Showing posts with label Canadian History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canadian History. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 5, 2017

Canada 150: Tomorrow

 In the final entry in this three-part series I would like to discuss Canada moving into the future. Four days ago Canadians from coast to coast to coast celebrated the formation of the country. I think many of us reflected on our present position. We rejoiced in the many riches this country has offered us and our families and simply enjoyed ourselves. I am sure that some among us took a moment to reflect on our history, with pride and with criticism. I wonder how many of us took some time to think about the future of this country and its people.

Now that the big party is over I think it would be wise for us to start to think about where we want our country to go and what we want it to be in the future. For me the question comes down to this, 'What do we want Canada to look like when we celebrate its 200th birthday?" 2067 is approaching sooner than we may think. More importantly the decisions we make today in our communities, cities, provinces, and country will shape our/their future.

Perhaps it is out of character for me, but I am quite optimistic about the future of this country. Unfortunately I do not think our leaders or we as citizens give much attention to long-term thinking so here are some questions we should start thinking about today.

On Canada Day there were approximately 36.5 million Canadians. We are one of the smaller wealthy, Western countries of the world. That does not seem likely to remain the case. By 2067 Canada will have nearly doubled its population (based on estimates) to over 60 million. That would make us roughly the same size as Italy, the UK, and France. I think Canadians are comfortable thinking of themselves as a small country, but this is going to change in the space of a couple of generations.

Canada today is about the size of Poland, and despite our greater wealth, we are only expected to contribute so much to international military operations, foreign aid, and leadership. This will change in the coming decades. Barring unforeseen consequences or disasters this is the path we are on. As we grow we must also mature into a country more willing to exert its influence on the world. All signs point to less stability in the near future, so a more robust Canadian military and foreign policy will likely be needed.

Nearly doubling our population alone will have a tremendous impact on our communities. What will be the next great cities in Canada and how will we prepare for that? How do we spread growth around so that our largest cities don't crack under the strain? How do we prevent the loss of valuable green space and farm land in sprawling cities? How do we adapt/expand our infrastructure to meet these new demands? Some provinces and cities have plans on the books to try to address the medium term change, but many are failing to comply. It is reckless to just stumble blindly into the future given the costs that will be involved.

One thing that will probably be a big question for Canada is how we adapt to and deal with the impacts of climate change. I have my doubts that humanity will be able to bend the curve on CO2 emissions in a meaningful way in time. What is our policy about the Arctic? How will we enforce our sovereignty? Will this expand our agricultural potential in the 'near North'? Will we have to move people as sea levels rise and storms become more powerful? How will we deal with inconsistent precipitation leading to drought and flood years? These are things we need to start thinking about and will shape 2067 Canada.

There are many things we cannot predict, nor do anything about. We are entering a period of intense automation, which may make work as we know it obsolete. Perhaps we are on the verge of the Star Trek utopia, or, a dismal society where there is a large underclass of unemployed/unemployable people. New industries will rise and fall. New technologies may change our lives, communities, and society as we know it. Politics domestically and internationally are unpredictable to say the least. However, as we walk into the 21st century I feel there is every indication that for next fifty years Canada is set to continue on a path of becoming an even greater country, if we have the wisdom and foresight to make it so.

Tuesday, June 20, 2017

Canada 150: Yesterday

To mark our country's 150th birthday I will be writing a trio of posts. I want to look at Canada's past, present, and future. It, of course, won't be definitive in any way, but figured it would be a valuable way to talk about our sesquicentennial. Before I go on to the topic I would like to take a moment to point out that this week marks the seventh anniversary of this blog. What a strange idea that is.

I've written about Canada's history before. I've written on specific topics and on the general notion. This post will fall firmly in the latter category.

The 150th anniversary of Canada has stirred significant controversy. The first is setting Canada's birthday and age at 150. Critics argue that setting the date there inherently cuts the narrative of people before 1867 off. Our country does not exist in a vacuum so there is an inherent time before Canada that led to Canada. You can tell our story 1867 forward but I think many Canadians don't see it that way. Quebecois, First Nations, Inuit, and Acadians and on want to see their deep history reflected in this national narrative.

This fundamentally reveals the truth that any historian can tell you: Canada doesn't have history, it has histories. This isn't just about identity politics. We can examine history through a social lens, an economic lens, a regional/local lens, a cultural lens, and on and on. If you look at a generic history of Canada you will find an exceptional amount of attention on personalities which loses marginalized voices. The story of Canada as we traditionally tell it doesn't give insight into life in Saskatchewan in 1890s, or the impact on the collapse of the fur trade on workers and our economy, or any other number of voices that aren't 'central' to understanding how we got to where we are.

Canadians are tragically ignorant of their history. I have seen this as a teacher and in my interactions with normal Canadians who have no idea what I'm talking about when I have mentioned fundamental parts of our history. Obviously I likely set an unreasonably high bar, but the critical failure surely doesn't inspire confidence.

Canada's histories are certainly things to be celebrated, learned from, criticized and enjoyed. One of the problems our ignorance causes is that blind celebration seems ignorant. Canadians can be tremendously proud of their history. Likewise we don't need to feel damaged every time a figure or moment in history is problematized by critical commentary. This feedback enriches the project.

Take for example the connection of this country with the national railway. I think the 'traditional' telling of that story is quite boring. It's about how great men and visionaries stitched together the country with a ribbon of steel. Now that story is incomplete without discussing Chinese labourers, the corruption and graft on the railways, the state of the West at the time, and the dramas all those entail.

Richard Gwyn wrote a fascinating biography of Sir John A. Macdonald, which I reviewed on this blog. The human portrait of one of our great leaders does not diminish the man, but elevate him. Being critical of our national heroes does not mean we are tearing them down.

