Showing posts with label Polling. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Polling. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 5, 2015

The Public, the Partisans and the Press

Yesterday Prince Edward Island held a provincial election. The Liberals will remain the government but there were a few interesting changes. The Greens won a seat and the Liberals lost several seats to the Progressive Conservatives. Despite performing well the NDP failed to win any seats this time. Today Albertans will cast their ballots to choose MLAs in their own election. Some of the coverage I've read and listened to had me thinking about election coverage.

The most shocking thing about the Alberta election is that polls indicate that the NDP are surging and may form government. All the caveats that polls are polls should be kept in mind, but it shapes the conversation, especially for the media and media shape the conversation for the public. The trouble is that the press and the partisans they talk to see elections very differently than the public who ultimately decides them.

I will be forced here to speak in generalities because it is not as though I have done specific research to back my observations. With that disclaimer in place I think it is fair to say that partisans (supporters of particular political parties) see things through ideology. Because they are interested in politics they develop a set of values and beliefs and attach themselves to political parties that closely align. There are, for a lack of a better term, tribal partisans for whom the ideology may be incidental to their support of the red or blue or purple team. This level of dedication is how partisans can stay committed to a party even when the values of those parties change. In the mind of ideologues the parties are nicely arrange on a spectrum with camps of voters who move between the parties left or right.

To write stories and gain understanding journalists talk to partisans (ex. political operatives, campaign managers, strategists, candidates, activists, etc.) about the political dynamics inside the city/province/country. As a result the view of the political world that we get is one shaped by the partisan perspective. This is fundamentally flawed.

Both the media and the parties have an assumed classic liberal disposition towards how our democracy works. That means that voters are rational actors who weigh the policies, experience and character of politicians and make informed decision, along with whatever values match their own. It is an ideal that was espoused by the American Founders and democratic theorists now for centuries and one that I fear bears little resemblance to reality in mass democracies.

The assumptions of partisans (and therefore the press) is that there cannot be such a thing as a Wild Rose-NDP swing voter, or PC-Green, which obviously does exist. The truth is that unfortunately politics is driven much more by personality than one might initially suppose. I think American presidential elections really prove this point. How is it that there were voters who would support Hillary Clinton but not Barack Obama if he were the Democratic candidate for president? They were members of the same party and had essentially the same platform but within the public mindset their differences made it so Barack Obama would struggle in the general election where Clinton may have sailed by easily. In 2000 it was summarized by "Who would you rather have a beer with?" This in general better reflected the public's mood. The move in politics in recent years acknowledges this, such as in Issenberg's Victory Lab book.

Coming to Alberta. How is it "conservative" Alberta might elect a NDP majority government tonight (not likely but a possibility)? Albertans are frustrated by the ruling party and Premier Jim Prentice. Naturally Albertans cast their eyes to the alternatives. Brian Jean is unsteady and new in his role as leader of the Wild Rose. David Swann, leader of the Alberta Liberal Party, has been somewhat of a dud in the election and his party has never gotten off the ground. Rachel Notley has been a credible alternative with a family name in politics and by all accounts has presented herself and her party well. Voters don't see things in the harsh black and white lines that partisans, and by extension the media, do.

Personality matters. Values trump policy. The gut feeling of a voter on who they 'like' can do more good than any number of debates or talking points or TV ads. Alberta and PEI's elections could be valuable case studies as we move towards the autumn federal election.

Happy Election Day, Alberta, make good choices.


Tuesday, May 21, 2013

Explaining B.C.’s Election



There is much understandable handwringing over the recent British Columbia provincial election, which resulted in a shocking upset. The Liberals, long forecasted to be politically dead, won government with a strong majority. What is even stranger about the result is that for months the NDP had a strong, stable lead.

How do we explain this sudden change in fortunes?

Explanation 1 – Polling is broken

Eric Grénier of 308 Blog argued that there is no reason this should have been called incorrectly by the polling industry. There have been some other recent upsets, such as the Quebec provincial election and (especially) the Alberta provincial election. However, Grénier says there is no excuse in the B.C. case. Pollsters were trying to model for parties that previously never existed. Both the CAQ and Wildrose were new and therefore projecting their support proved difficult. In British Columbia the Liberals and NDP have been fighting it out for decades, and the 2013 election does not look so different from the 2009 election.

There is some concern about the methodologies being used. Internet panels seem increasingly suspect in the face of these recent elections. The tried and tested method of calling with live questioners seems to be the most effective way of measuring the electorate.

Explanation 2 – Low turnout

Low turnout does strange things to elections. Parties with the strongest, most motivated base tend to do well in these scenarios. It appears that NDP support was soft in British Columbia leading up to election day. Who knows how many people simply stayed home rather than vote? Low participation can open space for upsets. All of a sudden the third place party that consistently pulls in 15,000 votes has enough to win the election in a particular riding. This phenomenon is best seen in by-elections. Look at the most recent ones in Calgary Centre and Victoria. The Greens performed extraordinarily well, far beyond their usual number, partially due to low turnout.

Explanation 3 – Parties matter

I believe the best explanation for how the B.C. Liberals did so well is found in the same explanation for why the Quebec Liberals did so well. In both cases these centre-right parties had strong, clear bases of support and the mechanics to turn out the vote. With strong support among identifiable groups these parties are able to mobilize much more easily and win the election riding by riding. Volunteers calling up supporters, driving people to the polls, and getting their voters to the polls gives them a distinct edge. Get out the vote campaigns is critical in every election, and it is arguably how every tight election is one. To win parties must push voters to the polls and not merely hope they choose to do their civic duty.

Explanation 4 – Campaigns matter

Going into the last provincial election in Ontario it looks like we would soon be governed by Premier Hudak. As the campaign went on the Progressive Conservatives bled support as voters learned more about their platform, Hudak stumbled over a few key issues, and the Liberals mounted attacks. Very few elections in Canada have ended where they began. Campaigns matter or we would not have them. People become convinced, people change their minds, people choose to vote. The post-mortem from British Columbia seems to suggest that the NDP ran a poor campaign. The focus on the positive and not responding properly to Liberal attacks merely left them weak and vulnerable.

I think the four above explanations can help us watch the next election; don’t worry about polls so much, pay attention to turnout/engagement, party strength is critical and the course of a campaign is critical. All of these things were equally true before the B.C. election, but we tend to just accept the simplicity and clarity of polls and ignore everything else.