Showing posts with label Canada Election 2015. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canada Election 2015. Show all posts

Friday, September 27, 2019

Book Review: The Candidate by Noah Richler

Good stories about politics are disappointingly rare. Good stories about politics set in Canada are even rarer. When I first got wind of Noah Richler's The Candidate: Fear and Loathing on the Campaign Trail I hesitated to pick it up for a variety of reasons, but having finished reading it I am very glad I did.



In 2015 I was a very active member of the New Democratic Party. After four years of a Harper majority I was ready to put my shoulder to the wheel and push to replace the Conservative government with the first New Democratic government in history. It was a heady time, but my closest political friends and I knew that it was going to be a difficult fight and nothing could be taken for granted. However, there was also a whiff of hope and ambition - that we could pull it off and make history. Little did I know Noah Richler and I were on a similar journey.

I bring up my personal narrative here because so much of my experience fed into my enjoyment of the book. I don't believe you have to have been engaged in politics or a New Democrat to enjoy this book, but I think it adds something tremendously to have that little smirk and nod knowing precisely the sort of experience Richler is describing. It is wonderful to have those experiences reflected.

Noah Richler was the NDP candidate for Toronto-St. Paul's in 2015 challenging the incumbent MP Carolyn Bennett. The book follows the journey from his decision to run to working with the party to find a seat to challenge and then the campaign.

Richler describes the bizarre and informal world of politics with great human and a certain wry look. One of the things that I like best is that Richler is motivated by genuine issues of concerns. He has topics that he is opinionated and passionate on and struggles how to square that passion with the realities of running a real campaign. Richler is also flawed, like everyone. He has to find a way to deal with the fact that he expressed his opinions in public and therefore gets in trouble for how his words on social media from the past are interpreted.

There's a bunch of aspects that I appreciate in the story. For example the way the riding executive is described. The unglamorous and unassuming people who dedicate themselves to the political process. The awkwardness of politics, mainly approaching strangers and trying to convince them of a point of view out of nowhere. How the NDP volunteers was described also made me smile because it fit my experience for the most part.

What Noah Richler expresses about the party itself and the frustration about the campaign in 2015 mirrors my own. Four years on that disappointment still clouds some of my political thinking. People made mistakes during that campaign, I have no doubt. One of my favourite scenes is when Richler describes an event in Toronto and the well-heeled audience is full of Liberals and Conservatives back-slapping each other, the true powers behind the country and the NDP feel excluded and unwanted. Perhaps that shapes elections more than we'd like to think.

Overall, I have to very much recommend this book to people curious about how elections work and the more human side of things. It is a great read for people thinking about running, certainly. I'd also add that it would be fun for veterans of the political process.

Tuesday, February 9, 2016

Learning the Wrong Lesson from Elections

One of the most common errors political parties and politicians make is over-learning the lessons of the previous election and applying them to the current one. This idea has been rolling into my head since the 2015 federal election. As I have mentioned in posts preceding this one, the NDP fell into this trap. They are hardly the first party to fall victim to it, and they definitely won't be the last.

Here's how it goes. In the wake of election the defeated party or parties are forced to reflect on the outcome. Voters, for their indescribable reasons, chose Party A over Party B. In order to correct the problems advocates within the party push to move the party to resemble the victorious party in whatever way was deemed the reason for victory. I've seen this many times in American politics. When the Democrats are defeated there are calls to move towards the centre to recapture voters. When the Republicans are vanquished and appear to be in the wilderness their critics suggest a move to the left and a more open party would ensure them victory.

Sometimes this is successful. The 2006 victory of the Democrats was partially brought about by recruiting ore conservative candidates that could win in redder states and districts. More often than not though this idea has a habit of breaking down.

Voters, it seems to me, want alternatives, not pale imitations. Parties that simply copy their opponents risk making themselves irrelevant. They are unlikely to woo the base of the other party and alienate their own supporters and voters hoping to real change. In election strategy jargon they call this contrasts, ways you can demonstrate favourable differences with your opponents. Each political party has core brands or associated values, trying to borrow someone else's will, at best, feel inauthentic.

The 2015 election offers an interesting case study in this regard. In the wake of the 2011 election both the Liberals and New Democrats had to decide how to approach the coming election, and both, for different reasons, needed to find a new leader. The NDP's membership made a choice to follow Jack Layton's model as a centre-left party, remain on the left on social issues, continue to advocate for key groups, but present a 'friendlier' fiscal and rhetorical framework. This is afterall part of the way Stephen Harper had managed to build his majority, his perceived stewardship of the economy and public purse. The Liberal Party, often thin on ideology, selected a new leader to try to win them the election, the charismatic Justin Trudeau. Trudeau is not the man you would pick if you thought you had to run a campaign similar to Harper to win an election. Someone like Ralph Goodale would fit much more in that model.

Leaving aside the platforms one can look at the campaign to see how the parties differentiated themselves. For four years the Conservatives banked on another election built on economic concerns, and so did the NDP. The election actually turned on Stephen Harper and essentially became a referendum on him. Justin Trudeau offered the stronger contrast with the Prime Minister.


Parties are poised to make a similar error again. Already the Conservatives are making noises that they need a "Sunny Ways" leader to take them into the future. Likewise in the NDP there are concerns that the Liberals flank to the left is what doomed them, so a shift leftward with a new leader is the answer to their problems. If Canadians decide to kick Justin Trudeau and the Liberals out of power in 2019 it will be if they find an alternative the like, not if each party presents their version of Liberal-Light or Trudeau-Light. Parties, generally, need to be true to themselves and offer an option, not play the "Me Too!" game. 

Tuesday, November 3, 2015

Benefits of a Long Campaign

At several points during the election campaign I thought, "Thank God we have eleven weeks," or "How could we have done this in six weeks?" As you may recall much of the conversation at the beginning of the campaign was about the fact that the 2015 federal election was the longest campaign in modern history and therefore the most expensive campaign that would greatly expand the spending limits. Despite the added costs and challenge I think it is hard to say that the public did not benefit from a longer campaign.

This was the first election that I worked very closely with a campaign. I have volunteered on a few campaigns, but this was a different level of immersion entirely. I believe that the higher voter turnout, up to nearly 69%, can be attributed in part to the longer campaign. One of the first things you learn in a campaign is that voter contact is key to turning out your vote. Campaigns had eleven weeks to reach out to voters, compared to the usual six weeks. Add in the fact that election advertising had much longer to reach a greater number of Canadians and the media had more time to inform voters about the campaign and the issues. Every once in a while I'd hear a story about a voter who didn't know that there was an election on.

The short campaign benefits the incumbents disproportionately. In an era before fixed election dates this was even more the case. Incumbents can quickly secure their nominations, usually unchallenged and go on with the rest of the campaign. Challengers have to be invited to compete in a nomination contest, sign up members, hold a meeting and then try to bring together the local party afterwards. This directly affected Brampton South, my riding. The NDP did not nominate a candidate until August 17th. We were working towards an August 30th meeting when the election was called. The reason for the delay is quite simple. There are rules governing how the nomination meeting has to be run, such as at least two weeks notice to party members before holding a meeting sent by mail. Not to mention candidates need to sign up new members and want more time.