As we mark our 150th birthday, and the centuries that preceded it, I would strongly urge Canadians to take some time to reflect upon their history. Visit a museum, read a book, watch a documentary, or talk to someone about our shared history.

Tuesday, August 9, 2016

Teaching History in Ontario, Badly

Be forewarned that the following post could be classified as a rant and recommended to be read with a rapid, irate tone of voice.

Why do so many children in Ontario receive a lacklustre history education? I have the grade 10 mandatory Canadian history course in mind. I took that class as a student, I learned about that class as a teacher-candidate, I taught that class as a teacher and now I help students who take it as a tutor. Time and time again I see students have a poor educational experience, completely turned off from the discipline and ignorant to their own country's history.

There is fundamentally little wrong with the CHC2D/P curriculum. The document provides guidelines for a five unit course that focuses on the periods 1914-1929, 1929-1945, 1945-1982, 1982-Present and a unit on historical inquiry. However this document bears almost no resemblance to the education I see students receiving. I assume that the mentalities and approaches to history calcified in the previous curriculum and teachers have not bothered with updating their materials and approach. Which is baffling given that they are expected to address the present which is constantly moving forward.

In my experience CHC2D/P, also known as Canadian History since World War I, is taught as 3.5 units. The first unit is an exhaustive study of World War I, this is followed by a combined 1920s/30s unit, which is of course followed by World War II. If there is time a fourth unit is dedicated to "the rest". The entire second half of the 20th century and the 21st century is boiled down to whatever can be crammed in before the final exam. I recall when I was a high school student our class got past the mid-1960s while our peers across the hall ended WWII in June. I suppose it is a great irony that history teachers are unable to manage time, but for me, talking to students, it is immensely frustrating.

What I once assumed to be a laughable fluke seems actually to be the norm. If classes manage to get to the fourth unit, 1945-Present, it is so watered down and broad little meaningful information can be extracted by the students.

Most teachers (I hope) are not wasting time with their pupils, but they have poorly allocated the time they do have. From looking at countless worksheets and unit tests teachers become far too obsessed with the World Wars. Students are forced to study minute details about those conflicts. More time is dedicated to those 10 combined years than to the rest of the century. World War I was likely the most consequential war in the modern era. It fundamentally shaped the world into what we know it as today, but if you think a grade 10 student needs to understand the Schlieffen Plan as a term, but not be able to identify who Tommy Douglas was then you and I have very different understandings of Canadian history. The Schlieffen Plan is only relevant if you know about the Franco-Prussian War in 1870. Otherwise, "The Germans invaded Belgium to surprise France in their offensive" is all that needs to be said on the topic.

Instead weeks of school time are dedicated to battles that Canada did not participate in and scrutinizing every piece of military technology. I am not arguing that World War I is not important, what I am asking is that if you wanted to teach someone what was relevant about Canada's history would you spend a quarter of the time on 1914-1918?

I believe the focus on the World Wars reveals a strong Eurocentric bias in the Ontario curriculum. Hitler's rise to power is not terribly relevant for a Canadian history class. It would be exceptionally relevant in a world history course though, or government. The focus on the World Wars sucks the oxygen away from other pressing issues. Labour unrest and political radicalism was at its peak in that period and arguably has far more to do with the country we live in today as the Battle of Ypres and the Liberation of the Scheldt. The Winnipeg General Strike and general unrest from 1910-1940 deserves just as much say.

Perhaps my perspective on this next part is heavily influenced by where I grew up. The Canada we know and love today was born in the Post-War period. The wartime, and hard times of the early 20th century are crucial, but many of the institutions we associate with our country comes from the post-war period. The welfare state, socialized medicine, our flag, multiculturalism, open immigration, technology, Canada's status as a middle/minor power all stems from mid-20th century. I teach mostly non-white students. When I ask them about their family history and they say their grandparents or parents came in the 1970s I can tell them that that was because of the point system and previous to that they likely could not. It shocks them, literally, that there was a time when people like those in their families were not welcome here. A great deal of time is spent on events (many of which are only tangentially related to Canada) rather than the spirit of Canada in different time periods. From proudly white and British and a reticent French contingent to what we are now was a hell of a journey, one this course isn't communicating.

History has certain fracture points that tend to echo decades or centuries down strongly. Martin Luther's theses is one example that pops to mind. But aside from these moments the most recent past has a greater impact on our day-to-day life. The last couple decades are critical for understanding the world we currently live in. In particular the events of September 11th, 2001 would fit well in a history course today. It profoundly impacted our lives today in Canada and elsewhere and the ripple effects are still out there. Students in this course, 15-16 years old, have no memory of 9/11. They don't understand that North America has transformed since then. That the post-Cold War euphoria transformed into the paranoia security state etc. we know today. Right now a graduate from CHC2D/P has very little information that helps them understand how Canada came to be the country it is today. Canadians know shockingly little about their history and politics. Is it any wonder if they are left with 40-50 year gap in their knowledge to how we got from World War II to the present?

Finally, Canadian history is not and should not be a film studies course. The number of students I have spoken to that have described multiple classes being dedicated to multiple films for little tangible educational benefit is staggering. I showed clips in my class. The most I showed, I believe, was the episode of Band of Brothers on a long-weekend Friday where they liberate the concentration camp, as I thought the visuals would be more effective for them. The D-Day landing in Saving Private Ryan is incredible, but the whole film doesn't belong. Hollywood is not renowned for its tact and thorough depictions of historic periods, events or figures. Offering them as a solid resource gives a plastic, flimsy understanding of history to students.

History, by its nature, is a narrative discipline. We're trying to tell stories, present arguments and offer up perspectives. A dull recitation of facts and dates with more relationship to world or European history with scant context and the enticement of frequent films is hardly serving our students to become informed, knowledgeable citizens. Not all history teachers are bad at what they do; though a shocking number who teach though are not trained in history. We are lucky to have a mandatory history course, but who is it currently serving? It's time for Canadian history to better reflect the entire 20th century and for what's happening in classrooms to better match what the curriculum intends.

