Nothing
has worried me more about the future of Ontario democracy lately than the news
that dozens of papers in the province will be shuttered. A deal between
Postmedia and Torstar will result in the closing of 38 community newspapers in Ontario. News media has been in crisis over the last couple of decades. Newsrooms and
coverage has been contracting, investigations and critical reporting shrinking.
Newspapers are hollow shells of what they once were.
The
journalism in most smaller and medium-sized cities and towns has been severely
lacking in the twenty-first century. The fourth estate is fighting a rearguard
action against irrelevancy and insolvency.
The
simple truth is that journalism, especially mass reporting, has been critical
to the healthy function of our democracy. We are less than a year away from
municipal elections, and only a few months from a provincial election. The next
elections will be much the poorer without their commentary and coverage.
As
I write this I can hear the criticism clear as day. The newspapers had a narrow
viewpoint, a small ownership base, they were/are a dying medium that failed
financially and failed to adapt to new circumstances and alternatives exist to
take their place. These, for the most part, are valid critiques. However, we
have not seen a website, Twitter account, etc. replace a newspaper and truly
fill its function. The journalism could be relied upon to be factual, even with
editorial bias.
Let's
consider some of what we have lost in these communities and others. Newspapers
during an election can be counted upon to at
leastprofile
all the candidates for office for their audience. Newspapers often organize
debates and moderate them. Perhaps most importantly they provide a platform for
candidates to communicate to the public en masse without expending great
amounts of money. I've worked on campaigns and the hardest thing is getting the
public's attention. Newspapers and local media catch a distinct audience in a
geographic audience and can serve them meaningfully and deeply.
Then
there is the usual coverage of day-to-day politics and government. How are
public institutions faring? What issues confront the community? How do changes
in laws and policies or events impact local people and organizations?
Newspapers have been failing in some of these respects, but nothing has offered
their reach, capability, or public service.
As
we move forward we risk depriving the public of objective sources of local
information. Our civic life will only be poorer in their absence until
alternative models can be arrived at.
Despite the fact that we
have seen Prime Minister Trudeau slug it out in the boxing ring it appears that
the press in general is quite content to treat him and his government with kid
gloves. I noted some reaction by media observers of the coverage of the Prime
Minister in the wake of this exchange.
A reporter begins with a
joke asking Trudeau to explain quantum computing, and then after the laughter
dies down asks a real question about the government's arms deal with Saudi
Arabia. Instead of dealing with his government's hypocritical position to sell
military hardware to a repressive regime he offered a humorous explanation of
quantum computing. It was a funny clip, but the concern is in the reaction.
The video quickly went
viral. The glee evident in headlines about the smart, sassy PM putting a
reporter in his place. Odd given that his fellow media colleagues leapt upon
him. There is a fundamental problem with the coverage of Trudeau - he's popular
and he's clickbait. For fairly simply reasons people like Trudeau and like
positive news stories about him. Media are desperate for traffic and so the
clip of him making an 'off-hand' remark is far more effective than a long essay
criticizing his government's hypocrisy vis-a-vis the Middle East.
Another wrinkle on this is
the fact that apparently Trudeau was coached on what quantum computing was and
was ready to deflect it. Much like the "It's 2015" line, it was carefully scripted and Trudeau
is talented enough to make it appear natural.
I have mixed feelings
about Stephen Lewis, but one thing that can be said for the man is that at the
NDP convention he offered a full-throated criticism of the Trudeau government
that has been far too absent in the public discourse. You can read the
transcript of his remarks here.
Where are the changes to Bill C-51? Where is the transparency of government,
long promised?
Until public perception of
Trudeau and his government shifts it is unlikely to move the public discourse
significantly. This may be a reinforcing cycle though as the public has little
criticism to glom onto, especially now that both major opposition parties are
off in the wilderness.