The longer campaign also made it a better, more substantial campaign. The initial "gotcha" stuff got out of the way pretty early, which in a standard campaign would have dominated the early third. Several substantive issues came to the forefront during the campaign including the Duffy trial, the Syrian refugee crisis, niqab and civil liberties, and debts and deficits. Historically our elections often only revolve around an election or two, but in the last campaign there was enough time to present a number of competing visions for Canada. The longer campaign also allowed time for more debates and gave local organizers more opportunity to prepare for their own.

It is not all upside, of course. The longer campaign means a heavier burden on candidates and volunteers. One of the most troubling stories during the last election for me was that an NDP candidate in Saskatchewan has to resign as the candidate due to financial pressures. Being a core volunteer for 11+ weeks was certainly challenging for me. Remember that candidates often have to take a leave of absence from work and are living off debt or savings during a campaign, or a spouse's single income. A longer campaigns, if not considered carefully, will exclude less well off candidates from running.

Overall I think it's clear that the benefits outweigh the cost and that perhaps as a country we should move the minimum length of an election 50 days. Though if we do other related parts, such as funding , need to be re-examined.

Tuesday, October 27, 2015

2015 Federal Election Reflection

Now that eight days has past (has it only been eight days?), let's talk about the election.

For anyone who follows me on social media it will have been clear that I was very disappointed in the result. I am a member of the New Democratic Party and volunteered for Amarjit Sangha, the candidate for Brampton South. New Democrats were on the verge of forming government, but support peaked on August 27th at 37%.

There is a lot to write about in the election, I'll do my best to keep this succinct. If you want a great overview of the campaign I would strongly recommend Paul Well's very long piece about the campaign here. 

I was pleased to see turnout went up. Before the election I developed a infographic for a friend that suggested that when turnout went up dramatic shifts in power could happen, such as in the Alberta provincial election. I am confident that many of the new voters were drawn to the Liberals, but all three parties were motivated to get their vote out. However, it is important for those supporters to remember that Trudeau's majority is in fact arguably less legitimate than Harper's. Harper won a majority in 2011 with 39.6% and Trudeau won with 39.5%. Though with a larger overall turnout the sense of legitimacy from the country as a whole is stronger. Regardless the distortions of First-Past-the-Post continue.

The victory of the Liberals can be attributed to three things. First was the exhaustion of the electorate with the Conservatives. There was a strong case made by Tom Mulcair in the House of Commons and a long list of scandals drained enthusiasm and support from Harper which was only compounded by a bitter, angry, and Islamophobic campaign. In this environment the struggle was over who would be the best option to defeat the Conservatives. At the start it was the NDP, but as the NDP vote sank the Liberals gained momentum. Finally, the tremendously low expectations for Trudeau played into his hands. No serious gaffe or misstep marred his campaign. Meaning that as it went on the "He's not ready" meme worked less and less effectively as it rang hollow.

Trudeau's majority was built by sweeping Atlantic Canada, vote splitting in Quebec and a strong win in Ontario that mirrors Kathleen Wynne's provincial win in 2014.

I was hoping to offer some insight in the aftermath about the specific vote in Brampton. Sadly, looking at all five ridings (Brampton East, Brampton North, Brampton Centre, Brampton South, and Brampton West) they were swept up in a Liberal wave that gave the Liberals almost every single seat in the GTA. The peculiars of each campaign in this environment are almost meaningless.

And what of the vanquished Harper? The near-decade long premiership of Harper has come to an end. He announced his intent to resign as PM and leader of the Conservative Party. Now the Conservatives will turn inward and must fight the urge to eat their young. First the party must find an appropriate interim leader and other Conservatives must debate whether or not they want to lead the 99 member Conservative caucus as the Official Opposition. The Conservatives should take heart though. They had 99 seats with a smaller share of the vote in 2004. It is fair to say the Conservatives had something of a fresh breakthrough in Quebec.

And what of the NDP? Upon reflection I think the NDP made the very common mistake of fighting the last war. If this election was the conclusion to the 2011 election, or a replay of it I think that Tom Mulcair could be the one picking cabinet members now. But this was not a replay of 2011 and the dynamic was very different. An interesting observation I heard from a journalist is that the NDP coalition simply became too unwieldy. It was a complex composition of voters with divergent opinions and interests. It forced the NDP to take positions that would alienate parts of its coalition. This was embodied in the niqab debate.

In my opinion Tom Mulcair should continue as the NDP leader. With the Conservatives wandering off into the wilderness the Trudeau government will need an effective opposition. Mulcair has proven more than capable at holding a government to account. The NDP managed to hold on in Quebec, which suggests the Orange Wave may have some lasting permanence. A number of 'safe' NDP seats were lost, that should be recoverable in the next election and 2015 was the second best result for the NDP in number of seats.


While Stephen Harper exits Canadian political life it is important to remember that Harperism will not leave with him. I doubt this is the last time we'll see an aggressively centralizing, media-controlling prime minister. The Liberal Party embraced many positions of the Conservatives over the last four years and heading into the election. Prime Minister-Designate Trudeau may have a challenging four years ahead of him. His caucus is large, but his majority is somewhat thin. It is heavily rooted in Eastern and Central Canada. With the growing size of Canada's House of Commons he will have a larger group of backbenchers, over 150 of whom are rookies, to manage. Expectations will be high for the Liberals and undoubtedly the Canadian public and opposition parties will be watching carefully. 

Sunday, October 18, 2015

2015 Canadian Federal Election Prediction

Well reader, tomorrow is the day. Across the country hundreds of campaigns are scrambling to complete the last bit of work before millions of Canadians cast their ballots. If polls are to be trusted (which they should not be) the election night will be a big disappointment to my fellow New Democrats and we will likely be in a minority parliament for the next couple of years. Many websites this time around have presented models and projections for what the outcome will be for each seat. It will be interesting to see how much egg ends up on their collective faces. I will be spending election day working for my local NDP candidate after I cast my ballot. Then I will be going through my long-standing tradition of watching the results with a drink and some popcorn.

General Thoughts

I think this election will be very tricky to predict on a seat-by-seat level. The strength of the NDP coming into the election, the resilience of the Conservatives and the growth of the Liberal and Bloc vote makes the likelihood of strange splits more likely.

My prediction is not based on sophisticated polling or modeling. It reflects a synthesis of the information I have looked at and my own gut instinct.

The North

I think it is fair to say that the Conservatives face an uphill battle in the North. The question is whether or not the splits will be severe enough to allow their election. At this point I'd say the NDP will be returned in the Northwest Territories and the Liberals have a good shot at picking up Yukon and Nunavut. They are likely to be close though, so keep an eye on them. If the Liberals or NDP could bring down Leona Aglukkaq in Nunavut it would be a big loss for the Tories.

Ridings to Watch: Nunavut

CPC - 0
LPC - 2
NDP - 1
GPC - 0
Atlantic Canada

The Conservatives seem doomed in Atlantic Canada. Their changes to Employment Insurance has disproportionately hurt this region. The opposition parties have both been buoyed as the Conservatives have slipped. The Conservatives have almost no hope to pick up new seats in Atlantic Canada, the question is how much they will lose. In Newfoundland it will be a sea of red, five of the seven seats should safely go Liberal. The NDP should be able to hold on to St. John's East, but it will be a fight between them and the Liberals to hold on to St. John's South-Mount Pearl.

