Showing posts with label Affordable Housing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Affordable Housing. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 2, 2018

Housing First in the Deep Cold

On December 30th I visited some friends. It was a cold night, a very cold night. We were in relative comfort and spent an evening playing board games and enjoying each other's company. I even managed a second place finish in Lords of Waterdeep, which is a rare feat. I tell this story for what happened at the conclusion of the evening.

When we were all done I climbed into my vehicle, started the engine for a moment and began to drive. My friends live ten minutes away from me, so waiting for the car to heat up for such a short drive seemed silly on the face of it. So I got in and drove. I made it a few hundred meters when despite a nice coat, hat and gloves I started shivering in the car. It was -24 degrees centigrade.

During the recent cold weather an error was made at a Toronto emergency shelter and people were turned away while there was still space available. During my brief ride from my friends to my house I was deeply uncomfortable, though not in any serious danger. I can scarcely imagine sitting out in the cold all night. The consequences could be, and often are, lethal.

Canadians rightfully complain about living in one of the coldest countries on the planet. Our major cities, I'm sure, are some of the coldest in the world for their size. As a result, our urban leaders have to confront a simple truth: if we do not provide adequate housing in the winter, people will die.

It's conversations like this where we need to separate questions about general housing affordability from the crisis that is homelessness. A person with an addiction, or mental illness isn't a family making $42000 who can't afford to rent in Toronto. Increasing supply or rent control will not ultimately get us to address this particular problem.


Cities in Canada need to adopt a housing first strategy. It is unconscionable to rely on temporary and emergency housing and turn these people out into the streets. Housing first means that people in bad situations are given a stable place to live. It makes the provision of care and social services much simpler. Experts argue that it costs less in the long run, but it is by no means cheap. Worst still any housing first program would disproportionately benefit those that society currently pushes as far to the margins and away from our mental landscapes as we can. Moral choices are not always cheap or easy ones, but acting in immorality for the sake of some savings at the cost of human suffering is difficult to stomach. 

Tuesday, May 24, 2016

Quick Thoughts: Are we in a housing bubble?

Off the top I will admit that I remembered last night and late tonight that it was Tuesday and hence blog day. My day disappeared into a couple of projects, errands and work and the next thing I know I have less than three hours to post something interesting.

I did not have time to have anything properly prepped (last said by me, red faced, to a high school teacher). Instead I thought I would write down something that has been on my mind for weeks/months but haven't found the time to write out properly. I may revisit this with a proper post later.

I live in the Greater Toronto Area. I live with my family and we have lived in the same house my entire life. Every year prices have crept up and up and pushed potential buyers further afield. I am of the right age that a few of my friends have bought their first or second homes. More than a few have been pushed further into the Toronto commutershed, or deeper into suburbia to find homes they can afford. It's the 'drive until you qualify' formulation writ large.

This philosophy seems like a poorly disguised trap to me. Living further away from your work and essentials drives up costs, hidden in gas bills, second/third cars, insurance, and most importantly - time. It also has this daunting ripple effect. People cannot afford to live in inner Toronto so move to the inner suburbs, the inner suburbs prices people out and they live in the core 905, and out and out they go. Now my neighbourhood of simple 1960s suburban homes prices at ~$500000 when they cost a fifth as much 20 years ago. It seems to me the people living in these houses couldn't buy them today if they were forced into the market with no equity.

Watching a film like The Big Short has me wondering if the Canadian housing market found the perfect amount of heat to keep prices and investment flowing in the industry but not clearly manifest as a bubble. Prices, as near as I can tell, have not gone down in years and years. No one putting their house on the market today expects to lose money.

There are other troubling symptoms, but the excess isn't here to suggest the kind of runaway freight train that happened in the U.S. Still, I am worried, and the pace may be deceiving us. How sustainable is this ever climbing ride? Is a plunge on the horizon? And if it is, does the longer the wait mean worse outcomes for us all?

Tuesday, September 1, 2015

Review: Show Me a Hero, HBO Mini-Series

Normally I only review books on this blog, but I wish to make an exception and review a series that concluded this week. I will not be spoiling the conclusion of the series, but I will provide a basic framework for the story.



Show Me a Hero is an adaptation of Lisa Belkin's book of the same name detailing the story of the political and social battle in Yonkers, New York over federally-mandated social housing in white, middle-class neighbourhoods in the 1980s and 90s. The book was adapted by David Simon and William F. Zorzi who also partnered together on the hit HBO series The Wire.

The six-part mini-series approaches the conflict from a number of perspectives. The drama of the story and its main thrust comes from the political battle on city council. Nick Wasiscsko, played by Oscar Isaac, is the protagonist and the perspective we get on this conflict. Yonkers city council are united in their displeasure of having to accept the court order for social housing to be built in their white neighbourhoods. The housing question and how to deal with it becomes a central focus of Yonkers politics throughout the much of the first half of the series.

HBO has brought together a star-studded cast to play the major figures of the era. Jim Belushi plays Angelo Martinelli, long-serving mayor of Yonkers. Alfred Molina masterfully embodies the grand-standing Councillor Hank Spallone. Winona Ryder plays Council President Vinni Restiano. Three others who are notable are Jon Bernthal as the NAACP lawyer, Clarke Peters as a neighbourhood consultant and Catherine Keener as Mary Dorman, a concerned white homeowner. Keener embodies a great deal of the fear and concern of white residents while humanizing them beyond simple racism.