Tuesday, August 11, 2015

Book Review: Nation Maker by Richard Gwyn


Full Title: Nation Maker: Sir John A. Macdonald, His life, Our Times Volume II: 1867-1891 by Richard Gwyn

Reading about Sir John A. in 2015 seemed oddly fortuitous. The country is on the eve of its sesquicentennial and this election year may be hugely defining for the future of Canada. At such a time it is valuable to take a moment to reflect on how we came to get where we are and no prime minister has had a greater influence on this country's destiny than Macdonald.



Richard Gwyn presents a simple thesis, Canada was hardly inevitable and at a time of great fragility one of the ablest statesmen in the world laid a foundation for a nation-state. As a student of Canadian history I can say much of this is hardly a shocking premise, however, little scholarship has been dedicated to our first prime minister, which Gwyn seeks to correct. Certainly Macdonald wasn't alone in this mission, he was joined in the nation-building project by a cadre of incredibly able men, such as George-Etienne Cartier, Charles Tupper and Hector Louis Langevin. Gwyn does not deny the important role of Macdonald's cabinet and other politicians, instead he stipulates that Macdonald was possessed with the great skill to manage the diverse and fractured interests of the country and hold it together.

On a personal level Macdonald is a deeply sympathetic man. Reflecting on the entire character of the monograph I am reminded of the lovable rogue. Macdonald was hardly a perfect man, in fact he had deep character flaws and by any modern standard was corrupt, but he was charming, humourous and brilliant. I never previously delved into the personal life of Macdonald, but Gwyn presents a man who suffered many personal tragedies, but managed them with great dignity. The story opens with Macdonald remarrying; Agnes Bernard, many years his junior, would be by his side for much of his life and a doting and caring wife. Macdonald's son Hugh and he would have a tense relationship but found some resolution in his later years. Macdonald also had a daughter named Mary who sadly suffered from hydrocephalus, which is now easily remedied, but left her physically and mentally impaired her whole life. Mary's life in the final chapters and epilogue were particularly touching.

It might sound strange but Macdonald comes across as a man ahead of his time. He oversaw governments of men of different faiths and ethnicities, he spoke in favour of women's suffrage and despite the record of his government he accepted the Canadian state's responsibility towards First Nations people and took steps to protect them from abuses from liquor traders. Gwyn goes so far to challenge the established depiction of Macdonald as a racist.

As much as this book is a biography of Sir John A. it is also a history of early Canada. The rich tapestry of characters and personalities are vividly laid out. The conflicts of Canada's early years are fleshed out by the real people who lived and fought in those times. The central conflict of early Canada, the struggle between Protestant English and French Catholic, is the constant thread as well as the central nation-building project, the national railway. Louis Riel plays a prominent role in the narrative. What's amazing is that so many things that held the country together, like the railway, were in no ways certain. Macdonald only got them done through tenacious insistence, or by hook and by crook.

There is no doubt that Richard Gwyn does an exceptional job in humanizing and bringing life to our first prime minister. He was flawed and struggled and set many precedents of future prime ministers, some of them bad. He was no stranger to trying to wait out a decision, duck controversies, playing both sides, and living in the mushy middle. But he was also a man of profound vision. A British country from sea to sea to sea. Macdonald saw Canada reach its current boundaries, he played imperial politics to his adopted homeland's advantage, he forged a ribbon of steel that held the country together and introduced protectionist policy that created an industrial heartland out of the hinterland. A strange thing happens when a leader is in place for as long as John Macdonald was, over 18 years. Institutions and the political culture become rooted in their nature. While each subsequent PM has made his and her mark on the institution it in many ways is as Sir John started it. Macdonald seems an oddly appropriate founding father for our country, flaws and all.

I would recommend this book to anyone interested in learning about Canada, interested in biographies or politics. I think the text is fairly accessible for most readers.



Tuesday, January 13, 2015

Sir John A. and Our Past

Sunday marked the two hundredth birthday of Sir John A. Macdonald, the first prime minister of Canada and arguably the architect for the country as it came to be. Journalist and Macdonald biographer Richard Gwyn calls Macdonald the indispensible man without whom the country would never exist. Reviewing Macdonald's legacy it is easy to imagine how that might be the case. The formation of a nation out of the disparate parts of British North America into a cohesive country was by no means inevitable.

Sadly we suffer for a bias towards the present and many, when examining history, tend to look for the straight lines that lead to the current point. The outcome was X so it was always going to be X and everything led to it. This was not the case when it came to Canada. The colonies in the northern half of this continent had no clear and common interest aside from being British territories.  

Sir John A. managed to form a coalition and through careful negotiation brought the colonies of British North America into agreement to form a common dominion. Uniting Canada (now Ontario and Quebec), Nova Scotia and New Brunswick was fairly impressive on its own, but Macdonald was a man of extraordinary vision. The purchase of Rupert's Land and construction of the Canadian Pacific Railway was nation-building on a scale this country has not seen since.

Canadian history has moved strongly away from the "great man" model. While Americans revere their presidents we have made our leaders very human. Many know Sir John A. was a drunk, but few know of the personal tragedies he suffered. It is perhaps healthier that we look at Macdonald as a man and not a petty demigod, but perhaps we are a bit harsh. Sir Winston Churchill may have had a drinking problem and held views repugnant to our modern sensibilities but the man was incredibly important to the history of the world. We recognize that and his flaws.

Prime Minister from 1867-1873 and again from 1878-1891 was essential in developing the key elements of early Canada. So many of our national institutions stem from that time, such as the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, the national policy, the railway, and development of manufacturing in central Canada.