The rise of the Liberals in Nova Scotia has put a number of NDP seats at risk. Popular MP Meagan Leslie could even lose her seat in Halifax, but I believe she'll hold on. The rest of the province will probably go to the Liberals.

New Brunswick is the Conservatives best hope in Atlantic Canada. They should hold on to three or four seats in that province. The NDP should continue to hold Acadie-Bathurst. More urban ridings in New Brunswick will be likely to flip to the Liberals such as Fredericton, and Moncton-Riverview-Dieppe.

PEI should return to a Liberal stronghold.

Ridings to Watch: St. John's South-Mount Pearl, Halifax, Saint John-Rothesay, Miramichi-Grand Lake.

Atlantic Canada

CPC - 3
LPC - 20
NDP - 3
GPC - 0

Quebec

The biggest story of the last election, the Orange Wave, is being challenged in Quebec. At the start of the campaign it looked like the NDP might expand their advantage in the province. However the race broke apart with Conservative, Liberal and Bloc support growing. This is by far the hardest prediction/projection to make. With four competitive parties it is possible to win with a very small number of votes, comparatively speaking. I suspect that the Conservatives may enjoy a significant advantage from these divides.

Ridings to Watch: Trois-Rivieres, Saint-Maurice-Champlain, Quebec City, Marc-Aurele-Fortin, Louis-Herbert, Laurentides-Labelle, Beauport-Limoilou.

CPC - 15
LPC - 24
NDP - 35
GPC - 0
BQ - 4

Ontario

If any party wins a majority it will from a breakthrough in Ontario. There are three regions in particular to look at in this election: Toronto, 905, and Southwestern Ontario. Toronto should see the Conservative get rolled up by a Liberal wave. The Liberal strength has put NDP seats in jeopardy in the downtown. The Conservatives built their majority with seats in the 905. Both the Liberals and NDP are poised to make gains against the Conservatives. Halton Region, Peel Region, York Region and Durham Region are real battlegrounds. Southwestern Ontario is a different beast. The NDP have been hopeful for years that their appeal could work in Southwestern Ontario. With Conservative support slipping there are real opportunities in places like Sarnia, Brantford and Essex.

Ridings to Watch: University-Rosedale, Oshawa, Oakville, Kenora, Eglinton-Lawrence, Brantford-Brant Brampton East.

CPC - 45
LPC - 59
NDP - 17
GPC - 0

The Prairies

Support in the Conservative heartland is waning which gives fresh opportunities to the NDP and the Liberals. However, the deeply unpopular NDP government in Manitoba is hurting that parties' chances. Therefore we're likely to see Liberal gains in Manitoba and NDP gains in Saskatchewan. The new urban ridings in Saskatchewan offer a real opportunity to the NDP to re-establish a presence in that province.

Ridings to Watch: Saskatoon-Grasswood, Regina-Lewvan, Elmwood-Transcona, Charleswood-St. James-Assiniboia-Headingley, Churchill-Keewatinook Aski.

CPC - 16
LPC - 5
NDP - 6
GPC - 0

Alberta

The idea of solid Conservative Alberta will likely take another beating on Monday night. With Conservative support down and a larger number of urban ridings the Liberals and NDP are ready to pick up seats in Alberta. Calgary and Edmonton are the most likely to yield results, but the NDP has been targeting Lethbridge as a potential area for pick-up.

Ridings to Watch:
Calgary Confederation, Edmonton Centre, Edmonton Griesbach, Lethbridge, St. Albert-Edmonton

CPC - 28
LPC - 4
NDP - 2
GPC - 0

British Columbia

This province might give the NDP the best news of the evening. BC has been more of a Conservative-NDP battleground than anywhere else. If NDP strength holds out a lot of seats could fall their way. The wildcard is Green support. The Greens early on showed a great deal of popular support on Vancouver Island, at times enough to win a second seat. The question is whether or not it will pan out.

Ridings to Watch: Burnaby North-Seymour, Fleetwood-Port Kells, Pitt Meadows-Maple Ridge, Surrey Centre, Victoria.

CPC - 15
LPC - 10
NDP - 16
GPC - 1

Total/Overview

CPC - 122
LPC - 124
NDP - 80
GPC - 1
BQ - 4


My gut tells me the Conservatives will win more seats than the models currently suggest, and perhaps even the most seats after tomorrow night. The NDP will make gains in parts of the country but their weakened position in Quebec will cause them to lose ground overall in the House of Commons. This outcome is very uncertain though. It is possible that the Conservatives may win the most seats with fewer votes than the Liberals, or that the splits result in incredible surprises, much like what we saw in 2011. Or, perhaps the Liberals have enough momentum to start their own Red Wave and form a majority. We'll know the general shape of the result around midnight Tuesday. Fingers crossed for no voting problems, everyone have a good E-Day! 

Tuesday, October 13, 2015

The Case Against Strategic Voting

The first thing I should say before I go forward is that there is no wrong way to vote. Strategic voting is an entirely fair way for citizens to make up their mind. If that's how you want to make your voting selection then that is totally fine. In my opinion though it is a flawed method to use. I'll also say that I may be too late for many of you as advanced polling closed yesterday at 8 P.M.

Strategic voting has taken hold much more strongly in this campaign than in previous elections. It has always been a part of the political calculation of the politically engaged in a first-past-the-post system. They have taken on a more formal role with websites dedicated to promoting strategic voting and advising voters to go a certain way.

Strategic voters rely heavily on accurate, timely information but in no way can guarantee that. Some of the organizations have been conducting riding-based polls, whose accuracy has been suspect in the past. Most rely on historic results and models based on provincial/regional polling. How does that work? Models work by determining how 30% support translates on the local level. It is at best an educated guess and rarely takes into account the local campaign and candidates.

The example I point to is Bramalea-Gore-Malton. In the 2011 federal election Jagmeet Singh (NDP) challenged Bal Gosal (Conservative) for the seat. If you asked anyone the smart strategic vote would be for the Liberal candidate, Gubrax Mahli. The NDP had never won in Brampton before, and the Liberals had controlled Brampton very recently. So off the strategic voters marched to the Liberal camp. Jagmeet Singh lost the seat by 600 votes and months later would be elected in the provincial election. This is clearly a sign that strategic voting failed. Now, despite an NDP MP, the previous results, strategic voting websites are still advocating voting Liberal in Brampton East, the successor of Bramalea-Gore-Malton. 

The power of strategic voting is only evident in the hypothetical math in the aftermath of any election. How many times have we heard, "If 5000 voters switched from the NDP to the Liberals they would have won Ottawa-Orleans," or substitute any number of other ridings. It presumes that all parties on the left are interchangeable. The Liberals have moved to the right during the Harper years in an effort to win back Blue Liberals/Red Tories. If you're on the hard left of the NDP there isn't a great deal of space between the Liberals and Conservatives. What of the Greens? Are their values interchangeable with the NDP? They tend to be more centrist.

This is my problem with strategic voting philosophically. Strategic voting masks the true opinion and intent of the voter. Often parties have very different philosophies and approaches to politics. Even if the votes do not translate to seats the parties and politicians take heed of where support is in their ridings. Parties can identify growing bases of support and build on them for the future.

I have met more than a few "Anyone But Conservative" voters, or Anti-Harper voters. To them they don't care who they vote for as long as they defeat the local Conservative candidate. It becomes more complicated if you're a voter who has objections to your alternative, or what if you want to stop the Liberals?