It was convenient timing that had me reading Shopping for Votes: How Politicians Choose
Us and We Choose Them during the 2015 federal election. Delacourt lays out
in a clear narrative how marketing and advertising has changed politics over
the course of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. There is an interesting
intersection in this book between changes in Canadian society, culture and
politics. The rise of consumerism caused all three to adapt. One would impact
upon another and force the other to change further. The introduction of basic
marketing principles gave parties a distinct edge in the 1950s and 60s, but
then as voters became cynical politics was forced to follow.
A deep dive into how politics and marketing became one.
One of the things I appreciate about this book is that it
has given me a knew lens through which to look at Canadian politics. As I
alluded to above, the cultural shift towards a distrust of institutions and
politics could be more accurately found in consumerism than politics. Prime
Minister Stephen Harper's brutal central control is rooted in his understanding
of consumer-citizen politics and what it takes to succeed in a world of brands,
slogans and value propositions.
Delacourt makes frequent reference to a certain category
of Canadians, the Tim Horton's voter. Tim Horton's successful marketing and
massive market share has made it a national symbol. It also typifies a certain
class of voter. Middle class/lower-middle class, without airs, not particularly
engaged in politics. This cohort is a significant portion of the Canadian
electorate. Swinging as much as 10% of the electorate can be the difference
between third-party and governing majority. The parties have used market
research and databases to slice and dice the electorate. They pinpoint the
voters they know are in their camp, target them, find the poachable groups and
pull them into winning coalitions.
The consumer-citizen (a concept and phrase that makes my
skin crawl) has resulted in some idiotic policy. The example that comes to mind
from Shopping for Votes is the
snowmobile tax credit. Rural outdoors-people was a target group and so the
Conservatives developed a policy directly to appeal to them. Governing is
secondary in the focus-grouped, messaged-controlled reality of the era of
consumer politics.
In her book Delacourt presents feasible explanations for
the 2011 Conservative majority and the Orange Wave in Quebec. In marketing
terms a more traditional advertising campaign launched the NDP into first in
Quebec, while modern micro-targeting brought the Conservatives to majority. At
the conclusion of the book Delacourt suggests that all three parties are now
using the same strategies. Perhaps it will merely come down who can most
effectively micro-target and mobilize voters.
The sad reality is that voters do process candidates and
parties like products in many ways. Brand loyalty and partisanship are not so
dissimilar. Commercial products have become more political as well, arguing
that they stand for sets of values and not simple products/services for profit.
The idealistic, classic liberal view of democracy is not rooted in reality,
sadly. How candidates look, sound and any number of other obscure items can
shape a voter's intention. I tease my mom because she's leaning towards voting
NDP, but doesn't like Tom Mulcair's beard. On the other hand the beard is
becoming part of the brand and being taken on by NDP partisans as a fun symbol.
I would strongly recommend this book for anyone wanting a deeper
understanding of how Canadian politics (and other modern democracies) work.
This book is similar to Sasha Issenberg's The
Victory Lab, but far more accessible and better framed in the world of
politics than the opaque worlds of academia and advertising. Check it out, and
be warned that the it might be hard swallow if you have high-minded values of
democracy.
It is unlikely that many
people know the name Deborah Drever. She was recently elected to be the MLA for
Calgary-Bow for the NDP. However a string of discoveries on her social media
accounts gained media attention which embarrassed the party. After a photo came
to light that contained a homophobic slur the party moved to suspend Drever from the caucus.
To be clear I do not
intend to defend Ms. Drever. What I will say is that the 26-year-old MLA is
being judged for photos from when she was 19-years-old in some cases. Some of
them are far more recent and the frivolity of youth provides limited cover to her
statements. I am only one year older than Ms. Drever and as a person who has
participated in politics and thought about a career in the partisan side of
government I have often feared what comments I have made on Twitter or Facebook
or elsewhere on the internet that can come back to haunt me. I can easily
recall things I've said in jest that out of context would be humiliating for a
public figure.
Deborah Drever is not an
outlier but an omen. We have had politicians behaving badly on social media
before, that's not new, what is new is a younger person who has spent years on
social media being asked to account for comments they made well before they
entered the public sphere. It seems to me that this is a question that our
political culture is going to have to increasingly wrestle with because there
will soon come a time when all politicians have this sort of baggage.
