Showing posts with label Infrastructure. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Infrastructure. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 1, 2016

Beware Infrastructure Spending


Often governments promise to revitalize a flagging economy through infrastructure spending. Listening to the recent news on how the federal government plans to spend infrastructure I think people should understand the difference between valuable and trivial infrastructure spending.

Years ago when the Conservatives launched their Economic Action Plan it included all sorts of projects, but one example that comes to mind is the construction of new hockey arenas for municipalities. This is a form of infrastructure, but it has almost no magnifying effect on the larger economy. After the centre is built it generally creates little, if any, employment and does nothing to benefit the regional economy. In fact, if might be a net negative given the ongoing expense to the municipality to support it and maintain it.

There are other forms of infrastructure that have a lasting impact and positive economic spin-offs. One of the most important things rulers did centuries and millennia ago did to build their countries was construct roads. Linking together the disparate parts of their kingdom or empire with a more reliable transportation network brought goods and people together and caused the expansion of trade and the growth of cities. As time has passed the mode has shifted. It went to canals and railways and public transit. To be clear, expanding a highway rarely counts as the sort of economic development I am talking about here.

The goal with stimulus infrastructure spending should be to make long-term investments that have tangible benefits to the economy. What would have more economic benefit, repairing the roofs on a thousand community centres or funding a project like the Downtown Relief Line in Toronto? New stations across the city would become new hubs for development. It is easy to imagine tens of millions of dollars of new construction following those projects.

When I lived in Fort Smith there were conversations that a permanent road should be built from Fort Smith to Fort Chipewyan and on to Fort McMurray. That construction would dramatically reduce the cost of development and business in that region of Alberta and costs in the Northwest Territories. It also would revive Fort Smith as a gateway community instead of one at the end of the road.


I generally view the economy as a Keynesian, but building rec centres and filling potholes should not be counted as the kind of infrastructure spending that will alleviate unemployment and be viewed as meaningful investments. Real infrastructure improvements to get the economy moving should be more than wish list promises and make-work schemes. Governments need to have the courage to stay that money in programs such as these are better spent on projects with strong long-term results and not be comforted by cutting a cheque for every little town in Canada. 

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Worth Reading – February 28, 2013


I have decided to break one of my rules about Worth Reading. I’m expanding the selection to ten. It won’t always be ten posts, but sometimes seven felt very constraining. I’ve also been considering the future of The Orange Tory blog. This past Tuesday I posted a piece about the declining empathy I have noted among people. I have received good feedback about it but there were issues that came up this past week I wanted to address. Sometimes one post does not feel like enough. I briefly considered a Sunday essay. The topic would not be related to current events directly and be more of a commentary. I still haven’t decided whether or not I’ll do this, but I’m considering something along these lines.

We often hear how strong the Canadian economy is, but what we don’t hear often enough is many of the underlying weakness. One of the things that has crippled the American economy is the high level of consumer debt, which Canadians are also amassing. Another issue is the debt the provinces are taking on.  This isn’t just an Ontario issue, across the country the provinces are cash-strapped and struggling, even Alberta.

Premier Kathleen Wynne’s government got hit with more controversy when new documents were revealed related to the gas plant closures in Oakville and Mississauga.

Metrolinx has set up a cool interactive challenge. Can you fund the infrastructure projects? What balance of taxes and fees will you use to pay for projects?

One of the big news items over the last couple of days was the release of a new political book called The Big Shift by John Ibbitson and Darrel Bricker. The authors argue that the 2011 election heralded a fundamental realignment of the country away from traditional eastern power centres to Western Canada. The Conservatives, they claim, are poised to be the “Liberal Party of the 21st century”, or, Canada’s natural governing party. A lot of columnists have responded with their own critiques. Susan Delacourt counters that it is hard to change the political DNA of Canada. In the Hill Times we have how the Conservatives changed politics in Canada. I’m hoping to pick this book up sometime this year and perhaps post a review.

Perhaps the biggest piece of news for a political nerd like me this week was the updated version of the Federal Ontario Boundary Commission’s report. The boundaries have been significantly altered in this version. I imagine I’ll dedicate next week’s post on the topic. A relatively new blog, Ontario Projections, has a write up on it if you want to check it out. 

Doug Saunders in the Globe and Mail discusses the international phenomenon that is “Vancouverism”. Vancouverism is the practice of increasing density in cities and developing infrastructure (particularly public transit) to match. However, as Saunders points out, there is an irony in that what the world is embracing, Canada is backing away from.

Samara’s series on Redesigning Parliament continues. This week I was particularly interested in a post that suggests that parliament needs to return to its supreme place in our political culture. 

Finally, something else urban/transit related. The author asks, “does light rail actually reduce congestion?” The answer may surprise you.

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Bankrupting Brampton and Cities


Today I was going through the Brampton Guardian when I got to the Commentary page. Terry Miller, a columnist with the local paper, was discussing Brampton’s budget, link here. Reading Miller it seems that Brampton is faced with the same budget issues it is always faced with. Funding is allocated, there is a proposed property tax hike and while the budget is mostly set there is a massive gaping hole in the projections.

The reason for this is simple – capital funding. Financing the expensive business of building/maintain roads, bridges, and other basic infrastructure is immense. It is critical because a basic level of infrastructure support is necessary for the stable operation of a city. In the case of a city like Brampton, which is undergoing rapid expansion, makes these gaps acute.

Brampton is (tragically) not alone in this. The cities in Ontario and across Canada are dependent upon the support of the provincial and federal governments. However, unlike in American jurisdictions these commitments are not made consistently or within a concrete framework. The city (and others) rely on one-time transfers. As Miller puts it, “The current budget makes the best of what is available but doesn’t provide for the future except for a 1% tax transfer into infrastructure spending, federal gas tax sharing, which could change up or down, and federal provincial infrastructure funding schemes that are usually project based and most often require local financial participation…usually 1/3. But the sources of revenue won’t match the need to keep building the services needed to service this city. Added to those problems are the city’s share for the new Peel Memorial Hospital and Highway 10 transit requirements soon to be unveiled by Metrolinx.”

The funding expected from these sources and the expected growth of expenses in Brampton do not come close to matching one another. In less than a decade the shortfall will be roughly a billion dollars that the city alone will have to meet.

The city does what it can to keep taxes low. Brampton, like all local governments in Ontario, is dependent upon property taxes which are highly regressive and punishing to property owners. Sources of revenue such as development fees will one day vanish as the last green-field site turns into homes. Brampton fights to maintain a balanced budget and to not borrow money, but it is left with few choices.

Why do the federal government and provincial governments refuse to support cities? Canada is an urban nation, and despite the need for basic services the higher levels of government choke resources from our local institutions. The Ontario and Canadian governments need to take cities more seriously if they are to thrive and serve their residents. Bankrupting the engines of our economy will do little to solve the bottom line for the province or federation.