Another problem with strategic voting is that is often a simple ploy to buttress the traditional two main parties and suppress the vote of alternatives. People have the right to vote for the parties they like and strategic voting offers an intellectual fig leaf to marginalize them.

No one can tell you with any accuracy how people will vote on October 19th. Models and predictions can only tell you so much. The reality is though that a single vote rarely decides an election. With that being the case why not vote for the party/candidate you believe in? That's how democracy is supposed to work.


Tuesday, September 29, 2015

Campaign Update: The Feel on the Street

As of September 29th there are only 20 days left until the election comes to a conclusion. Despite the length and complexity of the campaign it is soon coming to a close. As we approach election day much of my efforts have shifted into organizing and canvassing neighbourhoods. I won't go into depth about the strategy of the campaign because that's our business, but as I canvas neighbourhoods I am noting patterns that I figured I could share.

The vast majority of voters I encounter fall within two camps. First are the committed Conservatives. They are a minority overall but of the voters who are determined to vote a particular way they are definitely the largest group I talk to. People who are voting Conservative know they are voting Conservative. After all the bad news for Conservatives they are down to their very base of support. The second group is far larger and far more difficult to deal with. They are left-leaning undecideds. Now they are not necessarily 'left-leaning'. These people could have no expressed political ideology. On our canvassing I often remark to my companions "another ABC" code for Anybody But Conservatives. Anti-Conservative or Anti-Harper voters are thick on the ground on Brampton, but have not yet decided where to leap.

Obviously this does not describe all voters. Many are utterly undecided and willing to consider all parties. Others are committed Liberals or New Democrats.

What's heartbreaking to me as I knock on these doors is that many want to vote for the NDP, but are too scared to. They cannot, in their minds, risk voting for the NDP for fear a Conservative might win. Strategic voting will play a big role in this campaign, which in many ways is unfortunate. Strategic voting is always questionable to me. It presumes that everyone else isn't acting the same and that you have absolute knowledge. It relies heavily on polling information and worse still, projections.

Let's use a riding in Brampton as a case study. Brampton East was narrowly lost by the NDP in 2011 and was won provincially in 2011 and 2014. Yet a website advocating strategic vote suggests that ABC voters should vote Liberal. This hardly makes sense to me.

Not to mention, if strategic voters want to avoid having to make these decisions in the future shouldn't they support the NDP and bring an end to the First-Past-the-Post system that creates the need? The Liberals have no interest in reforming our electoral system.

Most voters I am meeting are undecided. Their votes are very much up for grabs. The election and polls could swing wildly as we approach the final vote. In the meantime I'll keep chipping away and turn Brampton South orange.




Tuesday, September 8, 2015

Campaign Update: Now it Begins?

Though Canadians have hardly noticed an election campaign has been unfolding across the country for about a month. People still enjoying their summer vacations and the warm weather are now confronted with the reality that today is the first day of school and with that the parties will turn up their attention on the voters as well.

Despite a month having passed I have noticed shockingly little election activity. Everywhere I go signs are sparse. The incumbent parties tend to have a better operation off the ground and have a stronger presence at this point, but even that is pretty flimsy in my estimation. As for myself I have been working for the Brampton South NDP candidate, Amarjit Sangha. He was nominated after the writ was drawn up so we are just getting underway officially now. In fact, our campaign office is opening this Saturday at 2 PM at 8975 McLaughlin Rd, Unit 10. Very exciting!

When this campaign began it was stated that the Conservatives wanted to exploit changes in the election laws to allow them to spend a great deal of money. This is correct, but they haven't spent it evenly. We should expect heavy bombardments of advertising and other forms of campaigning in October and later into September.

The disengagement of the electorate in general is reflected in polling as well. The numbers have been stable and essentially moving within the margin of error. In many ways we are in the midst of a three-way tie. Consistently polls show the NDP with a modest lead, followed by the Conservatives and the Liberals. This morning I saw some polls suggesting the Conservatives have fallen to third, but we'll see if this pans out. First, as I said earlier in this campaign, following the national numbers is virtually meaningless. Provincial/regional breakdowns is far more useful in understanding what is happening in this election. It should be accepted that when the time comes the frontrunner will receive far more scrutiny and attacks. The Conservatives have millions of dollars waiting for the right time.

On the local scene, Brampton will be having its first debate on September 18th. All of the New Democrats and Greens have confirmed they will attend, three of the five Liberals and none of the Conservatives. I am curious to see if this tactic of avoiding the media and any form of scrutiny continues for the Conservatives going forward.

All in all it has been a quiet start to the election but this is about to change. In coming weeks I expect (hope) that signs start appearing across Canada to indicate Canadians' interest in the campaign. I am caught in a bit of a rock and a hard place for how to discuss the election. I am an active participant on one side. I cannot actively discuss all of my activities because that would be revealing internal business of the campaign. Regardless, I will do my best to write about the campaign as it moves forward.



Tuesday, August 18, 2015

Is 2015 a Change Election?

Is 2015 a change election? I am sometimes the downer of my friends and colleagues by pointing out the fact that even though we and many people we know do not like Prime Minister Stephen Harper there is a very strong chance that he may be re-elected. To progressives and those who have carefully watched the mismanagement of the previous years, or tuned into the Duffy trial the writing seems to be on the wall.

In Canadian tradition it is unusual for a political leader to last more than ten years. If re-elected Prime Minister Harper will have been in power 10 years in January 2016. After ten years a growing number of Canadians will be growing tired of Mr. Harper and interested in looking for alternatives. Part of the reason that governments/leaders tend not to last longer than ten years is that scandals and controversies pile up around them and drain them of public support. Jean Charest in Quebec, Dalton McGuinty in Ontario and Brian Mulroney federally are all excellent examples of leader taken down by years of baggage.

However, there usually is a straw that breaks the camel's back. For McGuinty it was the gas plants; a nagging political issue that threatened to destroy his government that was in a precarious minority. The Harper Conservatives have been in trouble before. Before the 2011 election Parliament censured them for disrespect for parliament. Sadly Canadians are worried more about financial transgressions than democratic ones. Even still, Tony Clement (CPC - Parry Sound-Muskoka, ON) misspent millions of dollars for cosmetic upgrades to his riding and he was re-elected easily, as were the Conservatives. It's always shockingly strange when something like Bev Oda, a former minister, nearly brings down the government with $16 orange juices when Clement can be forgiven his callous misuse of public funds.

Critics of the Conservatives can (and do) make lists of abuses under Prime Minister Harper and provide amble evidence why it is in the best interest of the country to replace him.  But that is not the average voter. Voters, generally speaking, don't care about omnibus bills or respect for parliament (to my great and profound sadness). What might stick is fraud. If any one thing might end the premiership of Stephen Harper it is the trial of Senator Mike Duffy. Remember that politics is about perceptions and not realities. Even if Stephen Harper cannot be directly tied to any of the allegations, just like the $16 orange juice it will create a narrative. Trials are smoke and smoke mans fire.