It reminds me a bit of the
episode of The West Wing, The
Supremes, when they have to nominate a Supreme Court justice but anyone with
controversial decisions has to be nixed from contention. That is until they figure
out how to put Donna's parents' cats on the bench. This is a tangent... The
point is that people live their lives on social media and to our great
misfortune privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to preserve, especially
for those who wish to engage in the political discourse. I've heard it said that
social media has basically transformed everyone into a public figure to greater
or lesser degree.
On a somewhat related note
I heard a tidbit from the UK election that had me wondering. From the BBC I
heard that every MP elected under the age of 30 was a member of a political
family. To me this raised real questions about whether or not there was room
for young Members of Parliament outside of nepotism. The NDP has trumpeted
successful elections of younger candidates in 2011 federally and in Alberta
this May but that came during a wave. Would these young men and women have even
been considered for this opportunity if they were not perceived to be such long
shots?
I would hope that in
coming years we will be respectful to candidates and barring seriously
controversial material we can ignore the things that are a little more
embarrassing to drag out in the public eye. However, I would say that things
such as blog posts or essays written by politicians could be fodder for
questioning. Dissecting someone's character from 140 characters seems far less
valuable.
What worries me is that
this is a simple story for partisans to find and journalists to report. Instead
we are more likely to humiliate those who come forward into public life, which
again raises questions about how will we engage the next generation to become
leaders and take on positions of authority within our communities.
Out of nowhere it appears
we're about to change how debates are conducted in this country. If I
understand the timeline of events correctly the Conservatives rejected the
debates hosted by the Media Consortium in favour of up to five debates put on by
any organization who wishes to coordinate them. Federal Leaders' debates are
problematic in this country. Consider the fact that in this country we are
lucky to get two debates (one in English, one in French) compared to the United
States where candidates for president are expected to debate endlessly for the
nomination and an independent commission structures, I believe, three debates
during the final weeks of the campaign.
The scene at the last federal debate.
An independent commission
is likely the model Canada should be moving towards. The eleventh hour
negotiations gives way too much leverage to the governing party, or the party
in first place. Rules should be set months, or perhaps years in advance so that
everyone goes into it fairly. Add in the question of who should be allowed to participate
at all and you raise all sorts of other problems.
The move by Prime Minister
Harper to make changes to the debates is not at all surprising. Susan Delacourt
does a pretty fantastic job laying out why Harper would like to see changes.
The people I have spoken
to about this expressed some cautious optimism, but I have my concerns. As
Delacourt writes the Conservatives want the debates to be held in the summer,
months before the election is to be officially called with a great deal of time
for the public memory to fade if Harper comes across poorly. A bump in the
polls for Mulcair, Trudeau or May would long vanish when the leaves fall from
the trees and Canadians start to seriously make up their minds.
This approach raises real
questions. Will the parties try to insist on networks and moderators that would
be more friendly to them? What concessions might be demanded? Getting away from
the Consortium's debates might be for the best but launching into this
uncertain future is not exactly encouraging. So far two debates seem approved,
one by Maclean's and Rogers and another by Quebec's TVA.
This causes me to wonder
about the local debates. Remember that Canada won't have one election in
October but 338. I seem to recall that debates were somewhat frequent in my
former riding as community organizations all put forward their own 'meet the
candidates/debate' events. By the end of it the candidates knew each other
quite well. It was even collegial despite the fact they often disagreed
profoundly. That's not always the case. MPs in safe ridings have little
incentive to be berated. Local media and community groups should be considering
their own approach to their own local debates and how they might be improved as
the election nears.
Debates are not the be all
and end all. The ability to give a witty retort reveals very little about who
has the best policies, ideas and temperament. That said it gives the candidates
a chance to stand equally before the public and be seen. That alone is
important. The challenge is to make that valuable.
I try to think of myself as a progressive man, but I fall
within many categories that place me in a privileged position in society. I am perceived
as white (despite not having a purely European background). I originate from a
middle-class family and currently earn a comfortable living. I am heterosexual
and cisgendered, and, most importantly to my comments that follow, I am male. I
offer this as a prelude because on this topic I feel disclosing how a person
self-identifies is a valuable piece of information for understanding their
comments and perspective.
