Showing posts with label Suburbs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Suburbs. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 7, 2016

What Works for Small Businesses? Strip Malls, Big Box, Corridors and Districts

Last week I wrote a post about starting a business in a suburban location. I received some feedback in person and from a commenter and I wanted to address some of that.

First, here is the comment from Mr. Milne:

I'm no expert, but maybe the willingness of suburbanites to drive to a particular place might have an impact on its viability? In my suburban hometown of St. Albert in Alberta, many of our businesses are concentrated along the main highway that runs through the city on its way into and out of Edmonton, or on roads that branch off it. While driving everywhere to shop isn't always ideal, sometimes it's necessary if you have something that's too big or unwieldy to carry on foot or on a bicycle. 
As for downtowns, Edmonton has its Whyte Avenue. However, I very rarely go down there because parking is such a pain in the ass, and traffic is so heavy. At the St. Albert strip malls, I find that I usually have more choice about which exit to use when I get back on the road. 
Just some thoughts from a suburbanite.

So, I followed up on his feedback. I've never been to St. Albert, Alberta, but with the power of Google Streetview I took a look.


This is Highway 2 in St. Albert. If I am not mistaken it is the road Mr. Milne was referring to. From the highway interchange to the middle of St. Albert the highway is mostly lined with commercial businesses. While the form is the strip mall that I talked about in the initial piece the city planners have clearly designated Highway 2 as a commercial corridor. A commercial corridor is a street that is overwhelming dedicated to retail, entertainment and other services. This has a certain beneficial effect. In essence a long, thin district is created that residents know can serve their needs. It is not dissimilar to the main drag of a downtown where the most prominent businesses are placed. A certain economy of scale kicks in because people looking to do shopping will be drawn to Highway 2. This concentrates customers and gives the businesses a larger pool of clients to work with.

However, many of my criticisms of strip mall development stand. I presume the speed limit on Highway 2 to be around 60 km/h. Even using Google Streetview I find it difficult to identify the businesses tucked beyond the parking lot, especially because other buildings at times obscure them. I also note that while there are a few independent businesses that the vast majority in this strip mall are chains/franchises.

My hometown of Brampton has a couple of commercial corridors, but they are not consistent and tend to be interrupted by residential areas or parks so that their corridor nature is impeded. The two strongest examples though are Queen Street and Kennedy Road. Below is Kennedy Road:


Kennedy Road between Steeles Avenue and Queen Street is dotted with commercial development. What makes it interesting to me though is that the vast majority of businesses are independent, small businesses. Follow the Streetview map north from where it began. You'll notice very few chains. You may also notice that the vast majority are owned or cater to the South Asian or West Indian communities. The parking lots are narrower on Kennedy Road so the businesses are closer to the street to it is easier to see what's inside. The units seem quite small and densely packed, particularly if you look at a complex at Kennedy and Clarencewhich is 2-3 stories.  Ironically what makes Kennedy Road work for small businesses is that it is undesirable. Kennedy is beside an industrial area, you may have noticed the warehouses, and is considered a less affluent part of the city overall.

As opposed to corridors there are shopping complexes. They are islands of commercial activity, usually along a highway. Here is one on Bovaird in Brampton near Mount Pleasant.


Not exactly easy to see what's inside without entering, is it? There is a slightly better building slightly to the east that's closer to the street and contains a number of independent businesses. However, these big box developments cater to large, well-established chains that work best when you know what a McDonald's or a Fortino's already is.  

I think when people read my criticisms about suburban life they think I mean we should all live in Toronto, that I am just one more millennial that wants to live in the big city and resents my dull suburban upbringing. That is not at all the cases. Sometimes I think the best urban environments I have been in are in small and mid-sized cities. In cities like this it is achievable to enjoy an urban environment with much reduced traffic and issues parking if you need to drive. Let's look at a city I know very well, St. Catharines.