For modern-day Canadians Macdonald's most troubling legacy might be his stance on issues of race. Canada's long and troubled relationship with First Nations and Metis peoples definitely predate 1867, but certainly developments in Canada's West were tantamount to genocide. Interestingly Patrice Dutil offers some defence of Macdonald, stating that the crisis unfolding in the West was beyond his control and he attempted to intervene to alleviate suffering. While Macdonald restricted the vote of Chinese men he saw no reason to restrict black voters, and even advocated for a time to enfranchise single women. In short, it is difficult to cast our first prime minister in black and white tones.

Macdonald represented a form of "Canadianism" that is unfamiliar. Canada existed to be a British vanguard, a project of the Empire and not necessarily something with its own distinct identity. Perhaps this aspect of our legacy makes it all the more difficult to make sense of Macdonald; we are very different now from where we started. However, despite his flaws this country owes a tremendous debt to the man who helped it come to be. As wrong as we may judge his actions to be now there is no doubt he was a man of vision. We cannot disown him any more than we can disown our past for they are one in the same.

Tuesday, November 11, 2014

The Future of Our Past


First I would like to thank everyone for the positive feedback on my piece on feminism last week. I heard back from a lot of people who do not normally comment on my blog, and virtually all that feedback was positive. Negative feedback seemed to come from those more inclined to spam their own point of view and may not have even ready my piece. I hope to write pieces like that again in the future.

Given that today is Remembrance Day I want to take a moment to reflect on the future of this civic holiday. For decades now Canadians have marked the end of World War I, that bloody and damaging conflict. Canada emerged a quite different country than the one that entered. I believe that we scarcely understand the social, cultural and mental trauma that war had on the countries involved.

To great extent while our public consciousness for World War I has faded dramatically it still is at the core of Remembrance Day. For many reasons the Second World War has eclipsed the First World War and it did so remarkably early on. Remembrance Day has principally been built upon these two wars. The Korean War (1950-1953) was called the Forgotten War in its time and its comparative impact is so much smaller. The various missions Canada has participated in are abstract and intangible.

We live, almost, in a post-war era. Canada may not go to war with a nation-state as it did in the world wars again. Our enemies are diffuse and are just as likely now to kill a soldier in Canada as one in a warzone in a distant land. The wars of the early twentieth century drew the nation’s resources to the singular purpose in a war of survival and no other conflicts have replicated those stakes. Wars of the twenty-first century are entirely different creatures and look very little like our past.

But as time marches on and our veterans pass on the glories of the early part of the last century fade from memory, to story, to history, to intangible. How will Canadians speak of World War I fifty years from now? Or the Korean War? I believe World War II will always capture popular imagination, but those other conflicts will fade, like the Boer War or the War of 1812. Today at the Remembrance Day ceremony the Reverend referenced 2014 for being the bicentennial of the last year Canada was invaded and the centennial of the beginning of World War I. It struck me in that moment that both of those facts are relics of history and connect less and less to anyone alive today.

I am forced to wonder what this holiday will mean to future Canadians. How will they feel connected to servicemen and women and our shared past? How will they remember?

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Whither Tories?


Today I read a column by David Brooks of the New York Times. This is not unusual in and of itself, but the topic was far more philosophical than Mr. Brooks’ normal serving in terms of a piece. Brooks argues that there are two schools in American conservatism – traditional and economicand that the fiscal conservatives have come to run the show. His analysis happens to not deal with the rise of the social conservatives or libertarians, but I will put that aside for now.

Traditional conservatives are described as “intellectual heir to Edmund Burke, Russell Kirk, Clinton Rossiter and Catholic social teaching. This sort of conservative didn’t see society as a battleground between government and the private sector. Instead, the traditionalist wanted to preserve a society that functioned as a harmonious ecosystem, in which the different layers were nestled upon each other: individual, family, company, neighborhood, religion, city government and national government.”

Reading Mr. Brooks’ column I thought he might be referring to a trans-Atlantic ideology at the founding of at least three nations (U.K., U.S. and Canada), and probably more – Toryism. Toryism is a distinctly difficult ideology to pin down. It was swept away later by more familiar clashes of ideas. Toryism in its inception was a protection of the status quo, and in particular a defense of the British monarchy and tradition from the English Civil War to the American Revolution. 

Given my own background and biases I associate Toryism with the pre-Confederation leaders of Canada and our first Prime Minister Sir John A. Macdonald. Tories tend to dote quite a bit towards authority and respect the rule of law. The Canadian phrase “Peace, Order and Good Government” seem the most effective synopsis of what Canadian Toryism is. The orderly structuring of a society and peaceful commerce and livelihoods of its inhabitants are of the utmost value to Tories. The school of thought developed in opposition to liberalism, which emphasizes the individual over the collective.

Toryism is a very attractive notion even in modern times. Brooks describes traditional conservatives saying “Because they were conservative, they tended to believe that power should be devolved down to the lower levels of this chain. They believed that people should lead disciplined, orderly lives, but doubted that individuals have the ability to do this alone, unaided by social custom and by God. So they were intensely interested in creating the sort of social, economic and political order that would encourage people to work hard, finish school and postpone childbearing until marriage.” Individuals left to their own devices cannot be trusted, which is what society is for in the first place. It’s the same reason the unregulated free market is dangerous.

In Canada and other Westminster Parliamentary democracies the right-wing parties are often called Tories, but the relationship between the Conservative Party of Canada and the traditions of Toryism is quite tenuous. Tories in Canada are probably best understood as being the Red Tories of the old Progressive Conservative and Conservative Parties, but it is more than being moderate on social issues. The libertarian and social conservative factions are actively disruptive to society. Tories see a natural and fitting role for the state which cannot be said for all those who are called Tories in today’s parlance.