I am not sure if it is because of the growth of critical
analysis of more topics in popular culture, or the fact that I am more
interested and so follow up on articles that discuss these topics, but regardless
I have read many more feminist or gender-issue articles over the last year on
popular culture. Popular feminist figures in new media such as Laci Green and Anita Sarkeesian have helped to broaden my perspective, along with the formal education I
received at university.
As far as I understand it the basic premise of feminism
is that all people are equal and that historic prejudices and power structures
exist within our society and institutions that disadvantage certain groups. As
a historian this is a very difficult premise to disagree with. I do not have
the space here or the knowledge to outline the historic development of this
important movement, but it is fair to say that how this end is accomplished has
been hotly contested.
I’ve wanted to write on this topic for a while. My
interest in writing about this topic has been spurred on by three issues that
pointed out that social problems are more imbedded than most of us are
comfortable admitting.
GamerGate. Sigh. GamerGate is the catchall term to describe the vociferous
attacks, online and real-life, directed towards women in the video game
industry and the media outlets that cover them. These attacks are perpetrated
under the banner of “ethical journalism” that doesn’t even provide a fig leaf’s
worth of decency for the most horrendous misogyny the internet can offer up. For
example, Ms. Sarkeesian has been targeted with threats to her life and public
talks where she is critical of tropes of video games damaging depiction of
women.. Several women have been harassed and had their private residences
shared on the internet forcing them to leave their homes.
GamerGate is particularly disturbing because video games
have done a lot in the last few years to shed the “boy’s club” and overtly
sexist appearance. A growing cast of interesting video games, designers and
studios are creating experiences and characters much more relatable as human beings
and not just digital eye-candy. Still, the medium has a lot more work to do.
There are real questions of ethics in the video game industry, but this has
been made irrelevant in the witch hunt. Sex sells and there are more than
enough depictions of elf-maidens in bikini-armour out there to depress anyone
hopeful for the future of video games.
In Canada media the firestorm swirling around Jian
Ghomeshi once again highlights how we deal with prominent, powerful men accused
of sexual assault or violence against women. For various other crimes large
segments of the public would unquestionably consider the allegations against
Mr. Ghomeshi, but as is tragically typical of rape/assault cases the character and
credibility of the victim is the first questioned. I am embarrassed to admit
that my mind first went there. While I am not a fan of Mr. Ghomeshi I have
listened to and enjoyed his interviews and thought he was a valuable contributor
to Canadian media. The only protection his accusers seem to have is that they
are not alone and that Mr. Ghomeshi has left a trail of women behind in his
life who are now ready to stand together.
When a similar story happens to, for example, a college
football player I can easily and comfortably dismiss the defenders because that
person is not part of my cultural tribe. As a Toronto-based media icon and
progressive the willingness to accept Ghomeshi and openly reject his victims at
face-value proves that elements of rape culture and misogyny are not too
difficult to find when the perpetrators of these crimes are people we ourselves
are fond of. The treatment of these victims and how these crimes are handled
makes it no surprise that they go underreported.
The third piece of media I wanted to share was the video
recorded of a woman walking down New York City’s streets and the endless parade
of catcalls made after her. See the two-minute video below.
In my heart of hearts I hoped that brash New Yorkers were
more inclined to this behaviour. However my opinion was heartily rebuffed when
I was told by a journalist that his female friends often experienced harassment
and a former co-worker of mine reported serious, and threatening street
harassment twice in the space of a week. And upon reflection I can remember how
my friends were sometimes treated as we walked down the street and suddenly
this video did not feel so alien.
It should not matter what any of these women were
wearing. No one deserves to be harassed. No one deserves to be assaulted. No
one deserves to be attacked. In the cool, dispassionate mind many would accept
this. Except we don’t. Many of us still cannot help but blame the victim
because we are socialized to believe that women are not in control of their own
bodies.
