Showing posts with label Alberta Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alberta Politics. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 26, 2015

Young Politicians and Social Media Baggage

It is unlikely that many people know the name Deborah Drever. She was recently elected to be the MLA for Calgary-Bow for the NDP. However a string of discoveries on her social media accounts gained media attention which embarrassed the party. After a photo came to light that contained a homophobic slur the party moved to suspend Drever from the caucus. 

To be clear I do not intend to defend Ms. Drever. What I will say is that the 26-year-old MLA is being judged for photos from when she was 19-years-old in some cases. Some of them are far more recent and the frivolity of youth provides limited cover to her statements. I am only one year older than Ms. Drever and as a person who has participated in politics and thought about a career in the partisan side of government I have often feared what comments I have made on Twitter or Facebook or elsewhere on the internet that can come back to haunt me. I can easily recall things I've said in jest that out of context would be humiliating for a public figure.

Deborah Drever is not an outlier but an omen. We have had politicians behaving badly on social media before, that's not new, what is new is a younger person who has spent years on social media being asked to account for comments they made well before they entered the public sphere. It seems to me that this is a question that our political culture is going to have to increasingly wrestle with because there will soon come a time when all politicians have this sort of baggage.

It reminds me a bit of the episode of The West Wing, The Supremes, when they have to nominate a Supreme Court justice but anyone with controversial decisions has to be nixed from contention. That is until they figure out how to put Donna's parents' cats on the bench. This is a tangent... The point is that people live their lives on social media and to our great misfortune privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to preserve, especially for those who wish to engage in the political discourse. I've heard it said that social media has basically transformed everyone into a public figure to greater or lesser degree.

On a somewhat related note I heard a tidbit from the UK election that had me wondering. From the BBC I heard that every MP elected under the age of 30 was a member of a political family. To me this raised real questions about whether or not there was room for young Members of Parliament outside of nepotism. The NDP has trumpeted successful elections of younger candidates in 2011 federally and in Alberta this May but that came during a wave. Would these young men and women have even been considered for this opportunity if they were not perceived to be such long shots?

I would hope that in coming years we will be respectful to candidates and barring seriously controversial material we can ignore the things that are a little more embarrassing to drag out in the public eye. However, I would say that things such as blog posts or essays written by politicians could be fodder for questioning. Dissecting someone's character from 140 characters seems far less valuable.

What worries me is that this is a simple story for partisans to find and journalists to report. Instead we are more likely to humiliate those who come forward into public life, which again raises questions about how will we engage the next generation to become leaders and take on positions of authority within our communities.




Tuesday, May 12, 2015

Post-Mortem on the 2015 Alberta Election

There is no doubt that the results of the Alberta election were a stunning upset. Four decades of Progressive Conservative Association rule was brought to a screeching end. I'll do my best to summarize my thoughts on this in a succinct manner.

2015 Election Results, Wikipedia
The Alberta NDP's victory last week was massive and unprecedented. It was the first win like that by a left-wing party in the province's history. On the other hand commentators have noted that it is not entirely dissimilar to the landslide victories that ushered in the rule of Social Credit or the PCs. However this isn't quite the case. The Alberta NDP won a much narrower victory than the PCs or Social Credit Party did when they took power in 1971 and 1935 respectively. The NDP took 40.6% of the popular vote and won 53 of 87 seats. As a person who consistently advocates for electoral reform I should point out that the majority won is as distorted as those when  by most governments in the First-Past-the-Post system.

