Showing posts with label Michael Ignatieff. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Michael Ignatieff. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Five Years with Stephen

On January 23 it was the fifth anniversary of the election of Stephen Harper as Prime Minister of Canada. I had not originally planned to make any special note of Prime Minister Harper’s half-decade as the leader of the government, but then I saw a commercial on television that changed my mind.

Over the last few weeks the Conservative Party of Canada has released a number of political attack ads targeting leader of the opposition, Michael Ignatieff. Harper also recently concluded an interview with Peter Mansbridge, and then came this ad:



I’m all for speculating for how elections will turn out, I’m less interested in when they will be called. That being said, it looks like this spring might be another election season, and since I’m in the business of predicting elections, this might be Stephen Harper’s best shot at a majority in a long time.

I should first make something abundantly clear, despite having “Tory” as the second part of my blog’s name I am not a member of the Conservative Party and I am not a partisan for them. In fact, I’ve only ever been a member of the NDP. That being said, I believe Harper is making a highly measured and effective pitch to “middle Canada.” Harper has cultivated a certain hockey dad mystique about him, I don’t know if it’s all an act, he does like hockey and he is a dad. Harper has increasingly put himself in a position where a large number of Canadians would likely nod along with him.

During his interview with Peter Mansbridge, viewable here, Mansbridge asked Harper if he intended to bring the death penalty back to Canada. Harper said that no, he didn’t have any plans to bring it back, but (and here’s where he gets a whole lot of Canadians nodding) there are times when he thinks it may be appropriate, and thought it could be used in extraordinary circumstances. The next day Ignatieff and the Liberals took the bait, they jumped on it criticizing Harper for a secret agenda. I frankly view this as a mistake. For the Conservatives to make their opponents look foolish next election all they have to do is say, “We don’t plan to bring back the death penalty, we just sometimes this, like many Canadians, that it should be used on our most vile criminals.” And there you have it.

Probably hundreds of times in my life I’ve heard people’s reactions to crime news items and muttered how a person should be put to death if they get caught, if not worse. The rapists, pedophiles, and those who break all the social norms. It’s the type of argument that would work on the vast majority of the suburban family types I know and grew up with, those that don’t think the death penalty should come back, but believe that perhaps there are those who deserve death for what they’ve done.

The second think I’d like to point out is that ad that I started the blog with, that I embedded above (I just learned how to do that!). The ad is cheesy, like all Canadian political ads, but there are two features I want to point out. The first, because I think it’s funny, is that if you go to the 38 second mark and watch you’ll see the Prime Minister drinking from a coffee cup. Pause at 39 seconds. It’s a Beetles coffee mug, the subtle reminder that our P.M. has shown a sense of humour lately and some musical talent. The second thing, is that from the narration, to the imagery and the messaging, the commercial reminds me of an accounting ad. That’s what Harper is selling Canada, he’s a competent, effective manager, and you should trust him to manage your biggest investment, your country.

I’m not a Harper fan, though I do respect our Prime Minister. I see the politics here, like using E.I. benefits that opposition forced into the budget to run on yourself, but I also see a good appeal to voters. Five years under Harper has not been that bad, and in general he has been a pretty good P.M., not perfect, but good. I have my complaints, and I don’t know if I ever want to see a Harper majority, but with moves like these we may see one within the next 12 months.


Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Constituency of One

It has been two months since I last contributed anything on here, for which I am sorry. I have been busy. So has Ottawa.

The Canadian budget is coming to a vote. And the illustrious Liberal Party has decided to back it under their new leader Michael Ignatieff. It makes sense. The budget has a lot of money that the broad Liberal ideology cannot object to. Also, the idea of calling an election in the current climate, under a relatively unknown leader is probably - strategically - a bad idea. Bad or unstable economic times feeds two reactions amongst Canadians historically. Option one is throw the bums out, ask R.B. Bennett about that one. The other is to hold on to the party in power, and strengthen their government because they are trusted on the economy and stability is desired, Mulroney.

It's never known how the Canadian public will decide, that's usually figured out during the campaign, and how much they blame the economic downturn on the government in power.

The point isn't about the government as a whole. Or even the economic downturn. It's about four MPs from Newfoundland.

According to these Liberal MPs the budget is punative to their home province, a total of $1.6 billion in transfer payments. The Liberals under Ignatieff have already vowed to support the vote so that the Harper government doesn't collapse. To make this work Ignatieff has allowed a "one-time" protest vote for the Newfoundland MPs against the budget.

Ignatieff shouldn't have the right to "allow" these MPs to vote the way their constituents would want, to represent their interests. This is unconscionable. Ignatieff said, "I decided to permit them in the budget vote tonight a one-time vote of protest to signal their displeasure and my displeasure at these unilateral actions which, in my view, weaken our federation, cause strains in our federation at a time when Canadians should be pulling together."

MPs should care about what matters for their constituents and the business of party-line is becoming destructive to the interests of the Canadian people, especially to their regional interests. Newfoundland in the last election had a concerted ABC campaign - Anyone But Conservative - Resulting in the election of 1 NPD, 6 Liberal and no Conservative Members of Parliament. Perhaps we should abandon national parties, because of the abuse of our regional interests and follow the Bloc's lead and merely fragment ourselves.

I suppose it doesn't matter for now though, because for now they've been permitted to protest.