This is St. Paul Street in St. Catharines, the main street of its downtown. The majority of businesses in the area are independent. Given that St. Catharines is a college town a good number of them are bars and restaurants, but that is not unusual for a downtown. If you look elsewhere you will find on King Street more service-oriented businesses, such as law firms and banks. Businesses are clearly visible from the street, the area is well served by public transit and pedestrians and cyclists have an easy time moving around. While it is a quiet time of day and year, you see many more people walking around Downtown St. Catharines than in either of the corridors or the complex above.

I am sure a planner or business expert could better explain the process but it seems to me that commercial districts (like a downtown) and to a lesser extent commercial corridors offer small businesses opportunity that isolated strip malls outside of corridors or large complexes do not. Buildings in a downtown tend to be flexible and can serve multiple purposes. They can have rental housing in them to help keep costs down and build up the local consumer market. Districts can cater to niche interests because they are gathering together a large group of people and not asking people to come to them. Close proximity to the street gives them free advertising that is missed if cars are whipping by at 60-80 km/h. If the drive is your primary concern it should be noted that wide avenues draw traffic and one has to drive from store to store, while in a denser setting it is reasonable to park centrally and walk between stops. When was the last time you walked store to store at a big box complex? Not to mention trying to make a left turn out of a strip mall onto a busy avenue is a personal nightmare for me. Putting aside any ideology or preferences just look at the numbers. Where are there more independent businesses? What message is that sending us, and then one should consider why it is occurring.






Tuesday, May 31, 2016

Small Business and the Suburbs

Some readers may be aware that over the last few years, and the last year in specific I have been working on ideas for a small, independent business. The idea has always attracted me. I like the notion of being my own boss and while making money making a positive contribution to my community. At first I thought about setting up my business in my hometown, Brampton, but I discovered a competitor had beaten me to the punch and so I looked elsewhere. Yesterday I met with some people from the Brampton Economic Development office. For anyone considering starting a business I would highly recommend speaking with your local chapter.

I sat down with one of their experts about locations in the city and neighbourhoods that might be of interest. After about an hour of conversation we parted ways, me with new ideas in my head and went to reconsider if Brampton might work for what I hope to accomplish.

I sat staring at a map last night, and drove to the locations we discussed and as I reflect back upon that experience I wonder if there might be a fundamental problem. Is suburban-style development hostile to independent, small businesses?

Hostile is probably too strong a word, what is probably more accurate to say is that they are a steeper uphill climb than in a more urban environment. I do not think the particular problem is Brampton, instead it is the land-use patterns in the city commonly found elsewhere. Downtown Brampton offers some solutions to the problems I am about to list, but instead I Want to talk about some of the problems first.

Every business has a certain logical catchment area. This is the area in which customers are likely to encounter a business in their daily activities, or the proximity to the business in their day-to-day lives. You can probably draw a circle around your business and within which you can reasonably expect customers to drive/walk/bike/transit to your business, and beyond which people are far less likely. In denser urban environments this circle could contain tens of thousands of potential customers. Given the lower densities found in suburban environments the business is drawing a smaller population. There is also an element of specialization here. Let's take the example of a bakery. Most people don't have need for a bakery anymore as they buy their bread from grocery stores. Bakeries now almost exclusively cater to desserts and pastries. Are there enough people five kilometers around a strip mall to make a bakery sustainable? Obviously in some cases yes, but it certainly more of a challenge.

If a business wants to reach beyond that circle it needs to pull in an audience and reach across the boundaries. In a suburb like Brampton that means driving. Transit, while improving, take longer, operates on an independent schedule and may not deliver you to your end location. Brampton is a large, sprawling city. Even as a person who has lived here most of his life my knowledge of it is constrained to certain districts and regions. Rarely do I find myself north of Bovaird, or in East Brampton. Likewise, a customer is unlikely to visit a business that is beyond a certain mental horizon. It took me months to go visit a board game store in Brampton because it seemed so distant and inconvenient.