But any fantasy that the Conservatives will be routed from power needs to be tempered with the simple fact that the electorate is strongly divided. The Conservative vote is very efficient. Rural ridings across the country and certain Western ridings will stick with them even if they drop below 30%. Even below 30% they will likely win about 100 seats. Meanwhile their opponents, the New Democrats, Liberals and Greens are all scrapping for many of the same voters in the same places. Take for example my hometown, Brampton. In 2011 the Conservatives won all of the seats here, but Brampton, like much of the 905, used to be solid Liberal territory. Even at their peak the Conservatives only narrowly beat their Liberals opponents in some ridings. In 2011 the NDP made a breakthrough in eastern Brampton. In the 2014 provincial election that strength was reaffirmed and spread westward. It's possible that 2015 will see three-way races across the city which might result in smaller margins of victory and Conservatives winning despite declining popularity.

As stated before, the electorate is divided. There are a great deal who ready to dump the Conservatives and try something new, but there is probably about 20-25% of the population who will be voting CPC no matter what. If this is a change election the opposition parties are going to have to work very hard on the ground to prove it.  

Tuesday, August 4, 2015

Primer for the 42nd Canadian General Election

On Sunday August 2nd Prime Minister Stephen Harper visited Governor General David Johnston and asked him to dissolve parliament triggering the forty-second general election in Canadian history.  For the next two months, until October 19th, the country will be in an election period. For most Canadians this will impact their lives very little, especially for the first 40 days or so. In recent past elections have only lasted about 37 days, however after World War Two many were 60+ days in length. So while this campaign is the longest one in Canada since 1874 it is not particularly freakish in our history.

In this post I hope to lay some of the basic foundations for citizens as we move into the campaign season.



Basics

There is not one election going on in Canada at the moment. As a parliamentary democracy Canadians will elect 338 Members of Parliament to form the 42nd House of Commons. The way the media and voters often describe the election is through the selection of who they want to become Prime Minister. This is a fair way of weighing one's vote, but it does not actually fit with how our system works. If a party receives 170 seats they will control a majority of the seats in the House of Commons and that leader will become Prime Minister. Any outcome other than that is less clear, and will be discussed at a later date.

During the election Stephen Harper (Conservative) remains the Prime Minister, and his cabinet remained government ministers. However, by convention their powers are curtailed. This is called the caretaker convention. No major policy should be carried out during the campaign. The media will be watching carefully for the government to abuse their powers. Impressively the government released its caretaker convention to the public. Tom Mulcair, leader of the NDP and Leader of the Opposition will be fighting to unseat the current government and become the first federal NDP government in history. The Liberals under Justin Trudeau will attempt to restore their fortunes from third place and vault back into government.

Where the Parties Stand

When the House of Commons was dissolved there were 159 Conservatives (CPC), 95 New Democrats (NDP), 36 Liberals (LPC), 2 Bloc Quebecois (BQ), 2 Greens (GPC), 2 Strength in Democracy, 8 independents and 4 vacancies. Thirty seats were added to help balance the population changes in the country. A significant number of MPs have decided to retire heading into this election. Together this means that incumbency will be much weaker in many seats than in previous elections. A number of organizations have calculated the results if Canadians voted exactly the same in the new boundaries. Not only were new seats added but others were adjusted to help balance populations. These are the numbers I am using below.

Tip: Ignore the national polling numbers. They are an average of Canadian opinions across the country, but voting trends are easier to interpret at a regional/provincial level. For example, two polls could show the Conservatives at 30%, but it include a 10% boost in Alberta and a 10% decline in British Columbia hidden in the average. Despite a stable popular support this would likely result in a drop of several seats for the Conservatives. Where the votes are matter a great deal.

Atlantic Canada

CPC - 15, NDP - 6, LPC - 11

Atlantic Canada is normally a rock for the Liberal Party. In July the Liberals were polling at ~40%, over 10 points higher than the second place NDP. It's possible the Conservative Party could be routed from the region, New Brunswick is the only province in which they have significant strength. The NDP will be hoping to hold on to what they currently have in Atlantic Canada, and possibly expand with a couple of additional seats in Nova Scotia (South Shore-St. Margaret's, Central Nova, or Cumberland-Colchester), one in New Brunswick. The Liberals play well in all ridings in this region and are hoping to pick off NDP and Conservative seats in every province. They have a particularly good shot in urban ridings in New Brunswick.

If the election seat counts are close all of these Atlantic battlegrounds will matter. Even though Atlantic Canada has fewer seats than Alberta they are all much more likely to flip.

Quebec

CPC - 5, NDP - 61, LPC - 8, BQ - 4

The major question after the 2011 election was whether or not the Orange Wave that swept Quebec was permanent of a strange fluke. Polling since the election would suggest that NDP are firmly in place as the favourite party of Quebec voters. Though the 2011 election should remind us how quickly things can change. The return of Gilles Duceppe as leader of the BQ might boost their prospects. Both the Liberal and NDP leaders hail from Quebec, which certainly wins them additional support. The NDP won 59 seats in 2011. For a long while I assumed that this must represent a high-water mark and that in 2015 it would only be sensible to expect the number of seats to decline, even if only slightly. However, it looks possible the NDP will hold on. The Conservatives have two major areas they are hoping to play for. The area around Quebec City tends to be more favourable to them and they are targeting Mont Royal in Montreal. Mr. Harper is unlikely to do well in Quebec, but getting his total into double digits would help secure his government a great deal. The Liberals will focus their energies in Montreal trying to retake the seats lost to them in 2011.

Ontario

CPC - 83, NDP - 24, LPC - 14

Ontario is the biggest prize in any federal election. It has the most seats by a wide margin and offers a number of contests between the parties. It is a bit silly to talk of the province as a whole because its own internal regions behave differently. The Liberals used to own the whole province of Ontario in the 1990s. The Conservative surge through rural and suburban (and even urban) Ontario helped to secure their majority government. If the Liberals hope to form government or the Conservatives hope to keep power it will be decided here.

In the province's capital city the Tory incumbents will try to hold on as many voters find their way back to the Liberal Party. Vote splitting, if the NDP rise again in Toronto, may be the only thing that protects them. In downtown Toronto it will be a knockdown, drag-out fight between the NDP and the Liberals. NDP candidates have been aggressively campaigning there for weeks already. In the 905, suburbs around Toronto, the fight will generally be between the Liberals and the Conservatives. Winning these seats pushed the Harper Conservatives into majority government. The NDP may be able to gain seats in Oshawa, Brampton, and around Hamilton, but unless numbers swing dramatically it will mostly be a red-blue fight in the 905. In the rest of the province the NDP have a strong shot at gaining in the North and in Southwestern Ontario where its provincial cousins have fared well. Rural seats should be safe for the Conservatives, but if the Liberals start to go up many seats beyond the suburbs could start to flip.

Prairies

CPC - 22, NDP - 5, LPC - 1

It should hardly be surprising that the Conservatives do well in the Prairies. This is their home turf and base (with Alberta). Both opposition parties are polling up though and boundary changes in Saskatchewan make it much friendlier to the NDP. Urban seats in Winnipeg, Saskatoon and Regina will likely swap Conservatives for Liberals and New Democrats in this election, unless Conservative popularity goes up. Currently the NDP have no seats in Saskatchewan, but the 308 Blog by Eric Grenier is projecting as many as six seats could go to them. Saskatchewan and Manitoba are real battlegrounds in this election.