It might seem strange, but I consider myself a Tory and a New Democrat and have squared those ideas together. I imagine that strain of Canadian political thought or voter who is a Tory has an awkward time in the current political dynamic. All three of the major political parties are inheritors of the Tory tradition but none really embody the values anymore. So, whither Toryism, and its proud tradition?

Tuesday, August 21, 2012

A Year without Jack


Tomorrow will mark the one year anniversary of the death of Jack Layton, leader of the NDP and leader of the opposition. The tributes will ring out and New Democrats and other progressives will gather to mourn the loss of their leader and reflect on his life and the year that has followed.

The most notable organization has been the Dear/Cher Jack program by the Broadbent Institute. The website has asked for submissions on how the passing of Mr. Layton has affected their lives and how they have honoured his memory. It is a fitting tribute, and the words of prominent and everyday citizens have been kind reminders of the impact of one extraordinary man.

I think it would be fair to say that since 2011 Canada has been living through an intensely political time: the censure of the Harper government, the election of May 2011, Mr. Layton’s resignation and funeral, a string of provincial elections across Canada, the NDP leadership contest, several contentious federal pieces of legislation – in particular the budget (C-38), the looming Liberal leadership contest and the pains of majority for the Conservatives. In recent weeks we have the provincial election in Quebec and by-elections here in Ontario. Mr. Layton has had an impact on all of these events.

As a historian I sometimes wonder how present events will be described in later histories. It seems to me that the progressive movement has been mobilized in Canada now and is now posing a serious challenge to Liberals and Conservatives. I am not suggesting that the NDP are on their way to permanent majorities as they become the natural governing party of Canada, but the party has been growing provincially and federally and now provide the alternative options for progressive Canadians. Future Canadian political historians will be hard pressed not to credit Jack Layton for this shift.

The Orange Wave in Quebec, assumed by many to be a brief affair, appears to have resulted in a more permanent commitment. Since the selection of Tom Mulcair (NDP – Outremont, QC) to lead the party, the NDP have remained in first in Quebec in the 40% range. More importantly the NDP are now consistently tied with or beating the Conservatives in polls. Within Ontario Andrea Horwath (ONDP – Hamilton Centre) was able to build up her support following their federal counterpart’s success and now hold the balance of power in the provincial legislature. Polling suggests the ONDP is competitive in the Kitchener-Waterloo by-election, which has been long out of reach for the party. In the Atlantic Provinces the NDP is displacing the Liberals more and more as the party of opposition, and polls show conflicting information, but British Columbia could swing dramatically towards the NDP provincially and federally in the next vote.

It is entirely within the realm of possibilities that in 2015 the New Democrats will form government. This reality is only possible because of the remarkable breakthrough that Jack Layton had in Quebec and creating the NDP, not the Liberal party, as the alternative to the Conservatives.

For my part, I can honestly say that Jack Layton is the reason I am a New Democrat. I joined the party in the spring of 2011 and have been increasingly active in politics since that time. I am not sure to what extent Mr. Layton’s message and spirit has motivated my commitment to the NDP, and in politics in general, but I do know that his leadership is what drew me to the orange banner in the first place. The extraordinary convention last March, which I participated in, was a wonderful celebration of Mr. Layton's life and commitment to the vision he presented. In his final letter to Canadians Jack Layton said, “Canada is a great country, one of the hopes of the world. We can be a better one – a country of greater equality, justice, and opportunity. We can build a prosperous economy and a society that shares its benefits more fairly.” I cannot help but feel that this hopeful vision of Canada can be our destiny, if we choose it to be.

I miss our Happy Warrior, and I cannot help but think we are poorer for his absence. Still, we can build upon his legacy and, with any luck, a new generation of Canadians, of all political persuasions, are inspired by his leadership to change Canada for the better.

Here are some links I’d like to share on this anniversary:

One of the more memorable ads from the 2011 NDP Campaign

Rev. Brent Hawkesbeautiful eulogy of Jack Layton at his State Funeral

My posts from Jack Layton’s resignation, Our Happy Warrior, and after his death, Good-bye Jack.


Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Regionalism or Sectionalism in Canada



While the tragedy in Toronto, on Danzig Street is dominating much of the media and many of our thoughts tonight I have decided not to write about it. Commentary without greater context is not worthwhile at this stage.

Something I wanted to discuss is division in Canada along regions. When Tom Mulcair (NDP – Outremont, QC) made his statements in regards to the Alberta tar sand development the Conservative Party and others quickly attacked him as pitting West against East in a cynical attempt to win votes. It was also said that this hurt the overall unity of the country by commenters, such as Rex Murphy.

I do not believe this issue is exclusively that of Tom Mulcair, but of wedge politics in general. Wedge politics is the use of specific issues that divides communities into stark camps and forces people to choose a side. Typically campaigns employ this strategy if a majority will be drawn to their side. Wedge issues often have very thin margins leading to very hot rhetoric to coalesce a side.

Obviously the oil sands/tar sands development is a wedge issue. Canadians in central and eastern Canada view the economic benefits through the lens of some of the environmental consequences. In Alberta that distinction can be trickier. The oil industry is the backbone of Alberta’s (and increasingly Canada’s) economy. That being said despite the attacks on the leader of the federal NDP his policy is not that far removed from the Alberta Premier, Alison Redford, of the Progressive Conservative Party.

A Conservative example? How about so-called tough on crime legislation? People who study crime suggest that longer prison sentences and tougher sentencing will do nothing to lower overall crime rates. Still, the types of reforms instituted by the Conservative government are incredibly popular among a certain segment of the population. Left-wing voters across the country oppose the policy, and several provinces object to it given that it will increase costs with negligible benefit.

Prime Minster Stephen Harper’s crime legislation is as unpopular in Quebec as Mr. Mulcair’s statements about the oil/tar sands are in Alberta.