Outside of the Downtown a business in Brampton is probably found in a mall, a strip mall or a shopping complex. I am unfamiliar with malls, so I'll leave that aside. The design of a strip mall and shopping complex are such that people going there already know why they are there. People don't browse in these locations. They drive to their store and leave. Worse still, unlike a traditional downtown, oftentimes the businesses are not visible from travellers on the road. The complex obscures businesses deep in its well of buildings and parking lots, and the strip mall is difficult to see. These types of shopping complexes encourage chains and franchises because customers have some idea what they are. It would be exceedingly easy to miss a unique name on one of those towering signs or hanging over a building and, since you are likely driving, it is difficult to investigate.

Finally the suburban development pattern that I have observed tends to create larger spaces. This is likely a benefit to some but that square footage costs money in rent and maintenance. A 3000 square foot restaurant might not make a lot of sense to an entrepreneur with limited resources, but a 1500 square foot one may let him/her get started and test the market.

There are no doubt successful independent, small businesses to be found in the 'burbs. When I reflect though on my favourites in my hometown only two are out in the sprawl while the rest are tucked inside the small downtown. These are definitely things I think about as I decide whether or not my idea is feasible and I wonder how many are faced with similar dilemmas.




Tuesday, February 23, 2016

Book Review: The End of the Suburbs by Leigh Gallagher

In The End of the Suburbs: Where the American Dream is Moving by Leigh Gallagher makes the argument that the suburban mode of development reached its peak in the 1990s and 2000s and we it has begun its decline as the monolithic form of the built environment. As Gallagher makes clear in her conclusion, the suburbs aren't really over. With millions of homes built in the suburban style and millions of Americans still enamoured with the vision of a big house on a piece of land it will likely always remain. However, the author argues, alternative modes of living are becoming more dominant and reflect a sea change. 



Many of the economic and social factors that created the suburbs are in decline or in reverse. It's probably fair to say that we are in the third (maybe fourth?) generation  of the suburbs. The logic that created the first few versions of the suburbs have broken down. The initial suburbs were directly alongside the central city. The inner ring of suburbs that developed next were often serviced with public transit and were dense and walkable. However for the second, third, and fourth generation of suburbs prospective homebuyers were driven further into former agricultural areas along freeways. It seems though that the suburban experiment in the 1990s began to reach a point of diminishing returns. Commutes got longer and longer and prices kept climbing. Gallagher writes that many point to the mortgage crisis and high gas prices for killing suburbs, but the truth is that urban property values began to climb again (after decades of decline) in the 1980s.

The cars that promised liberty were transforming into prisons as millions of North Americans trapped themselves for hours a day grinding their ways between work and home. The demographic explosion that justified the suburbs, the Baby Boom, is much diminished. Birth rates have cratered. There is far less need for properties for kids to play in with many bedrooms when fewer people are coupling and having children.

The End of the Suburbs reads like a very long article as it is written in an accessible, casual way, which makes sense given that the author is a journalist. The author conducts interviews that demonstrate many of the failings of suburban life, and contrasts them with people proposing, building or living alternatives. A number of big developers appear in the book, which gives a clear example of how the market is transforming on the demand and supply sides.

There is a slim undercurrent in the book that suggests what is emerging is suburban-like cities and city-like suburbs. I had similar thinking looking at some of the 'new hip' neighbourhoods of Toronto, like Liberty Village. All the chains and wealth of the suburbs have been poured into condominiums and boutiques offering faux-authentic brick even though it's the same chain from the strip mall in the 'burbs.

I think Gallagher does a convincing job laying out the case that the unending sprawl is going to slow down, if not come to an end. But, what will take its place isn't the past but some hybrid of urban and suburban living. I would recommend this book for anyone interested in the future of the suburbs and the housing market. It is entirely accessible to a lay audience but sophisticated enough for people well versed in the subject.