One of the reasons I am writing this piece is that I deal
with these contradictions. Do I respect women more or less because of their
appearance? Do I judge a woman on how she’s dressed rather than who she is?
While I think a woman should dress as she pleases do I still quietly slut-shame her? It’s the contradictions in our culture that further confuse and
problematize these issues. A popstar dancing in limited clothing in front of a
giant lit sign reading “FEMINIST” seems to drip with hypocrisy to me, but conflict among the intelligentsia
can’t seem to determine whether or not this is a betrayal of feminism or
celebration. At least it’s not as dumb as a young actress declaring that she’s
not a feminist because she “loves men.”
Some of the most ardent misogynists are those who say
this is a settled issue. That sexism is “fixed” and that only those ardent
man-haters are the ones that want to talk about it. This is not a settled
issue. Across our culture and entrenched in our media are symbols and exploitation
defined by gender. More and more men are openly the victims of sexism as well
are their depiction in media becomes more masculinized and dissociated from
reality. Perhaps the great curse is that progress means both genders are
blatantly objectified now.
This is by no means a “correct” opinion. Given the
diversity of opinions and approaches I am confident that I have failed to
properly articulate these various perspectives in some way. Try as I might to
be a proper 21st century feminist man I am burdened and conflicted by a
socialization and culture and reinforces misogynistic values towards many
different groups. So far the only solution I have found is to actively
challenge the status quo both external to the world around me and, perhaps more
importantly, the world inside my head.
The Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications
Commission has recently drawn attention in this country for trying to regulate
Netflix. Netflix’s content competitors, Bell, Rogers and others have complained
about Netflix’s ability to circumvent regulations that impede their own
performance. The CRTC threatened Netflix to regulate them and impose penalties
if they did not voluntarily comply, which Netflix has declined to do.
It strikes me that Canadian content laws rest in a place
that between meaningless and useful to make them just ineffective. As I understand
it Canadian content laws require a certain percentage of their broadcasts to
contain material made in this country. Going off of my memory (and I admit I
could be wrong here) during prime time, defined as between 6 PM and midnight
has to a certain percentage produce in Canada. Theoretically this is to
encourage the broadcast of Canadian television shows, and encourage these
companies to produce their own shows set in Canadian locales and themes.
However, Global, CTV, CityTV and others use the time to broadcast their news
hours, evening and late night, and simultaneously show American television
programs.
As near as I can tell the Canadian content laws for
television have done nothing to encourage broadcasters to produce new Canadian
programs. The occasional show pops up, such as Corner Gas or Murdoch Mysteries,
but they are by no means the centrepiece of the private television channels.
Just flip through the Canadian channels between 7 PM and 11 PM and that much
will be clear. In recent years a certain number of Canadian-light shows have
been making an appearance, such as Rookie Blue and Orphan Black, which are both
quietly set in Toronto and filmed in Canada.
However, as Canadians turn away from their televisions
and rely on pay-as-you-go services such as Amazon, iTunes and subscription
services like Netflix these regulations seem increasingly irrelevant. Given
their toothless nature of the current laws I see no reason why we should
continue them unless we fundamentally rethink the approach. I am not
comfortable with the idea of mandating what should be broadcast. I think the
changing media landscape and the success of shows like Orphan Black and Rookie
Blue in the global market that Canadian produced shows can find success
elsewhere. This country has a strong and talented film and television industry.
I don’t know why a sitcom set in Toronto, or a police procedural in Vancouver
could not be successful. American networks don’t disdain Canadian content, and
there are so many of them that they’ll take cheaper foreign-made content.
Instead of mandating quotas perhaps we should do more to
encourage more Canadian production. If we insist on regulation is must not be
as ineffective and meaningless as it is now.
Note: A commenter on Twitter informed me that the location of a television show does not define it as Canadian content, but who makes it. The example provided was that the TV show "Vikings" is considered Canadian content. To my point of view this points out further flaws. This commenter, Ian Kiar, added that the main complaint of companies have is that they pay revenues into the Canadian Media Fund and Netflix does not.