Alberta

CPC - 33, NDP - 1

Alberta probably isn't the province you think it is. The recent election of a NDP provincial government should reaffirm that. The fact that Edmonton and Calgary are led by progressive mayors should also shatter some illusions people hold about that province. The opposition parties have been growing in strength in Alberta. The redistribution of seats created some more urban seats in Edmonton and Calgary that both the NDP and Liberals hope to pick up. From their base in Edmonton-Strathcona the NDP hopes to push out into other Edmonton seats. The NDP have the win in their sails in that province coming off an amazing win. Most seats will remain firmly Conservative but the cities will be places to watch.

British Columbia

CPC - 28, NDP - 11, LPC - 2, GPC - 1

BC might be the ultimate battleground province. The polls often show a three-way race in the westernmost province. All parties have a reasonable hope of picking up additional seats, including the Greens who will be fighting to maintain Elizabeth May's seat and gain Victoria. The city of Vancouver and the Lower Mainland of the province will see competitive races for all the parties. If the NDP hope to form government they will have to perform very well in British Columbia.

The North

With only three ridings it is difficult to generalize for the North. Incumbency will help a great deal, but given the comparatively small size of the electorate the swing of a few thousand votes can completely upend the election. The Conservatives are aggressively seeking to take the Northwest Territories riding from incumbent Dennis Bevington of the NDP, but Conservatives have to watch out in Nunavut and Yukon as their own incumbents fend off the Liberals, NDP and Greens. If the Liberals begin gaining momentum they might sweep the North completely.

What's Next?

I was going to discuss possible outcomes but this post is already long. Right now parties are scrambling to complete their nomination process for candidates. Given that this election was foreseen for a long time many ridings already have candidates. The Conservatives have nominated 294/338, NDP 263/338, Liberals 303/338, Greens 172/338 and the Bloc 41/78. Since the election isn't until October 19th there isn't quite the panic as if this was a 37-day campaign. My own riding's NDP association (which I am involved in) is getting ready to host our meeting.

For voters I would recommend checking to see if you're registered to vote in the election. After doing that you may want to find out your riding. Other than that voters can afford to enjoy a little more of the summer before the election takes shape. Keep reading here for more information!



Tuesday, May 19, 2015

The Next Federal Debate

Out of nowhere it appears we're about to change how debates are conducted in this country. If I understand the timeline of events correctly the Conservatives rejected the debates hosted by the Media Consortium in favour of up to five debates put on by any organization who wishes to coordinate them. Federal Leaders' debates are problematic in this country. Consider the fact that in this country we are lucky to get two debates (one in English, one in French) compared to the United States where candidates for president are expected to debate endlessly for the nomination and an independent commission structures, I believe, three debates during the final weeks of the campaign.

The scene at the last federal debate.
An independent commission is likely the model Canada should be moving towards. The eleventh hour negotiations gives way too much leverage to the governing party, or the party in first place. Rules should be set months, or perhaps years in advance so that everyone goes into it fairly. Add in the question of who should be allowed to participate at all and you raise all sorts of other problems.

The move by Prime Minister Harper to make changes to the debates is not at all surprising. Susan Delacourt does a pretty fantastic job laying out why Harper would like to see changes.

The people I have spoken to about this expressed some cautious optimism, but I have my concerns. As Delacourt writes the Conservatives want the debates to be held in the summer, months before the election is to be officially called with a great deal of time for the public memory to fade if Harper comes across poorly. A bump in the polls for Mulcair, Trudeau or May would long vanish when the leaves fall from the trees and Canadians start to seriously make up their minds.

This approach raises real questions. Will the parties try to insist on networks and moderators that would be more friendly to them? What concessions might be demanded? Getting away from the Consortium's debates might be for the best but launching into this uncertain future is not exactly encouraging. So far two debates seem approved, one by Maclean's and Rogers and another by Quebec's TVA.

This causes me to wonder about the local debates. Remember that Canada won't have one election in October but 338. I seem to recall that debates were somewhat frequent in my former riding as community organizations all put forward their own 'meet the candidates/debate' events. By the end of it the candidates knew each other quite well. It was even collegial despite the fact they often disagreed profoundly. That's not always the case. MPs in safe ridings have little incentive to be berated. Local media and community groups should be considering their own approach to their own local debates and how they might be improved as the election nears.

Debates are not the be all and end all. The ability to give a witty retort reveals very little about who has the best policies, ideas and temperament. That said it gives the candidates a chance to stand equally before the public and be seen. That alone is important. The challenge is to make that valuable.

Tuesday, May 12, 2015

Post-Mortem on the 2015 Alberta Election

There is no doubt that the results of the Alberta election were a stunning upset. Four decades of Progressive Conservative Association rule was brought to a screeching end. I'll do my best to summarize my thoughts on this in a succinct manner.

2015 Election Results, Wikipedia
The Alberta NDP's victory last week was massive and unprecedented. It was the first win like that by a left-wing party in the province's history. On the other hand commentators have noted that it is not entirely dissimilar to the landslide victories that ushered in the rule of Social Credit or the PCs. However this isn't quite the case. The Alberta NDP won a much narrower victory than the PCs or Social Credit Party did when they took power in 1971 and 1935 respectively. The NDP took 40.6% of the popular vote and won 53 of 87 seats. As a person who consistently advocates for electoral reform I should point out that the majority won is as distorted as those when  by most governments in the First-Past-the-Post system.

Something I've heard quite a bit is whether or not this means there has been a sea change in Alberta politics. I would counter by saying that Alberta is not as conservative as people think it is. Edmonton and Calgary have grown tremendously over the last twenty years. The political differences between the major cities and the rest of the province are asserting themselves more and more. Three politicians embody the leftward drift of the Alberta electorate: Naheed Nenshi, Don Iveson and Allison Redford. Nenshi, perhaps the most popular mayor in Canada, is an urban progressive. He may not hew to a left-wing ideology but his politics appear that way. I'll put it this way, Stephen Harper and Nenshi are both from Calgary but they are very different politicians. Iveson is considered by some Alberta commentators to be bringing a Nenshi-style approach to Edmonton. Allison Redford, the disgraced former Premier, was seen as more of a liberal than a conservative. She made frequent trips to Ontario and the space between her and premiers like Kathleen Wynne was not seen to be that great. Governing parties like the PCs tend to move into the centre, and Redford was arguably on the left-side of the party. Jim Prentice was a return to a more conservative PCAA.

Regardless, those three politicians symbolize the Alberta was not the same province that many hold in their imaginations. It should be remembered that our electoral system distorts our vision of Alberta. Before the provincial election there was speculation that the Liberals and NDP might pick up some seats federally. In the previous provincial election the NDP and Liberals both performed well. The overall point is that things were shifting much earlier than just in this campaign.

Two parties seem in deep trouble: the Alberta Liberals and the PCs. They will have a difficult time recovering from the setbacks in this election. Despite the dirges sang for the PCs I think it is the Liberals who are in greater trouble. The Wild Rose on the other hand have reach their historic best despite a bad few months. We could be looking at a three party system in Alberta for a time - NDP, Wild Rose and PCs.

How will this affect the federal election? The answer is probably not much, sadly. Remember that political parties in this country are also highly regional. The Conservatives will continue to do well in the West for some time, especially while its leader hails from there. As I wrote about last week the Alberta electorate was looking for a capable alternative to the Prentice PCs and found it in Rachel Notley. In Alberta both Justin Trudeau and Tom Mulcair will likely stand as reasonable alternative and so it is unlikely to coalesce behind one opposition. Add in a critical factor, the right was divided in Alberta between the Wild Rose and PCs. This will not be repeated federally.

