imprisoning students who want nothing more than to leave, why don’t we let them leave? While I could not put a reasonable estimate on it, it seems to me that teachers spent the majority of their time on a small number of students, those with learning issues and behavioural issues. If we allowed those with behavioural problems to leave and begin their working lives we may be better served. Cutting out the most problematic 1-3% of a school population could be hugely beneficial. Anyone with teaching experience just has to think of the times when “that student” is away and how much more smoothly the class runs.

My solution is as follows. We should dramatically increase the quality and availability of adult education. When these students are in their twenties and realize the shortcomings of not having a diploma they should be able to return to public education. The first problem is that a G.E.D. is not considered as valuable as a regular diploma. I do not see why we could not change that. First of all, I don’t see why we should distinguish between the two. This would eliminate any stigma, though any employer could do the math and see a discrepancy in age and the date the diploma was issued.

Here’s my question: Does it matter when the diploma is issued so long as it is issued? Or, is “when” important? To me, I say no. Instead of jamming programs in so that children complete an Ontario Secondary School Diploma in 4-5 years, why not just make it easier for those who do not get it at the first shot to get it at the second attempt? This kind of program would benefit those who struggled in their youth, immigrants and those seeking to improve their basic education. Seems like a no-brainer to me.

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Student Success, Provincial Failure

This may not be my wisest blog posting as it could impede my ability to be hired in this province, but I feel like making my objections about Student Success and the impact it is having in classrooms and on our province is necessary.

The fundamental problem in the Ontario educational system is a misunderstanding of what is wrong with the public system. Earlier in the previous decade it was determined that the low rate of student graduation was a fundamental concern. This is a false diagnosis. The thinking of the McGuinty government was that the post-modern economy requires a more educated workforce. The days of dropping out of high school and getting a well-paying job in manufacturing are over, at least for now.

The government reasoned that most jobs would require a high school diploma in the new economy, at a minimum. This was intended to put Ontario on track for success. On the contrary the programs in place will hurt Ontario in the long run.

The assumption that a more educated workforce is needed is probably valid, but that is not the goal of the government. The goal of the government is to increase the level of accreditation, not education. These are fundamentally unconnected ideas.

With the goal of increasing the number of diplomas in Ontario requires reducing the standards that we demand to award a diploma. The population is not different one year to the next. Some are brilliant, some are below average and there is the vast squishy middle. Before these initiatives about 68% of students graduated, which seems about right. The stated goal is 85%. That means promoting the 17% that would previously fail. The government wants immediate results.

A true reform program would begin at the kindergarten and primary level and we would see real improvements after several years. The quicker solution is to fudge the numbers. Credit Recovery, literacy courses to substitute the written test and other components of the Student Success are programs which allow students to achieve the same results as their peers by doing less work, and being less accountable.

Ontario has succeeded in graduating more students, but they have largely done this by lowering standards rather than raising student achievement. Let’s be clear, if Ontario was graduating 85% of its students under similar programs and expectations as those in 2000, I would be ecstatic. This is not the case.

Ontario has selected quantity education over quality education. Sacrificing quality for quantity is a frightening choice. The main devalues the worth of an Ontario Secondary School Diploma, and likewise, the Honours List. Reduced standards mean that a lower quality of student can enter and “succeed” in applied and college level courses. This forces those who were in the previous upper levels of applied/college into academic/university. To keep everyone moving through the system at high rates teacher expectations must drop. Employers, colleges and universities can have trouble distinguishing the comparative value of one diploma to another. Therefore marring the standards negatively affects all graduates.

Ironically, the stated goals and ambitions of the Ontario government are being directly undermined by its programs. Rather than graduating more under one banner, the province would be better off streaming. Streaming is a process were students are separated by ability and skills. If we must graduate everyone (or 85% of the student population) distinguish between their relative success in their diploma.

Establish Class A, B, C, D, and F Diplomas, or whatever naming scheme or number is deemed appropriate. Reduce the standards for the lower diplomas and increase for the others. Class A and B will go on to university, B, C, and D to college and D and F to the workforce. Let’s not sacrifice what the O.S.S.D. means for the sake of greater numbers. Let’s look at education and society as it is, not as some fantasy.

More is not better. Reducing quality for the sake of quantity is a risky venture. The Liberal government under McGuinty will use these statistics of improved graduation rates to claim he has improved education in the coming election this year. There are elements of Student Success that has merits, especially those that better serve students directly entering the workforce or college, but there are worrying impacts of other components. We must understand where these policies are taking us, and what preferable options are out there.

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

What About the Boys?

The classic liberal inside me rails against looking at people as categories. As I’ve spoken about before I don’t like it when people accept birth as a recipe for destiny. Being born a certain race or a certain class does not determine the path for the rest of your life. This belief sits at the heart of my worldview.