Similar to The Wire the other half of the story is told through a group of characters living in public housing in Yonkers. Through the eyes of four women one begins to see the difficult position those in social housing find themselves. One of the characters, Newman, an expert in social housing, gives voice to why some of these problems persist: excessive concentration leads to marginalization, poorly defined public spaces become no man's lands and a haven for drugs and crime. These portrayals go a long way to humanizing the people in the social housing projects. It is not to say they are angels and some defy the law and the social norms of white, middle-class culture, but this makes them better than simple caricatures. Still, as I watched the series you found myself more invested in their lives than the political drama unfolding.

Despite being set nearly thirty years ago the themes of Show Me a Hero are very applicable in modern-day America. Social housing remains a major issue. The case in the story is about desegregation, i.e. moving social housing units into East Yonkers rather than concentrating them further in minority neighbourhoods. I imagine this remains a controversial, and intractable problem in many American (and Canadian) cities. Another fascinating element is that this isn't just a story about black and hispanic people wanting to move into the white neighbourhoods. The characters living in social housing, and a representative of the NAACP, express concern of moving into a place that they are not wanted, away from their community. Reintegration is not as simple as "build it and they will come." Other themes in the series are class and political gridlock. Much of the opposition is couched in terms of economics (ex. preserving home values) and as stated above we see the economic impact of poor social housing on its residents. Political gridlock and intransigence is the central drama of the piece. Politicians who in backrooms express reasonable positions take outrageous positions to ensure their own popularity and electoral fortunes.

In terms of the politics it is interesting how divorced the two sets of stories are from each other. It is notable when they intrude. There are no African-Americans on the city council, no clear advocates for those characters in the story. The passionate fiery debates at city council are between a city council and angry white residents, with no advocacy group in support present. Those who would benefit from new social housing are largely unheard and disconnected from the political discussion, which I feel is a comment by Simon.

Finally, while watching this series I was frequently reminded of Steve Paikin's book The Dark Side: The Personal Price of a Political Life. Politics is not all glamour and power. The men and women who step forward to make decisions are called upon to lead. Sometimes they are pulled into difficult situations and must sacrifice their own promises for a greater public good, a public good their supporters cannot, or will not see. There is a human cost to politics and this mini-series embodies that.

I would highly recommend this series, especially to fans of The Wire. The mini-series offers a thoughtful commentary on a contentious public policy issue that rarely gets attention and humanizes people on all sides of the discussion. Oscar Isaac, Catherine Keener, Ilfenesh Hadera, Natalie Paul, LaTanya Richardson Jackson and Dominique Fishback bring their flawed characters to life in a sympathetic way that allows the audience to approach this fight from many different angles. This story resonates strongly in North America in 2015 and should be viewed widely.

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Condominiums and Affordable Housing


Last week I briefly touched on some of the housing issues confronting people living in Peel as a result of growing income inequality. I wanted to drill down a little on that issue.

The housing issues facing families, especially those on below-average (or even average) incomes is particularly acute. Getting the space needed at a reasonable price is very difficult. For singles, couples or small families one of the solutions offered to the “middle class” seeking affordable housing has been condominiums.

Condos conveniently skirt the social stigma of renting, allows people to accumulate equity and provides some social prestige. In many ways condos have supplanted traditional starter-homes. Starter-homes are typically one- or two-bedroom houses that are usually smaller than others available on the market. They are ideal for single adults or couples without children, or perhaps one child for those in the middle class. I know a lot of peers are living in, or saving for, their home in the sky. In our shift to greater density it seems natural for condos to replace older, smaller residential homes.

Sadly, other factors are at work. As I mentioned last week, starter-homes are now well out of the reach of young adults just getting their lives together and most young families. My recent survey of the Brampton housing market showed that homes begin at $300,000+. Condominiums seem to be the only option below $300,000, at least in this city by my survey. The various condominium markets across Canada have been sources of rampant speculation. Low interest rates, Canada’s strong banking system and overall economic stability have made Canada a very attractive market to invest in. As a result these shoeboxes in the sky are now selling for exorbitant prices.

Given that so many condominiums are now investment properties with the owners waiting for them to accumulate value many are putting them on the market to rent. This is leading to another disturbing trend. From the Toronto Star, condominium-renters are not protected by the same laws that protect people renting a normal apartment. This giant loophole allows owners to arbitrarily and massively increase rents.

The condo boom is fraught with other challenges. There are increasing questions about maintenance fees and consumer protection issues. ONDP MPP Rosario Marchese (ONDP – Trinity-Spadina) has been fighting to improve the laws governing condos for years now. Condo-owners do not have a simple way to have their needs addressed and there is a lot of concern over the long-term structural stability and soundness of these new buildings.

What once seemed like a smart plan for me and my peers increasingly seems like a way to get fleeced. However all the new construction anywhere seems to be new houses, where even townhouses start at $300,000, or condominiums. It is apparent that more affordable options are needed, along with a greater supply of apartments and other rental choices. Not providing affordable housing of some kind will only push people further from job centres and cause the GTHA/Toronto commutershed, which already includes much of central Ontario, to sprawl even further outward, leading to greater problems of employment, traffic, infrastructure expense, and environmental degradation.