There is a possibility that the NDP will be able to convert local strength, activists and candidates to their cause and start from a much stronger base. If the NDP are lucky the provincial government will remain popular and rub off on them in a positive fashion. But it is not a one-to-one relationship. The Ontario NDP wanted to ride the federal successes just six months after and fell well short in 2011. An advantage may be that the Conservative Party may feel pressured to defend some Alberta seats more if they appear to be in play. That's money and resources not going to other battleground ridings. The provincial Liberal Party appears to be on the verge of crisis. This will be unlikely to dramatically affect their federal cousins, but it certainly is no help.

Finally, a great deal of comparison was made between Rachel Notley, premier-elect of Alberta, and Bob Rae, Ontario's former NDP premier. I think this is a false comparison. Notley does face substantial economic headwinds, but her premiership starts off much more like Ontario Premier David Peterson. Peterson ended the four decade rule of the Big Blue Machine and helped to modernize Ontario politics. It also ended one-party rule and start the three-party competition that Ontario has had since. I am hoping Alberta walks that path. Peterson's government was responsible for critical reforms in the 1980s in Ontario and ushered in a more representative government. I hope Notley does the same, with greater political success.


So ends a dynasty, but dynasties are bad for democracy. Choice, competition and power divorced from one single political party does a long way to stimulate the democratic process. The long-term consequences won't be known until the next provincial election (and the five after it), but it certainly going to be interesting to watch. 

Tuesday, February 17, 2015

Prelude to the Election - Nominations

For all intents and purposes the country is already in the midst of an election campaign. Despite the fact that the election is still months away from being called it is very clear from the behaviour of the party leaders that that is merely the last formality. If memory serves the Prime Minister recently made an important announcement regarding security, which for the record sounded exactly like a stump speech, not in Parliament, but in York Region, north of Toronto. This so happens to be a critical area for the Conservative Party to hold if it hopes to maintain power. Similarly Tom Mulcair (NDP – Outremont, QC) has been crossing the nation trying to build goodwill. I have seen more than a few pictures of the Leader of the Opposition behind counters, wearing aprons and meeting people in normal settings.

Generally, more quietly, has been the steady nomination of candidates around the country. I have recommended this resource many times before, but once again I wish to highlight the excellent work Alice Funke is doing in collating all of this information at her website, link here.

Here’s an interesting point. The Conservative have nominated 202 candidates so far, of which only 37 are women for a percentage share of 18.3%. For the Conservatives to have approximately 50% of the candidates be women they would have to nominate 95 women in the remaining 134 seats they have left available. The Liberals lead in nominations with 203 candidates, of which 33.5% are women. The NDP have nominated 133 candidates and are doing the best with 41.4% of their candidates being women. Obviously there are many metrics to see how representative a slate of candidates are, but gender is a quick and easy one at a first glance.

The redrawing of riding districts will make for a very different campaign. There are a growing number of open seats where no incumbent, or a sitting MP will be contesting. While incumbency is less powerful in Canada than say the United States it remains a factor in the benefit of the MP. There are about 50 seats that are open, roughly one in seven in the country. Much of the parties’ resources will be dedicated to winning these contests.

Nomination contests are also interesting moments inside political parties that the public rarely gets a view of. There are two types of contests for a nomination: acclaimed and uncontested. Both have positive and negative implications for the party. Acclamations occur when only one candidate seeks the nomination to run for the party. While every situation is different it could be because the incumbent or another strong candidate is running and therefore scares off competition. Perhaps influential people lean on challengers and they withdraw from the race. Another possibility is that the person has volunteered to be the sacrificial lamb. In politics we rarely discuss the candidates who stand no chance but wave the banner anyway. They are needed and they are valuable, but the prestige of winning 10% or less of the vote is not so wonderful. A high number of acclamations may suggest that the party I unable to naturally attract fresh blood and talent or that too much pressure is being applied in some way.

Contested nominations can be signs of a healthy, vibrant party. Many candidates fighting for the right to run for the party in the election suggests not only are they engaged, but they believe they can win. However, these divisions can be fractious and spawn deep resentments within the party locally, regionally or nationally. The Liberals have suffered badly from this leading up to the 2015 election as time and time again it appears meddling from the central party is skewing nominations. The most grievous and recent example is the recruitment of Eve Adams (LPC – Mississauga-Brampton South) to the party and the effort to parachute her into the Eglinton-Lawrence riding.

It seems likely by the end of the summer the parties will have selected around 300 of their candidates to go into the election in October. I poured over the information for the ridings in around my old ridings in Ontario and found it interesting to see who it was throwing their hats in the ring to become our next class of parliamentarians. For those interested there is plenty of time to get involved and help pick, or even to be one of these candidates.

Tuesday, November 18, 2014

The Revival of Government Propaganda

“Canada’s Economic Action Plan”. That is probably a familiar phrase to Canadians across the country. However identifying what the Economic Action Plan actually is is a more difficult task. The slogan has been assigned to the federal budgets over the past few years and so basically everything the federal government has done since the “program’s” inception has been part of it. More narrowly it has been used to label infrastructure projects and various funds to support... something. I trail off there because the Economic Action Plan is often more about the appearance of action than real results. Take for example the promises of trades’ education. The last time I spoke to someone in the field the promises of support result in nothing in reality. Yet the ads continued to play hyping programs that support training that essentially do not exist.

The millions of dollars spent on the Economic Action Plan ads have far more to do with comforting the public that the government is combating the recession than actually providing information or creating programs. As outrageous as the advertising is, and skewed to show the federal government in a positive light, it has become part of the norm of Canadian political life for the last few years. 

Lately though it appears the federal government under Prime Minister Stephen Harper (CPC – Calgary Southwest, AB) is preparing to set the groundwork for the next election through public funds to support his party. The first advertisement is from Health Canada offering dramatic and frankly frightening consequences of marijuana use on children. The ad is unprecedented as far as I am aware and its arrival is clearly targeted at Justin Trudeau (LPC – Papineau, QC) and his party’s support for the legalization of marijuana. The Conservatives have run ads attacking Trudeau’s position and often uses his position as a talking point. Using public funds to clearly attack the policy of a rival is wrong and an abuse of power.

Yesterday, however, I saw the new Economic Action Plan ad touting tax cuts. Why do tax cuts require advertising? The simple truth is they do not. Most will happen automatically so it's not as though Canadians need to be prompted to apply for them. This is an effort to celebrate the government and boost its popularity. It damages the non-partisan nature of the Canadian government itself and further deteriorates the health of our democracy.

Propaganda has always been part of politics, but there were certain understandings about what was and was not proper. I think most people would suggest that if the government of the day has not crossed the ethical line then they have blurred it significantly. This isn’t the government advertising tourism, or a public health campaign, or some other justifiable plan, it is a celebration of government policy. These are increasingly partisan ads. They may not violate any laws but they violate the spirit of our system of government.

For further reading on this I strongly recommend John Ivison’s piece on this. 