Likewise I would like to believe that a person’s gender does not inevitably shape his/her life. I said I would like to believe. Gender roles are fundamental in every society. Natural and cultural values are assigned to the sexes and shape our interactions. In our society we are aiming for true equality between men and women. At this, we are failing. Boys are getting left behind.

I was thumbing through the October 25 issue of Maclean’s magazine and discovered this article. There are growing trends amongst the youth in Canada that give me pause about the future of men in our society. It is a widely known fact that universities are increasingly skewing towards women, roughly 60-40 female: male. At first I had no concern over this, but upon reading this Maclean’s article, it is clear that the trouble starts early on.

Ontario secondary schools are divided into two major streams, applied and academic. Applied is a less intensive program academically. Applied students are disproportionately male. Are we to accept that men are simply dumber than women?

The article points to the fact that males mature slower than females. This creates a gap in early years that boys may interpret as a weakness in education, turning them off. However, Maclean’s briefly points to another factor that I think may be more important.

Over the last 30 years or so education has transformed from a teacher-centred practice to a student-centred practice. The cliché of women being more in touch with their feelings, and attuned to their own emotions and thoughts allows them to succeed in this type of environment. On the other hand, boys tend to thrive when there is strong structure and a more authoritarian leader in the classroom. Part of me wants to believe that men and women don’t respond differently to different styles of teaching, but it seems they may.

In a previous era when these boys dropped out of high school they would find work in factories and shops and earn a respectable living for decades. From this healthy salary they could raise a family, and live a comfortable middle-class existence. That’s not the case anymore. What becomes of these young men?

Drop-out rates are higher for men than women. According to the article many women drop out of high school to start/raise a family (or did), young men who drop out don’t do that generally. The title of this article is what caught my eye most, “Are we raising our boys to be underachieving men?” Sometimes when I looked into the faces of my students, or think about my peers I do not see the drive and ambition I hope to. Too much apathy, and a disregard for their own futures means that they may be less bright, and frankly - dull.

I’m not a gender warrior, my point isn’t that feminism has gone too far and now everything is screwed up. I wonder now that professions are skewing female how this will affect society. I have a lifetime to watch it unfold, and so do the young boys the system isn’t working for now.

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Education and Elections

It’s a political junky’s favourite day – election day. I’m avidly following on television. So far my prediction is holding up pretty well, but it is still very early. As near as I can tell I’m wrong about one race.

We just left behind a municipal election. One election people pay very little attention to are the elections of school board trustees. Even though school board trustees are possibly the lowest level of government we elect, they are the highest officials in our educational system. The Minister of Education has a lot of power, yes, but much of the time the Ministry outlines broad policy and then school boards determine local policy. Local boards often overlook policy recommendations from Toronto, or put them in the drawer. Boards have a lot of power, more than people realize.

Yet most school board elections get only a few thousand votes. Most people do not bother to investigate the candidates. It is hard to imagine that in an area of such importance that we care so little. Education is often held up as the key determinant of economic competitiveness in the 21st century. How can we say we’re taking education as a serious matter if we don’t examine the policies being implemented in our area?

There are some matters that I think schools should take into consideration right now. Here are two ideas that I think if introduced would generate a healthy change. First, research has consistently shown that if schools start a little bit later that it makes a big difference. In my experience students don’t wake up until about ten, but we drag them in and whip them into paying attention. I wonder how different a school environment would be if we went from an 8:30-2:30 clock to a 10-4 clock.

Something else I think would transform schools is if we provided more free lunches and breakfasts. Too many of my students come to school hungry. They haven’t had any breakfasts, and if they do it is a poor one. I’ve seen students swigging from 750 mL Coke bottles at 9:30 in the morning, or eating from bags of chips during O Canada. I’m not typically an advocate of institutions intruding on what I consider the domain of personal and familial responsibility, but if some won’t take care of their children, then someone must.

Sometimes I feel no one is taking the education process serious. It’s either critical to our success as a city, province and country or it’s not. If it is, then we should treat it with the respect it deserves.

Now, I’m going to go watch more election results to get my fix.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Civically Minded

Usually we learn over time to read the instructions. For whatever reasons, we as young people like to dive in and begin work on things without figuring out how to do it first. It’s likely some combination of youthful exuberance and impatience. Those of us who never learn this skill have a lot more problems during the rest of our lives. Some of them inevitably end up on Canada’s Worst Handyman or Driver.

Perhaps the most important thing people are entrusted with that they don’t read the instructions for is citizenship. The owner’s manual of any country, essentially, is its constitution. How many of us have read it? How many of us actually know our specific rights, or only have a vague notion of them from what we’ve heard and read. I’ve heard people in Canada talk about their Fifth Amendment rights, which is, of course, American. No doubt they picked it up from Law and Order.