Canada is a highly regionalized country. Our politics reflect that. If you doubt me go through the Wikipedia pages for Canada’s elections during the twentieth century. Regions of the country tend to vote as blocks to represent their interests. If the discussion of sustainable development is an effort to pit regions against one another then there is nothing new there.

Canada’s regionalism is emphasized by our electoral system. The First-Past-the-Post disproportionate awards the first place party overall. For example, in Saskatchewan the NDP won about a third of the vote, but received no seats. Saskatchewan is 100% represented by the Conservatives, therefore increasing the appearance of regional divisions.

While this style of politics is familiar, and tested there are serious consequences. Canada probably is not the type of country that can sustain itself by pitting regions against each other, especially in the case of Quebec. If Quebec, or any other province feels abused by Confederation they will exercise to remove themselves from the federal system. Perhaps Alberta or Ontario won’t separate, but they’ll push for greater provincial powers and weaker federal government.

There’s little value in giving  a sermon about the beauty of unity politics, because they generally don’t win elections. However, having a message that speaks broadly to the whole of the public is an effective way to win public support. The current Harper Conservative government appears to be appealing to a very narrow part of the electorate. As a party they are beginning to pay a price for it. There is a consequence to using that wedge; hopefully it is for the party, and not the country.


Tuesday, May 22, 2012

A Reluctant Republican?


I am a monarchist. It is my evaluation that a constitutional monarchy is the best form of government available. In reality the form of government is only marginally important. Republican, monarchial, presidential or parliamentary – they are all valid and can produce healthy democratic systems. In addition, I feel the Windsor family, the royal family of Canada, has led Canada with great dignity, particularly in the person of Queen Elizabeth II.

I am still satisfied with most of the elements of our system of governments, but there is a growing issue at the core of our government that concerns me.

Political scientists in Canada like to point out that the office of the Prime Minister is perhaps the most powerful executive in the Western world. Very few countries grant their leaders the sweeping powers and strict control that the man or woman at 24 Sussex Drive possesses. Canadians often consider the United States’ President to be an incredible powerful leader. The truth is that the President has influence, and his or her power is only exercised with the cooperation (or resistance) of the two other branches of government (Senate/House of Representatives and the Supreme Court).

In Canada the Prime Minister is restricted by the courts, and the need to command a majority in the House of Commons. However, the House of Commons has been significantly cowed by our Prime Ministers, dating back to the leadership of Mr. Trudeau. Since that time there has been a worrying concentration of power in the person of the Prime Minister. Dan Gardner on CTV’s Question Period recently quipped that Canada has a presidential system without the checks and balances. Andrew Coyne, in a remarkable debate with Sheila Copps (Does power corrupt Canadian Prime Ministers?) said that Parliament has in effect become an electoral college for the Prime Minister. The person  leading the party with the most seats because President/Prime Minister of Canada, to rule unperturbed until the next election.

But, in our system of government the Prime Minister is not the head of state. The office is a servant to a far higher power, our monarch, and sovereign. The Kings and Queens of Canada have long ago abandoned governing Canada directly. Instead they relied upon their agents, the Governors General to act on their behalf. Sadly, as power waned from monarchy the levers of control exercised by our monarchs fell into the hands of the Prime Minister. The Governors General fear to act because they lack legitimacy as political appointees to an unelected office.

What on paper should constrain our head of government is no more than words on paper. The Senate, the House of Commons, and the Governor General fail to properly provide the restraint needed in a proper democracy. I have a hard time finding fault in Richard Poplak’s article against Mr. StephenHarper and the anti-democratic nature of Canada. At minimum, I sympathize with Mr. Poplak’s concerns, and share his deepest fears.

The acquisition of power of the monarchy to the Prime Minster should be, and must be, reversed. Governor General David Johnston sadly cannot simply begin to act as though this is the nineteenth century and exercise his constitutionally enshrined powers – he simply does not have the legitimacy. In Canada, like most democracies (if we can still bear the name), rely upon the vote to instill legitimacy. Perhaps then it is time to be rid of appointed Governors General and created elected Presidents. The manner of election would have to be decided by greater minds than me. I have heard suggestions that perhaps an election by all of Canada’s legislatures would be valuable, or a simple national popular vote, similar to France’s. Hopefully we would not repeat the mistakes of the past and impose a First-Past-the-Post system. Our presidential elections could be non-partisan. Candidates for the high office should perhaps be drawn from the bar, or the bench, and only those with constitutional expertise could hold office.

Does electing our head of state mean an end to the monarchy? What if we elected the Governor General and kept the Kings and Queens of Canada to preside overall. I have no other objections to monarchy as a system, and I still favour it – so long as we can amend it to create a more democratic nation. This is not a partisan concern. The centralization of power, erosion of parliament and weakening of democracy is something that should concern all citizens. Power is not easily wrestled back once surrendered, but it is critical that it is. 

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

The Charter: An Imperfect Document


Today is the thirtieth anniversary of Canada’s formal constitution, the Constitution of Canada and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The anniversary has triggered some stiff debate on how it should be marked. Prime Minister Stephen Harper has opted, essentially, not to celebrate the patriation of the constitution at all. Journalists, opinion makers, partisans and lovers of the law have all attacked Mr. Harper for failing to celebrate this document of national importance. Instead of piling on the Prime Minister I think it might be worthwhile to explore what he may be considering.

While many Canadians cherish the rights inside the Charter and value its role in shaping our country into a more equal place, there are those who have major, justified issues with our constitution. I hate to boil this down to simple partisanship so early in this post, but it seems to me that Liberals want the Constitution to be celebrated more than anyone else. It is only fitting given that the patriation of the constitution was Prime Minister Trudeau’s crowning achievement. When Craig Oliver interviewed Justin Trudeau (Liberal – Papineau, QC) on CTV’s April 15, 2012 episode of Question Period, he discussed the constitution in terms of his father’s legacy. Trudeau suggested that the government’s silence on the Charter was motivated by partisanship.