Something I've heard quite a bit is whether or not this means there has been a sea change in Alberta politics. I would counter by saying that Alberta is not as conservative as people think it is. Edmonton and Calgary have grown tremendously over the last twenty years. The political differences between the major cities and the rest of the province are asserting themselves more and more. Three politicians embody the leftward drift of the Alberta electorate: Naheed Nenshi, Don Iveson and Allison Redford. Nenshi, perhaps the most popular mayor in Canada, is an urban progressive. He may not hew to a left-wing ideology but his politics appear that way. I'll put it this way, Stephen Harper and Nenshi are both from Calgary but they are very different politicians. Iveson is considered by some Alberta commentators to be bringing a Nenshi-style approach to Edmonton. Allison Redford, the disgraced former Premier, was seen as more of a liberal than a conservative. She made frequent trips to Ontario and the space between her and premiers like Kathleen Wynne was not seen to be that great. Governing parties like the PCs tend to move into the centre, and Redford was arguably on the left-side of the party. Jim Prentice was a return to a more conservative PCAA.

Regardless, those three politicians symbolize the Alberta was not the same province that many hold in their imaginations. It should be remembered that our electoral system distorts our vision of Alberta. Before the provincial election there was speculation that the Liberals and NDP might pick up some seats federally. In the previous provincial election the NDP and Liberals both performed well. The overall point is that things were shifting much earlier than just in this campaign.

Two parties seem in deep trouble: the Alberta Liberals and the PCs. They will have a difficult time recovering from the setbacks in this election. Despite the dirges sang for the PCs I think it is the Liberals who are in greater trouble. The Wild Rose on the other hand have reach their historic best despite a bad few months. We could be looking at a three party system in Alberta for a time - NDP, Wild Rose and PCs.

How will this affect the federal election? The answer is probably not much, sadly. Remember that political parties in this country are also highly regional. The Conservatives will continue to do well in the West for some time, especially while its leader hails from there. As I wrote about last week the Alberta electorate was looking for a capable alternative to the Prentice PCs and found it in Rachel Notley. In Alberta both Justin Trudeau and Tom Mulcair will likely stand as reasonable alternative and so it is unlikely to coalesce behind one opposition. Add in a critical factor, the right was divided in Alberta between the Wild Rose and PCs. This will not be repeated federally.

There is a possibility that the NDP will be able to convert local strength, activists and candidates to their cause and start from a much stronger base. If the NDP are lucky the provincial government will remain popular and rub off on them in a positive fashion. But it is not a one-to-one relationship. The Ontario NDP wanted to ride the federal successes just six months after and fell well short in 2011. An advantage may be that the Conservative Party may feel pressured to defend some Alberta seats more if they appear to be in play. That's money and resources not going to other battleground ridings. The provincial Liberal Party appears to be on the verge of crisis. This will be unlikely to dramatically affect their federal cousins, but it certainly is no help.

Finally, a great deal of comparison was made between Rachel Notley, premier-elect of Alberta, and Bob Rae, Ontario's former NDP premier. I think this is a false comparison. Notley does face substantial economic headwinds, but her premiership starts off much more like Ontario Premier David Peterson. Peterson ended the four decade rule of the Big Blue Machine and helped to modernize Ontario politics. It also ended one-party rule and start the three-party competition that Ontario has had since. I am hoping Alberta walks that path. Peterson's government was responsible for critical reforms in the 1980s in Ontario and ushered in a more representative government. I hope Notley does the same, with greater political success.


So ends a dynasty, but dynasties are bad for democracy. Choice, competition and power divorced from one single political party does a long way to stimulate the democratic process. The long-term consequences won't be known until the next provincial election (and the five after it), but it certainly going to be interesting to watch. 

Tuesday, May 5, 2015

The Public, the Partisans and the Press

Yesterday Prince Edward Island held a provincial election. The Liberals will remain the government but there were a few interesting changes. The Greens won a seat and the Liberals lost several seats to the Progressive Conservatives. Despite performing well the NDP failed to win any seats this time. Today Albertans will cast their ballots to choose MLAs in their own election. Some of the coverage I've read and listened to had me thinking about election coverage.

The most shocking thing about the Alberta election is that polls indicate that the NDP are surging and may form government. All the caveats that polls are polls should be kept in mind, but it shapes the conversation, especially for the media and media shape the conversation for the public. The trouble is that the press and the partisans they talk to see elections very differently than the public who ultimately decides them.