I’m not going to complain about adolescents or young adults, because it is the system that seems to be failing. Given my interests and education if I become a high school teacher one of the courses I want to teach is Civics. In Ontario students are required to take one half-credit course on Canadian Civics. Four months. It’s the only class in the entire Ontario curriculum specifically dedicated for students to develop an understanding of their roles as citizens, and we give them four months to accomplish it.

My peers often give me strange looks when I say I want to teach Civics. Usually it is taught, poorly, by a teacher who drew a short straw. It requires no special education to teach it, and is usually foisted on someone with a Social Science degree. As a great credit to our political class, a large number of Canadians are apathetic about the political system. The reason is because we are governed comparatively well. Peace, Order and Good Government – the nation’s motto – seems to fit well with how we’ve been going along, so it doesn’t really matter if it’s Chretien, Martin, Harper, Ignatieff, etc. The ship of state continues on a steady-as-she-goes course, likewise with the Province, and with most cities.

Why does Civic Education matter? There are three main reasons that come to mind immediately. First, learning your actual rights and responsibilities. The first is self-explanatory, but the second is often overlooked. As a citizen of a municipality, region, province, and nation you have certain duties to perform. It’s not enough to simply be a citizen, but to be informed and aware of the condition of your body politic. It isn’t just your right to vote, it’s your responsibility. Without your voice the government is incomplete. 40% of the public doesn’t vote, based on Canada’s system of elections if all of them came out and voted it would likely form a majority government, think about that.

Second, representative government requires an active citizenry. Informed, active citizens have changed the face of history. In the 1960s numerous cities across North America faced outrage and protest when plans to construct expressways by demolishing neighbourhoods came on the table. This riled up communities and they resisted. Spadina in Toronto is an example of this. If people said nothing and allowed the municipal government to do as it pleased their homes and community would have been destroyed. People aren’t heard if they don’t speak out.

Third, teaching how to use government more effectively. Government is complex with many layers. By understanding the responsibilities and powers of each level of government and who can get you what you need.

There could be a fourth item, how to politically organize, and what your politics are. I may choose to avoid teaching it, because there is a risk of teaching your ideology. However, there is a benefit to having students learn how to protest, how to politically organize and how to sway the opinions of those in power.

Civics doesn’t just benefit those who learn, but society as a whole. It’s an investment in the future to ensure the stability and health of the country, province, region or municipality. Because after all, the children are our future, and we have to make sure they’re ready to take over.

Wednesday, July 21, 2010

Teaching Today

While sitting in my dentist office last week I picked up a copy of Maclean's magazine, essentially a Canadian version of Time magazine. As I flipped through the magazine one article in particular caught my attention. The headline was as follows, "Watch and learn, kids". The article discussed the role movies and films have taken in Ontario classrooms over recent years.

Films have long since had a place in the classroom. Educational films have been around since the cliche "duck and cover" videos distributed in the 1950s. However, according to the article and my own anecdotal experience, Hollywood films are increasingly present in the classroom. Films are intended, or at least should be intended to supplement lessons, not provide them. Romeo + Juliet, the Leonardo Dicaprio version, provides additional insight, but in no way should replace the classic text in English classrooms.

The worst offender, according to the Maclean's article, is geography classrooms where films like The Day After Tomorrow are shown. The film has no basis in scientific fact, and teaches nothing of value. Movies nowadays are used as tools to help control classes, as the carrot to reward good behaviour. There's nothing necessarily wrong with this as a concept except that films eat up an extraordinary amount of class time given the length of the films and the periods. In classes of specialized study, like geography, playing a 2-hour movie can cut considerably into the percentage of time for that subject in a semester.

As a future educator I can see the value in using videos in the classroom, but I cannot truly see the value in watching a film that has no connection to the material you are teaching. There would be nothing wrong, in my opinion if in a history class you played the first few minutes of Saving Private Ryan to illustrate the invasion of Normandy on D-Day, or in Enemy at the Gates for the fierceness of the Eastern Front.

Students should not have to be openly bribed to pay attention and work in class. Films are being misused by some teachers in my opinions to give themselves a break, which though understandable may be inappropriate.

A documentary is soon to be realized called Waiting for "Superman". The film focuses on the plight in the modern American educational system. I strongly urge you to watch the trailer. While it's easy for us here in Canada to get up on our high horse and look down at the Americans two important ideas are key to keep in mind. One, trends tend to match our continental neighbours. What happens in one tends to exist in the other, so we may be about to plunge with the Americans in quality of education. Second, apathy is a recipe for failure. The system of education and standards of teaching must constantly be revised.

I worry that our system of education in Ontario (and most of Canada) protects teachers and their interests than those of their students. It's not enough to be qualified, you have to be compassionate and caring enough to really make a difference. I've worked with some amazing, and a few bad teachers, and some definitely give the impression of coasting through their lessons and just letting the chips fall where they may. I suppose the first step is to try, both students and teacher for real learning to occur, save the blockbusters for the weekend.