Tuesday, August 26, 2014

How Harper Might Win in 2015

In the continuing strangeness in my life in Fort Smith I had the opportunity to meet Prime Minister Stephen Harper on Friday. As part of the Prime Minister’s annual “Northern Tour” he visited Fort Smith to make a funding announcement to support an agricultural program. Farming used to be more widespread in the Northwest Territories. I’m sure at one point every household had their own garden, much like they did in Newfoundland. However, I assume, the advent of more efficient transportation and cooling made groceries more accessible.

However, I am not particularly interested in speaking to the government’s announcement on northern agriculture. I cannot speak to anything I did in my capacity at work, the agreement, signed by my employer and I, forbids that, so I must curtail my comments about Mr. Harper’s visit.

In the evening I attended an event put on by the Conservative Party’s local riding association. For the record, not so long ago I was sitting on the riding association for the NDP, and I paid no money to the Conservative Party to attend. I was invited by friends and so I attended.

At the event the Prime Minister began to lay out his 2015 election plan. He trumpeted the work his party has done in government (however dubiously) and castigated the Liberals and NDP as poorer alternatives. In a crowd of people who probably reasonably represent the undecided/neutral voters and Conservative-leaning it suddenly became all the more apparent to me that it is possible that Mr. Harper may return his party to Ottawa with a majority after the next election.

I will not lay out the Prime Minister’s case for him because we will get enough of that in the weeks and months ahead. It is an argument built upon a few key pillars, but these pillars, I believe, will resonate with a significant number of Canadians.

The obvious first plank is the economy. Plenty of economists will say that the Government of Canada and the Conservatives oversell the health of the economy. More importantly than the truth of the matter and whether or not the benefits of the slow growth is reaching everyone, the Conservatives can sell easy to understand policies and a positive message; lower taxes, a balanced budget while providing new programs and funding. While the opposition tells a tale of doom and gloom the Conservatives get to champion the strongest middle class in the world. Justin Ling, a journalist at Loonie Politics, recently commented on this divide. Life for middle-class Canadians is fairly good, so criticism by the opposition could ring hollow.

The second pillar sort of fits under the title “Commonsense”. This one word accomplishes a lot. First, it suggests that the alternative approaches are somehow empty-headed, poorly conceived or theoretical. Second, it moves even the more radical policies of the Conservatives into the centre. Commonsense cannot be radical, it’s where rational people come to their conclusion. During his speech Mr. Harper alluded to several ways this might be employed. The deficit – certain, “commonsense” cuts were needed to get Canadians value for their money. Crime – a “commonsense” approach that puts the victim first. The opposition is marginalized for their “fringe” opinions, and Mr. Trudeau or Mr. Mulcair’s missteps fit this narrative, i.e. the budget will balance itself.

Finally, the Conservatives will offer a stick. “We live in a dangerous world”. We’ll probably hear that phrase a lot and it will encompass both the geopolitical instability that Canadians worry about and the Conservatives blunt foreign policy addresses, along with the continued economic instability. The risk of changing governments, for switching to either an untested party (NDP) or untested leader (Justin Trudeau) will give many Canadians pause, perhaps enough pause to return the Conservatives to power.


The election is about a year away, and there’s no way to predict the outcome. Friends of mine on the left hope that Stephen Harper will be retired from public life... but I am increasingly unsure of that possibility. Between a divided opposition and the arguments I made above enough Canadians may trust the devil they know. 

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Pushing Boundaries – Seat Redistribution


The Ontario Federal Elections Boundary Commission has released a revised report of its proposed boundaries for the next Canadian election. Hearings will take place in the House of Commons on the new boundaries. I sincerely doubt that these MPs will have a substantial impact on the future ridings. It would look problematic if MPs intervened and succeeded in changing the boundaries arrived at after extensive public consultations. The media consensus seems to be these will be the boundaries.

The Commission’s report is available here, but I can summarize some of the major points. Ontario has been allocated 121 seats in the next Parliament, which is an increase of 15. These fifteen seats were distributed to areas that have experienced population growth and require new districts to account for the growing population. Many ridings in rural Ontario have remained essentially unchanged. The Commission took a regional approach to adding seats: Brampton received two new seats, as did Durham, Markham, and Toronto while Mississauga, Cambridge, Hamilton, Oakville, Ottawa, Simcoe and York each received one.

The ridings around the GTHA (Greater Toronto-Hamilton Area) have seen significant changes where population growth has been the greatest. The three new ridings in Peel will significantly shift the political landscape. Areas of Toronto saw a major redesign of its political boundaries. In particular the region in the downtown with the major condominium development has a new riding that has broken apart Trinity-Spadina.

Proposed Federal Boundaries for Brampton and Mississauga

This is the map of the latest proposal for Brampton and Mississauga. Other maps are available here. The major difference here compared to the original proposal from last year is the removal of Malton from the easternmost Brampton riding. Currently Bramalea-Gore-Malton includes Malton and the old Gore region of Brampton, along with parts of Bramalea. In the new map Brampton East will only include Brampton territory. Brampton-Springdale and Brampton South-Mississauga are gone and instead they have been replaced by Brampton Centre and Brampton North. In my riding, Brampton West, the riding has been split in half along Queen Street for the most part. Brampton West now consists of Brampton north of downtown and north of Queen Street and the new riding of Brampton South is the southwestern quadrant of the city.

Overall I am quite happy with the Brampton map. Compared to the initial map put forward this one is much better. In previous posts I’ve emphasized the importance of voter equality: each riding should have as equal a population as possible. The new Brampton ridings are very close to the provincial quota of 106,000. This won’t be true for long, but at least the Commission got that part right. During the public event I attended there seemed to be two big issues: the inclusion of Malton within Brampton and splitting downtown into three ridings. Excluding Malton freed the Commission to redraw the lines to put all of downtown in one riding. It was a simple and effective fix.

Sadly, this came at a cost. The ridings in Mississauga are badly overpopulated now. Each one is at least 10% over quota. The largest, Mississauga East-Cooksville is 14.67% over quota. This Commission did not make voter equality a fundamental point and therefore the result are ridings that vary in population size from Algoma-Manitoulin-Kapuskasing with 79,801 people (-24.87%) to Brant with 132,443 (+24.70%).

Given the changes in political geography people have began to scrutinize the new maps to discover the potential impact on the next federal election. The best breakdown I’ve seen so far comes from a group called Poll Maps. At that link you can take a look at the party breakdown if an election was held today in that area with the voting results from 2011 or 2008. In summary, if in 2011 the Conservatives, NDP, Liberals, Green and Bloc get the exact same number of votes in the exact same places there result would be 189 seats for the Conservatives, 108 for the NDP, 36 for the Liberals, 4 for the Bloc and 1 for the Greens. I have read panicked commentary that this means the Conservatives are guaranteed to win the next election. The CPC won in 2011 because they won swings ridings in the suburbs and the suburbs received most of the new seats. If you ran the 2004 elections numbers it would look good for the Liberals. The voting will change, it is inevitable. The system is not rigged.

Now a more painful process begins. The political parties and local activists will have to build up new organizations and memberships to get ready to fight the next campaign. For sitting MPs they will have to pick where they want to run, which may lead to tough nomination fights, or incumbents running against each other.

Finally, we have to do this process on a provincial level. The Ontario seats are badly out of alignment with each other. As I said, my riding, Brampton West, is so big that it was split in two. However, provincially there is no plan to address this imbalance. With a minority government I fear that not much will be done in the near future, but pressure should be applied to address this problem.