I will be forced here to speak in generalities because it is not as though I have done specific research to back my observations. With that disclaimer in place I think it is fair to say that partisans (supporters of particular political parties) see things through ideology. Because they are interested in politics they develop a set of values and beliefs and attach themselves to political parties that closely align. There are, for a lack of a better term, tribal partisans for whom the ideology may be incidental to their support of the red or blue or purple team. This level of dedication is how partisans can stay committed to a party even when the values of those parties change. In the mind of ideologues the parties are nicely arrange on a spectrum with camps of voters who move between the parties left or right.

To write stories and gain understanding journalists talk to partisans (ex. political operatives, campaign managers, strategists, candidates, activists, etc.) about the political dynamics inside the city/province/country. As a result the view of the political world that we get is one shaped by the partisan perspective. This is fundamentally flawed.

Both the media and the parties have an assumed classic liberal disposition towards how our democracy works. That means that voters are rational actors who weigh the policies, experience and character of politicians and make informed decision, along with whatever values match their own. It is an ideal that was espoused by the American Founders and democratic theorists now for centuries and one that I fear bears little resemblance to reality in mass democracies.

The assumptions of partisans (and therefore the press) is that there cannot be such a thing as a Wild Rose-NDP swing voter, or PC-Green, which obviously does exist. The truth is that unfortunately politics is driven much more by personality than one might initially suppose. I think American presidential elections really prove this point. How is it that there were voters who would support Hillary Clinton but not Barack Obama if he were the Democratic candidate for president? They were members of the same party and had essentially the same platform but within the public mindset their differences made it so Barack Obama would struggle in the general election where Clinton may have sailed by easily. In 2000 it was summarized by "Who would you rather have a beer with?" This in general better reflected the public's mood. The move in politics in recent years acknowledges this, such as in Issenberg's Victory Lab book.

Coming to Alberta. How is it "conservative" Alberta might elect a NDP majority government tonight (not likely but a possibility)? Albertans are frustrated by the ruling party and Premier Jim Prentice. Naturally Albertans cast their eyes to the alternatives. Brian Jean is unsteady and new in his role as leader of the Wild Rose. David Swann, leader of the Alberta Liberal Party, has been somewhat of a dud in the election and his party has never gotten off the ground. Rachel Notley has been a credible alternative with a family name in politics and by all accounts has presented herself and her party well. Voters don't see things in the harsh black and white lines that partisans, and by extension the media, do.

Personality matters. Values trump policy. The gut feeling of a voter on who they 'like' can do more good than any number of debates or talking points or TV ads. Alberta and PEI's elections could be valuable case studies as we move towards the autumn federal election.

Happy Election Day, Alberta, make good choices.


Tuesday, March 10, 2015

Alberta's Looking Glass

Last week Premier Jim Prentice (PCAA - Calgary-Foothills) found himself in trouble for saying the following when asked about the provincial deficit:



"In terms of who is responsible, we all need only look in the mirror, right. Basically all of us have had the best of everything and have not had to pay for what it costs."

Mr. Prentice's political opponents have used this statement to great effect and it also triggered a dramatic response on social media. 

The backlash is understandable for sure. Alberta's budget woes has nothing to do with spending problems, as far as I can tell. It is common to hear progressives to say tax levels are insufficient, but in the case of Alberta that is quite true. Alberta has no sales tax and the lowest corporate tax in the country. Alberta has used its natural resource wealth to subsidize its entire government. Now and previously in 2008, and several times before, a sudden drop in the price of oil threatens the province's books.

Conservative or right-wing governments respond to these crises by slashing public spending as a solution to the deficit. However anyone with basic knowledge of the province's history can tell you that Alberta suffers from instability in revenues not instability in spending. Analysts have frequently called for Alberta to adopt a Norwegian model to manage its natural resources and to divert royalties from natural resources to accumulate wealth for the entire province for generations to come. Instead Alberta uses its wealth to top up revenue.