I feel that many who are cheering on the Charter forget the very recent controversies that surrounded it. Several major issues were ignored or overlooked. Prime Minister Brian Mulroney tried twice to address the issues of the Canadian constitution that Trudeau introduced. Both the Meech Lake Accord and Charlottetown Accord failed, and after a decade of constitutional reform issues the Canadian government has run screaming from any talk of it.

The Province of Quebec never ratified the Canadian constitution. The centre of the Meech Lake Accord was to bring Quebec into the fold. The second attempt, Charlottetown Accord, included the voices from Canada’s First Nations, Metis and Inuit communities. The Accord would have recognized Quebec as a distinct society, increased the sovereignty of Aboriginal peoples, reformed the Senate and entrenched key social program priorities. This Accord also failed. The appetite for Canadian constitutional debate quickly waned after much of the nation’s political capital had been spilled in the process.

The 1993 federal election saw the dissolution of the largest majority government in Canadian history and the fracturing of Canada into distinct regional power bases as the Reform and Bloc Quebecois rose from the ashes of constitutional reform. Mr. Harper and a generation of politicians came up with the mist of a deeply divisive constitutional debate; one they are not fond of recalling, nor celebrating.

Those limitations identified in the original constitution in 1987 and 1992 still exist. The patriation of constitution was a major opportunity to address concerns in Canada, and it was missed. I find our constitution to be ineffective for three key reasons. One, it fails to offer adequate provisions for Aboriginal Canadians. Two, the constitution has locked Canada in with an undemocratic Senate, and makes reform to the House of Commons difficult. Three, the amendment formula is so difficult to achieve that meaningful constitutional reform has only been attempted as large omnibus movements (like the Accords), or minor issues, like renaming Newfoundland, Newfoundland and Labrador. In fact, the government has tried to work around the constitution, rather than amending it!

Because our constitution is so difficult to amend the Parliament and Supreme Court have had to bend over backwards to make the constitution fit instead of simply amending it. I think the best example of this is Gay Rights and Section 15 of the Charter. The Charter does not provide for the constitutional protection of homosexuals. I think the Charter should simply be amended to include sexual orientation. Instead, given the difficulty, courts and legislatures have interpreted sex to mean sexuality, though the intent at the time was gender protection.

The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is an important document, and as the New York Times recently reported, it is becominga model for the world. However, it is still deeply flawed. During the NDP leadership campaign Nathan Cullen (NDP – Skeena-Bulkley Valley, BC) was fond of saying Canada is a nation that works bad in theory and good in practice. To me this suggests that Canada’s constitution has put in legal barriers that hinder our effective governance, that our politics and extralegal arrangements help overcome.

In general Canadians like their constitution, including, as Andrew Coyne recently pointed out, Quebecers. It is interesting to contrast American and Canadian attitudes to their respective constitutions. There are factions in both nations that fetishize their govern documents, and in fact it is a dominant ideology within the United States. I hope Canada never goes that route. Our governing document should be challenged and considered, and in my opinion, amended. It is not perfect. To be clear I am not advocated for dozens of amendments every year, but a few periodic changes that have broad consensus would be valuable.
So, here’s to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Constitution of Canada, and may it continue evolve in time to govern our country even better in the future. 

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

Opening of Crown-First Nations Gathering


This morning in Ottawa a summit began which could have long-ranging and dramatic outcomes to Canada. A gathering of First Nations’ leaders and officials from the Government of Canada and Crown began today. The opening remarks by Governor-General David Johnston, Prime Minister Stephen Harper and National Chief Shawn Atleo were encouraging. Perhaps I am overburdened by low expectations. Aboriginal-Federal relations have been so dismal any progress at all offers hope.

The conference was the work of Mr. Atleo of the Assembly of First Nations. Following the revelation of the Attawapiskat crisis he continually called on Mr. Harper for a meaningful meeting to discuss the way forward for First Nations in Canada. Both Mr. Harper and Mr. Atleo expressed a desire to reform the Indian Act, which governs First Nations peoples in Canada. The Prime Minister stated he has no intent to repeal the Indian Act.

Stephen Harper and the Conservative Government may not be the ideal negotiating partner, but he is the head of government, and has the authority to make these changes. Any changes at all to Aboriginal policy will be controversial. As a Conservative Harper is happy to give Aboriginal-Canadians greater opportunity and end the crippling regulations on reserves. Whether he will be willing to commit the Federal government to helping to eliminate poverty on reserves and improving the standard of living... we shall see.

I am cautiously optimistic about the Crown-First Nations Gathering because I think, like many Canadians, I want to see these historic problems addressed, and the embarrassing conditions of some Aboriginal communities end. As citizens we can push our leaders to make the changes needed, and not allowing the dialogue to break down.

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

Why Canadian History is Awesome


This post will not quite jive with what I normally do on this blog, but I have been known to take requests from readers – and one requested this so here we go.

For those of you who may not know, I am a graduate student studying history. History is often something not easily justifiable as a field of study. Within the study of history I am the only student studying Canadian history. I have had to endure many slings and arrows from fellow history nerds about the relative superiority of their subsection. Therefore I present to you:

Ten Reasons Canadian History is Awesome

10 - An Old Nation

A common criticism of Canada is that it is a young country, and therefore its history is very limited. This is a myth. Yes, the Dominion of Canada which has evolved into the country we know today was founded a little over 150 years ago. This is a limitation that virtually no other nation faces. No one measures French history at the start of the Fifth Republic in 1958, nor American history after the adoption of the Constitution in 1787, etc. Canada has had at least 10,000 years of human habitation. Even taking into account the incredibly narrow view that European contact is the marker of a start of Canadian history – our origins precede the United States with the 1497 discovery of Newfoundland by John Cabot, or the Viking colony from 1000 CE. We know far too little about Canada before 1000 CE, but that just means we have work to do.

