Showing posts with label United States Election 2016. Show all posts
Showing posts with label United States Election 2016. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 18, 2016

The 2016 Election and the Duty to Represent

Over the last couple of weeks it is hard to watch the American election and not feel like at the presidential level (at least) there has been terrible failing of their system. Polling broadly suggests that both parties, somehow, managed to nominate the least liked candidates in their history. It's as though they wanted to see what a LBJ vs. Nixon match up would look like in 1976, though those comparisons are far too charitable.

When I think of the Americans I know I have a hard time seeing them in either of the candidates purporting to represent them. Obviously there is a difference of degrees here. Clinton's checkered past as a career politician, as was recently written in the Huffington Post, is likely exacerbated by the fact that she is the first woman to run for president. I think that's a simple excuse and more could probably be gleaned from the long public life and her husband's presidency. Clearly, by far and away, it is the Republicans who have disappointed their electorate.

Conservatives and critics of the Obama administration have valid opinions that should be voiced in the public sphere without being subsumed by sexual assault allegations and tinfoil hat conspiracy theorists. The transformation of the Republican Party over the decades has left a growing segment of the electorate without a coherent voice. That all said, I have written previously that Donald Trump is clearly speaking for a segment of the American public and those who dismiss them do so at their own peril.

Perhaps as America becomes a majority minority nation one must consider if the two-party system still serves them well. Previously there were strong factions within the parties, i.e. moderate New England Republicans, Dixiecrats, etc. While on a national level the parties were not necessarily consistent the local variation allowed for political competition to a certain extent. With a diversifying population and interests it is hard to imagine that two parties can successfully encompass them all. For instance, on a political compass calculator Hillary Clinton is considered a right-of-centre politician. Yet the Democrats have to find a way to bring in the most left-wing element of the country within that tent.

How different would America look today if they used a different electoral system? What if they used a run-off system, like France? The country as a whole could choose rather than a slim slice of voters in primaries/caucuses. What if they had a parliamentary system? Would a Socialist Party under Bernie Sanders, and Green Party be prepped to form a coalition with centrist Democrats under Clinton while the Trumpists, Tea Party and Republicans are pushed to the opposition?

In a sense political parties have no obligation to anyone but themselves. Yet in a two-party system the static nature makes their failures a much greater risk. As much as I hope 2016 is an abject lesson to the parties in America I fear it will be one more point on their downward trend.

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

The 2016 Presidential Contest Begins

America's perpetual election cycle is preparing to take another pause for actual voting. Obama is in his last full year as President of the United States and so the contest to replace him will soon officially get underway. Of course candidates have been jockeying and competing with one another for well over a year but the actual voting does not begin until February 1, the date of the Iowa Caucus. For those of you who may not have followed an American presidential contest before, it can be a complicated process. Each American state/territory holds a caucus or primary to select delegates for the national convention that chooses the presidential candidate.

The Democratic contest has been rather sedate. Hillary Clinton is by far the front runner. She leads in every poll, and most state polls that I have seen. Her challenger is Bernie Sanders, Senator for Vermont. Sanders has been the progressive conscience of the congress for many years and is a self-declared socialist. Sanders only hope is if the anti-Clinton vote manifests again, but that seems unlikely given his firm left-wing positions.

Most of the excitement, it is fair to say, has been in the Republican contest. Donald Trump leads in all the early primary states (Iowa, New Hampshire, South Carolina, Florida). However his lead has been slipping, mostly to Senator Ted Cruz of Texas. I shared an article by David Brooks last week in Worth Reading. Despite the legitimacy conveyed by his title Cruz remains a harsh ideologue. This should not be interpreted as a sensible move towards the establishment by Republican primary voters.

More moderate, sensible Republican choices such as Jeb Bush, Chris Christie, John Kasich and Carly Fiorina are nowhere in this race. Bush leads this group and he's polling at 5% in Iowa and 8% in New Hampshire. Despite an open shot at the White House Republicans seem poised to select what can only be described as a fringe candidate. Donald Trump's right-wing populism and success of other outsider candidates like Ben Carson, has pushed the more 'normal' candidates into extreme ground.

I'd like to dismiss the possibility that Donald Trump might become the Republican candidate for president, but looking at the polls it is hard to shake. It seems pretty clear that his support has been slipping over the last couple of weeks, but Cruz has been the primary beneficiary.

Years ago I listened to Republican and Democratic strategists repeat the basic theory that if the Republican Party remains the party of White Men then it is doomed. America is becoming increasingly diverse. Having candidates that openly alienate entire segments of the population, i.e. Latinos is a recipe for irrelevance.


I stopped following American politics closely around 2009, but the prospect of these primaries has awoken my morbid sense of curiosity. I haven't been paying close enough attention to make any predictions as this stage, but with a tight Republican contest I will definitely cast my eye southwards from time to time. 

Tuesday, December 15, 2015

The New Right in America

There has been a tremendous amount of media attention on the American Republican contest, and more specifically on the candidacy of Donald Trump. Trump has received a great deal of scrutiny from international press for his promise to forbid Muslim immigration and suggestion that Muslims should be identified. Some have questioned whether or not Trump is a fascist which has caused me to ponder the place of the New Right in America.


The New Right is a term that is used to describe the growth of far-right wing political parties in Europe. Disturbingly many of these parties have been making advancements in elections in recent years. Some examples include the Front Nationale in France, the British National Party in the UK, or Golden Dawn in Greece. Some common features are hyper-nationalism, emphasis of historical grievances, promise of the restoration of greatness, anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim.

The New Right movement has been largely seen in European countries and not the so-called immigrant nations of the United States, Australia, New Zealand and Canada. It has been assumed that this was because these countries had a more flexible sense of national identity and more tolerant. I think this view whitewashes the racist history of these respective countries, but it is likely a decent overall explanation. However, there is no reason to assume that this level of tolerance need to continue perpetually. Faced with a declining economic situation, ongoing international conflicts in the Middle East (ISIS), perceived threat of domestic terrorism, and the Syrian refugee crisis it is unsurprising that there has been a growth of more radical ideologies and acceptance of reactionary positions.

It is definitely possible to frame Donald Trump within other American traditions, such as Nativism or the Know Nothing Party. However I think his candidacy might be better framed within the New/Far Right. Of course the disturbing thing isn't that Trump is a candidate, but that he is a popular candidate. National polls have him at 41%. This would be a resounding defeat, but given his well documented extremism it is jarring.

As Trump's extreme positions gain popularity it compels other candidates to move further to the right and legitimizes these ideas. Unlike in Europe the New Right in America will not spawn a new political party but a faction with the Republican Party. The question is how much sway these types of candidates and this faction will hold when ballots begin to be cast in February in the Iowa Caucuses.