Showing posts with label Federal Government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Federal Government. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Oda and the Iceberg


Today the resignation of Bev Oda (CPC – Durham, ON) officially resigned from the Harper government and as a Member of Parliament. Anyone who knows who Bev Oda appears to be reacting rather positively to her departure from public life. After her deeply embarrassing $16 orange juice, luxury hotels, and limos the public patience was at a breaking point. Her Conservative colleagues have offered a weak defence of their erstwhile former-Minister, but in an interview with CBC’s Evan Solomon she declared she had no regrets, and therefore the government’s burden with Oda is not quite over.

I am glad Bev Oda has resigned. Her abilities as a minister were somewhat suspect and her stumbles and public failings over the last few months has only hardened the criticism over her competence. On an anecdotal level I have a number of friends who live in the riding of Durham. The talk there before Oda’s resignation was how embarrassing it was to have her as an MP. It is unlikely Durham would have flipped to one of the opposition parties without a landslide in 2015.

I write this blog because I love politics, but sometimes I absolutely hate politics. Bev Oda was pressured to resign, though no one admits it that much is pretty clear. One would hope that the reason was MPs were beginning to get negative feedback about this issue and pressured her and the Prime Minister’s Office. More likely (sadly) is that polling from the PMO showed Oda was a drag on the party. The convenience of summarizing Oda’s crimes with “$16 orange juice” made her a wonderful target for her detractors, regardless of affiliation.

Oda is not the most odious member of the Conservative Government. At the moment I believe that title goes to the Treasury Board Secretary Tony Clement (CPC – Parry Sound-Muskoka). Mr. Clement redirected a $50 million fund that was earmarked for reducing border congestion and funnelled it into pet projects in his riding and elsewhere. The most famous/notorious example is a gazebo.

Minister Oda charged thousands of dollars unnecessarily to the public purse. Once outted she repaid the cost, but the stink stuck. The audacity of the $16 orange juice stuck in enough people’s craw that she had to go. Yes, I used the word craw. SecretaryClement misdirected funds, was caught by the auditor general, called out forviolating accountability rules and has paid no political price for it.

Peter McKay’s helicopter joyrides, the mishandling of the F-35 procurement, and Dean Del Mastro’s election fundraising problems are all, in many ways, far greater violations of the public trust... but they do not make for as good of a sound bite as “$16 orange juice”. This is why I can be driven to hate politics at time. We often become fixated on the smaller, more dramatic scandals than the deeper problems and obstacles to good governance.

Yes, it is a good thing that Minister Oda resigned today, but she is only the tip of a much larger iceberg of what is wrong in the current federal government. She was one part of a much greater problem, but the symbolic sacrifice has been made, though greater problems lurk beneath.

Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Can the Centre Hold?


The United States has centuries of discussion around the concept of states’ rights. It is one of the fundamental features of their politics. In Canada the notion of provinces’ rights, or provincial rights is comparatively limited and undeveloped, or at least it has been. I would argue the key reason for this is twofold. First, the smaller, poorer provinces have benefited from a powerful federal government in terms of equalization programmes etc. Greater provincial rights could turn into less federal funding. Second, provincial powers at the federal level typically devolves into a debate about Quebec separation/independence. Quebec politicians, particularly those in the Parti Quebecois have demanded greater autonomy from the federal government.

While the other provinces within Canada may have griped about the power of the central government they did exceedingly little about it. That, I believe, may be changing.

The recent Alberta election was a battle between conservative parties, the Wildrose and the Progressive Conservatives. There is some argument whether or not the Redford-led PCs should be thought of as conservative, but I think it’s fair to say they are an Alberta centrist party. Last night’s result would somewhat endorse that. That being said, the parallels between Redford’s Progressive Conservatives and Dalton McGuinty’s Ontario Liberals are... interesting.

I interpret the battle between the PCs and Wildrose not as a right between centre-right and right, but of a provincialist and federalist party. Redford and her supporters frequently pointed to cooperating with other provinces and federal government and winning them onside for tar sand development, as well as her experience advocating for Alberta in Washington D.C. It might be a bit of a simplification but Danielle Smith, leader of Wildrose, appeared to argue for ‘Alberta first’ policies. The connection between the Wildrose and the Firewall Letter also supports this argument. The Firewall idea was to erect barriers between the federal and provincial government to avoid interference and gain autonomy, much like Quebec.

I saw this angle barely discussed in the media, so I think it may have been overlooked to some degree. Alberta voters may have suggested that they wish to engage in confederation and not disengage. That, or simply thought the Wildrosers were not ready for government.

Ontario often argued it carried the weight of confederation. It made sacrifices to make confederation work. This is best demonstrated by equalization payments as Ontario supported social programmes across the country. During the constitutional debates of the 1980s Premier David Peterson made concessions not always in the best interest of Ontario to make a deal work. Peterson’s Liberal successor seems less committed to taking one for the Canadian Team. Premier McGuinty has expressed concerns that the equalization formula needs to be rethought. Given Ontario’s gigantic deficit and debt the notion of sending money off to other provinces likely irks the Premier.

The NDP, who swept Quebec, argue for asymmetric federalism, granting privileges to Quebec for its unique position within confederation. In general the Conservatives believe decentralization is a valuable concept. The party which has fought most consistently for a strong federal government, the Liberals, have been relegated to third and are politically adrift.

Immigration policy is being shifted to the provinces. The federal government is increasingly becoming a distribution centre for funds to support provincial initiatives. There is nothing intrinsically wrong with that, but it does weaken the purpose of the federal government. Other energy producing provinces such as Newfoundland and Labrador, Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia are likely chaffing under federal intervention, and the complaining about federal regulation not responding to local needs is legendary (discussions about the Newfoundland fishery comes to mind here). Ultimately the question is do Canadian want a strong federal government? Canada is a highly regional country. There are things appropriate for provinces and for the federal government to do, but power seems to be slipping more and more to the provinces. I believe we are poorly served by not having this conversation at all.