9 - Canada in the World, and the World in Canada

Canada is a strange country in that in its long history it has been very strongly tied to the rest of the world. While at other times in history other nations have been able to bar its doors and turn its back on the world, Canada has been unable to. Therefore those things which shook the world hit Canada, often particularly hard. The best example of this is the Great Depression. Canada was one of the hardest hit nations in the world with 32% unemployment, only being surpassed by Germany. In geopolitics Canada always seems to be in the thick of it. Whether the imperial conflicts of English and French, or the Cold War, Canada is front and centre. The final part of this point is that the world has found a home in Canada. Multiculturalism has brought hundreds of ethnicities and languages to Canada and created connections to the rest of the globe. The history and on-goings of the world are deeply tied to Canada and her people.

8 - Canada, Battlefield of History

Within the borders of what we now know as Canada have been several major battles that have shaped the destiny of the whole world. The battles that took place in Quebec, Nova Scotia and Ontario have as much (or greater) role in determining the present than any battle in World War II. The Battles of Louisbourg and the Plains of Abraham are not merely important for the formation of Canada, but they also effectively ended the French Empire in North America. During the War of 1812 British and First Nations repelled repeated American invasions, and also torched Washington – for the win.

If these battles do not seem significant, please consider the counterfactual scenario, or alternative history. If the British failed to conquer New France the upper half of North America may have remained French. Canada may have still come to be, and may still have been called Canada, but it would be a French nation, not French and English. Had the Americans succeeded in their conquest of British North America, realizing their dream of Manifest Destiny, the United States would rule from Baffin Island to the Rio Grande, which assumes that after conquering Canada and the western United States they would be satisfied.

7 - Towards a Common Country

What Canada is is not a static idea. What is Canada and who are Canadian is constantly in flux. In each century, and in different parts of the country, different answers arose to the same questions. Much of Canada’s history is a debate of who can be included. The most prominent example of this is the narrative of the struggle between French-Canadians and English-Canadians. Most countries, I dare say, have not operated this way in its history. The complex relationship between groups to define Canada is a fascinating and on-going part of our history.

6 - Canada – Original Stormtroopers

This is the go-to answer for most Canadians of Canadian history’s greatness – our national accomplishments during the World Wars. For much of our history Canada has punched above its weight. As a relatively small country we have had a disproportionate impact on the shape and outcome of major conflicts. Canadian forces have long been hailed as highly skilled, motivated and capable soldiers, as evidenced by our performance at Vimy Ridge, Passchendaele, Juno Beach and the Liberation of Holland – to name a few. Our fearsome reputation was well earned.  

5- Voice for the Voiceless

The form of history most in vogue in Canadian studies these days – or so it seems to me – is social history. Historians are very interested in providing voices to the voiceless. The voiceless are those in society who did not have access to political or social power – women, the lower classes, immigrants, First Nations, and on. Canadian history offers a panoply of perspectives and scenarios. Traditional views of how society operated in Canada’s past is always being challenged, presenting a fascinating mosaic. These histories are often equally contentious and illuminating.

4 - A Nation of Nations

“Canadianness” is a construction, and many Canadians (presently and in the past) have multiple identities. Canada is composed of hundreds, perhaps thousands of competing nations – be they our First Nations, with their distinct cultures, or the new arrivals. Each nation within Canada has a distinct story. Figuring out the tale of how Canada came to be is more often deciphering a mosaic, rather than interpreting a paint-by-numbers. Even our distinct regions and provincial interests mean that a national narrative can always be challenged. This diversity of peoples means that Canadian history is a very simple narrative to learn, but a very difficult thing to understand.

3 – Protest, Revolts and Revolutions

Canadian history is often labelled as being dull. What people mean by this is that it is not very violent, and we really need a good spilling of blood to get excited. I blame Hollywood. That being said Canadian history has its share of spilt blood, despite the perception otherwise. First, to understand the formation of Canada you have to understand the American Revolution, which produced two countries, not one. In 1837, 1870, 1885, 1919 and the 1930s we see major revolts in Canada. Many of them have a revolutionary tenor. It is only through brutal suppression of the government that they were not successful. Each time the people of Canada rose up another mark was made on the history of Canada.

The social and political evolution of this country has been profound from its earliest origins. The roots are ancient, but since then the tree that is this country has grown and changed dramatically, shaped by the hands of its people – not just its elites. The social justice principles so many Canadians hold dear were not an accident of history, they came from a concerted effort to make this a better country. These movements and their histories make this country a richer place.

2 - Our ‘Great’ Leaders

Great is a difficult term, but sometimes I think as cynical Canadians we hesitate to heap praise on our historic leaders. The truth of the matter is that many of our leaders can stand proud amongst the leaders of the world. Richard Gwyn has just put out a second volume to his biography to Sir John A. Macdonald, in an interview he said that Macdonald may be a better leader than his contemporaries, which include Benjamin Disraeli and Abraham Lincoln. But there are many figures from our past we can look to: Sir Wilfrid Laurier, Gen. Arthur Currie, Tecumseh, Joseph Brant, Tommy Douglas, Elijah Harper, Nellie McClung, Rene Levesque, Louis Riel, to name a few.

There are also the infamous, which I will not list. Canada has not shortage of colour characters shaping its past. None are saints, nor are they devils, they’re people who contributed to our present with fascinating stories.

1 - Who are we?

When I teach history I tend to start off with a simple idea, we cannot know where we are if we don’t know where we came from. We are products of our history. Even those new Canadians are part of a larger tapestry that fits within a larger patchwork assembled over hundreds of years. The actions of our forbearers have measurable impact on the lives we lead today. Our individual identities are inextricably tied to how we understand ourselves as a whole country or a nation.