Politicians have proposed in Alberta at many different points in the past that the introduction of a sales tax would help level out the economy and stabilize revenue. Even if you do not agree that sales taxes should be instated in Alberta the question of which revenues to raise will inevitably come up. In a sense this is what Jim Prentice was right about. If Albertans want to blame someone for the current financial situation they have to at least acknowledge that their own political culture has played a significant role. The sales tax and tax increases in general have been the third rail of Alberta politics for a long time. That isn't just made up by politicians but it is shaped by the opinion of the public at large. The public ultimately holds government to account, if some want to place the Progressive Conservatives' mismanagement then some blame belongs to the people who have kept them in power for over forty years.

Given the boom-bust nature of resource revenues it would only make sense to my mind for provincial (and national) governments to set their budgets to balance without accounting for any money from them. Let those revenues accumulate in heritage funds to be reinvested into projects with long-term benefits, or take the interest for government spending.

Budget and service cuts often fall on the most vulnerable, it seems unconscionable in a wealthy place like Alberta that they should bear the brunt of the pain when the Alberta economy could easily handle higher taxes. The question is whether or not Albertans want to make a change for longer term fiscal stability, or continue with their low tax unpredictability.




Tuesday, January 27, 2015

Serving the Public, Opposing the Government

The Leader of the Opposition is perhaps the most difficult job in Canadian politics. It comes with a great deal of political responsibility but very little actual power. Perhaps when best able to influence government policy, when the government is in minority, there is tremendous pressure not to give an inch to the governing party in efforts to make things difficult. Not to mention in those instances every move is about just building enough support to get to government.

It's a thankless job, but the good ones report to their post and grill the government, propose alternatives, work constructively and manage their parties in a way to remain coherent enough to present a united front on different issues and a government-in-waiting. In fact, the aspect of being the government-in-waiting is often overlooked as the constitutional convention where the Governor General or Lieutenant Generals may call upon the Leader of the Opposition to form government when confidence is lost. This convention ensures stability and continuity. If the new government fails to gain confidence of the house an election is called. Enter Alberta.

In the past few months Jim Prentice (PCAA - Calgary-Foothills) has become leader of the Progressive Conservative Association of Alberta and Premier of Alberta. He oversaw a resurgence of the flailing party while weathering the attacks of Danielle Smith (PCAA - Highwood) then leader of the Wildrose Party, until December 17th, 2014. On that day Ms. Smith and eight MLAs of the Wildrose Party crossed the floor to join the government. Outside of a time of war I cannot imagine any possible time in Westminster history that a Leader of the Opposition joined the government.

When I heard this story I was conflicted on how I felt. On the one hand our system of government gives parliamentarians a great deal of discretion in determining who they align themselves with and who sits as government. Crossing the floor, changing parties and forming new ones is part of how parliament should work. On the other hand it is easy to see how Smith's move was a craven, crass bid for political power.

However, it was the news today that had me stunned about the state of Alberta's Loyal Opposition. Raj Sherman (ALP - Edmonton-Meadowlark), leader of the Alberta Liberal Party announced his sudden resignation as leader of the Liberal Party and Opposition. According to the story I read in the Edmonton Journal Sherman resigned for personal reasons, and I do not fault a man for leaving public life to deal with personal matters, but the impact must be considered.

Where does that leave Alberta? With an estimated two months until the next provincial Liberals the second and third place parties appear as though they will not have permanent leaders. The New Democrats are also under a new leader, Rachel Notley (ANDP - Edmonton Strathcona). 

The people of Alberta deserve an effective and strong opposition, especially because of the single-party nature of the province's politics. The PCAA has been in power since 1971 and appears poised to be re-elected this spring. Albertans deserve a strongly articulated alternative vision and a their government would be greatly improved if one party was not so closely tied to government. However, I fear that Albertans will not get that option in 2015. The Leader of the Opposition is a key component in our system and it has been far too neglected in Alberta to the detriment of the public life that province. Hopefully politically engaged Albertans can stand up and present multiple perspectives to reflect its dynamic and changing nature.